Back to California Disability

Sophia Bennett

Is SDI the same as CASDI? Confused about my California EDD deductions

Okay so I've been seeing CASDI taken out of my paychecks forever and just assumed it was some random tax. Now I'm actually about to file a disability claim because I need surgery on my shoulder and my surgeon says I'll be out for at least six weeks. When I went to look up how to file on the EDD site I kept seeing 'SDI' everywhere but my pay stub says 'CASDI.' Are these the same thing? Am I covered? I've paid into whatever this is for years and I genuinely don't know if I'm about to file for the right program or not. Also my HR department is completely useless and just told me to 'check the EDD website' which, I tried, and I'm still confused. Any help appreciated before I do something wrong.

CASDI on the paystub and SDI in EDD's system are the exact same thing. CASDI stands for California State Disability Insurance — your employer just labels the deduction that way, and EDD calls the program SDI or sometimes DI for Disability Insurance. So yes, those years of deductions you've been seeing mean you've been paying into the program the whole time. When you go to file, head to myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online from there. You'll file Part A, which is your statement, and your surgeon will complete the medical certification on their end after you give them the receipt number SDI Online generates for you.

0 coins

Receipt number — okay, is that something I write down myself or does it get emailed to me somehow?

0 coins

SDI Online shows it on screen after you submit Part A. Write it down right there and then hand it off to your surgeon's office the same day if you can, because the provider has to get the certification in within 49 days of when your disability starts. The sooner they have that number the sooner they can find your claim and submit it.

0 coins

Came here to say exactly this. CASDI vs SDI tripped me up too when I filed last year. Same deduction, same program, two different labels depending on who's writing it.

0 coins

49 days also goes for you as the claimant, by the way. You have to wait nine days after your disability starts before filing, but then you have until the 49-day mark from the start date to get your own part in without being disqualified. For shoulder surgery that probably means filing right after the nine-day wait and not sitting on it.

0 coins

Wait, I have to wait nine days before I even file? I thought I could file the day surgery happens.

0 coins

Nine days after disability starts is when you're allowed to file, yes. But with surgery your disability typically starts the day of the procedure, so just count nine days from that and file on day ten or so. Don't wait much longer than that or you're eating into the 49-day window.

0 coins

The nine-day wait always throws people off. It has nothing to do with EDD processing — you're just not eligible to file yet during those first nine days.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was something I had to phone EDD to actually pin down. The SDI Online screen showed my status had moved but I couldn't tell whether the money had been issued yet or what date to expect it on the Money Network card. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to the disability line — they hold with EDD so you end up talking to a live agent. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the exact date the payment was issued and that it had already been sent to the card. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability if you need it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Money Network card — is that automatic or do you pick how you want to get paid?

0 coins

SDI Online lets you choose direct deposit instead of the card if you file online. If you don't set up direct deposit, EDD sends a Money Network prepaid debit card automatically. No checks unless you filed on paper.

0 coins

Good to know about the payment date question. My first payment I had no idea when to expect it and just kept checking the card balance every day.

0 coins

Just to put some numbers around the timeline for you: most payments go out within two weeks after EDD gets both parts of a properly completed claim — your statement and the medical certification from your surgeon. That two-week clock doesn't start until both are in, which is why getting your surgeon the receipt number fast matters so much.

0 coins

So the two weeks starts when my surgeon submits, not when I file?

0 coins

Exactly right. Your filing Part A alone doesn't start anything payable. The clock on 'properly completed claim' means EDD has both your statement and the medical certification together. If your surgeon takes a week to submit, add that week to your wait.

0 coins

The waiting period on top of that too — first seven days of the claim are non-payable no matter what, so the first day you can actually receive money is day eight of the disability period.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period thing: a lot of people think it's EDD taking time to process, but it's actually a built-in non-payable period that's part of every new claim. You just don't get paid for those first seven days, full stop. Day eight is the first day that can be paid. It's not a glitch or a delay, it's just how the program works.

0 coins

Honestly I thought the waiting period was something you got paid back for later and was shocked when I checked my Notice of Computation and saw those days just gone.

0 coins

Nope, never paid back. Those seven days are gone. Plan your budget around not seeing any money for at least that first week plus however long both parts take to get to EDD.

0 coins

Okay that actually changes my math a lot. I was planning on week one being covered. Good to know before I file.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation letter EDD sends — it shows what your estimated weekly benefit amount could be, based on your wages from a specific period. It does not mean you're approved. I made the mistake of thinking that letter was my approval and relaxed, then got confused when nothing else came for a bit. The actual approval shows up as payments hitting or not hitting.

0 coins

DE 2500E — is that the same as the Notice of Computation or a different letter?

0 coins

Different one. The Notice of Computation is the DE 429D, which is about your potential benefit amount. The DE 2500E is the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification that comes with your final payment and also signals when an extension might be needed. They're separate documents.

0 coins

The DE 429D also doesn't tell you how EDD calculated the specific quarter they used — to understand that you'd need to call and ask, or use EDD's calculator on their site to estimate based on your pay history.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox at week ten and I almost ignored it thinking it was junk. That form is EDD asking if you're still unable to work — if you're on automatic payment you get it after your fifth payment and you have to return it within 20 days or your benefits stop. I'd gotten five payments, gone into kind of a routine, and nearly missed it. Phoned the EDD disability line through Claimyr about the form and the agent confirmed my claim was on automatic payment and that the DE 2593 was the form I had to return to keep the claim active.

0 coins

20 days feels really short. Does EDD warn you before they cut things off?

0 coins

The form itself is the warning — it comes with return instructions. EDD doesn't send a separate heads-up before stopping payments. Just watch for it around the two-and-a-half-month mark if you're on automatic payment.

0 coins

For a six-week surgery recovery this probably won't come up for the original poster, but definitely worth filing it away for anyone with a longer claim.

0 coins

Automatic payment vs. the every-two-weeks form is a thing EDD decides, not something you choose upfront as far as I know. If you're not on automatic you get a DE 2500A every two weeks asking if you're still out.

0 coins

Since you mentioned HR was no help: your employer doesn't actually do anything on the SDI claim. It's completely between you, your doctor, and EDD. HR might need to handle your leave of absence paperwork on their end, but the SDI filing is yours to do independently through SDI Online. A lot of people wait for HR to initiate something that never comes.

0 coins

That's actually a relief. I was waiting to hear back from HR before doing anything which apparently would have been a mistake.

0 coins

Huge mistake a lot of people make. File your Part A yourself as soon as you're in that nine-day wait window, give the receipt number to your surgeon, and HR doesn't enter the picture at all for the SDI side.

0 coins

HR in my experience handles FMLA or CFRA paperwork — job protection stuff — which is separate from EDD. Two different processes running at the same time. If job protection matters to you, check with your HR about that side, but it has zero connection to your SDI payments.

0 coins

Something that bit me: I assumed my physical therapist could certify my claim because she was the one seeing me most often. Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of who can submit the medical certification. I had to go back to my orthopedic surgeon's office to get it done and lost about a week. For shoulder surgery your surgeon should be able to certify directly — just make sure the office actually has someone submitting it through SDI Online and not just promising to mail something.

0 coins

Good to know, my surgeon's office does seem to handle this regularly. I'll confirm with them that they're submitting through SDI Online and not by mail.

0 coins

Mailing vs. online doesn't change whether it counts, but online is faster. Either way give them that receipt number and confirm they've submitted before your 49-day window closes.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about unemployment while on disability: those two can't overlap for the same days. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work every week you claim it. If you're recovering from surgery and genuinely can't work, you're on SDI, not unemployment. Some people try to file both thinking they can stack them — EDD doesn't allow it.

0 coins

Isn't unemployment better money though? Not that it matters if you can't work, just curious.

0 coins

Benefit amounts are calculated differently for each program. For SDI, your weekly amount is estimated off a percentage of wages from a specific base period — the calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough number before you file. Can't really compare them in the abstract.

0 coins

And practically speaking: if you're medically unable to work, certifying for unemployment that you are able and available would be a problem. File the right one for your actual situation.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail for my claim after EDD reviewed it, and it said there was an issue with my eligibility. The DE 2517 — that's the form — also had an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) stapled to it with a 30-day deadline from the date on the letter to appeal. I phoned EDD about it through Claimyr and the agent told me the determination had been issued and that I should read the notice carefully and appeal within those 30 days if I disagreed with EDD's decision.

0 coins

DE 2517 is scary to get. Did you end up appealing?

0 coins

Filed the appeal with the DE 1000A and a detailed letter explaining my situation. The notice says to mail it to the return address on the form itself. Still waiting to hear, but at least the deadline didn't pass.

0 coins

Hopefully I never see that form but good to know it comes with the appeal form attached. That's at least not as buried as I'd expect.

0 coins

Is the CASDI deduction on your stub something your employer controls or is it set by the state? I always wondered if some companies take out more than others.

0 coins

The SDI contribution rate is set by the state — it applies to all California workers covered by the program. Your employer doesn't set that rate. What they do control is how they label it on the stub, which is why some say CASDI, some say SDI, some say CA SDI. Same deduction underneath.

0 coins

That makes way more sense. I work for a small company and always thought we might be getting a different rate because nothing ever seemed to match what friends at big companies said.

0 coins

The rate is uniform statewide. Any difference in what comes out is because wages are different, not because employers negotiate a rate.

0 coins

Extending a claim if six weeks turns into more recovery time: you don't file a new claim. Your surgeon fills out a form called the DE 2525XX — the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate — and submits it to EDD. EDD typically sends that form out with your final payment notice, the DE 2500E, so watch for it. If your recovery hits a complication and your surgeon says you need more time, ask their office about the DE 2525XX specifically.

0 coins

DE 2525XX is good to have written down just in case. My surgeon said six weeks minimum so there's a real chance it ends up being longer.

0 coins

Shoulder repairs can definitely run longer. Your surgeon knows the form — most offices that do surgical certifications have handled it before. Just flag it with them early if your recovery is slower than expected rather than waiting until your benefits are about to end.

0 coins

The extension gets tacked onto the same claim, same benefit rate, no new waiting period. EDD decides whether to approve the extended period based on the certification from the provider.

0 coins

Taxes on SDI benefits — California doesn't tax them at the state level. Whether they're taxable federally depends on your situation, and that gets complicated enough that EDD's own tax information page or a tax professional is the right place for the specific answer. Don't just assume either way.

0 coins

I'd assumed they were fully taxable at both levels. Good to know California doesn't take a cut.

0 coins

EDD's tax information is on their site and lays out the federal side in more detail. Worth reading before you make any withholding decisions.

0 coins

No one's ever withheld anything from my SDI payments and then I had a small surprise at tax time. Check the EDD information before assuming you owe nothing federally.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent of wages figure people quote: that range exists because lower earners get a higher percentage and higher earners get closer to the lower end of that range. Your actual weekly amount gets calculated off the highest-paid quarter of your base period — a 12-month window that sits roughly five to eighteen months before your claim starts. Use EDD's benefit calculator to get a real estimate before you bank on a number.

0 coins

That explains why my coworker quoted a number that seemed low for her salary. The percentage isn't flat.

0 coins

Right, and the base period can also include or exclude quarters depending on exactly when your disability starts. If your Notice of Computation looks off to you after EDD sends it, phone them and ask which quarter they used — the agent can tell you that from your claim.

0 coins

The minimum is having at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period. If someone only worked a few months before the disability started, it's worth checking that they hit that threshold before expecting benefits.

0 coins

PFL is a different claim from SDI — Paid Family Leave is for bonding with a new baby or caring for a seriously ill family member. It is not disability for your own medical condition. I've seen people on other threads confuse them. For shoulder surgery, you want SDI, full stop. PFL won't apply unless after you recover you need to bond with a child, in which case you'd file a separate PFL claim at that point.

0 coins

Okay I genuinely didn't know PFL was separate. I'd seen it mentioned alongside SDI and thought they were two names for one thing.

0 coins

Super common mix-up. Both come out of the same CASDI deduction on your stub, which makes it feel like one program. But SDI covers your own disability and PFL covers family situations — different claims, different forms, different processes.

0 coins

PFL also has no waiting period, which is one of the other differences. SDI has the seven unpaid days at the start. If someone tells you disability has no waiting period, they might be thinking of PFL.

0 coins

For reaching EDD if you have questions once your claim is in: the disability line is 1-800-480-3287 and they're there Monday through Friday 8 to 5 Pacific, closed on state holidays. You can also send a message through SDI Online — open your claim and use the Request Claim Update option, pick the type, and write your question. Ask EDD on EDD's site is another option if you just need a form clarified.

0 coins

Request Claim Update inside SDI Online — I didn't know that existed. Is there a response time on that?

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish a guaranteed response time for messages in SDI Online. For anything time-sensitive, the phone line is faster if you can get through. The message option is better for things that aren't urgent.

0 coins

Spanish line is 1-866-658-8846 if that's useful to anyone reading. Same hours.

0 coins

Workers' comp vs. SDI is another one worth flagging: a work injury goes through workers' compensation, not SDI. EDD's own guidance says it's not common to get both at the same time. For shoulder surgery from something that happened off the job, you'd be on SDI — but if the injury was work-related, that's a workers' comp situation and a different process entirely.

0 coins

Mine is definitely not work-related, I hurt it playing recreational volleyball, so SDI is correct for me. But good flag for others.

0 coins

Volleyball injuries, weekend stuff, non-work accidents — all SDI territory. Just wanted to make sure nobody files SDI for a job injury and then has an issue later when workers' comp was the right path.

0 coins

EDD's language is that there are exceptions to getting both at the same time — they don't say it's impossible. But it's not the common case and you'd need to understand what EDD has actually determined for your specific claim, not just assume you can collect from both.

0 coins

Your surgeon's office submitting through SDI Online vs. mailing a paper Part B: if they file online they don't also mail the paper form. One or the other. If the office says they mailed it, don't wait for a second online submission that isn't coming — just confirm with them that the paper form was actually sent with your receipt number on it and check SDI Online after a few days to see if EDD has it.

0 coins

I'll ask the office explicitly which method they're using and confirm the receipt number got to the right person there. No assumptions.

0 coins

Ask for the name of whoever is handling the submission and get a direct line if you can. Front desk staff sometimes say 'we submitted it' meaning they put it in a pile. The person who actually files in SDI Online or signs the paper form is who you want confirmation from.

0 coins

Offices that deal with disability claims regularly usually have a designated person for this. Surgical offices generally fall into that category since they deal with post-op recovery and disability paperwork constantly.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure