Back to California Disability

Geoff Richards

How long does SDI appeal take after mailing letter to California EDD?

So I got a Notice of Determination in the mail last week saying my disability claim was denied, and I sent in my appeal letter with the DE 1000A the same day. I explained everything, why I couldn't work, the dates, all of it. My doctor already submitted the medical certification and everything seemed fine until this notice showed up. I don't really know what happens next or how long does SDI appeal take after mailing letter. Do they send something back confirming they got it? Is there a hearing? I've never done this before and I'm honestly kind of panicking because I'm still out of work and the bills don't stop.

Mailing the appeal is the right first step. Once EDD receives it, the case goes to an administrative law judge for a hearing. You will get a notice in the mail with the hearing date and details. Keep a copy of everything you sent, your letter, the DE 1000A, and the original Notice of Determination. The 30-day window runs from the date printed on that notice, not the day you received it, so it sounds like you moved quickly which is good.

0 coins

The date on the notice, not when I got it, that actually worried me because mine sat in my mailbox over a weekend. So as long as I mailed the appeal within 30 days of that printed date I'm okay?

0 coins

Exactly right. The date printed on the front of the Notice of Determination is what counts. If you mailed within 30 days of that date you are within the window.

0 coins

I'm kind of in the same boat, not sure if mine even got there. Is there any way to check that EDD received the appeal letter?

0 coins

EDD doesn't send a separate receipt for the appeal letter, but you can reach them through SDI Online under Request Claim Update, or try Ask EDD, to ask whether it was received.

0 coins

Nobody tells you how long this takes and that's the maddening part. The hearing gets scheduled by the appeals board, not EDD directly, and the wait can stretch. You're basically in a queue. Keep certifying your claim if you can and don't assume the denial is the end of it.

0 coins

Wait, keep certifying even after a denial? I stopped because I thought the whole claim was just over.

0 coins

Continuing to certify while an appeal is pending is worth asking EDD about directly because it depends on the specifics of your denial. The Notice of Determination itself should explain what was denied and why, and that shapes what your options are. Don't take the denial as final until you hear from the administrative law judge.

0 coins

Yeah the notice should spell out what exactly got denied. Read it carefully because sometimes it's just one week or one piece they flagged, not the whole thing.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what my doctor's office used and EDD couldn't find the certification for weeks. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the line at EDD disability. Video on reaching a live person there: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my provider had filed under was off by one digit. Got that corrected and the claim moved.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my claim had a weekly amount that didn't look right to me, so I tried Claimyr too. The agent walked through which quarter of my base period they used and read me the weekly benefit amount right off the claim. Cleared up the confusion fast.

0 coins

What quarter did they end up using for yours?

0 coins

They said it was the highest-paid quarter from my base period, which turned out to be earlier than I expected. The amount on the notice matched once I understood which months it was pulling from.

0 coins

So the receipt number is what the doctor needs from you, not just your name and date of birth?

0 coins

Right. After you file your part in SDI Online you get a receipt number. That's the one your provider searches with to find your claim and submit the medical certification. Without the right number they can't attach it.

0 coins

Appeals board has its own timeline, separate from EDD. You file the appeal, it goes over there, they set a hearing. Some people wait a few months. Bring every piece of paper you have to that hearing.

0 coins

A few months is hard to hear when you're out of income, but I'd rather know. What counts as useful to bring to the hearing?

0 coins

The denial notice, your original claim paperwork, your doctor's certification if you have a copy, any letters from EDD, and anything showing why you couldn't work. The more the better.

0 coins

Doctor's notes from around the time you filed help a lot too.

0 coins

My denial came out of nowhere too, and I was so confused because my doctor had submitted everything. Turned out there was a gap in dates between when she certified and when I said the disability started. The appeal letter was where I explained that timeline in detail and it made a difference.

0 coins

A date gap, that could be my issue too. My disability started mid-week and I wasn't sure which exact day to put.

0 coins

Be as specific as you can in the appeal about the actual first day you couldn't do your job. If your doctor's paperwork has a different date than what you filed, explain why in the letter.

0 coins

The dates really are the thing that trips most people up. Worth going back and comparing what you wrote on your claim to what your doctor submitted.

0 coins

Sent mine certified mail. At least you have proof of when it left your hands.

0 coins

I didn't send it certified, just first class. Is that going to be a problem?

0 coins

Probably fine. The 30-day window is on you to meet, and if there's ever a question about timing, a postmark helps. For next time, certified is worth the extra two dollars.

0 coins

Learned that one the hard way on a different claim, anyway.

0 coins

The administrative law judge process is actually a real hearing where you can present your side, it's not just EDD reviewing the paperwork again. You can bring a representative if you want, though it's not required. Some people use legal aid organizations for disability appeal hearings.

0 coins

I didn't know I could bring someone. Would that actually help or is it overkill for a first appeal?

0 coins

For a straightforward case where it's mainly a paperwork or date issue, most people go alone and do fine. If the denial was based on something more complicated, having someone who knows the process can help you organize your argument.

0 coins

Legal aid around here has a wait too. Might be worth calling them early just to find out.

0 coins

Payment date on mine was showing weird in SDI Online, like it said issued but nothing hit my account. Spent a whole morning trying that number. Eventually tried Claimyr to get through to disability and an agent confirmed the payment had been issued on a specific date and told me to check with the Money Network card, not a bank account. That's when I realized I had the wrong account set up.

0 coins

An actual live agent at EDD, that honestly sounds like a commercial to me. That line is impossible.

0 coins

i thought the same thing but i was stuck for days and tried it and it worked, agent confirmed which weeks got paid on my claim and i hadnt set up direct deposit right either

0 coins

okay if two people are saying it worked I might actually give it a shot, my payment situation is a mess right now

0 coins

the money network card thing catches everyone once

0 coins

Appeals filed after the 30-day window are not automatically thrown out. EDD says a late appeal needs reasons for the delay, and the administrative law judge looks at those reasons. So if someone missed the deadline, it's still worth filing and explaining why.

0 coins

Mine was within 30 days but good to know in case anyone reading this waited longer.

0 coins

What counts as a good enough reason for being late? Like if you just didn't understand the process?

0 coins

The judge decides, so I can't say what clears the bar. Explain your situation honestly in the appeal and let them assess it. Not knowing about the deadline is worth mentioning if it's true.

0 coins

Honest and specific is always better than vague when it's going to a judge.

0 coins

my denial was because my employer contested it, not because of anything i did wrong. that made the appeal different because i had to show my work situation not just my medical stuff

0 coins

An employer can contest a disability claim? I didn't know that was a thing.

0 coins

Employers can respond to disability claims, yes. The appeal process still goes through the administrative law judge, and you would explain your side of the work situation there. Your medical certification from your doctor is still important evidence.

0 coins

yeah bring every text email whatever from your employer around the time you stopped working, that stuff helped me

0 coins

Has anyone had the hearing done by phone versus in person? I keep wondering which is better if you have that option.

0 coins

From what I've read, phone hearings are more common now and work fine for most cases. In person might feel more formal but the judge weighs the same evidence either way.

0 coins

The hearing notice will usually explain how yours is set up. If you have a preference you can try contacting the appeals board to ask.

0 coins

Mine was by phone and went fine.

0 coins

While you wait for the appeal hearing, is there any other income support you can apply for? Like can you file for unemployment at the same time, anyway.

0 coins

Unemployment and disability can't cover the same days. Unemployment requires being able and available to work. If you're still unable to work, disability is the right track. Once you're able to work again you could file for unemployment at that point.

0 coins

right that makes sense, was just thinking out loud

0 coins

County programs and food assistance might have faster timelines if things are tight during the wait.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail after my fifth automatic payment and I almost missed the 20-day return window because I thought it was junk. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD disability to ask whether mine had been received after I sent it back. The agent confirmed the date it came in and that my payments were continuing.

0 coins

What did the agent say about how that form is processed once they get it?

0 coins

Just that it had been received on a specific date and my claim was still active. Nothing about the internal side of things, just what was showing on my claim.

0 coins

been trying that disability number three weeks straight, mornings mostly, can never get through

0 coins

Don't overthink the hearing itself. Tell your story straight. When you stopped working, what your doctor said, what the notice said was wrong. Judges have heard it all.

0 coins

Straightforward is reassuring to hear. I tend to ramble when I'm nervous.

0 coins

Write down three main points before the hearing. That way if you lose your place you've got something to come back to.

0 coins

Three points is a solid approach, keeps you from going in circles.

0 coins

Got a Notice of Determination on my claim that said I wasn't eligible and the reason didn't match anything I'd done. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD disability agent and had them look at exactly what triggered it. Agent found the claim start date in the system was off, different from what I'd filed. That explained the whole thing.

0 coins

My Notice of Determination came and I still can't figure out if the denial is about my dates or my doctor's certification. I'm going to try Claimyr for that because I need someone to actually look at what's in the system. What should I have ready when I try it?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the Notice of Determination in front of you. Know the date range you filed for. The agent can pull up what's on your claim and tell you what they see.

0 coins

Having the notice right there makes the call faster.

0 coins

The claim ID is in SDI Online under your open claim. Good to write it down before you call.

0 coins

The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, not back to EDD. That's a separate office with its own process. Worth knowing because correspondence and hearing notices come from them, not from EDD directly.

0 coins

That explains why my neighbor said she got mail from somewhere that didn't say EDD on it. I'll watch for a different return address.

0 coins

The hearing notice will come from the appeals board. Keep an eye out for it and don't ignore anything that arrives in the weeks after you file.

0 coins

If you filed a detailed letter instead of the DE 1000A because you misplaced the form, that is acceptable. The appeals board needs a detailed explanation either way.

0 coins

Has anyone appealed more than once? Like if the first appeal doesn't go your way?

0 coins

There are further levels of review after the administrative law judge decision, but the specifics get complicated quickly. Most people's situations resolve at the first hearing level.

0 coins

The notice you get after the hearing will explain your options if you want to continue. That's the right document to read at that stage.

0 coins

Hopefully it doesn't come to that but good to know the door isn't completely closed.

0 coins

Your doctor staying involved matters during the appeal. If your provider is willing to write a supplemental letter or be available to clarify dates, that can strengthen your case at the hearing.

0 coins

My doctor's office said they'd write whatever I need. Should I bring a new letter or just the original certification paperwork?

0 coins

Bring both. The original certification shows what was filed, and a newer letter addressing the specific reason for denial can speak directly to what the judge is looking at.

0 coins

My doctor wrote a one-page letter just for my appeal and the judge referenced it during the hearing.

0 coins

the waiting is the worst part honestly. filed my appeal six weeks ago and nothing yet, just watching the mail every day

0 coins

Six weeks and still nothing, that's hard. Have you tried contacting the appeals board to ask where things stand?

0 coins

didnt know i could do that, thought you just had to wait

0 coins

The appeals board has contact information separate from EDD. You can reach out to ask about your hearing date without it affecting the process.

0 coins

Appeal letter already sent. Nothing to do now but wait for the hearing notice and prepare. Panicking won't speed the queue.

0 coins

Needed to hear that bluntly. I keep refreshing SDI Online like something is going to change.

0 coins

SDI Online won't reflect the appeal status. That's the appeals board's side. Watch your mail.

0 coins

yeah sdionline is basically useless for appeal stuff, everything comes by mail

0 coins

Did you send the appeal to the address on the notice itself? Because if you sent it somewhere else that could be an issue, anyway.

0 coins

I did send it to the return address on the notice. I re-checked before mailing.

0 coins

That's exactly right. Forms and appeal documents go to whatever address is listed on the notice, not to EDD's general address.

0 coins

Good. That's the one thing you don't want to get wrong.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure