Back to California Disability

Dmitry Kuznetsov

Do I certify for SDI if employer insurance already paid disability?

So my company has a short-term disability plan through our HR benefits and they paid out for the first few weeks I was out recovering from a back procedure. Now I'm looking at my SDI Online account and there's a certification step and I genuinely don't know if I'm supposed to complete it. Like, does getting the employer insurance payout mean I already handled the disability claim side, or are these two completely separate things and I still need my doctor to submit the medical certification through SDI Online? I don't want to mess up my claim by skipping a step I was supposed to do, but I also don't want to file for something twice if that's not how it works. Has anyone dealt with both at the same time?

Filing through SDI Online and receiving benefits under your employer's short-term disability plan are two separate things entirely. Your employer's plan is a private arrangement, and California EDD's State Disability Insurance is a state program funded by the CASDI deduction on your paycheck. You need to complete the SDI certification step regardless of what the employer plan paid. Your doctor still submits the medical certification through SDI Online, and EDD reviews the claim on its own. The two programs don't cancel each other out, though how any overlap in payment is handled is something EDD determines on your claim specifically.

0 coins

So I still need to get my doctor to submit through SDI Online even though HR already processed their side? I'll call the doctor's office today.

0 coins

Yep, the SDI certification step is yours to handle with EDD regardless of what HR did. Two completely separate tracks.

0 coins

Does EDD even know about the employer plan, or do you have to tell them? I'm in a similar spot and have no idea if I need to disclose that somewhere.

0 coins

EDD asks about other income and benefits on the claim form, so answer those questions honestly. Beyond that, EDD makes its own determination based on your case.

0 coins

Start date on my claim got flagged and I couldn't figure out why the dates EDD had didn't match what my doctor submitted. Spent three mornings trying that disability line and kept getting the busy signal recording. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got on the phone with an actual EDD agent. Video on reaching someone at EDD's disability line if you want it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the start date they had on file was two days off from what my doctor put on the medical certification, which is why things stalled. Once I knew exactly what the mismatch was I could have the office resubmit with the right date.

0 coins

The start date mismatch, did EDD tell you which date they were going off of, theirs or your doctor's?

0 coins

They told me the date that was sitting on my claim in their system, and that's the one that didn't match what the doctor's office had sent. So I took that specific date back to the office and they corrected it on the certification.

0 coins

Been hitting that line since Tuesday. Four tries, same result every time. Might look into what you used.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something here because the employer plan question comes up a lot. A voluntary or employer-funded short-term disability plan is different from California's SDI program. SDI is funded through that CASDI line on your pay stub, money you paid in, and the certification process through SDI Online is how EDD processes your claim for those benefits. The employer plan doesn't complete that process for you. You still need the medical certification submitted by your provider, and you still have the seven-day waiting period at the start of your SDI claim before the first payable day.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period, is that seven calendar days from when I stopped working or from when EDD gets the certification?

0 coins

Calendar days from when your disability began, the first day you couldn't do your regular work. The waiting period is baked into the claim, not tied to when EDD processes the paperwork.

0 coins

So even if EDD gets everything fast, you don't get paid for those first seven days no matter what?

0 coins

Correct, EDD's site is clear that the first seven days of every new DI claim are a non-payable waiting period. The eighth day is the first day benefits can actually be paid.

0 coins

The overlap question is real and EDD is not super clear about it upfront. If your employer plan paid you full wages, EDD still runs SDI as its own program, but how the payment amounts work out for weeks where you got both is EDD's call, not something you can figure out from the form alone. What I'd do in your position is make sure the medical certification is submitted, then watch SDI Online for the Notice of Computation, which tells you what your weekly benefit amount is. That's the actual number to compare against what the employer plan paid.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet. Is that normal while the claim is still pending?

0 coins

Completely normal. The Notice of Computation usually comes after EDD processes the certification. Once your doctor submits and EDD reviews it, the notice shows up.

0 coins

Mine came in the mail like ten days after the certification went through. Gives you a clear picture of what the benefit amount should be.

0 coins

Don't skip the certification. Even if the employer plan covered you, you paid into SDI from every paycheck and you're entitled to file. Get your doctor to submit through SDI Online and let EDD sort out the rest.

0 coins

This. The CASDI deduction funds SDI specifically. You paid into it.

0 coins

Yeah that's how I'm thinking about it now. I'll make sure the doctor's office has the receipt number from when I filed.

0 coins

my employer plan paid me for 2 weeks and then edd kicked in after, it wasnt a problem just had to make sure the dates were right on both sides

0 coins

Did you have to do anything special on the SDI side to flag that the employer plan had already paid, or did it just work out?

0 coins

i just answered the questions on the form honestly and it worked out, nobody called me or anything

0 coins

The medical certification is the step most people get wrong in this situation. Your doctor or provider needs to find your claim in SDI Online using the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A. If they don't have that number they can't link the certification to your claim. Confirm with the doctor's office that they have it before they try to submit.

0 coins

My doctor's office said they'd handle it but I never gave them a receipt number. I need to check on that immediately.

0 coins

Look in SDI Online under your claim. The receipt number is there. Give it to them before they try to submit anything.

0 coins

Is the receipt number the same as a claim ID or is it a different thing entirely?

0 coins

They are different. The receipt number is what you get right after filing Part A, before EDD assigns a claim ID. Your provider uses the receipt number to find your claim and submit the medical certification.

0 coins

Certify through SDI Online no matter what the employer plan did, that part is on you and your doctor. The employer plan is HR's thing. SDI is EDD's thing. Two separate trains.

0 coins

yeah the employer plan doesnt touch the edd process at all

0 coins

Exactly, anyway, the main thing is making sure the receipt number gets to the doctor so the certification actually links up.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my injury claim came out lower than I expected and I had no idea which quarter EDD used to calculate it. Couldn't get anyone at 1-800-480-3287 for days. Tried Claimyr and an EDD agent picked up. She told me which quarter of my base period they'd pulled the wages from and confirmed the weekly benefit amount on the notice was correct based on those wages. At least I knew then that the number wasn't a mistake, just a low quarter.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation is sitting here and I can't tell if the amount is right for my situation either. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when the agent answers?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your Notice of Computation in front of you. The agent will reference specific dates and amounts, so you want to be able to follow along and ask about any number that doesn't match what you expected.

0 coins

The base period calculation is on EDD's site too if you want to estimate first. The disability benefits calculator there can give you a rough idea before you talk to anyone.

0 coins

You are definitely supposed to certify through SDI Online! The employer plan doesn't replace EDD's process at all. Think of it as two separate pots, the employer plan is what your company set up, and SDI is the state program your paycheck funded through the CASDI deduction. File with both if you're eligible for both!

0 coins

Yep. File both, let EDD do their thing.

0 coins

I feel better about this now. Going to get the receipt number to my doctor's office today.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up on a past claim was assuming the employer plan days and the SDI waiting period overlapped cleanly. The SDI waiting period is the first seven days of your disability, those days are not payable under SDI regardless of what the employer plan did. So if your employer plan covered day one through fourteen, EDD's first payable day under SDI is still day eight, not day fifteen.

0 coins

So the waiting period starts from my first day of disability, not from when the employer plan stopped paying?

0 coins

Correct. Day one of your disability is day one of the waiting period for EDD. Day eight is the first day SDI can actually pay, independent of the employer plan's timeline.

0 coins

I was totally confused about this. I thought the waiting period was EDD processing time. So it's literally just seven days of the claim that never get paid?

0 coins

Right, it is a non-payable period built into every new DI claim, not a processing delay. EDD's FAQ spells it out if you want to find it on the site.

0 coins

My coworker went through almost the exact same thing last year, employer plan paid her for a few weeks and then she did the SDI claim on top of it. She said the main thing was just being honest on the forms about what the other plan paid and EDD handled the rest. She didn't have any problems as long as the certification was in.

0 coins

Honestly that's reassuring. I think I was overthinking whether filing SDI would cause some kind of conflict with HR.

0 coins

The HR side and the EDD side really do stay in their own lanes mostly. Just keep the certification step moving.

0 coins

Employer plans and SDI have coexisted as long as either has existed. File, certify, let EDD decide.

0 coins

Short and right.

0 coins

what he said

0 coins

Make sure your provider is on EDD's list of who can certify a disability claim. It includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and a few other licensed professionals depending on the condition. If the wrong type of provider submits, EDD won't accept the certification.

0 coins

My doctor is an orthopedic surgeon so I assume that's fine, but I had no idea there were limits on who could certify.

0 coins

Orthopedic surgeon is fine. The ones to watch out for are physical therapists, they're not on EDD's approved list.

0 coins

Physical therapists came up in a thread I saw where someone's claim got delayed because the PT submitted instead of the MD. Ended up needing the actual physician to redo the certification.

0 coins

If the certification doesn't show up as received in SDI Online after a few days, call the doctor's office and confirm they submitted and have the right receipt number. Don't wait two weeks to follow up.

0 coins

How do I check in SDI Online if the certification was received? Is there a specific place to look?

0 coins

Log in through myEDD, open SDI Online, and look at your claim status. It'll reflect when the medical certification has been received on EDD's end.

0 coins

Weeks on my claim showed paid in SDI Online but the amount for one week looked off. Tried phoning EDD a dozen times over two weeks. Used Claimyr and talked to an agent who went through which weeks they had on record as paid and the amount for each. Turned out one week had been partially processed because I'd reported a couple days back at work and EDD had prorated it. Made sense once I had the breakdown.

0 coins

The prorated week thing happened on my claim too. I had one week that showed less than the rest. Used Claimyr for it as well. The agent confirmed the medical certification EDD had on file was the one my doctor submitted on the twelfth, matched up correctly, and that the low week was just the partial return-to-work amount being applied. I went back through my claim notes after and it tracked.

0 coins

The partial week calculation caught me off guard too. How long were you at it before you tried that?

0 coins

About nine days of trying the line before I went another way.

0 coins

Is there a deadline to get the medical certification submitted? Like if my doctor's office is slow about it can my claim get messed up?

0 coins

Your provider needs to submit the medical certification no later than 49 days after your disability began. Missing that window can disqualify the claim, so it's worth following up with the office if you haven't heard anything.

0 coins

49 days from the start of my disability, not from when I filed Part A?

0 coins

From when your disability began. Same clock that applies to when you file your own Part A. Both parts of the claim need to be in within that 49-day window.

0 coins

I filed my Part A pretty quickly so I think I'm okay on the timeline, but I'm going to confirm with the office that the certification went in.

0 coins

Something I got confused about early on was thinking EDD and an employer's insurance plan were somehow connected, like EDD would see what the employer plan did and adjust automatically. They don't share that information. EDD runs its own determination based on your claim and your base period wages. The employer plan is completely separate.

0 coins

That's exactly the assumption I had. I thought they were somehow linked through payroll or something.

0 coins

They're funded differently, administered by different entities, and report nothing to each other. The only connection is you, the claimant, and what you report on the forms.

0 coins

DE 2525XX had been sitting with my doctor's office for two weeks and I was losing track of whether it had gone to EDD or not. Tried the EDD disability line a few times over several days and the line either rang out or the recording ended the call. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent. She told me the extension form hadn't been received yet as of that date and that my claim was going to run out if it didn't come in. Went straight to the doctor's office that afternoon with that information and they submitted it the same day.

0 coins

Two weeks and the line just ended the call every time. That tracks with what I've been dealing with. I'm not sure anything gets through on that line.

0 coins

The agent I spoke to worked for EDD, picked up my claim right away, and had all the information in front of her. I don't know why the line itself is so hard to get to.

0 coins

That extension form timing is tight. Good that you found out before the claim ran out.

0 coins

if your employer plan is a voluntary plan through work you might want to double check how that interacts with edd, i heard its different somehow but im not sure exactly how

0 coins

For anything specific to a voluntary plan, the best move is to ask EDD directly how it applies to the particular claim. The rules can vary and EDD makes the determination on the individual case.

0 coins

yeah thats probably smarter than guessing

0 coins

The SDI certification process and the receipt number question are worth knowing cold before anything else. EDD's SDI Online guidance says clearly that your provider uses the receipt number from Part A to find and submit the medical certification. Without that number, the certification floats in the system unmatched. I'd put the receipt number in your provider's hands before they try to submit anything.

0 coins

Got the receipt number out of SDI Online this morning and texted it to the doctor's office. They confirmed they'll submit today.

0 coins

That's the step! Once the certification links up everything else can move forward.

0 coins

Good. Now just watch SDI Online for the certification received confirmation and then the Notice of Computation after that, anyway.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX, it covers extending a claim when recovery takes longer. Not a new claim, just the same claim going further. Your treating provider handles it, not you.

0 coins

Good to know in advance in case my recovery timeline runs long. I'll ask my surgeon about it at my next appointment.

0 coins

Just to close the loop on the original question. You certify for SDI regardless of what the employer plan paid. The two are separate programs. File your Part A, get your doctor to submit the medical certification through SDI Online with your receipt number, and EDD runs its own determination from there. That's the whole process.

0 coins

Receipt number is with the doctor's office as of this morning. Certification should go in today. Really appreciate everyone walking through this.

0 coins

You got the right answer. Good luck with the recovery.

0 coins

Hope it goes smooth from here.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure