Does a doctor have to sign off on disability in California EDD?
Tore something in my shoulder at the gym about three weeks ago and my orthopedist has me completely off work while I wait for surgery. My job is physical so there's no modified duty or desk option. I finally got around to filing the SDI claim through SDI Online last week and now I'm stuck on this one thing. The claim form had my part done pretty quickly but then it asks about a doctor certifying. Does a doctor have to sign off on disability to actually get paid, or is my word enough that I can't work? My surgeon's office has been kind of slow responding and I'm worried this whole thing stalls out if I'm waiting on them.
76 comments

Ella Russell
Your surgeon's office does need to submit the medical certification — that's the part EDD needs before they'll pay anything. When you filed on SDI Online you got a receipt number at the end. That number is what your doctor's office uses to find your claim and submit their side of it. If you haven't already, call the office and give them that number so they can pull up the claim and complete it. EDD needs both the claimant part and the provider's certification to move things forward.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorGot it, I did save that receipt number. I'll contact the surgeon's office today and make sure they have it. Do they fill it out on paper or is it also done online?
0 coins
Ella Russell
Both options exist. Most offices these days submit through SDI Online directly, which is faster. Some still mail the paper version. Either way the receipt number lets them match it to your claim.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Confirming the receipt number is the key piece here. My physical therapist's office initially tried to submit without it and EDD couldn't match it to my claim at all.
0 coins
Gavin King
Wait — did you say your physical therapist submitted? EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim doesn't actually include physical therapists. They're not among the licensed professionals EDD recognizes for this. You'd need your orthopedist or surgeon to certify it.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Oh wow, I had no idea. The PT said they did it but maybe they meant they forwarded something to the doctor. I honestly don't know what ended up happening, the claim did go through eventually. But yeah, good point — you need a doctor or someone on EDD's approved list, not just any healthcare provider.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
To add to what was said above: EDD has a specific list of who can certify. It includes MDs, DOs, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, dentists, psychologists, and licensed midwives for pregnancy-related stuff. For your shoulder situation your orthopedist or surgeon is exactly the right person. They'd submit the medical certification confirming you can't do your regular work and how long they expect that to last.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorSurgeon it is then. They already have all the info about the surgery timeline so hopefully it's not a huge lift for them.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Offices that do this regularly usually have someone on staff who handles SDI certifications, it's not a new thing for them. Give them the receipt number and they'll know what to do.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
DE 2500E came on a Friday but the actual deposit didn't post until the following Tuesday, so I wanted to know exactly which date EDD considered the payment issued. Called the disability line using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to a live agent, and the agent pulled up my claim and told me the specific date the payment was released on their end. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ On your question though — yes, the medical certification is non-negotiable. No cert, no payment. My claim sat untouched until the certification was matched.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThanks for that. I'm going to push the surgeon's office hard today. Good to know the cert is literally the thing blocking payment.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
The two-week payment estimate they give doesn't start until BOTH parts are in. Some people count from when they filed their claimant part and then wonder why nothing happened — the clock really starts when EDD has the full claim including the certification.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Two weeks is an estimate, not a guarantee. Mine took a bit longer. But yes the certification being in is what starts any of it.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
One thing worth knowing: your surgeon has until 49 days after your disability started to submit the certification. So if you got injured three weeks ago, the clock has been running. Not trying to stress you out but it's worth making sure the office doesn't sit on it thinking there's infinite time.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Author49 days total from when I got hurt, not from when I filed? So I've already used about three weeks of that window?
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Exactly right. The 49-day window runs from your disability start date, not from when you filed the claimant form. You filed a week ago so you have time, but the office needs to submit their part before that window closes or you could be disqualified.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Worth adding: you also had to file within 49 days of your disability start date yourself. Since you filed last week and got hurt about three weeks ago, you're fine on your end. Just get the doctor's side in soon.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Also keep in mind the first seven days of your claim don't pay anything regardless of how fast everything gets submitted. That's the waiting period — it's just not payable, it's not a processing delay. So if your disability started three weeks ago your first payable day was day eight, and EDD will calculate from there once the cert is in.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorSo those first seven days are just gone, not paid?
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Right. Every new DI claim has that one-week non-payable window at the start. It doesn't mean anything went wrong, it's just how SDI is set up.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
I mixed this up when I filed — thought the waiting period was processing time and kept expecting payment to start sooner. Nope, those days are genuinely just not covered. Good to know going in.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
This gets confused a lot. The waiting period and the time it takes EDD to process are two different things. You're waiting for processing AND you're not getting paid for the first seven days even after everything is processed.
0 coins
Lara Woods
My situation was similar — out for a knee replacement, orthopedist had to certify. The office told me they'd submitted but EDD showed pending for almost two weeks. Eventually it cleared. What I'd suggest is staying in touch with the surgeon's office and also checking SDI Online regularly. EDD sends a Notice of Computation once things are matched, so that's usually how you know the certification came through on their end.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorWhat does the Notice of Computation tell you exactly?
0 coins
Lara Woods
It shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts based on your wage history. It doesn't mean you're definitely approved — just that EDD has calculated what you could receive. Actual payment comes after.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
The notice comes from your highest-paid quarter in the base period they look at. If yours looks low, check EDD's disability calculator on their site to see what you expected before assuming something went wrong.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox after my fifth automatic payment — I hadn't heard about that form before and panicked thinking something was wrong with my claim. Had an agent confirm through EDD's disability line using Claimyr to reach them what it was: the agent told me it's the continued eligibility questionnaire they send at the ten-week mark and I had 20 days to return it or benefits would stop. Got it back in the mail the same day. For the certification question though: no cert submitted means claim literally does not process. It's not just a delay, it goes nowhere.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorGood to know about that form — I'll watch for it once I'm further into the claim. And yeah, calling the surgeon's office is my first move today.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Had no idea about the DE 2593 either until someone in another thread mentioned it. 20 days goes fast if EDD mails it and it takes a few days to arrive.
0 coins
Eli Butler
I've seen people assume that if the doctor fills out FMLA paperwork the SDI certification is handled too. It's not. Those are completely separate. The SDI medical certification is specifically for EDD and goes through SDI Online (or mailed directly). Your doctor's office needs to know to do both if you need both.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorMy HR actually mentioned FMLA and I was wondering if it crossed over. So FMLA protects the job, SDI is the actual pay replacement through EDD — different forms entirely?
0 coins
Eli Butler
Exactly. FMLA is federal job protection through your employer. SDI is California's income replacement through EDD. Same disability, two separate processes. EDD doesn't care about your FMLA paperwork and your employer doesn't get the SDI cert.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
For anything about FMLA or CFRA job protection, HR or the Civil Rights Department's CFRA page is the right place to look. EDD handles the SDI income side only.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
If the surgeon's office is dragging their feet you can try asking them specifically for whoever handles SDI certifications. Some offices route that to a billing coordinator or a medical assistant rather than the doctor reviewing it themselves. The doctor still signs off but it moves faster when you're talking to the right person.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThat's actually a really useful tip. I've been leaving messages for the main desk. I'll ask if there's someone specific.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Agree with this. Big orthopedic practices especially tend to have a designated person for insurance and disability paperwork. Gets there much faster.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Also worth asking what their usual turnaround is for SDI certifications. Some offices say 5–7 business days as a standard thing. If you know that going in you're not anxious every day wondering.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Heads up: once EDD has both parts and your claim starts moving, your payment can go to a Money Network prepaid debit card or you can set up direct deposit through SDI Online. If you haven't picked a payment method yet, logging into myEDD to set up direct deposit early might save you a little time later.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorI'll set that up. Didn't even know direct deposit was an option — I assumed it would just mail a check.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Direct deposit is available because you filed through SDI Online. Paper filers don't get that option. The Money Network card also works fine, but direct deposit is usually faster once payments start.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
I had a Bank of America EDD card from a while back and was confused when this claim used Money Network. EDD switched to Money Network for the debit card — it's not BofA anymore.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Been through this twice now — shoulder surgery last year, then a separate issue this past spring. Both times the medical certification was the thing holding everything up, not EDD's processing time. First claim the office submitted in four days, smooth. Second time they took almost three weeks and I had to go in person to light a fire under them. Keep pushing.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorTwo claims in a year, that's rough. I appreciate the firsthand comparison — sounds like the office speed is really the variable.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Without question. The SDI process itself was about the same both times once the cert was in. The difference was entirely the office.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
Going in person is underrated. Email and voicemail are easy to deprioritize. Showing up tends to get things moving.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
Notice of Determination came through on my claim after I'd been waiting and I didn't understand what it meant. Got through to a disability agent and the agent told me my claim hadn't been approved — the determination was a denial because EDD said the information on file wasn't sufficient. The agent also said I had 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal using the DE 1000A form. Long way of saying: if your claim gets a Notice of Determination instead of moving to payment, read it carefully. It's not the same as a Notice of Computation. I used Claimyr to get through on that call when the regular line wasn't connecting.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThat's scary. What was missing from your claim?
0 coins
Alice Coleman
The certification my provider submitted didn't match the dates I put on my claimant form. Small discrepancy but EDD flagged it. The appeal sorted it out — I gathered the original form, my supporting paperwork, and mailed the DE 1000A within the window.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
This is why the receipt number matching matters so much at the start. A mismatch like that can cause exactly this problem. Better to catch it early than deal with an appeal.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
30-day appeal window is strict. If your notice date is on a Friday, start counting from that Friday, not when you receive it in the mail.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Quick flag on the person who mentioned physical therapists earlier: EDD's certified provider list doesn't include PTs. Only the providers on EDD's list can submit the medical certification. For a shoulder injury like yours, your orthopedist or surgeon is squarely on that list as a licensed physician. Just making sure that's clear since the PT point came up in the thread.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorYep, surgeon is who I'm going with. Already sent a message to their office this morning with the receipt number attached.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Good. That's the right move. Once they submit through SDI Online it should start to clear up pretty quickly.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Something that might help set your expectations: EDD's target is usually to process things within about two weeks of getting a fully completed claim — both your part and the certification. So the two-week clock starts when both are in. If your surgeon submits in a few days you could be looking at payment in maybe three weeks from now give or take. Not a promise, just roughly how it typically goes.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorThree weeks feels manageable. I have a little in savings and my surgery is scheduled so at least I have a rough sense of the timeline now.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Use the EDD disability benefits calculator on their site if you want a rough sense of the weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives. It uses your highest-earning quarter from your base period. The notice will give you the official number but it helps to have a ballpark.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Knowing even a rough weekly amount helps with budgeting while you wait. Much better than just guessing at zero.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
My whole experience with SDI filing was messier than it needed to be because I didn't understand that the doctor part and my part were submitted separately. I thought when my employer filled out some paperwork the whole thing was handled. Nope. The employer doesn't have a role in the SDI filing process at all. It's between you and EDD, and separately between your doctor and EDD.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorMy employer actually handed me a stack of forms too and I wasn't sure what was what. So the SDI claim is entirely separate from whatever HR is doing?
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Completely separate. Your employer might have their own short-term disability or leave paperwork, and FMLA or CFRA paperwork runs through HR, but the SDI claim through EDD is just you and your provider. EDD doesn't loop in the employer.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Important clarification and it trips a lot of people up. The employer packet is usually about job protection and their own records. The SDI income replacement is a separate filing entirely with EDD.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
EDD disability vs workers' comp question because someone earlier touched on separate programs: if you got hurt AT work, workers' comp is what covers you, not SDI. If the shoulder happened at the gym like this person said, that's non-work-related and SDI is correct. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorGym injury so yes, non-work-related, SDI is right. Good clarification though because I could see that being confusing.
0 coins
Sofia Price
I had a coworker who got hurt at work and tried to file SDI. The claims overlap question is complicated, but you're right that they're different programs for different situations.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
The process you're in is exactly normal for SDI. File your part, give the receipt number to the provider, provider submits their certification, EDD matches them, claim starts moving. It feels opaque while you're waiting but it's a defined sequence. The certification is the last piece you're missing.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorKnowing the sequence helps. I think I was scared it was more complicated than it is.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
The complication usually comes from the doctor's office, not EDD's side. Once both parts are in EDD's system the process is fairly predictable.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Agreed. And for what it's worth, follow up with the surgeon's office in writing if you can — a text or email creates a record that you asked and when.
0 coins
Julia Hall
Logging in to myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ regularly while you wait is worth doing. SDI Online shows the claim status and you'll see it update when the certification comes in. Better to watch it there than to call and wait on hold trying to find out if EDD got the cert.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorI've got the myEDD login set up. I'll check it every couple of days.
0 coins
Lara Woods
Status updates don't always happen in real time but they're usually a good indicator. When you see the status shift you know things are moving.
0 coins
Julia Hall
EDD also typically reaches out within about 14 days after the medical certification is received to let you know where the claim stands. So check SDI Online and also watch for mail.
0 coins
Arjun Patel
For anyone worried about whether their provider is on EDD's approved list: the safest bet for a physical injury is a licensed medical doctor, which covers your orthopedist and surgeon. Nurse practitioners and physician assistants can also certify. The list is broader than people expect but it does have limits — your certifier needs to be working within their licensed scope.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
AuthorSurgeon is definitely covered. I feel a lot better about where this stands now.
0 coins
Gavin King
The scope of license point is key. A provider who is on the list in general still has to be certifying something within what their license covers. Your orthopedic surgeon certifying a shoulder injury is as clean as it gets.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
To close the loop from earlier in the thread: PT not on the list, orthopedist and surgeons squarely on it, NPs and PAs also yes. That's the core group most people run into.
0 coins