Back to California Disability

Diego Flores

Can you apply for disability before surgery in California EDD?

So my orthopedic surgeon has me scheduled for a procedure on my shoulder in about three weeks and my whole recovery is supposed to be 8 to 10 weeks where I can't do my job at all — I work in a warehouse and there's no modified duty option. I've been reading around and I'm genuinely confused about when I'm supposed to file. Do I file my SDI claim now before the surgery happens, or do I have to wait until after and then file? I don't want to miss some deadline or do it in the wrong order and mess up my benefits. Has anyone gone through this and figured out the right timing?

The timing tripped me up too when I had my hip replaced last year. I thought I had to wait until I was already out of work to do anything, so I didn't touch SDI Online until three days after my surgery date — ended up fine but I was stressed. What EDD actually says is that you should wait until nine days after your disability starts before filing, and your disability start date is the first day you can't do your regular work. For a scheduled surgery that's usually the day of the procedure itself. You also have up to 49 days from that start date to file without getting disqualified, so you have a window, but earlier is better. The 49 days also applies to your doctor submitting their medical certification, so make sure your surgeon's office knows they need to get that in through SDI Online too.

0 coins

So my start date would be the actual surgery day, not today while I'm still working? That makes a lot more sense. I was worried I had to file immediately.

0 coins

Yep the disability start date is when you're actually unable to work, not when you find out you're having surgery. Had the same question before my appendix situation.

0 coins

Notice of Computation came about a week after I got my claim filed and my surgeon's office sent in the certification — that's the letter that shows what your weekly benefit amount could be. What I didn't understand at first was that it isn't your approval, it just tells you the potential amount based on your wages. I'd been trying to get through to EDD to understand what the figures on mine meant, couldn't get anyone on the line for three days straight. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to an actual EDD disability agent who pulled up my claim and walked me through which quarter of my earnings they used for the calculation. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ The agent told me the base period they were looking at and confirmed the certification had been received. I stopped panicking after that.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation part is helpful — I didn't know that wasn't the actual approval. So after I get that letter I still have to wait to hear if I'm actually approved?

0 coins

Exactly right, the notice just shows numbers, your actual eligibility gets determined separately and you'll see payments start coming through or get a different notice if there's a problem.

0 coins

I had the same confusion with my claim, got the notice and thought I was done waiting when really it was just starting.

0 coins

Pre-surgery filing is something a lot of people ask about and there's a specific answer. You cannot file before the disability begins — meaning you can't file today for a surgery happening in three weeks. The form in SDI Online, the DE 2501 if you go paper, asks for your disability start date, and EDD needs that date to exist before you submit. Nine days after that start date is when filing opens. So your window opens nine days after surgery day and runs to 49 days after surgery day. Mark both on your calendar now so you don't forget in the post-op fog.

0 coins

Nine days after surgery day — got it. I'll set a reminder. What do I actually need to have ready when I log into SDI Online to file?

0 coins

Your myEDD login, your employer's name and address, your last day of work, your surgery date as the disability start, and your doctor's name and contact info so they can find the claim. After you submit you'll get a receipt number — give that to your surgeon's office right away so they can submit their part.

0 coins

The receipt number thing is so important. My doctor's office lost mine the first time and the certification sat unmatched for two weeks before anyone figured out why.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was just EDD processing time and kept expecting my money to show up during it. Someone here corrected me on another thread and I want to pass it along: the first seven days of your claim are a non-payable waiting period, meaning EDD intentionally doesn't pay those days — it's not a lag in their system, it's baked into the program. Your first payable day is the eighth day of your disability. For a shoulder surgery that's about a week after your procedure, so plan for that gap before any money moves.

0 coins

Okay so the first week is just gone no matter what? That's annoying but at least I know to plan for it.

0 coins

Yeah there's no way around it, every new claim has that seven-day period. Had my ACL surgery and thought the same thing you did before someone set me straight.

0 coins

I didn't realize it was every new claim. I was out twice in one year for related stuff and had to serve it both times.

0 coins

Something my HR person got wrong when I had my procedure — she told me to file through the company's short term disability and also file SDI at the same time. I can't speak to how those two interact because honestly EDD is the one who decides that, but I do know SDI is completely separate from whatever your employer offers. File SDI directly in SDI Online, don't assume your HR is managing any part of that for you. Some employers have their own voluntary plans but the SDI Online filing process is yours to handle.

0 coins

My company doesn't have anything like that so I think I'm just going straight SDI. Good to know I'd be doing it myself regardless.

0 coins

Definitely check with HR just to be sure, but yeah for most warehouse jobs it's straight SDI.

0 coins

HR at my last job also said something wrong about SDI timelines. I'd just go straight to edd.ca.gov and trust that over anyone at the office.

0 coins

The medical certification part is what almost derailed my claim. My surgeon submitted his part but used an old version of the form and EDD didn't match it to my claim for almost two weeks. When you give your surgeon's office the receipt number from SDI Online, ask them specifically to submit through SDI Online, not paper. The online submission is way faster to get matched to your claim. If they insist on paper, the provider completes Part B of the DE 2501 and mails it — just know it'll take longer.

0 coins

I'll definitely push for online. My surgeon's office is pretty tech-forward so I think they'll do it that way.

0 coins

Most bigger practices have it set up already. The receipt number is what they need to find your claim on their end.

0 coins

My physical therapist tried to submit mine and EDD rejected it. Apparently physical therapists aren't on the list of providers who can certify a DI claim. Had to go back to my actual physician.

0 coins

That's right — EDD has a specific list of who can certify. It's physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, and a few others depending on the condition. Physical therapists aren't on it, so the physician or surgeon has to be the one to sign off.

0 coins

Went into my claim thinking I'd be on workers' comp because it happened at a gym while I was doing something for work travel. EDD sorted it out but the short version is: if the injury is work-related, it's workers' comp territory, not SDI. A shoulder surgery for something not work-related, which sounds like your situation, is straight SDI. If yours was somehow work-related you'd want to talk to your employer about a workers' comp claim instead.

0 coins

Mine is totally unrelated to work, it's a degenerative thing. So SDI is the right path.

0 coins

Then you're in the right place. File SDI as soon as your window opens after surgery day.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid on my claim got confusing fast — I was part-time near the end of my recovery and wasn't sure how EDD counted those weeks. The automated line at 1-800-480-3287 gives payment info but it didn't have the detail I needed about partial weeks. Got Claimyr to get me in with an EDD agent who pulled up the specific weeks on my claim and confirmed which ones had been issued and which were still pending. For pre-surgery planning like the original question, what matters is that partial return to work has to be reported to EDD and they determine how a partial week gets paid.

0 coins

Good to know about the partial return to work piece. My recovery might have a phase where I can do some light desk work before I'm fully back.

0 coins

Report it when it happens, don't try to figure out ahead of time exactly what you'll get — EDD is the one who calculates that based on what you report.

0 coins

I made the mistake of not reporting a couple of hours I worked during my recovery and then got an overpayment notice. Not worth it, just report everything.

0 coins

My sister told me to file for Paid Family Leave instead of SDI for my surgery and I'm glad I didn't listen. PFL is for taking care of a family member who's ill or bonding with a new baby, not for your own medical situation. For your own surgery and recovery you want DI, which is the disability side of SDI. Easy to mix them up but they're separate programs with different purposes.

0 coins

I had seen PFL mentioned somewhere and wasn't sure how it fit. So for my own shoulder surgery it's definitely DI, not PFL.

0 coins

Exactly. PFL comes up sometimes after a pregnancy claim ends and someone wants bonding time — that's when DI transitions to PFL. For your surgery it doesn't come into the picture at all.

0 coins

I mixed these up at first too. The names are confusing because they're under the same SDI umbrella but they really are different claims.

0 coins

Before my knee surgery I called EDD thinking I could pre-register or something and get ahead of everything. The rep I spoke to said pretty clearly there's nothing to do before the disability starts — you can set up your myEDD account and get familiar with SDI Online, but you can't initiate the actual claim until after surgery day and after the nine-day window opens. What I did do ahead of time: created my myEDD login, found my employer's EDD account number on my pay stub, and printed out what my surgeon would need to submit the certification. Showed up to my pre-op appointment with all of it.

0 coins

Setting up myEDD in advance is a great idea. I'll do that this week so it's ready to go when my window opens.

0 coins

Takes maybe ten minutes and saves scrambling later. The SDI Online portal is inside myEDD once you're logged in.

0 coins

I wish I'd done this. Filed my claim from a hospital bed on my phone three days post-op because I hadn't set anything up and it was way harder than it needed to be.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up for me around the end of my initial certified period — that's the extension form my surgeon submits if you need more time off than originally certified. My recovery hit a complication and my doctor said I needed six more weeks on top of the original estimate. I'd heard that you have to file a whole new claim and I was dreading it. EDD actually sends the extension form with your final payment notice, and your doctor submits it; you don't start over. Had an issue where I couldn't tell whether my doctor's office had sent it in yet and the SDI Online status wasn't clear to me, so I used Claimyr to get an EDD agent on the line who checked my claim and confirmed the DE 2525XX had been received and which weeks it covered.

0 coins

Really glad you mentioned extensions — my surgeon has already said there's a chance I need more time depending on how the repair looks. So I'd just have her submit that form and my claim continues?

0 coins

That's how it works. You don't file a new claim. The physician/practitioner completes and sends in the DE 2525XX. EDD sends that form to you along with the notice about your final payment so you can pass it to your doctor.

0 coins

I didn't know extensions worked that way. I was about to tell my doctor to file a whole new claim for my extra weeks.

0 coins

Don't do that — it'll create a mess. Same claim, extension form, doctor handles their end.

0 coins

The 49-day deadline is the one people most often miss when they're recovering from surgery. You're focused on healing, maybe in pain, and suddenly three or four weeks have gone by and you haven't filed yet. The clock starts from your disability start date — the surgery day — and runs 49 days. Your doctor has the same 49-day clock for their medical certification. If your surgeon's office drags their feet or doesn't know they have to submit online, you can end up with a gap that's hard to fix. I'd hand the receipt number to the office at your post-op appointment and confirm they've submitted it within a few days after that.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the doctor having their own 49-day deadline too. I'll be way more explicit with my surgeon's office about the timeline.

0 coins

Be specific with them. Some offices are great about it and some have never heard of SDI Online. The more information you give them upfront the better.

0 coins

I was on unemployment when my injury happened — came off my job and then needed surgery — and I tried to stay on unemployment through my recovery because I figured it was money coming in. Someone at EDD explained that you can't collect unemployment and disability for the same days. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work. If you're recovering from surgery and can't work, you're in DI territory, not unemployment. I had to transition my claim and it added time, so just know going in which program fits your situation.

0 coins

I'm still employed, just taking leave for the surgery, so unemployment doesn't apply to me. Good to know that distinction though.

0 coins

Yeah if you're employed and coming back after recovery, SDI is your whole situation. The unemployment crossover mostly confuses people who lose their job right around the same time as a medical thing.

0 coins

My neighbor went through that exact overlap and it was really complicated. Best to get EDD on the line to sort out which claim applies to which days.

0 coins

Payment timing is something to think about now while you're planning. Most payments come within two weeks after EDD gets both your claim and the medical certification. If your surgeon submits the certification quickly and you file right at the nine-day mark, you're probably looking at payments starting around week three or four of your recovery. That's money you won't have for the first couple of weeks, plus the seven-day waiting period. Plan your expenses with at least a two to three week gap in mind from surgery day before anything hits your account.

0 coins

Two to three week gap is helpful to know. I have enough saved to cover that but it's good to actually plan for it rather than assume money shows up immediately.

0 coins

A lot of people assume it's faster than it is. Having that buffer makes the whole thing less stressful.

0 coins

Payments go to a Money Network card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online. Set up direct deposit when you file so you're not waiting on a card in the mail on top of everything else.

0 coins

Payment method was something I didn't set up before my claim processed and I ended up waiting longer than I needed to. If you file through SDI Online you can choose direct deposit right when you submit. The default is a Money Network prepaid debit card which gets mailed to you. If you want the money to go straight to your bank account, pick direct deposit during the filing process — you can also update it in SDI Online after the fact but do it as early as possible.

0 coins

Setting up direct deposit when I file — adding that to my checklist.

0 coins

It's one of the steps in SDI Online during the filing flow, easy to miss if you're rushing through it.

0 coins

I got the Money Network card because I didn't know about the direct deposit option. It actually worked fine but direct deposit would have been faster for me.

0 coins

I kept confusing myself trying to figure out how much I'd get paid before I even filed. The percentage is somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your wages from a specific base period depending on your income level, but the actual number is on your Notice of Computation after you file, not something you can know exactly beforehand. EDD has a benefits calculator on their site that gives you an estimate if you want a rough idea while you're planning, but don't treat it as the real number until you see the notice.

0 coins

I'll use the calculator to get a ballpark. Nice to have some estimate before I'm actually out of work.

0 coins

Just go to edd.ca.gov and search disability benefits calculator. It asks for your quarterly wages from about a year back so have your pay stubs or W-2 handy.

0 coins

The base period looks at a specific 12-month window ending a few months before your claim starts, not your most recent pay. The calculator walks you through it.

0 coins

My surgeon's office actually told me to file for SDI before the surgery so my claim would be in the system earlier. I did it and EDD rejected the initial submission because there was no disability start date that had passed yet. Had to refile after the surgery. The person above who said you can't file before the disability starts is correct — no matter what your doctor's office tells you, the system won't accept a claim for a date that hasn't happened.

0 coins

Good real-world confirmation that pre-surgery filing doesn't work. I'll stay patient and file on day nine.

0 coins

The office was trying to help but they don't deal with EDD's rules every day. Set a reminder for day nine and you'll be fine.

0 coins

Automatic payments are something that wasn't explained to me when I filed. After five payments — which is about ten weeks — EDD sends a form called the DE 2593, the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire. You have to return it within 20 days or your benefits stop. For a shoulder surgery with 8 to 10 weeks of recovery you might not hit that mark, but if your recovery extends at all you will. Keep an eye out for it in the mail.

0 coins

I had no idea about that form. 20 days is tight if you're not watching the mail. I'll make a note.

0 coins

EDD will also send you a final payment notice when your certified period is running out, and that's also when the extension form comes if your doctor needs to certify more time.

0 coins

I missed the DE 2593 and my payments stopped for two weeks. Had to get EDD on the line to sort it out. It restarted but there was a gap. Watch for that envelope.

0 coins

Filing online through myEDD is the fastest route — EDD says it's their preferred method and in my experience the SDI Online system is pretty straightforward once you're in. Paper forms take longer to process and you're adding mail time on top of everything. For someone who has a surgery scheduled and can plan ahead like you're doing, file online on day nine, give the receipt number to your surgeon, and check SDI Online every few days to see when the medical certification shows as received.

0 coins

Online filing it is. I already have a myEDD account from when I looked at something else a while back so I just need to get back into it.

0 coins

If you haven't logged in recently you might need to reset your password or verify your identity again. Do that before surgery while you're still feeling normal.

0 coins

The question of whether you get paid for the actual surgery day confused me. The surgery day is your disability start date, and the first seven days including that day are the non-payable waiting period. So no, the surgery day itself is not a paid day — but it's also not wasted, it's just the start of the clock. Your first payable day is day eight.

0 coins

Okay so surgery day starts the clock, the first seven days don't pay, and day eight is the first payable day. That actually clicks now.

0 coins

That's exactly it. And the nine days before you can file your claim overlap with that waiting period, so you're not really sitting around waiting before you file anyway.

0 coins

Worth noting that the waiting period is specific to DI claims. If you end up filing for PFL afterward for bonding or something, that program doesn't have one — but that's a separate situation from your surgery.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure