Back to California Disability

Ana Erdoğan

Got a notice of determination from California EDD — what does it actually mean for my claim?

Okay so I finally heard back from EDD after weeks of silence and it wasn't what I was hoping for. I had surgery on my shoulder in October and filed my SDI claim through SDI Online maybe five days after, gave my surgeon's office the receipt number right away, they submitted the medical certification within that same week. Everything seemed fine. Then nothing for almost three weeks — no payment, no notice, nothing showing up except the claim sitting there in SDI Online. Then yesterday I got this notice of determination in the mail. I'm honestly not sure what it means. The letter references my claim but I can't tell if it's saying I'm denied, or just that there's some issue they need resolved, or what. I've heard people use the term loosely and sometimes they mean their actual approval and sometimes they mean a denial. The language on mine is not exactly clear to me. Has anyone else gotten one of these notices after going through the whole filing process and having their doctor submit everything? What was the situation and what did you end up doing about it? I'm five weeks out from surgery and still can't go back to my job in the warehouse so I really need to understand what this document is telling me and whether I need to do something right now.

The letter itself should spell out the decision — if EDD is denying your claim or making it not payable in some way, that notice of determination is specifically the form DE 2517. It comes with an appeal form attached, the DE 1000A, and there should be a reason stated somewhere on the letter for why the claim isn't being approved. The key thing is the date printed on the notice, because you have 30 days from that date to file an appeal if you disagree with whatever it says. So flip to the top or the bottom and find that date and don't let it slip.

0 coins

Found the date, it's about two weeks ago so I still have time. The reason listed is kind of vague — something about insufficient medical documentation. Does that mean my doctor's certification didn't go through correctly?

0 coins

Vague denial reasons like that are frustrating. It could mean the certification wasn't matched to your claim, or there was something missing from what the provider submitted. Either way you need to contact EDD and find out the specific reason before you write your appeal.

0 coins

If the reason on the notice is about medical certification, your surgeon's office should double-check that they submitted through SDI Online using your receipt number, not just mailed something in separately. Those two systems don't automatically link up if the provider mails a paper form when you filed online.

0 coins

DE 2517 came to me too, back when I had a back injury last year that kept me out of my job at a shipping facility for about two months. Mine said something about wages not meeting the minimum. I ended up needing to know exactly which quarter EDD used to calculate the potential benefit amount on my claim, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent. The Notice of Computation they had on file showed a different base period quarter than I expected, and the agent confirmed the weekly amount it showed and which quarter had been used. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I had that information I understood why the wage calculation came out the way it did and I could figure out my next step.

0 coins

Mine seems to be about the medical side, not wages, but this is helpful to know the notice of computation is a separate document from the determination. I don't think I've received a computation notice yet actually.

0 coins

Paystubs from my own job in construction showed three quarters that looked good to me but EDD still used the one I didn't expect. I ended up doing the same thing, phoned EDD to find out what was actually on the notice they'd generated for my claim.

0 coins

The base period thing trips a lot of people up. The calculator on EDD's site helps you estimate which quarter they're likely to use before you even call.

0 coins

Before you spend time on an appeal, ask yourself whether the problem is fixable without one. If your doctor's office submitted the certification and it didn't get matched to your claim for some reason, EDD might be able to resolve it without a full appeal. Contact your surgeon's office first and ask them to confirm they used your SDI Online receipt number when they filed their part. If they submitted it on paper or used the wrong ID number, that's the actual problem and the determination might have been issued just because EDD never saw the certification.

0 coins

My office said they filed online. I'm going to ask them specifically about the receipt number tomorrow morning.

0 coins

Happened to me after a knee procedure — office filed online but they had a typo in the receipt number. EDD never matched it. Took about ten more days after the correction for things to process.

0 coins

Yep, the receipt number issue is surprisingly common. The office might think everything went through on their end because the form submitted without an error, but if the numbers don't match it just floats there unattached.

0 coins

I want to be real with you — EDD's notice of determination language is intentionally dense and I've seen people read the same letter two different ways. The form is a DE 2517 and it's specifically for when a claim or some part of a claim is NOT payable. If you got one and you're confused, there's no harm in treating it like a denial until you get confirmation otherwise. That 30-day appeal window is not forgiving.

0 coins

That's making me more anxious but I think I needed to hear it bluntly. I'm going to try to get EDD on the phone today.

0 coins

The 30-day clock has caught a lot of people out. I had a friend who waited because she thought the letter was just informational and by the time she understood it was a denial the window was closing.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not from when you received it. If the letter sat in your mailbox a few days before you opened it, that counts.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I got my DE 2517 last spring — I went into SDI Online through myEDD and sent a message through the Request Claim Update feature. I picked the option that matched my situation and explained that I'd received a determination and needed clarification on the specific reason. They responded in SDI Online within a few days and the message was much more specific than the letter had been. It doesn't stop the appeal clock but it at least told me what I was actually dealing with before I wrote my appeal letter.

0 coins

I didn't know you could message them through SDI Online directly. Trying that tonight.

0 coins

The message option in SDI Online saved me a lot of grief when my claim had an issue. Much better than trying to get through on the phone when you're in the middle of a recovery and don't have energy to hold for two hours.

0 coins

You have to find your claim ID first and select it before the Request Claim Update button appears. It's a little buried but it's there.

0 coins

Just to make sure nobody gets confused here — the Notice of Computation (the DE 429D) and the Notice of Determination (the DE 2517) are two completely different documents. The computation notice shows your potential weekly amount and your max. The determination notice is specifically about whether the claim is payable. Getting a computation notice is not an approval, and getting a determination notice doesn't necessarily mean the whole claim is dead — it might be about specific weeks or a specific issue. Read yours carefully for what period it covers.

0 coins

Mine seems to cover the whole claim period, not just specific weeks. Which is what's scaring me most.

0 coins

My determination last year covered only a two-week gap where my doctor's extension came in late. The rest of the claim was fine. So yes, definitely read the dates listed in the notice carefully.

0 coins

Even a whole-claim determination can sometimes be resolved if the underlying issue was something fixable like a missing certification or a wage record question. That's why the appeal exists — it's your chance to put the missing piece in front of a judge.

0 coins

WAIT wait wait does this mean you haven't gotten any payments AT ALL yet? Because if you filed five weeks ago and still haven't seen a single payment something is really wrong. The determination notice explains part of it but EDD should have been in touch about the status within roughly two weeks of getting your completed claim — both your part and your doctor's part. Five weeks of complete silence before this letter is not normal. Have you checked SDI Online to see what your claim status shows?

0 coins

No payments at all, correct. Status has just been pending this whole time and then the letter showed up. I didn't know the two-week contact timeframe was a thing.

0 coins

The two weeks only starts after EDD has BOTH parts — your statement and the medical certification. If the certification was never matched to your claim, EDD may have never had a complete claim to process. That's probably what triggered the determination.

0 coins

Five weeks out from surgery and no payments yet — that's a really stressful situation. Hope you get this sorted out quickly.

0 coins

Weeks 7 through 9 of my own claim were marked as not paid on my DE 2517 and I had no idea why those specific weeks were excluded. I phoned EDD's disability line and got through to an agent through Claimyr — the agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been issued payment and which were still showing as unpaid, and confirmed that those three weeks had been flagged because my continued eligibility form hadn't been received in time. Once I knew that, I knew what to fix.

0 coins

That DE 2593 continued eligibility form is something I haven't even thought about yet — my situation is at the very beginning so it hasn't come up. But good to know it can affect specific weeks like that.

0 coins

Five months into my own claim at a hotel where I do maintenance, I missed the DE 2593 deadline once and it held up two weeks of payments until I got it in. The form is easy to overlook when you're focused on recovery.

0 coins

The form goes out after your fifth automatic payment, so about ten weeks in. Return it within 20 days or it stalls everything.

0 coins

For what it's worth — if the determination came because of a certification issue and not a wage or eligibility issue, your chances on appeal are pretty decent IF you can get the actual certified documentation in front of EDD. You'd attach the corrected or confirmed certification to your DE 1000A appeal form and write a brief explanation of what happened with the receipt number or the submission. Keep it factual and specific. Don't just say 'my doctor submitted everything' — name when, through what system, and what receipt number was used.

0 coins

This is the most useful framing I've gotten so far. I'm going to call the surgeon's office first thing tomorrow to get the exact submission date and confirmation from their portal.

0 coins

Agree completely. Appeals that come with documentation attached move a lot better than appeals that are just a letter saying you didn't deserve the denial. Specifics are everything.

0 coins

Real question that I think matters here — do you know for sure your surgeon is on EDD's list of who can certify a DI claim? Most physicians absolutely are, but just want to make sure nobody's sending you down the appeal path when the core issue might be something else entirely. Licensed medical doctors and osteopathic physicians are on the list, so a surgeon should be fine. But I've seen posts where someone had their physical therapist try to certify and EDD rejected it because physical therapists aren't authorized to submit the medical certification.

0 coins

It was my orthopedic surgeon who submitted, so I think that's fine. Good to know physical therapists can't do it though, I would not have guessed that.

0 coins

Orthopedic surgeon is completely fine. The certification list is actually broader than most people think — nurse practitioners and physician assistants can certify too. A PT being left off is one of those things that surprises people.

0 coins

My physical therapist actually told me they couldn't do it and sent me back to my doctor's office. Good thing they knew because I would have waited thinking it was submitted.

0 coins

Has anyone here gone through the actual appeal hearing process with EDD? I'm kind of in a similar boat — got a notice of determination about six weeks ago, filed my appeal on the DE 1000A with a letter, and I'm waiting for the hearing date. I'm wondering what to expect when I actually get to the hearing itself.

0 coins

Appeal hearings in EDD disability cases are run by an administrative law judge. It's less formal than a courtroom but you should bring every document you have — your determination notice, your appeal form, any confirmation from your doctor's office that they submitted, your SDI Online records. Be ready to explain the timeline clearly.

0 coins

The timeline from filing the appeal to actually getting a hearing date can vary. You'll get a notice in the mail with the date and instructions. Some hearings are done by phone, some in person.

0 coins

Okay good to know it's the judge who runs it. I was nervous it was going to be an EDD staffer who'd just rubber-stamp the original decision.

0 coins

My determination came after going back to work part-time before my claim period was up. I'd reported my partial work hours the way I understood to, but EDD sent the DE 2517 saying some weeks were overpaid. The notice said I could appeal within 30 days. I appealed because the hours I reported and what EDD calculated didn't match — turned out there was a reporting week mismatch that I hadn't understood. The appeal resolved it.

0 coins

Part-time work situation hadn't even occurred to me since I haven't been back at all yet. Good to know the appeal process can actually fix those kinds of calculation disputes.

0 coins

Part-time return situations are genuinely complicated and EDD's rules on how a partial week gets paid aren't super intuitive. Appeals for those seem to go better when you can show the exact hours you reported.

0 coins

My pay stubs and the notes from when I reported my hours were what made the difference. Had I not kept those records the appeal would have been much harder to support.

0 coins

Five weeks since surgery with no payments and now a denial notice — EDD's disability system can feel really defeating when you're already in a rough spot physically. I hope things turn out okay. For what it's worth, most people I've seen post about denial notices end up getting it sorted out, especially when the issue is a documentation problem rather than an actual eligibility problem.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring. I'm trying not to spiral but it's hard when bills don't stop just because EDD has a problem.

0 coins

The documentation issues really are very common. The fact that you filed on time, your doctor filed their part, and you're following up quickly puts you in a much better position than a lot of people who post here.

0 coins

Appeal deadline aside — have you also thought about Ask EDD? It's EDD's online contact form. You can send a message specifically about why the determination was issued and ask what documentation they need to resolve it. Some people have had luck getting EDD to withdraw or reconsider a determination if the fix is simple, without going all the way through a formal appeal hearing.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a path other than the formal appeal. Is Ask EDD the same as the Request Claim Update in SDI Online?

0 coins

They're different. Ask EDD is a general contact form at edd.ca.gov. The Request Claim Update is inside SDI Online through myEDD and is more specific to your claim. Both can work but the Request Claim Update might be faster since it's tied directly to your claim record.

0 coins

Used Ask EDD once and got a response in about a week. Used Request Claim Update another time and got one in a few days. For something urgent like an appeal deadline, I'd do both.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up for me about four months into a hotel maintenance injury claim that ran longer than expected. My doctor submitted the extension form but nothing updated for three weeks and I was worried the extension had been denied. I ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr — the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX had been received and told me the extension period it covered. That cleared up a lot of anxiety about whether my claim was about to end unexpectedly.

0 coins

Good to know the extension process even exists — I'm not there yet but it's something to keep in mind since my recovery timeline is uncertain.

0 coins

Extension submissions through the provider work the same way as the original certification — your doctor files the DE 2525XX, EDD processes it, and you should hear something. The form typically comes to you with the notice EDD sends when your final payment is processing.

0 coins

The form gets sent to the doctor, not to you, as part of the final payment notice. That's why a lot of people don't realize it exists until they're about to run out of benefits and the doctor's office mentions it.

0 coins

Worker at a food distribution center here, had a hernia surgery in the spring and got a determination notice about two weeks after my doctor submitted the certification. Mine turned out to be an approval — which I didn't realize at first because the letter language was confusing. I actually thought it was bad news. Took me a day of panicking before someone told me to look for whether the letter uses the word 'not payable' or similar.

0 coins

Wait — so a determination notice isn't always bad news? I may have been misreading mine this whole time. Going to look at it again right now.

0 coins

There is a distinction here worth making — the DE 2517 is specifically the form that comes when a claim is NOT approved. What you may have gotten, if it was actually good news, could have been a different notice altogether. Worth checking the form number at the top of your letter.

0 coins

Ah — looking back I think what I got was actually the Notice of Computation showing my potential weekly benefit amount. I genuinely confused the two when I first posted this. The original poster should definitely check the form number at the top.

0 coins

The confusion about what the determination notice means versus the computation notice versus just the claim sitting as pending is so common. EDD sends multiple documents throughout the process and they don't always arrive in the order you'd expect. Computation notice first usually, then claim activity, then either payments or a determination if something went wrong.

0 coins

Mine definitely says DE 2517 at the top so I think it really is the denial notice. But I also want to double-check whether I got a DE 429D at some point and just didn't recognize it.

0 coins

Check your mail from the last four weeks carefully. The computation notice is easy to mistake for junk or for a general information mailing if you're not specifically looking for a form number.

0 coins

EDD mail doesn't always look official from the outside. If the return address is from EDD in Sacramento, open everything.

0 coins

My claim went from pending to determination notice in what felt like no time, and mine was about a wage issue — EDD said I hadn't earned enough in the base period. I hadn't heard of the base period concept before and had no idea that there was a minimum wage threshold to even qualify. For anyone else confused by that part: EDD looks at wages from roughly five to seventeen months before your claim starts, and you need at least $300 in wages that had the SDI deduction taken out during that period.

0 coins

The base period timing is what gets people who had a gap in employment or switched jobs right before getting hurt. If you worked for a company that wasn't taking the CASDI deduction out of your check, those wages don't count.

0 coins

Exactly. I'd been working a contract gig for about six months before my injury and didn't realize those wages weren't subject to SDI. It was a whole education.

0 coins

That's also why EDD has the wage calculator on their site — you can check whether your wages in the relevant period are likely to meet the threshold before you file, so you're not blindsided by a determination notice after the fact.

0 coins

Appeal form DE 1000A was lost in my own situation — I actually couldn't find it and panicked. Turns out you can send a detailed letter to the return address printed on the determination notice even without the official form. The letter needs to explain clearly why you disagree and what your basis is. EDD will accept it as long as it has your name, claim number, and the specific reason you're appealing. And if you can track down the original form, include it, but the letter alone is enough to preserve your rights within that 30-day window.

0 coins

Really important to know. I was afraid if I lost the form I'd have no way to appeal.

0 coins

That's correct — EDD's rules allow a detailed letter in place of the form, but I'd still recommend printing a new DE 1000A from EDD's site if at all possible, since it already has the fields EDD is looking for and makes it easier for them to process.

0 coins

Agreed, use the form if you can. The letter is a safety net, not a preference.

0 coins

Coming back with an update because a few people asked me to follow up. I spoke with my surgeon's office and they confirmed they did file online but used an outdated receipt number from a test claim I had filed and then cancelled. So the medical certification was sitting there unattached to my actual claim. The office resubmitted using the correct receipt number. I also sent a message through the Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online explaining the situation and that I would be appealing while the resubmission was being processed. Feeling cautiously hopeful but I'm still filing the appeal before the deadline regardless.

0 coins

Filing the appeal while the fix is in process is exactly right. If the resubmission resolves it, the appeal becomes moot. If it doesn't, you haven't lost your window.

0 coins

The receipt number issue being the root cause here tracks with what I said earlier. Really glad your office caught it and was willing to resubmit. Good luck with the rest of the process.

0 coins

This is a good resolution even if it's not fully resolved yet. Keep an eye on SDI Online over the next couple weeks — if the medical certification gets matched to the claim properly you should see activity there before anything shows up in the mail.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure