Back to California Disability

Leslie Parker

PFL claim approved then denied no payments received debit card — what happened to my benefits?

So I'm completely lost and honestly a little panicked. Filed what I thought was the right claim after my baby was born, got an approval notice, and then nothing showed up on the debit card. Checked SDI Online a few days later and somehow the status had flipped to denied. No payments at all, the card balance is zero, and I never got a clear explanation of why it went from approved to denied. I'm on maternity leave and really counting on these payments. Has anyone seen something like this happen? Did I file the wrong type of claim maybe? I'm not sure if I mixed up disability and PFL somewhere along the way.

The dates on your Notice of Computation and your denial notice are the first things to pull up. If you got both a DE 429D and a DE 2517 in the mail, the denial notice is the one that tells you why and gives you 30 days from the issue date to appeal with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Found both of them. The DE 2517 says something about wages but I don't totally understand it. Does 30 days mean from when I got it in the mail or from the date printed on the notice itself?

0 coins

Date printed on the notice itself. Don't go by when it arrived.

0 coins

Okay filing that appeal form today then, thank you.

0 coins

DE 2525XX sat on my claim for two weeks before EDD matched it, and my payments were frozen the whole time. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the phone about the extension. The agent pulled up my claim and said the DE 2525XX had come in but hadn't been linked to the right claim ID yet. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The receipt number on my claim keeps coming back as not found when my doctor's office tries to submit the medical certification. Want to try Claimyr for that. What did you have ready when you talked to the agent?

0 coins

Had my claim ID, the receipt number I got when I filed, and the name of the provider's office. The agent needed all three to find the right record.

0 coins

Got all of that written down. Going to give it a try this week.

0 coins

That frozen payment thing is brutal. My extension sat for three weeks before anything moved.

0 coins

Worth asking yourself whether you filed a PFL bonding claim or a DI pregnancy/childbirth claim, because the two are different claims entirely. Disability covers the period you couldn't work before and right after the birth, and bonding after that is Paid Family Leave with its own separate filing.

0 coins

Think I might have filed PFL when I should still have been on a DI claim for the recovery. Would that cause the denied status?

0 coins

It could easily explain it. If you filed PFL before your DI claim for childbirth was actually closed out, the dates might overlap and EDD would kick one of them back.

0 coins

Had a friend go through almost exactly this. She had to file DI first for the recovery weeks, then a separate PFL claim for bonding after. EDD was pretty clear they can't run at the same time.

0 coins

EDD's disability line just rings and rings and then drops. Been trying on and off for two weeks on a pending claim and I haven't gotten a person once.

0 coins

Mornings on a Monday are the worst. Tried every day for a week straight before anything different happened.

0 coins

Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, doesn't matter. Same result every time.

0 coins

Number's 1-800-480-3287. Staff answer eight to five Monday through Friday. That's all I can tell you.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right place to ask but I'm kind of scared I made the same mistake filing PFL when maybe I needed to file disability first. My doctor told me I'd be out eight weeks after a C-section and I just filed whatever the first option was in SDI Online.

0 coins

For a Caesarean birth EDD typically covers eight weeks of disability for the recovery. That comes under a DI claim, not PFL. PFL bonding is the next step after. If you filed PFL first you may need to sort that out with EDD before payments start.

0 coins

So I need to call them? I really don't know how to fix this if I already submitted the wrong one.

0 coins

Calling is the fastest way to get it sorted. The number on EDD's site is 1-800-480-3287.

0 coins

Okay, going to try calling first thing tomorrow morning then.

0 coins

My claim's start date showed up wrong in SDI Online, off by almost two weeks, and that pushed my first payable day past when I expected it. Phoned EDD through Claimyr and an agent went into my record and read me the exact date they had on file. Turned out the date I entered when I filed didn't match what my doctor's office put on the certification.

0 coins

The claim start date is the same thing that tripped up my payment method setup. Used Claimyr on mine too, got an agent who confirmed my direct deposit had never been activated and the payment was sitting waiting for a valid account on file. Had to get that corrected before anything moved.

0 coins

Wait, so a wrong start date can hold up the whole payment? That's wild, I had no idea that one field could do so much.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying the line before I got anywhere on mine.

0 coins

Direct deposit not activated is such a stressful thing to find out after the fact. At least the agent could tell you exactly what was needed.

0 coins

The debit card thing tripped me up too. I was waiting on a Bank of America card because someone told me that's what EDD sends. Spent like a week waiting for the wrong thing lol.

0 coins

The card EDD sends now is through Money Network, not Bank of America. Different card, different number to call if something's wrong with it.

0 coins

Yeah found that out the hard way. Money Network card showed up and I almost threw it out thinking it was junk mail.

0 coins

same thing happened to my roommate, almost missed it in the mail

0 coins

Appeal the DE 2517 and attach every document you have. Pay stubs, the approval notice, the denial notice, screenshots of SDI Online if you have them. Write a clear explanation of the timeline. The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A, mailed to the return address on the denial notice.

0 coins

Pulling everything together now. The approval notice came before the denial, can I include both to show it changed?

0 coins

Yes, include both. The administrative law judge will want to see the full sequence.

0 coins

Does a detailed letter work if the DE 1000A is lost? Asking for a situation where the original notice went missing.

0 coins

EDD's rules allow a detailed letter if the form is lost. Mail it to the same return address. Explain why the form isn't included.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation showed a weekly amount that looked way too low, so I phoned EDD. Got a live person through Claimyr and the agent walked me through which quarter of my base period they used. The quarter they pulled was one where I'd had almost no hours because of a slow season, and that's why the number on the DE 429D was low.

0 coins

Sounds convenient but that line hasn't picked up for me once in three attempts this month. How exactly did you end up talking to an actual person?

0 coins

Kept hitting the same wall you're describing. Claimyr holds the line and your phone rings when an agent is on. That's the whole thing. Agent I got confirmed the base period quarter and told me the amount on the notice was correct for what that quarter showed.

0 coins

got a denial notice myself last week and the agent told me which form EDD was still waiting on. actually got an answer after trying that line for days.

0 coins

Alright, might give it a shot. Nothing else has worked.

0 coins

If the approval flipped to a denial after you got the Notice of Computation, that sometimes means a certification issue came up after the initial review. My cousin thought she was set after seeing the first approval screen and then a DE 2517 showed up in the mail because her doctor's certification had a date gap.

0 coins

Mine could be the same thing honestly. The doctor's office submitted the certification but I never confirmed the dates were right on their end.

0 coins

Ask the office to pull up what they submitted in SDI Online and compare the dates to your claim's start date. If there's a gap EDD flags it.

0 coins

The certification dates and the claim dates have to line up. Even a one-day gap can create a problem in the system.

0 coins

Waiting period trips everyone up at first. The first seven days of a new DI claim aren't paid. That's not processing time, that's the actual waiting period EDD builds in. Day eight is when payable days start.

0 coins

So those first seven days just never get paid at all, even after the claim is approved?

0 coins

Correct. Never paid. It's not a delay, it's just not covered.

0 coins

Didn't realize that. Thought the whole time from day one would eventually show up on the card.

0 coins

Ask EDD in myEDD is worth trying if the phone line is impossible. Open SDI Online, pick the claim, and use Request Claim Update to send a written question about the status change. At least you get something in writing.

0 coins

Tried that last week and haven't heard anything yet. How long does that usually take?

0 coins

There's no set time they publish for that. The appeal deadline is fixed though, so don't wait on the Ask EDD response before filing the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Filing the appeal first and asking questions second is the right move here. The 30 days goes fast.

0 coins

edd denied my sisters claim after it said approved too and it turned out she was getting unemployment at the same time, they caught it and clawed it back

0 coins

EDD is clear that you can't receive unemployment and DI for the same days. They cross-reference wage records and claim dates, so overlapping claims tend to get flagged.

0 coins

yeah she had no idea they were checking for that

0 coins

The rule is pretty absolute on this. If someone files unemployment while still unable to work, unemployment actually requires that you be able and available to work every week you claim it. The two don't mix.

0 coins

Payments go to a Money Network card or direct deposit. If neither is set up correctly on the claim nothing gets issued. Zero balance on the card could just mean nothing was ever sent to it.

0 coins

Is there a way to check in SDI Online what payment method is on file for my claim?

0 coins

Log into myEDD, go into SDI Online, open the claim. Payment method information is there.

0 coins

And if something's wrong with the card itself, Money Network has their own support line separate from EDD.

0 coins

Filing an appeal while also getting the certification dates sorted out at the same time is probably your best path. The appeal protects your rights on the denial, and fixing the certification might clear the underlying issue.

0 coins

That's my plan now. Appeal filed, doctor's office contacted, and I'll check the payment method in SDI Online.

0 coins

Sounds like you've got it covered. Keep copies of everything you submit.

0 coins

Certified mail for the appeal envelope if you can. It gives you a date stamp if the timeline ever matters.

0 coins

Had no idea PFL and DI were separate filings! When I had my baby everyone just said apply for SDI and I didn't realize there were actually two different claims involved, one for recovery and one for bonding.

0 coins

They're two separate programs under SDI but you file them differently and at different times. DI for the pregnancy and childbirth recovery, then a new PFL claim for the bonding period after.

0 coins

So you literally have to file twice? That seems like something they should make way more obvious.

0 coins

100 percent agree. So many people miss the transition and lose the bonding weeks because they didn't know to file a second time.

0 coins

The medical certification receipt number is a thing I had to chase down with my doctor's office. They submitted but used an old ID from a previous visit, not the receipt number I gave them when I filed. Everything was mismatched and pending for two extra weeks, anyway.

0 coins

Going to call the doctor's office today to confirm they used the exact receipt number I got when I filed.

0 coins

Have the number ready when you call. Easiest way to confirm right then.

0 coins

The receipt number from SDI Online is the link between your claim and the medical certification. If they used anything else the records don't connect.

0 coins

got approved once and then denied on the same claim because i went back to work and didnt report it right. had to appeal and it took forever.

0 coins

Returning to work part time needs to be reported to EDD right away. How partial weeks get paid is EDD's call but the reporting is on the claimant.

0 coins

yeah i know that now

0 coins

Learned that one the hard way too. Report first, ask questions after.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is not flexible. Miss it and you have to explain why to an administrative law judge, and they decide whether to let it in. Don't assume you have more time than the date on the notice says.

0 coins

Filing it today, not waiting another day. The date on mine is already two weeks ago.

0 coins

Two weeks gone means about two weeks left. Move now.

0 coins

Mailing to the return address on the notice, not EDD's general address. That matters.

0 coins

Blood pressure and stress are real things when payments don't come in. File the appeal, get the paperwork together, and don't wait on anyone else to move first. You can sort out which claim type was wrong after the appeal is in.

0 coins

Thank you. Honestly just having a checklist of things to do helps more than I expected.

0 coins

Appeal in, certification confirmed, payment method checked. That's a solid three-step list.

0 coins

Add the dates. Write the date you mailed the appeal and the date on the denial notice somewhere you won't lose it.

0 coins

If the base period wage question comes up when you talk to EDD, ask them directly which quarter they pulled. The Notice of Computation has that information but the agent can confirm it faster on the phone.

0 coins

The base period is the 12 months ending about five to 18 months before the claim start date, broken into four quarters, and EDD uses the highest-paid one to calculate the weekly amount. The calculator on EDD's site gives an estimate.

0 coins

Exactly, and the actual number is always on the DE 429D when it arrives.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in the mail about a week after I filed and the amount surprised me, higher than I expected actually!

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure