If private disability insurance denies leave will SDI deny too — California EDD question
So my employer offers a short-term disability plan through some private insurance company and I just got a letter saying they're denying my claim. The whole thing came out of nowhere, they said something about not meeting their definition of disability. Now I'm panicking because I also filed with California EDD at the same time and I don't know if that denial is going to follow me over. Are these completely separate decisions or does EDD look at what the private insurer said? I've been out for two weeks already with a back injury and I really need something to come through. Anyone gone through both at the same time?
82 comments

Isaac Wright
The private plan and California EDD's SDI are completely separate. EDD makes its own decision based on your medical certification from your doctor and your wage history in the base period. What a private insurer decided doesn't factor in. The two programs have different definitions, different forms, and different standards.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorThat's genuinely relieving to hear. So my doctor's certification is what matters for EDD, not whatever the private plan decided?
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Exactly. Your doctor submits the medical certification through SDI Online, and EDD reviews that along with your work history. The private plan's letter isn't part of the picture.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Didn't know they were that separate. Good to know.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
DE 2525XX came back from EDD after my final payment notice when I needed more time off, and I had a question about whether my doctor had submitted it correctly. Spent three mornings trying to reach someone at 1-800-480-3287 and the line either rang endlessly or dropped before I got to anyone. Eventually tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got on the phone with an actual EDD agent. Video on getting a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed the extension form had come in and told me which weeks were still pending. As for your question, the private plan denial has zero effect on your SDI claim.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
Three mornings and nothing? I've tried that line probably a dozen times over the past two weeks and either get a busy signal or it disconnects me after the menu. Claimyr sounds almost too convenient to be real. How does that even work?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Totally get the doubt. The line is just brutal. Claimyr holds your place waiting for EDD to pick up and your phone rings once a live person is on. That's it. The agent I reached was an actual EDD employee who pulled up my claim right there.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Payment method question was actually what I ended up asking about. Used Claimyr myself after a week of mornings where I'd hit the same dead end. Agent confirmed my direct deposit info was on file and told me the payment had issued. Knowing the deposit was actually moving was the piece I needed.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
Authorok so the private denial really just doesn't cross over at all. that makes me feel way better about where my SDI claim stands
0 coins
Douglas Foster
Private insurance is its own thing. EDD doesn't care what they said. File your SDI, get your doctor to submit the certification, let EDD decide.
0 coins
Nina Chan
I'm in a similar spot and kind of scared my doctor's office won't get the certification in on time. Is there a cutoff?
0 coins
Douglas Foster
49 days from when your disability started. Tell your doctor's office soon.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
To add to that, your doctor needs the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A in SDI Online. Without that number they can't match it to your claim.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Worth pointing out that the two programs can have different definitions of disability entirely. A private plan might require you to be unable to do any job, while EDD's standard is whether you can do your regular or customary work. So a denial from one doesn't predict the other at all.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Wait, so EDD only asks if I can do my specific job, not any job in general? That's actually a much lower bar than I thought.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
That's how EDD defines it, yes. Your doctor certifies that you can't perform your regular or customary work, and EDD goes from there.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
The EDD language for this is on their DI FAQ page. 'Unable to do your regular or customary work' is the standard they use, which is different from many private plans that use an 'any occupation' definition after a certain period.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
EDD and your private insurer are completely different animals. I had a private plan deny me once and EDD still paid. The two decisions have nothing to do with each other. What drove me crazy was both of them wanting their own paperwork at the same time.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorYeah the paperwork overlap is real. My doctor's office is juggling both sets of forms right now.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Just make sure the SDI Online one gets priority. EDD's deadline is the one that actually cuts off your money if you miss it.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
Claim start date on mine got pushed back because of a data entry thing and I didn't catch it until my Notice of Computation showed fewer weeks than I expected. Tried the phone line for days, mornings mostly, and it just looped me through menus and dropped. Used Claimyr and got an EDD agent in one shot. She looked up my claim and confirmed the actual start date they had on file, which was off by almost two weeks. Got that corrected before it affected my payment count.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I don't totally follow what it does.
0 coins
Sean Matthews
So basically it waits on that EDD line in your place, and when a live person picks up your phone rings. You don't have to sit there redialing for hours.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
That actually makes sense. My situation is the base period quarters, I want to know which one they used to calculate my amount. That would be worth a call for me.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Start date errors are more common than people realize. Good catch before the payments processed wrong.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
I'm going through something similar and I keep second-guessing everything. My private plan denied me and now I'm worried EDD will find some reason too. My claim has been pending for eight days. Is that normal or should I be doing something?
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Eight days pending isn't unusual if EDD just received the medical certification. They say to expect contact about your claim status usually within 14 days after they get a properly completed claim.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
So I should just wait until day 14 before I worry? And the pending status doesn't mean they're going to deny it?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Pending just means they haven't finished reviewing it yet. It isn't a denial. The Notice of Computation comes first and that's what tells you the potential benefit amount, not whether you're approved or denied.
0 coins
A Man D Mortal
Pending is just pending. EDD moves slowly. It doesn't mean anything bad.
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Two separate systems, two separate decisions. Private plans are run by insurance companies. EDD is state-run. They don't share information or coordinate denials. Your SDI claim lives or dies on your own medical certification and your earnings record.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorEarnings record meaning the wages they look at to calculate the benefit amount?
0 coins
Declan Ramirez
Right. EDD looks at your highest-paid quarter in a 12-month base period. That's what sets your weekly amount. Nothing to do with what a private insurer decided.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
The estimate is on EDD's site with their benefits calculator. Actual number shows up on the Notice of Computation after EDD processes the claim.
0 coins
Emma Morales
my job had a private plan too and they denied me for some technicality. edd still paid me no problem. totally different process dont even stress about the connection
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorGood to hear from someone who went through both. That helps.
0 coins
Emma Morales
yeah just get ur doctor to send in the sdi cert asap thats the main thing
0 coins
Nina Chan
Notice of Computation on my claim showed a weekly amount that was lower than I expected and I couldnt figure out if they had used the right quarter. Honestly wasnt sure how to even ask EDD about it. Tried the phone a few times in the mornings and either got cut off or sat there for over an hour with nothing. Eventually I used Claimyr to get a live person on the phone. The agent went through my base period and told me exactly which quarter they had used and what the wage total was. It matched what I had, so the amount was right, I just hadnt understood how the calculation worked.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Got through to EDD after my own denial notice came and I was relieved to have an actual person pull up the file. The agent confirmed which weeks were listed on the Notice of Determination and told me the appeal deadline from the date on the notice. Knowing that date meant I could get the DE 1000A submitted in time. Appeals are 30 days from the date on the notice, not 30 days from when you receive it, which matters.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Did the agent say anything about what to include with the appeal form?
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Just that a detailed explanation of why I disagreed with the determination needed to go with the DE 1000A, or a detailed letter if I'd lost the form, mailed to the return address on the notice itself.
0 coins
Nina Chan
the base period quarter thing tripped me up too. the calculator on edds site helped once i understood what quarter they were even looking at
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Private disability and SDI are night and day different lol. Went through almost this exact thing last year. EDD didn't ask me anything about my private plan, they just wanted the medical cert from my doctor and that was it.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorDid you have any issues with the timing of both claims at once?
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Mostly just keeping track of which forms went where. EDD's SDI Online system is pretty clear about what it needs. The private plan was the annoying one with their own portals and phone trees.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Private plans can be more restrictive because the insurer is managing its own risk. EDD's standard is simpler. Your doctor says you can't do your job, they certify it, EDD reviews it.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Does the type of doctor matter? Mine is a nurse practitioner.
0 coins
Haley Bennett
Nurse practitioners are on EDD's list of who can certify a claim, so that's fine.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Physician assistants are also on the list. The main thing is that whoever certifies is doing it within the scope of their own license.
0 coins
Donna Cline
been there. private plan denied me, edd paid. don't let one affect how you feel about the other
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorHonestly this thread has calmed me down a lot. I'll focus on the SDI side.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
The SDI program is funded through the CASDI deduction that comes out of workers' paychecks. It's entirely separate from any employer-sponsored plan. EDD has its own eligibility rules and its own review process, and they don't pull in a private insurer's decision.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
So even if my private plan said I didn't meet their definition of disabled, EDD could still find that I do meet theirs?
0 coins
Logan Stewart
Yes. Because the definitions can be different. EDD's is about your regular or customary work. Your private plan may have used a stricter standard.
0 coins
Ruby Knight
That distinction is actually important for a lot of people who assume a private denial predicts an EDD denial. It really doesn't.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
The EDD phone line is a whole separate battle from actually getting paid. Getting information out of them took me days of trying. At least once you do reach someone they can actually look at your claim.
0 coins
Douglas Foster
SDI Online message requests help too if the phone isn't working. Go into your claim and use the Request Claim Update option.
0 coins
Mikayla Brown
Yeah I tried that too. Sometimes you get a reply, sometimes it just sits there. Phone is still the fastest when you can actually get through.
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Appeals are 30 days from the date on the notice, not from when you receive it. Worth knowing before anyone's deadline slips by.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Is that for overpayment notices too or just denials?
0 coins
Katherine Hunter
Both. Overpayment notices and denial notices both use the same DE 1000A appeal form and the same 30-day window from the issue date.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
If you miss the 30 days you can still appeal but you need to explain why it was late. An administrative law judge looks at the reason.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
My sister's claim got denied because her doctor used some older version of the form. Is that something that actually happens?
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Doctors who certify through SDI Online don't use a paper form at all. If your sister filed online, the certification goes through SDI Online. Paper claims use the DE 2501, and Part B of that goes to the address on the form.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
She filed on paper so maybe that's what happened. I'll tell her to check with her doctor about which version they sent.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
The important thing on a paper claim is that the provider mails Part B within 49 days of the disability start date. If they also submitted online, they don't mail it separately.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
Quarterly earnings during the base period determine the weekly benefit amount. The highest single quarter in a 12-month window is what EDD uses. Your Notice of Computation will show that quarter and the resulting weekly amount.
0 coins
Nina Chan
Mine showed a quarter I wasnt expecting them to pick. Turned out it was actually my highest one, I just hadnt added it up carefully before.
0 coins
Ali Anderson
The Notice is worth checking closely against your own pay records. The base period runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorI haven't gotten my Notice of Computation yet. How long does that usually take after filing?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
After both the claimant part and the medical certification are in, most payments issue within two weeks. The Notice of Computation usually comes around that time too. You'll get it before you see the first payment.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorTwo weeks from when the certification is received or from when I filed my part?
0 coins
Tami Morgan
From when EDD has both parts, your statement and the medical certification. That's when the clock on the two-week estimate really starts.
0 coins
Maya Diaz
Mine took closer to 12 days after my doctor submitted. Came through fine.
0 coins
Zadie Patel
Waiting period is seven days at the start of every new claim. Those days don't get paid. That's not a processing delay, it's just how the program works.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
So I lose the first week no matter what? Even if EDD approves everything?
0 coins
Zadie Patel
First seven days of the claim, yes. First payable day is the eighth.
0 coins
Yara Campbell
AuthorThat part I did know actually. My doctor mentioned it when I filed.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Does anyone know if pregnancy claims work the same way on the private vs SDI question? Friend is about to go on leave and she has both.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Same principle applies. EDD's SDI handles pregnancy and childbirth as a disability claim. The private plan makes its own call under its own terms. A denial from one doesn't bind the other.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
For pregnancy specifically, EDD typically covers about four weeks before the due date and six weeks after a natural birth, or eight weeks after a cesarean. The provider certifies the period. After disability ends, bonding with the baby is a separate Paid Family Leave claim, not an extension of the SDI.
0 coins
Lucas Parker
Good to know, I'll pass that along to her. She wasn't sure if the SDI pregnancy piece and the PFL piece were even different things.
0 coins