Does private short term disability denial affect SDI payments require repayment from California EDD?
So my employer offers a private short term disability plan through some insurance carrier, and I filed with both them and California EDD when I went out for a back issue a few months ago. EDD approved me and I've been getting paid. Last week the private insurer sent me a denial letter saying they aren't covering it. Now I'm spiraling a little because I don't know if the private denial somehow loops back to EDD and messes up my SDI claim, or if EDD is going to come after me for repayment because the other plan said no. Anyone dealt with this before? Do these two things even talk to each other?
78 comments

Luca Romano
EDD's SDI program and your employer's private plan are separate from each other. The private insurer's denial has no bearing on what California EDD decides about your DI claim. EDD approved you based on your own medical certification and your earnings record, not on what a private carrier concluded. Your SDI payments should continue as long as your claim remains valid on EDD's side.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorThat's genuinely a relief to hear. I was imagining some notification going to EDD automatically.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Same situation last year, private plan denied me, SDI kept paying. Separate worlds.
0 coins
NebulaNova
The private plan doesn't report to EDD. They have no connection.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Worth checking EDD's site to confirm, but from everything published there, California's SDI is funded entirely by the CASDI deduction workers pay, and your eligibility is judged on your own wages and your doctor's certification. A private carrier's decision isn't part of that calculation. Your Notice of Computation was based on your base period wages, nothing else.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Does that mean even if the private plan later reverses and approves me, EDD wouldn't take back what they already paid?
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
That's a question worth raising directly with EDD, because how they treat a concurrent private payment isn't something I'd want to guess at. Ask EDD through SDI Online or call the disability line to get a clear answer for your specific claim.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
I'm kind of scared of that too, not sure if getting money from two places at once would trigger something.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Payment date on my own claim was sitting blank in SDI Online for almost two weeks and I couldn't reach anyone no matter what I tried. Tried that disability line six mornings in a row and got the recording every single time. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally talked to an actual EDD agent. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and told me the payment had issued that morning and to allow a few days for it to post to my card. That was the first useful answer I'd gotten in two weeks.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
When you got through, did they verify anything specific before they'd give you account info?
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Just confirmed my SSN and claim ID. Pretty standard. Agent had my account up pretty fast after that.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Been dialing that 1-800-480-3287 number every morning for a week and a half. Can't get past the busy signal.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
The private plan denial shouldn't trigger anything on the EDD side, from what I've seen with clients going through this. But I would keep a copy of that denial letter just in case EDD ever has questions about overlapping coverage later. Document everything when it comes to SDI stuff.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorAlready scanned it. Good call, I'll keep it with my claim paperwork.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
Keeping your denial letter is really smart. Paper trails matter a lot with EDD claims.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
EDD doesn't know what the private carrier decided and doesn't ask. Two different systems.
0 coins
Mei Lin
yeah exactly its not like the private insurer calls edd to tattle on you lol
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Confirmed from my own claim in October. Private supplemental plan had a delay and EDD never blinked.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Wait, I'm confused about something related. My HR said the private plan is supposed to coordinate with SDI somehow. Does that mean EDD adjusts your payment down if the private plan pays you too? I'm on a pregnancy claim and filing both right now and now I'm nervous.
0 coins
Luca Romano
The coordination question is worth asking EDD directly because how a private employer plan interacts with SDI can depend on whether the employer has a Voluntary Plan arrangement, which is a separate setup some employers have through EDD. That's beyond what anyone here can answer reliably for your specific situation. Contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or the disability line.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Your HR using the word 'coordinate' probably means your employer's plan was designed to top off SDI, not replace it. But the actual mechanics of how EDD handles that are employer-plan-specific, so EDD is the right place to ask.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Okay I'll message through SDI Online. I didn't want to call because the line is brutal.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
DE 2593 landed in my mailbox and I almost missed the 20-day return window because I didn't know what it was. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask whether my form had been received after I mailed it. The agent confirmed they had it logged and my continued eligibility was fine. What to have ready if you try it: your claim ID and the date you mailed the form.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
My DE 2593 is due next week and I want to confirm EDD got it once I mail it. Going to try Claimyr for that. What else should I have on hand besides the claim ID?
0 coins
GalacticGuru
The mailing date and the address you sent it to, just in case the agent needs to check the right processing office. That was all they needed from me.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
didnt even know that form existed until this thread. been on claim two months already
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
HR told me the private plan would offset SDI but then the private plan denied me anyway, so I was paying attention to this thread. The private denial didn't change anything on my EDD side as far as I can tell.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorThat's exactly my situation. HR said the same offset thing. Good to know the EDD piece held.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Offset language in employer plans usually means the private insurer subtracts whatever SDI pays from what they owe you. If the private plan denies you, the offset math becomes irrelevant and SDI stays what it is.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Makes sense when you put it that way.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
The waiting period thing tripped me up when I first filed. I thought the seven days were processing time, not an actual non-payable stretch. Lost a week expecting payment that was never coming for those days.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Wait, so that first week is just gone? No matter what?
0 coins
Luca Romano
Every new DI claim has a seven-day waiting period at the start. Those days aren't paid, that's EDD's rule, not a delay. The first payable day is the eighth day of your disability. Processing time on top of that is separate.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
Yep, the first seven days are just gone. I wish someone had told me before I filed.
0 coins
Mei Lin
ugh same nobody explained that to me either
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
If EDD decides something is wrong with your claim they send a Notice of Determination. Until you get one of those in the mail saying otherwise, your approval stands regardless of what the private carrier did.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorHaven't gotten any notice so I'm going to take that as a good sign.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
No news from EDD is usually good news on a running claim.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
November 4th my medical certification showed received in SDI Online, and by November 14th the first payment posted. That 14-day window EDD mentions is roughly accurate in my experience. For anyone watching their pending status, the medical cert date is the one to track.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Mine has shown received for nine days. So maybe five more to go. I keep refreshing SDI Online every few hours.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
The refresh cycle is real. Nine days in with the cert logged sounds like you're in reasonable shape.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Nine days with cert received is well within what I'd expect. The two-week window starts from when both parts of the claim are complete.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Private plan denied me two years ago, SDI kept going the whole time. Never got any kind of notice from EDD about it. The two have nothing to do with each other as far as EDD is concerned.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorTwo years ago tracks. Good to hear it from someone who's been through it.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
That's the clearest real-world confirmation of this. EDD didn't blink even then.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Not sure if this is a dumb question but can the private insurer appeal to EDD on their behalf somehow to cancel your SDI if they don't want to pay? Like can they force a denial on the state side?
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Private insurers have no standing to appeal or interact with EDD on your DI claim. EDD's process runs between you, your licensed health care provider, and EDD. The private carrier isn't part of it.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Okay that makes me feel a lot better. I was imagining the worst.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
They can't. EDD doesn't take calls from private insurers about your claim.
0 coins
Mei Lin
my coworker had the exact same thing happen, private plan said no and edd kept paying her the whole time. she never heard anything from edd about it
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorGood to hear another real-life example. I'll stop catastrophizing.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Two independent systems. The private plan talks to HR, EDD talks to you.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
Notice of Determination came in my mailbox after my private plan appeal went sideways and I panicked thinking EDD had caught wind of it somehow. Used Claimyr to get through on the EDD disability line and the agent confirmed the determination was about my own claim's start date, completely unrelated to the private plan situation.
0 coins
Sofia Morales
That start date thing on a determination is exactly what I ran into on my own claim. Used Claimyr too after getting nowhere on my own, and once the agent confirmed which weeks were actually paid out on my account, I realized I'd miscounted the waiting period days and thought I was owed more than I was. Had to do some math and then it made sense.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
been trying that disability line for three weeks straight. maybe its finally time to try something different.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorKnowing the determination was about the start date and not the private plan thing would have calmed me down immediately. Glad you got a clear answer.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
For the original question, here's the cleaner way to think about it: your SDI claim was approved on your own merits, your wages, your medical certification, your eight-day waiting period. The private insurer evaluated a completely different contract with different rules. One decision doesn't feed into the other.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorFraming it as two separate contracts makes it click. Appreciate that.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
That framing is exactly right and probably the most useful way to explain it to someone panicking about this.
0 coins
Amara Nnamani
Your employer's HR might have told you the private plan 'coordinates' with SDI but that language describes how the employer designed their benefit, not how EDD operates. EDD approved you, issued payments, and that determination stands on its own until EDD changes it.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
HR language and EDD language are really not the same thing. Learned that the hard way with my pregnancy claim terminology.
0 coins
Luca Romano
Exactly right. 'Coordination of benefits' is an insurance industry term. EDD has its own rules and doesn't apply private carrier coordination logic to your SDI.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
If you're really worried, the most direct route is to send a message through SDI Online using Request Claim Update, describe what happened with the private plan denial, and ask EDD directly whether it affects your open claim. Gets it in writing and gives you an official answer.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorGoing to do exactly that today. At least then I'll have EDD's own answer on record.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
SDI Online's Request Claim Update is the right path. Log in through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ if you haven't set that up yet.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Always better to have it in writing from EDD than to rely on what HR said.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
If EDD ever does send you something in writing that you disagree with, the Appeal Form is included with the Notice of Determination and you've got 30 days from the date on the notice to get it in. That's the window that matters.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
Author30 days from the notice date, got it. Haven't received anything concerning yet but keeping that in mind.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
Don't sit on it if one does show up. 30 days goes fast when you're dealing with everything else.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
What if you miss the 30 days? Is it over?
0 coins
Luca Romano
A late appeal can still be submitted but you'd need to explain the reason for the delay. An administrative law judge reviews whether the late filing is accepted. Better not to test it if you can avoid it.
0 coins
Giovanni Mancini
just want to say the private plan denial question is way more common than i thought. been seeing variations of this question for months and the answer always seems to be: edd doesnt care what the private carrier said
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
Pretty consistent answer across a lot of different circumstances, yeah.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Because they're genuinely unrelated. Not EDD being generous, just two separate legal frameworks.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
From a practical standpoint: watch your SDI Online account for any new notices and keep certifying or returning your DE 2593 on schedule. As long as you stay current on your end, the private plan situation shouldn't create any disruption.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
AuthorDE 2593 is on my radar now after seeing it mentioned. Didn't even know that was a thing before this thread.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
The DE 2593 arrives after your tenth week of benefits if you're on automatic payment. You have 20 days to return it. Mark a reminder as soon as it shows up.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Ten weeks in and automatic payment, then the DE 2593 shows up. Good to know that's coming.
0 coins