Back to California Disability

Benjamin Kim

Got a call notice response from California EDD disability — what do I do now?

Few weeks out from an abdominal procedure and filed my SDI claim through SDI Online pretty quickly after. My surgeon's office submitted the medical certification around day nine, so I figured the whole thing was set. Then yesterday I got a letter from EDD disability and I honestly wasn't sure what to make of it. It doesn't say approved, it doesn't say denied, it just references my claim and asks me to respond by a certain date. I'm calling it a call notice response because that's basically what it feels like — EDD is reaching out and I have to do something, but the letter isn't totally clear on what. Has anyone gotten something like this partway through a claim? I don't want to mess up my response and lose my benefits. I'm still a good few weeks from being able to go back to my job in a warehouse, so this money really matters right now.

DE 2517 is usually what that kind of letter turns out to be — that's the Notice of Determination, and it comes when EDD decides something about your claim that isn't a straight approval. Read the whole thing carefully because somewhere on it there will be a reason code and a deadline. You have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to file an appeal if you disagree with whatever it says.

0 coins

Thanks, I'll look for that form number on it. Mine doesn't seem to list a reason code anywhere obvious, so maybe it's something else entirely.

0 coins

Could also be the DE 2593, the continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends after a certain stretch of payments. That one has a 20-day return window, which is tighter than an appeal deadline, so check the date on it right away.

0 coins

Good point, let me read the top of it more carefully. The dates on these things can sneak up on you.

0 coins

DE 2525XX sat on my kitchen counter for three days before I realized what it was. That's the form your doctor fills out when you need more time beyond the original end date — EDD sends it with the notice about your last payment coming, and if nobody submits it fast enough the claim just stops. By the time I understood what was happening I really needed to talk to someone at EDD about whether the extension period could still start from the right date. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I ended up reaching an agent — it holds your place in the phone queue so you get through to a live EDD disability rep. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2525XX hadn't been received yet and confirmed the date range my doctor would need to cover on the form. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. I called the surgeon's office that same afternoon with the exact dates.

0 coins

That form name is new to me. So the extension paperwork is separate from the original medical certification entirely?

0 coins

Completely separate. The original cert covers the period your doctor first certified. When you need more time the physician fills out the DE 2525XX — that's the supplementary certificate. EDD typically sends it along with the notice about your final payment, so keep an eye out for it in the mail around that time.

0 coins

Missed this on my own claim and had a gap in payments before my doctor got it in. Would have saved a lot of stress knowing this up front.

0 coins

Warehouse work is usually classified as physical or demanding, so your doctor's certification period might be longer than you're expecting. The key thing is whatever EDD sent you has a date on it somewhere — treat that date like a hard deadline regardless of what the letter actually is.

0 coins

Yeah the work is definitely physical, I can't be lifting anything for another few weeks at minimum. I'll find that date tonight.

0 coins

My doctor actually put my return date a bit earlier than I ended up needing, and when I went back to request an extension there was a brief scramble to get the paperwork moving in time. The 20-day window on that continued eligibility form is not a lot of runway.

0 coins

People mix up the waiting period and processing time constantly and it caused me a real headache on my claim. I assumed the seven days at the start were just EDD processing my paperwork, so I was counting them toward when I'd get paid. Turns out those seven days are a non-payable period built into every new claim — you don't get paid for them, period. Your first payable day is day eight. Had I understood that earlier I would have budgeted differently those first two weeks.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps because I was also fuzzy on that. So day eight is when payment eligibility starts, not day one of filing?

0 coins

Exactly. Day one of your disability, not day one of filing — the waiting period runs from when you became disabled. So if you waited nine days before filing like you said, the waiting period was already running during those nine days before you even filed.

0 coins

This tripped me up too. I thought I was behind on paperwork and I kept checking SDI Online every hour thinking something was wrong with my claim. It was just the waiting period doing what it's supposed to do.

0 coins

If the letter mentions your weekly benefit amount, that's the Notice of Computation, not a denial or a request to do anything. It just tells you the potential amount EDD calculated from your wages. Getting that notice doesn't mean you're approved — it just means EDD processed the financial side. The claim still has to go through the eligibility determination separately.

0 coins

Mine does mention an amount, so maybe that's what it is. It says 'potential' somewhere on it too which I noticed.

0 coins

That 'potential' language is on the Notice of Computation specifically. EDD uses it because eligibility isn't confirmed yet. If your amount looks way off from what you expected, the calculator on EDD's site lets you run your own estimate using quarterly wages to compare.

0 coins

Agreed — 'potential' is the tell. Mine said potential and I thought it meant my claim was in trouble but it was totally routine. Payments still came through after.

0 coins

Start date on my claim was recorded wrong after I filed on paper, and I didn't catch it until the first payment showed up for the wrong number of days. Calling EDD directly was the only way to fix it. Used Claimyr to get through since the hold times were brutal — the agent looked at my file and read back the start date EDD had on record, which was two days off from what I had written on the DE 2501. Got a correction request submitted on the spot.

0 coins

Two days off doesn't sound like much but I imagine it matters for the payment calculation. Glad you caught it.

0 coins

It matters especially because of that seven-day waiting period — a wrong start date can shift which days count as the non-payable period and which days you're owed money for. Worth double-checking your own claim start date in SDI Online.

0 coins

Filing on paper always feels riskier to me for exactly that reason. SDI Online at least shows you a confirmation screen with the dates you entered before you submit.

0 coins

Whatever EDD sent you, respond to it before you try to figure out exactly what it means. Missing the response window is worse than sending a response that asks for clarification. If there's a form attached, fill it out and send it back. If it's just a letter asking you to do something, do that thing and keep a copy.

0 coins

That's honestly the most practical advice here. I've been trying to decode the letter instead of just responding to it.

0 coins

Decoding can happen in parallel. But the deadline doesn't move while you're decoding.

0 coins

Seconded. I responded to one of these while still confused about what it was for and it turned out fine — EDD processed the response and the claim kept moving.

0 coins

SDI and workers' comp are different and I see people get confused on this. If your injury happened off the job and you're filing SDI, that's right. If it happened at work, that's workers' comp territory and EDD has said those two programs don't usually run at the same time. Your warehouse work and an abdominal surgery sounds like it was not a work injury, so you're in the right place, just want to make sure.

0 coins

No, completely unrelated to work. This was a planned surgery, nothing happened on the job.

0 coins

Good — just flagging it because I've seen people on these forums get sorted into the wrong program and wonder why things aren't moving.

0 coins

The letter might also just be EDD asking you to verify identity or confirm some detail on your original claim form. Those come through sometimes if something on the Claimant's Statement didn't match what EDD had on file for your wage records. It's not automatically a problem — EDD just needs the info before they can keep processing.

0 coins

That could be it too. I did file pretty quickly and I may have made a typo on one of the wage fields.

0 coins

If it's a wage discrepancy, they'll usually list what they have on file versus what you submitted. Bring your pay stubs to whatever you submit back so EDD can see the difference.

0 coins

Happened to me and it delayed things by about a week but once I sent the corrected info the claim moved again.

0 coins

Continuing on the DE 2593 point from earlier — if you are on automatic payments and you've received about five payments already, that questionnaire is coming whether you expect it or not. EDD sends it to check that you're still unable to work. Miss the 20-day window and benefits stop. It doesn't take long to fill out but set a reminder the moment it arrives.

0 coins

Noted. I'm not quite at five payments yet but I'll be watching for it.

0 coins

EDD also sends a DE 2500A every two weeks if you're not on automatic payment — that one requires you to certify each period manually. The DE 2593 is the automatic-payment equivalent after the first batch of payments.

0 coins

My DE 2593 almost slipped past me because it looked like junk mail from the outside. Any envelope from EDD gets opened immediately now, doesn't matter what it looks like.

0 coins

Responded to something similar about two months into my own recovery and what fixed the confusion was calling SDI Online's payment info line at 1-800-480-3287. They have automated info and you can also reach a live agent through it. Even just the automated part told me which weeks EDD considered pending versus paid, which helped me figure out what the letter was actually reacting to.

0 coins

Good to know that number works for more than just checking payment status.

0 coins

Between that and the Request Claim Update tool inside SDI Online, you can get a lot of answers without having to wait on hold. The Request Claim Update lets you send EDD a message tied to your specific claim ID.

0 coins

Weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation looked much lower than I expected and I couldn't tell which quarter of my earnings they'd used to calculate it. Had been out of regular hours for a while before my claim started. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD disability — the agent said they'd pulled my highest-paid quarter from the base period and read back the actual wage figure they had on file for it. Turned out the quarter was right, the lower amount was because that quarter happened during a slow stretch of my hours.

0 coins

That quarterly wage thing is confusing. So the amount on the Notice of Computation isn't based on your most recent paycheck?

0 coins

Not your most recent one. EDD goes back to a base period — roughly five to eighteen months before your claim started — and finds the quarter in that period where your wages were highest. If that quarter had reduced hours, the amount will reflect that even if you were fully employed right before your claim.

0 coins

Mine looked low for the same reason. The base period reached back far enough that it caught some months when I was part-time transitioning to full-time. The EDD calculator on their site lets you plug in your quarterly wages to see how the amount gets figured.

0 coins

Missing the medical certification deadline is what almost killed my claim before anything else went wrong. Provider has to get it in within 49 days of the disability start date, same window the claimant has. My doctor's office had the receipt number wrong and thought the submission went through when it hadn't. If you're watching SDI Online and the certification still shows as not received after a week of your doctor saying they filed it, have them double-check that receipt number before that 49-day clock runs out.

0 coins

The receipt number is what I gave to my surgeon's office right after I filed. I should confirm they actually used it rather than just assuming.

0 coins

Call the office and ask them to confirm the submission date and what receipt number they entered. If there's a mismatch, they'll need to resubmit using the right one, and EDD will show the certification as received once it's matched to your claim.

0 coins

The receipt number thing was a problem for me too. Office staff file these for dozens of patients and mix-ups happen. Worth verifying as a matter of routine.

0 coins

Pregnancy and standard DI claims work differently and I want to flag this because some people land here searching about pregnancy leave and the terms don't always match up. For pregnancy, EDD typically expects you to file about four weeks before your due date and the post-birth certification period is different depending on the delivery type. For a non-pregnancy disability like a surgery recovery, the timeline is based on what your doctor certifies.

0 coins

Due date is coming up in a few months and I've been googling to figure out when to file. Four weeks before is good to know — does that mean the SDI benefits start four weeks before or that's just when you submit the claim?

0 coins

That's when you submit, not when benefits start. Benefits for pregnancy typically start when your doctor certifies you can't work, which is often about four weeks out, but EDD goes by the certification, not the filing date alone. File early enough to give the system time to process.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. So the filing and the actual benefit start date can be different things.

0 coins

Something I had to learn the hard way was that SDI and unemployment can't both run at the same time for the same days. I tried to file for unemployment while on disability because I'd also lost my job and I genuinely didn't know you had to pick one. EDD was clear — disability is for days you can't work, unemployment is for when you can work and are looking. Once I was medically cleared I filed for unemployment from that point forward.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about that crossover at all. My job is still there waiting for me so it's not an issue, but good to know.

0 coins

HR at your employer is also the right call for questions about job protection while you're out. EDD handles the payment side, but whether your position is protected is between you and your employer and state leave law.

0 coins

I got confused about this too and went to EDD's site and found the same thing — one benefit at a time. If you're still unable to work, stay on DI.

0 coins

When EDD sends a letter requesting a response, the return address on the envelope matters. The form or letter itself will say where to send your response. Don't mail anything to a general EDD address — whatever the notice says, use that address.

0 coins

Good catch. I was about to look up EDD's main address.

0 coins

The form will also sometimes say whether they want it faxed or submitted through SDI Online instead of mailed. Read all the way through before you send anything.

0 coins

Bonding leave after a medical recovery gets confused with PFL sometimes — Paid Family Leave is a completely separate program for things like bonding with a new baby after a pregnancy disability claim ends. If your situation is a surgery recovery, PFL doesn't apply here. Just flagging it because the terms show up together a lot and some people assume SDI and PFL are the same thing.

0 coins

No baby involved here, strictly a recovery situation. But I appreciate the clarification because I had seen PFL mentioned in a few EDD articles and wasn't sure if it was related.

0 coins

They share the SDI program umbrella but they're separate claims with separate purposes. For a standard recovery you're in DI territory start to finish.

0 coins

The EDD site at edd.ca.gov does a decent job of explaining both programs separately if you want to read through the difference. The DI section covers everything for a surgery or illness recovery.

0 coins

Whatever the letter turns out to be, keep every piece of mail EDD sends and note the date you received each one. If anything goes sideways and you need to appeal something down the road, having that paper trail organized by date makes a big difference. Thirty days sounds like a lot of time until it isn't.

0 coins

Creating a folder for it right now. I'd already tossed the envelope from my Notice of Computation before I realized I should be keeping everything.

0 coins

Envelopes matter too in an appeal situation because the postmark can establish when EDD sent something versus when you received it. If there's any gap, that can matter for the 30-day appeal window.

0 coins

Learned this during my own appeal. The date on the notice is what the 30-day clock runs from, not when you got it in the mail, so if delivery was slow that window shrinks in practice.

0 coins

SDI Online's Request Claim Update feature inside myEDD is underused. You pick your claim, choose the update type, write your question, and EDD replies to that specific claim. For something like asking what a letter means or whether a response was received, it leaves a record in the system and doesn't require you to get anyone on the phone.

0 coins

Haven't used that yet. Can you send documents through it too or just messages?

0 coins

Primarily messages tied to your claim, but the reply from EDD also shows up in the same thread so you have a record of both sides. For documents, the form or notice will usually specify how they want it submitted.

0 coins

Sent a Request Claim Update when my medical certification was showing as still pending and EDD responded within a couple of days confirming it had been received but not yet matched. Useful to know the status before sitting on hold.

0 coins

Came back to update on the extension thing mentioned earlier — my doctor eventually submitted the DE 2525XX and EDD picked it up without any extra action on my part once it was in. The timing just had to match what EDD had on record as my original end date. If your surgeon's office is going to certify additional weeks, make sure they know what end date EDD has on file, not just what the original certification said.

0 coins

That's reassuring. I'll make sure the surgeon's office knows to look at what EDD has rather than just their own notes.

0 coins

The doctor's office may not automatically check EDD's record — you might need to tell them the end date EDD shows in SDI Online so they certify the right period on the DE 2525XX.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure