Can SDI be approved if doctor certifies disability is permanent
So my rheumatologist just told me my condition isn't going to improve and she's going to certify my disability as permanent when she submits the medical certification. I've been out of work for about three weeks now and I haven't filed yet because I got scared reading about this. Does California EDD actually approve SDI claims when the doctor writes permanent? I keep thinking they'll say I should be on Social Security instead or something. Has anyone had their claim go through when the certification said the disability is long-term or permanent? I work in a dental office and I'm genuinely not sure I can go back to what I do there, but I need something coming in while I figure this out.
83 comments

Grace Lee
My claim went through just fine even though my doctor wrote that my condition was ongoing with no expected end date. EDD's SDI is set up for up to 52 weeks, so a permanent diagnosis doesn't disqualify you. The question EDD is really asking is whether you can do your regular job right now, not what the future looks like.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorThat's actually really reassuring. So the certification just needs to show I can't do my job currently, even if the condition is permanent?
0 coins
Grace Lee
Exactly. The medical certification is about your current work capacity, not a prognosis. Your rheumatologist just needs to document that you can't perform your regular duties.
0 coins
William Rivera
Authorokay so she should focus on what I literally cannot do at work right now. I'll let her know before she submits.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
The SDI program pays benefits for days you can't do your regular or customary work. EDD doesn't require the disability to be temporary. A permanent diagnosis just means your doctor is being honest about the prognosis, and that honesty doesn't block the claim. What matters is the certification covers the period you're asking to be paid for.
0 coins
The Boss
wait so the certification period is separate from the prognosis? like my doctor says permanent but certifies me for a specific window?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Right. The medical certification covers a date range your provider specifies. The prognosis is just background. EDD looks at whether you're unable to work during that certified period.
0 coins
The Boss
that actually makes so much more sense now. I was confused about those being two different things.
0 coins
The Boss
DE 2593 showed up in my SDI Online account after I'd been on automatic payments for a while, and I had no idea it was coming. I tried the EDD disability line probably six or seven mornings in a row and kept hitting a busy signal or the line would just drop. I ended up getting through using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally talked to an agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent told me the DE 2593 needed to be returned within 20 days or my payments would stop, which I had no idea about.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
DE 2593 deadline sounds right, but the Claimyr thing reads like a marketing plant to me.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
Thought the same thing when I saw it posted somewhere else. Tried it anyway after three weeks of that line going nowhere. Agent confirmed my extension form, the DE 2525XX, had been received November 4th and was under review. EDD's own agent, nothing weird about the call.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Hm. Alright, might give it a go. The 20-day window on that DE 2593 is not something I was going to find out about by staring at SDI Online.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Permanent just means your body isn't going back to normal. SDI doesn't care about that. It cares if you can lift, stand, type, whatever your job needs right now. My forklift work was out of the question after my back surgery. Claim got approved, ran the full year.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorA full year, wow. Did you have to do anything after the initial approval to keep it going?
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Doctor submitted an extension form partway through. EDD sent a form with my payment notice and she filled it out. Payments kept coming.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
good to know the extension process exists. I didn't know that was a thing.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
There's a distinction worth flagging here between what SDI covers and what Social Security Disability covers. SDI from California EDD is meant for a temporary inability to work, up to 52 weeks, but that doesn't mean your disability has to be temporary. It means the benefit period is capped. You can have a permanent condition and still get SDI for the time you're out.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorThis is the part I was mixing up. I kept thinking permanent disability meant I had to go through Social Security first, but they're totally different programs.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Different programs entirely. SDI is a state payroll deduction, California-run, no overlap with the federal process. File your SDI claim and let your rheumatologist certify the period she can support.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
This thread is so helpful! I had the same confusion and was putting off filing for weeks thinking I didn't qualify.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
Three weeks out and you haven't filed yet? File now. The window to get your doctor's certification in is 49 days from when your disability started. Miss that and EDD can disqualify the whole claim.
0 coins
William Rivera
Author49 days total from the start date? Not from when I file?
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
From when the disability began. Your doctor has 49 days from that date to get the medical certification into SDI Online. You should wait about nine days after the disability starts before filing your own part, so get moving.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
To add to that, when you file your Claimant's Statement in SDI Online, you'll receive a form receipt number. Give that to your rheumatologist's office so they can find your claim and submit the certification on their end.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Patients sometimes worry that writing permanent will hurt their claim. Clinically it's just honesty. What EDD needs from the certification is that you're unable to perform your work duties during the period being certified. The duration of the underlying condition is a separate matter.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorMy rheumatologist mentioned she was going to be very detailed in the certification. Is that going to cause any issues?
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Detail helps. The more clearly she documents your functional limitations for your specific job, the stronger the certification.
0 coins
Anthony Young
My doctor was thorough on mine too and it went smoothly. File as soon as you can so the timeline works out.
0 coins
Charlotte White
My coworker freaked out about the same thing when her doctor said her condition was chronic. She filed, the certification went in, claim was approved. Permanent in the medical notes just means your body is what it is, not that EDD kicks you out.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Yeah EDD isn't reading the prognosis box and deciding you're too disabled. They want to know if you can work right now.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Exactly. And honestly even if the claim only goes a certain number of weeks, you get that time to figure out next steps without zero income.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
File the claim and get your doctor moving on that certification. Don't sit on it worrying about wording. I've seen guys on my crew with permanent injuries get SDI while they figured things out. The system isn't designed to block you for being honest about your health.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorFiling today. I found SDI Online through myEDD, is that the right place?
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
That's the one. Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online from there. Take note of the receipt number you get after filing.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
yes that's exactly the right place, and write that receipt number down the second you see it, anyway.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Notice of Determination came in the mail after my claim was initially flagged, and I had no clue what I'd done wrong. Tried the disability line so many days in a row I lost count. Ended up using Claimyr to reach an EDD agent, and they walked me through what the notice actually meant for my claim. The agent said I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal if I disagreed with EDD's decision.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
What did you have ready when you made that call, like did you need your claim ID or the notice number?
0 coins
Anthony Young
Had my claim ID and the date on the notice. Agent pulled up everything from those two pieces. Pretty straightforward once I actually reached someone.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
been trying that disability line since tuesday. different times, same result. nothing.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
my doctor wrote something like indefinite on mine and it still got approved no problem. they just want to see you cant do your job, thats the whole thing
0 coins
William Rivera
Authorindefinite got approved, good to know. did it take the normal amount of time to process or did it sit longer?
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
took like two weeks from when both parts were in. nothing weird about the timing
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Two things worth confirming before the certification goes in. First, check that your rheumatologist is a licensed provider EDD accepts for disability certification purposes. Second, confirm her office has your receipt number from SDI Online, not just your name, so they can link to the right claim.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorShe's an MD so I think she's fine? And I'll definitely pass the receipt number along, didn't realize that was how they find the claim.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
An MD is on EDD's accepted list. The receipt number piece is easy to miss but it's how the medical certification gets matched to your Claimant's Statement.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
If your doctor's office asks, the receipt number is what you get right after submitting your part of the claim in SDI Online. Some offices ask for it right away.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
my wife panicked about this same thing when she was filing. her orthopedist wrote something about chronic condition and the claim still went through fine. I think people assume EDD is looking for a reason to deny based on the wording but its really just about whether you can work, anyway.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorOkay, the number of people saying it went fine is really calming me down. I think I built this up in my head.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
totally normal to overthink it when youre worried about income. just file and get the receipt number to your doctor fast.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Receipt number from my SDI Online filing sat in my email for two weeks before I realized the doctor's office needed it. By the time I called the office to give it to them, we were getting close to the deadline. I tried reaching EDD to ask if the certification still had time, and after a few mornings of not getting through I used Claimyr to speak with an agent. The agent looked up my claim and confirmed the medical certification had not yet been received and that the form receipt number my provider needed was still showing unmatched on their end.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
Waiting on my claim to clear and I want to ask EDD about the waiting period on mine specifically. Going to try Claimyr for that. What's the most useful thing to have ready before making the call?
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Have your Social Security number, your claim start date, and your SDI Online claim ID pulled up. The agent can get to your record fast with those.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
the unmatched receipt thing is a real issue. ive heard of claims stalling for weeks just because the office used the wrong number.
0 coins
The Boss
Wait, I keep seeing people mention a waiting period. Is that the same as processing time? Like the days EDD takes to review your claim?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Those are different things. The waiting period is the first seven days of your claim, and EDD doesn't pay benefits for those days no matter how fast everything processes. It's not about EDD's review speed.
0 coins
The Boss
oh wow I had those completely mixed up. So I lose those seven days no matter what, they're just not covered?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Correct. The first payable day is the eighth day of the disability period. The processing time is on top of that and varies based on when both parts of the claim are received.
0 coins
Grace Lee
So many people mix those up. My sister thought her claim was taking forever but she hadn't counted that the first week just isn't paid, period.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
November 7th was my disability start date and I filed my Claimant's Statement on November 16th. Doctor submitted the certification November 19th. EDD issued the Notice of Computation about two weeks after that. Permanent condition, no issues with the approval.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorThis is exactly what I needed to see, an actual timeline from someone with a permanent condition. Thank you.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
The Notice of Computation showed up before any payment, it lists your potential weekly benefit amount. It's not an approval letter but it means EDD processed the claim.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
that two-week window seems to be pretty consistent from what people are saying here.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Payment date showed wrong in SDI Online for like a week on my injury claim and I panicked. Tried the EDD disability line maybe ten mornings straight, early too, and it either rang forever or dropped. Ended up using Claimyr to get an agent on the phone. Agent checked my claim and said the payment had issued on November 12th and should post to my card within a couple of business days.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
November timing on a payment date matches what happened on my claim too. I used Claimyr as well after my own payment showed pending for longer than I expected. Once EDD's agent confirmed my payment method on file was still the debit card, I knew it was just a mail delay and stopped worrying.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
ugh the line is brutal. i tried for like four days straight once and got nothing
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
yeah four days is pretty common from what i hear, that line does not make it easy.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
The 52-week cap is the thing to plan around if your condition is permanent. SDI gets you through up to a year, and that's time to explore what options exist after that. But for now, file and get your doctor's certification in!
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorMakes sense. One year of SDI buys a lot of time to figure out longer-term plans.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Exactly! And if your condition improves enough to do some work in the meantime, you can report partial work to EDD.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Nobody asks for a temporary diagnosis to get SDI. That's not a rule anywhere. The rule is whether you can do your job. Permanent just describes your body, not your eligibility.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorSaid plainly, that really lands. I think the word permanent just scared me.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Understandable. File the claim.
0 coins
Charlotte White
One thing that tripped up a friend of mine, not disability-related but worth mentioning: she thought SDI and Paid Family Leave were the same program and tried to file for bonding through her disability claim. They're separate programs. Disability is for when you can't work due to your own health, PFL is a different claim.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Definitely worth flagging. For someone in the original poster's situation, it's a straight DI claim for their own condition. No PFL involved unless they have a new child to bond with after a pregnancy claim.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Right, just wanted to toss that out there since I've seen a few people in this thread come from search and land confused about which program they need.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
After 52 weeks the SDI benefit ends. If the condition is truly permanent and you still can't return to work at that point, that's when looking into federal disability programs would make sense. For now, SDI covers what it covers and permanent conditions qualify the same as temporary ones.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorOkay, so file now for SDI, and if I'm still unable to work at 52 weeks I look at other options at that point. That's a clear path, thank you.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
That's the right order. Get the claim filed, get the certification in, and deal with the next step when you get there.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
sensible advice. one thing at a time.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Just to close the loop on something from earlier in this thread: a physical therapist is not on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. I made that mistake early on and had to go back to my physician to get the certification submitted properly. Make sure whoever signs off is on EDD's accepted list, which your rheumatologist as an MD absolutely is.
0 coins
William Rivera
AuthorGood to know. Mine is definitely an MD so I'm fine, but I could see someone assuming a PT could do it.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
EDD's accepted certifiers include physicians, osteopathic doctors, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, licensed midwives, and authorized officers at US government medical facilities. Physical therapists aren't on that list.
0 coins
The Boss
I almost asked my physical therapist to do my certification. really glad I checked first.
0 coins