Back to California Disability

Finley Garrett

Can SDI use out of state earnings to increase benefit amount?

So I moved to California about a year and a half ago from out of state and worked there for about eight months before relocating. After I got here I picked up a job pretty quickly and have been working for about ten months now. I just had a procedure done and my doctor says I'll be out for at least six weeks. I filed my SDI claim but my Notice of Computation showed a weekly benefit amount that felt really low, and I think it's because EDD only counted my California wages. I'm wondering if the out of state earnings I had before moving can get factored in somehow to push the benefit amount higher. Has anyone dealt with this? I really can't afford to only get a fraction of what I was making.

The base period EDD uses pulls from wages that had California SDI deductions taken out, the CASDI line on your California paystubs. Wages from another state don't have that deduction, so they don't count toward your SDI benefit calculation. The Notice of Computation reflects only what was earned under California's system. EDD's benefit calculator on their site can help you see how the quarters break down if you want to check the math yourself.

0 coins

I was afraid of that. So basically the eight months I worked before moving just disappear as far as SDI is concerned?

0 coins

For SDI purposes, yes. Those wages weren't subject to the CASDI deduction, so they fall outside the base period entirely. Your benefit amount is built from whatever California quarters you have.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense even though it's frustrating. At least now I know I'm not missing something.

0 coins

The base period looks at four specific quarters ending about five to seventeen months before your claim start date. If your California employment started ten months ago, some of those quarters might still be thin or empty. The quarter with your highest California wages is what drives the weekly amount on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

So if my highest California quarter was like the last few months before I got hurt, that's what they're basing it on?

0 coins

Exactly. Whichever of the four quarters in the base period had the most California wages is the one EDD uses to estimate your weekly benefit. The notice itself should show you those figures so you can see which quarter landed on top.

0 coins

The notice lays it all out. Worth reading it line by line instead of just looking at the bottom number.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim sat unmatched for two weeks because my doctor's office used the wrong reference when they went into SDI Online. Spent four mornings hitting redial on 1-800-480-3287 before the line either rang endlessly or dropped. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got to talk to someone at EDD. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my doctor had entered didn't match the one generated when I filed, which is why the certification was just floating. I gave the office the right number and it matched up the same day.

0 coins

Claimyr worked the same way for me. Tried that disability line on three separate days and got nowhere, so I went a different route. Agent I reached looked at my Notice of Computation and confirmed which quarter EDD had flagged as the highest-earning one for my base period, since the number on my notice looked off to me.

0 coins

Can I ask what you told the agent when you got on, like did you need your claim ID or anything specific?

0 coins

Had my Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the Notice of Computation in front of me. Agent found everything immediately.

0 coins

The receipt number thing is something I didn't even think about. My surgeon's office said they submitted but I never confirmed they had the right number.

0 coins

Before the medical certification can be matched, the provider needs the exact receipt number you received after submitting Part A in SDI Online. It is not the claim ID number that shows in your account dashboard. If the office has the wrong one, the certification simply does not attach to your claim.

0 coins

Wait, those are two different numbers? I think I might have given my doctor the wrong one. How do I find the receipt number now?

0 coins

Log into myEDD and open SDI Online. The receipt number was displayed when you first submitted your claim and should still be accessible there. If you cannot locate it, the SDI Online message system under Request Claim Update can help you sort it out.

0 coins

Found it, it was different from what I sent them. Calling the office right now.

0 coins

Ten months of California wages going into an SDI claim after a move is a pretty common situation. The benefit amount comes out lower than people expect because half that base period window might be quarters with no California earnings at all.

0 coins

My client said the same thing happened to her. Moved mid-year and then got sick a few months later and was shocked at how small the number was.

0 coins

It catches a lot of people off guard. The only wages that build the base period are ones that had CASDI withheld.

0 coins

Knowing the reason doesn't make it less stressful but at least I'm not waiting around for EDD to fix something that isn't broken.

0 coins

Your California wages over those ten months do still count, so the benefit isn't zero or anything. It just reflects what actually had SDI deductions on it. If your highest California quarter was solid, the weekly amount might be better than you think once you look at the Notice of Computation quarter by quarter.

0 coins

My last quarter before the procedure was my best. I picked up extra shifts, so fingers crossed that moves the number a little.

0 coins

Extra shifts in that final quarter could genuinely help since the highest quarter is the one that sets the rate. Worth checking the calculator on EDD's site to estimate it.

0 coins

out of state wages dont have casdi taken out so edd cant count them, your stuck with whatever california quarters you have

0 coins

That part's right, but one small add: the calculation uses the highest single California quarter in the base period, not all four quarters combined. So if one quarter is significantly stronger than the others it makes a real difference.

0 coins

ok yeah that tracks, one good quarter matters more than i thought

0 coins

Payment date on my second check never showed up in SDI Online and I had no idea if it was issued or stuck somewhere. Tried the automated line a few times but it just gave me the same canned status. Tried Claimyr and spoke with an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and told me the payment for those two weeks had been issued and gave me the date it went out, which helped me figure out it was a timing issue on the deposit end rather than an EDD hold.

0 coins

This reads like a sponsored post to me. EDD's automated line gives payment info at 1-800-480-3287, so why would you need a third party to find that out?

0 coins

Honestly I thought the same thing at first but I tried Claimyr myself when my claim went quiet for a week and a half. Agent confirmed my waiting period had ended and that the first payable week was the one I thought it was, which I hadn't been sure about. Cleared it up fast anyway.

0 coins

The automated line gave me nothing useful three times in a row. Fine, I'll look into it.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me too before this thread. Good to hear there are ways to actually get answers.

0 coins

The automated line at 1-800-480-3287 covers basic payment info. If your question is about why the amount is what it is, you need a person. The Notice of Computation explains the math but if you can't follow it, calling in and asking is the move.

0 coins

How do you even get a live person on that line? Every time I call I either get the recording or it hangs up.

0 coins

8 a.m. sharp, Monday through Friday works better than later in the day in my experience. No trick to it, just persistence.

0 coins

Called at 8 on four different mornings and still got dropped twice. The line is brutal.

0 coins

The benefit amount thing is tricky when you've moved states! EDD's calculator is actually pretty useful for running your own numbers before the official notice comes in.

0 coins

I wish I'd run the numbers earlier. Would have been less of a shock when I saw the notice.

0 coins

For sure! At least now you know what's driving it and can plan around it.

0 coins

EDD doesn't combine with another state's program. California SDI is funded entirely by the CASDI deduction on California paychecks. No CASDI, no credit.

0 coins

Worth adding that this also means if you ever go back to your previous state you'd have to build up wage history there too before their disability program would cover you at full rate.

0 coins

Yep. Each state's program is its own bucket.

0 coins

My coworker moved here from out of state a couple years back and ran into the exact same thing. She said her Notice of Computation was way lower than expected and panicked. Turned out she had two strong California quarters in the base period though and the amount ended up being fine. Definitely worth running the numbers.

0 coins

Two strong quarters makes a difference then. I had about two full quarters of solid hours before the procedure so maybe it's not as bad as I feared.

0 coins

Yeah the highest single quarter is what moves the needle. If yours was good you might be pleasantly surprised.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent estimate on the Notice of Computation depends on where your quarterly wage falls relative to the statewide average. Lower-earning quarters tend to get the higher percentage, higher-earning quarters the lower one. EDD's site has the calculator.

0 coins

So someone who earned less per quarter might actually get a higher percentage of their wages replaced? That's counterintuitive.

0 coins

That's how it's designed. Lower earners get a higher replacement rate. The notice shows you exactly where your quarter landed.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail about ten weeks into my claim and I almost ignored it because I didn't recognize the form number. Had questions about whether I needed to fill it out since I'd already been certifying. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD agent, who confirmed the DE 2593 was the continued eligibility questionnaire and that I had 20 days from the date on the form to return it or my benefits could stop.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything special to get the agent to pull up the form specifically, or did they just find it from your claim?

0 coins

Just gave my Social and claim ID and they had it right there. Really straightforward once I was actually on with someone.

0 coins

been trying that disability line since tuesday and i have not gotten through once. four attempts. four.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is one I hadn't heard of before this thread. Good to know it shows up around the ten-week mark.

0 coins

Not sure if this is related but I've been paranoid that my doctor's certification expired somehow. Is there a deadline for how long after you file the doctor has to submit it?

0 coins

The provider has until 49 days from the date your disability began to submit the medical certification. If your doctor's office hasn't sent it in by then, the claim can be affected. Worth confirming they submitted it and that they used the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A.

0 coins

I'm at like 30 days since the start date so I still have time. I'm going to call the office today to confirm.

0 coins

Also keep in mind that after the certification comes in, EDD typically reaches out about the claim status within about 14 days. If you don't hear anything after that it's worth checking SDI Online.

0 coins

A Notice of Determination arrived in my mail on a claim I filed last month, and I was not expecting it at all since I thought the claim was processing normally. Used Claimyr and reached an EDD agent who confirmed the notice had been issued and explained I had 30 days from the date printed on it to appeal using the DE 1000A form if I disagreed with the determination.

0 coins

My pending claim has been quiet for three weeks and I have no idea if a determination is coming or what. Going to try Claimyr myself and ask about where my claim stands. What should I have ready when I get on?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the receipt number you gave your provider. If you have the Notice of Computation with you that helps too.

0 coins

Three weeks of quiet sounds really stressful. Hope you get answers soon.

0 coins

my wife went through this last year, moved states mid-claim actually which is a whole other mess. point is the CASDI thing is the core of it, if the deduction wasn't on the check EDD never saw it anyway.

0 coins

Mid-claim move sounds like a nightmare. At least mine was before I even filed.

0 coins

yeah hers was complicated, she got it sorted eventually but took a while anyway.

0 coins

The waiting period is seven days and it's not paid. First payment starts at day eight.

0 coins

I read that somewhere but then saw a comment on another thread saying the waiting period gets paid eventually and panicked.

0 coins

That other thread was wrong. Seven days, not payable, that's just how it works.

0 coins

To be clear, the waiting period is a true non-payable period, not a delay. It never gets paid out later. The first payable day is the eighth day of the claim.

0 coins

Fifty-two weeks is the max a DI claim will pay. If you're only looking at six weeks out you're well within that, but good to know the ceiling exists.

0 coins

Six weeks feels like a lot right now honestly. Nice to know there's room if recovery takes longer.

0 coins

If your doctor ends up needing to extend you past the original end date, they submit a form on their end. You don't file a new claim for that.

0 coins

Payment goes to a Money Network debit card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online when you filed. Worth checking your payment preference now so there are no surprises when the first payment comes through.

0 coins

I actually set up direct deposit when I filed so hopefully that part goes smoothly at least.

0 coins

Good. Direct deposit is the fastest way to receive it once payments start.

0 coins

Just double-check in SDI Online that the account number saved is correct. Worth a few seconds to verify before the first payment processes.

0 coins

the out of state earnings question is asked constantly on here and the answer is always the same. casdi deduction or it doesnt count.

0 coins

Makes sense from EDD's side since the fund is built from those deductions. Someone who never paid into California's system can't draw from it.

0 coins

exactly. wish it was posted somewhere more obvious so people knew before they moved.

0 coins

To wrap up the core question here: the only wages that count toward your California SDI benefit are ones that had CASDI withheld. Work done in another state before moving doesn't qualify, no matter how recent. Your benefit amount is based entirely on the highest California wage quarter in your base period.

0 coins

Thank you for pulling that together. I feel like I finally have the full picture now. Going to focus on making sure my certification is matched up and then just wait for the payments to start.

0 coins

That's the right next step. Confirm the receipt number with the provider's office, then check SDI Online in a few days to see if the certification shows as received.

0 coins

Good luck. Keep an eye on that claim status in SDI Online.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure