Do I have to pay taxes on disability from California EDD?
Two months into my SDI claim after a back injury kept me out of my warehouse job, and I just got my first real look at how much I've been receiving. My coworker mentioned offhand that I might owe taxes on all of it and now I can't stop thinking about it. I know my regular paycheck always had that CASDI deduction taken out, so I figured the benefits themselves wouldn't be taxed again. But I honestly have no idea if that's true or if I've been wrong this whole time. Do I have to pay taxes on disability payments from California EDD? State taxes, federal taxes, both? I don't want to get blindsided come tax season when I'm already trying to get back on my feet financially.
77 comments

Ella Thompson
California state income tax on SDI benefits is zero — the state does not tax them, and that part is pretty settled. The federal side is the one that depends on your own situation, and for that EDD has a tax information page worth reading and a tax professional is really the right person to give you a straight answer on your federal return. What I'd say is don't panic about owing a huge amount — just pull up EDD's site and look at their tax information section so you know what questions to bring to a tax preparer.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThat's a relief about the state side at least. I had no idea there was even a split like that between California and federal. I'll look up the EDD tax info page before I do anything else.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
Came here thinking the same thing as the original poster. My disability claim started mid-year so I wasn't sure if I'd get some kind of form from EDD or if I just had to remember the amounts myself.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
EDD's tax information page addresses the form question too, so that's worth checking. A tax professional can walk you through what applies to your specific federal situation once you have that information.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
49 days was the number that stressed me out when I first filed — I had no idea my doctor's office had that tight a window to submit the medical certification. I ended up calling to confirm they'd done it. Anyway on the tax question: California definitely doesn't tax your SDI benefits, and for federal, EDD's tax page lays out the scenario. I'd bookmark that page and then ask a tax pro because the federal answer can vary.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThe 49-day window for the medical certification is news to me too — I think my provider got it in earlier than that but I didn't even know there was a deadline. Good to know for any extension I might need down the line.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
I had no idea the doctor had a separate deadline, I thought once I filed my part I was done. Ended up calling my provider's office two days before it would have been a problem.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
Exactly — your receipt number from SDI Online is what the provider looks up to find your claim and submit their part. If they don't have it, the certification can't be matched to your claim.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
Notice of Determination arrived in my mailbox about three weeks after I filed, saying my claim wasn't payable, and I had no idea what step to take or whether I'd even filed the right forms. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to the disability line — the hold times had been impossible every time I tried on my own — and an EDD agent pulled up my claim and told me the medical certification hadn't been matched to it yet, so they flagged it for me to follow up with my provider. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The Notice of Determination came with a DE 1000A appeal form and the agent said to appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice if I still disagreed after the certification issue was resolved.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorA denial notice three weeks in sounds awful. Good to know the appeal form comes attached — I would have no idea where to find the DE 1000A on my own.
0 coins
Chris King
30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it. That window moves fast, especially if the mail is slow, so opening EDD mail the day it arrives is worth making a habit of.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
The agent was clear it was 30 days from the date printed on the notice itself, so I counted from there and filed the appeal with the DE 1000A and a written explanation.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
My Notice of Computation showed up before I even thought about the tax question, and looking at the weekly amount on it was the first time the tax angle crossed my mind. The short answer I found is California doesn't take state income tax out of SDI benefits, and for federal you really want someone who knows your whole tax picture. EDD's tax page is the place to start before you go to a preparer.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
I read somewhere online that SDI is completely tax-free across the board and I was about to tell my wife that. Good thing I saw this thread first — the federal piece is apparently not that simple.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
The state side is settled — California doesn't tax it. Federal is the part where it depends on your own situation, which is why EDD's tax info and a professional are the right tools rather than a forum answer.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorSaving the distinction: state = no tax, federal = depends, check EDD's site and ask a tax pro. That's exactly the kind of clear framework I needed before I started second-guessing every deposit.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
Eight weeks out from my surgery and still on SDI when my employer's HR person mentioned I should be tracking my benefit amounts for tax time. I was completely confused because I'd assumed disability was just not taxed, full stop. Turns out that assumption only holds cleanly for California state taxes. The federal question depends on your own numbers and situation, so I'd go to EDD's tax information page and then a tax professional.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
I assumed the same thing — that the CASDI deduction coming out of my paycheck meant the benefits couldn't be taxed again. I think that reasoning holds for California state tax but the federal side is its own analysis.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
The CASDI payroll deduction does factor into the analysis, which is part of why the federal answer depends on individual circumstances. That's honestly just more reason to bring it to a tax professional rather than guess.
0 coins
Sophia Long
My HR person also brought this up and I had no idea what she meant. I thought disability benefits were just replacement income and treated the same as wages. Apparently it's more nuanced than that.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
My first week on disability I spent more time worrying about tax implications than actually resting, which my doctor was not thrilled about. The main thing that settled me down: EDD's own tax information page exists specifically for this question. California state taxes — not owed on SDI benefits. Federal — depends on your situation, go to a professional. That's as far as anyone here can responsibly take it.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorHeard. I think I was catastrophizing a bit. I'll pull up the EDD site tonight and get the actual tax info page, then find a preparer for the federal side.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
The catastrophizing is so real when you're already stressed about being out of work. At least the California answer is clean and simple.
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
There's a misconception I want to clear up that I've seen in a couple places: some people think that since you paid into SDI through your CASDI paycheck deduction, the benefits automatically come back tax-free at every level. California follows through on that logic for state taxes — no state income tax on SDI benefits. The federal government has its own framework that doesn't track the state's approach one-for-one, which is why EDD's tax page and a tax professional are the right resources for the federal piece.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
I had been making exactly that argument to myself — paid in through CASDI, so it's tax-free all around. Good to have the actual distinction laid out. State yes, federal is a separate question.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
My coworker was absolutely certain the CASDI logic covered federal too and I nearly repeated it to my own HR. This thread probably saved me an embarrassing conversation.
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
The CASDI reasoning is intuitive and it's right for California state purposes. It just doesn't map onto federal rules the same way, which is why the professional advice path exists.
0 coins
Harper Thompson
My claim finally moved from pending to paid last week after what felt like forever, and the first thing I did was google the tax question. Found a lot of conflicting information before landing in a thread like this one. The consistent answer from people who actually know: California does not tax SDI benefits for state purposes. Federal is a depends-on-your-situation question that EDD's tax info page and a tax professional can answer for your specific numbers.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThe conflicting information online is exactly why I ended up posting here. At least the California state answer is consistent across every reply in this thread.
0 coins
Harper Thompson
The state answer is clean. Federal is the one with variables, and I'll be taking my numbers to a preparer this year rather than guessing.
0 coins
Caleb Stark
Pending to paid is its own relief. I remember refreshing SDI Online constantly that last week before my payment showed up. Good that you landed on the right answer about taxes before you started filing.
0 coins
Jade O'Malley
Receipt number on my claim form didn't match what my provider's office had on file, so my medical certification sat unmatched for almost two weeks. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr after the hold line had me going in circles — the agent looked up my claim ID and told me the receipt number my provider had used was off by one digit, which is why the certification hadn't posted. Once my provider resubmitted with the right receipt number the claim moved forward. On the tax question: same as everyone here, California state taxes don't apply to SDI benefits, and for federal you need EDD's tax information page and ideally a tax professional.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
A one-digit difference in the receipt number held up your whole claim for two weeks. That's the kind of thing you'd never figure out just from staring at SDI Online.
0 coins
Jade O'Malley
The agent could see exactly which receipt number had come in from the provider and that it didn't match my claim ID. Without that, I would have kept waiting with no idea what was stuck.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThe receipt number thing is a genuinely useful warning. I gave mine to my provider's front desk but I never confirmed they had it entered correctly on their end.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
Employer told me when I went on leave that my SDI payments 'wouldn't count' for taxes, and I took that as gospel for three months before I started actually researching it. For California state income tax they were right — SDI benefits aren't taxed at the state level. For federal, that blanket 'doesn't count' statement is too simple. EDD has a tax information section and a tax professional is who you want for a definitive federal answer on your return.
0 coins
Sophia Long
My employer said something almost identical and I also just accepted it. The state piece holds up, the federal piece is more nuanced, and 'your HR person said so' is not the same as a tax professional said so.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
HR is great for a lot of leave questions but tax advice on federal disability income is not really their lane. EDD's page plus a preparer is the right path for that piece.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Waiting period thing that tripped me up early: those first seven days of a new SDI claim are unpaid regardless, so there's no tax question on them anyway — there's nothing to tax. The wait isn't processing time, it's literally a non-payable period built into every new claim. First payment-eligible day is day eight. Just mentioning it because it changes the calculation of how much you're actually receiving versus how much you expected.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
I thought the waiting period was how long it takes EDD to review everything and that my benefits would be backdated to day one once approved. Finding out day one through seven just aren't paid at all was a rough realization.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Completely different things. Processing time is how long EDD takes to review your claim after the medical certification is in. The waiting period is a mandatory unpaid week that every new claim has built in — the eighth day is when payable benefits start.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorI actually did know about the waiting period before I filed, but I can see how easy it is to mix those two things up, especially when the SDI Online screen just says pending without explaining why.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
The pending screen really does not help you understand what's happening. I had no idea whether I was in the waiting period or in a processing queue or whether something was wrong.
0 coins
Chris King
Five automatic payments came and went on my claim and then EDD sent a form I didn't recognize — the DE 2593. Turns out you have to return that within 20 days or your benefits can stop. I nearly missed it because it looked like junk mail. Not directly about taxes, but staying on top of your claim forms matters a lot when you're depending on those payments.
0 coins
Sophia Long
I had no idea a form like that existed. I've been on automatic payments for about six weeks and now I'll be watching the mail a lot more carefully.
0 coins
Chris King
EDD sends the DE 2593 after the tenth week of payments — so around the five-payment mark on automatic payment. It's a continued eligibility questionnaire and the 20-day return window is strict. If yours doesn't come in that window, call EDD.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
My DE 2593 came in an envelope that looked like it could have been an ad. I almost recycled it. Now I open every piece of EDD mail immediately.
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
Payment date on my claim showed as issued in SDI Online but nothing had hit my Money Network card after several days. Called EDD through Claimyr to ask an agent to look at the payment record — the agent confirmed the date the payment had been issued and which weeks it covered. The card issuer processing time is separate from EDD's issuance date, and the agent told me to give it a few more business days. On the tax question from the original post: California state taxes don't apply to SDI, and for federal you need EDD's own tax information and a tax professional.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThe SDI Online 'issued' date not matching when you actually receive funds on the card is confusing. I'd been treating those as the same thing.
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
The agent explained EDD issues the payment on a certain date and that shows in SDI Online, but the card has its own processing timeline after that. So the SDI Online date is not the date the money is available.
0 coins
Harper Thompson
I was also confused about the Bank of America debit card I'd heard people mention for EDD payments. Someone in another thread told me EDD's card is now through Money Network, not Bank of America anymore.
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
Correct — EDD's payment card is Money Network now. If someone sets up direct deposit through SDI Online they can skip the card entirely, but the default for SDI is the Money Network card.
0 coins
Caleb Stark
My claim was for a pregnancy leave starting about four weeks before my due date, and the tax question came up pretty quickly once my payments started. The state answer is consistent: California does not tax SDI benefits. For federal, pregnancy disability benefits run through the same analysis as any other SDI claim, and EDD's tax information page is where I'd start before going to a preparer.
0 coins
Sophia Long
I'm currently on pregnancy disability and hadn't thought about the tax angle at all. Good to know the state answer is settled and that EDD has a dedicated tax info section I can check.
0 coins
Caleb Stark
The state piece you can consider handled. The federal piece — just go to EDD's tax page first so you know what questions to bring to your preparer. It's a lot less stressful than trying to piece together forum answers.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
DE 2500A showed up every two weeks on my claim because I wasn't on automatic payment, and each one asked me to certify I was still unable to work. The certification process kept my payments moving, but every time I filled one out I wondered whether the amounts were affecting my taxes. Same answer as above — California state income tax doesn't apply to SDI benefits, and I'd point to EDD's tax information page and a professional for the federal question.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
I didn't know there were two different certification systems — automatic payment where EDD sends the DE 2593 at the ten-week mark versus the every-two-weeks DE 2500A. How does someone end up on one versus the other?
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
I honestly don't know exactly how EDD assigns which one — my claim just came with the DE 2500A from the start. That's probably a question for EDD directly since it may depend on the type or length of your claim.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
Extension on my claim came up when my doctor said I needed more time than originally certified. I didn't file a new claim — my doctor submitted the DE 2525XX, which is the supplementary certificate. EDD sends that form with the final payment notice, so watch for it. Getting the extension in before your current certification period ends matters a lot for keeping payments going without a gap.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorI had no idea there was a specific form for the extension or that EDD sends it to you. I was under the impression I'd have to start over with a whole new claim if I needed more time.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
No new claim needed — same claim, the provider submits the DE 2525XX. EDD sends it along with your final payment notice, so if you think you'll need more time, tell your provider to expect that form.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
I made this exact mistake — assumed I'd need to refile everything. Would have reset my waiting period if I'd done that. Good to know the extension keeps everything on the same claim.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
The waiting period is per new claim, so staying on an extension of the existing claim avoids going through another unpaid week. That's one of the bigger reasons not to close out a claim prematurely.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
SDI versus unemployment got confusing for me when my coworker suggested I apply for unemployment while I was still out on disability. Those two can't cover the same days — EDD is explicit that you can't collect both for the same period. While you're unable to work you'd be on SDI, and unemployment comes into play when you're able and available to work again.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
I had been thinking about this wrong — I assumed I could stack them or at least transition immediately. Knowing that unemployment requires you to be able and available to work makes the distinction a lot clearer.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
Exactly right. Disability is for the days you can't do your regular work. Unemployment is for when you can work but don't have a job. They're sequential, not parallel.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Someone at my work tried to file for both at the same time and ended up with a whole mess to untangle. EDD catches overlapping days and it creates problems on both claims.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
Maximum claim length is worth knowing about alongside the tax question: SDI pays out for up to 52 weeks of disability benefits on a single claim. Beyond that you'd need to look at other options. Within those 52 weeks, the California state tax situation on what you receive stays the same — no state income tax — and the federal question stays the same — EDD's tax page and a professional.
0 coins
Sophia Long
52 weeks is longer than I realized. I had it in my head that SDI was a short-term thing measured in a few months. That's a meaningful difference for a serious injury.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
It caps at 52 weeks, not at a specific number of months. The benefit amount is based on earnings from a base period — a 12-month window looking at your four highest quarters — and what you're eligible for is on your Notice of Computation.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
Workers' comp came up briefly in my claim because my injury happened at a job site, and I wasn't sure if that made it a workers' comp case instead of SDI. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time, but there are exceptions. My situation ended up being SDI, but that determination came from actually working through the right channels, not from guessing. If there's any overlap in your situation, don't assume — ask EDD and your employer directly.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
I was in a similar gray area and also had no idea which program applied. The workers' comp versus SDI question is not something I'd want to get wrong since the whole claim depends on it.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
Right, and getting it wrong can delay your benefits significantly in either direction. The right answer comes from EDD and from whoever handles workers' comp in your situation, not from what a coworker heard.
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
Bonding leave came up in my situation after my wife's pregnancy disability ended, and someone in HR mentioned Paid Family Leave as a next step. PFL is a separate claim from SDI — it has its own application and there's no waiting period on the PFL side. The SDI pregnancy disability covers the period your provider certifies you as unable to work, and bonding starts after that. Worth knowing they're two different claims with different processes.
0 coins
Caleb Stark
I had been thinking PFL was just an extension of my SDI pregnancy claim and that it would continue automatically. Finding out it's a separate filing was important — I would have let the bonding window close without acting.
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
PFL doesn't roll over from SDI automatically. You file PFL separately through SDI Online when the disability period ends and you want to claim bonding time. The tax situation on PFL benefits would also be its own question for EDD's tax page.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
AuthorThe SDI versus PFL confusion is everywhere. I appreciate having it laid out clearly in the same thread as the tax question since they obviously connect for anyone coming off a pregnancy claim.
0 coins