Can California EDD will take 100 percent of SDI benefits to repay overpayment?
So I got an overpayment notice from EDD last week and I'm honestly panicking. I went back to work part time toward the end of my SDI claim and reported my hours each week like I was supposed to, but somehow there's a discrepancy and they're saying I owe money back. My question is whether EDD will take 100 percent of sdi benefits to repay overpayment if I ever file a new claim down the road, or if there's a limit to how much they can take at once. I can't afford to have my entire check wiped out if I need disability again. The notice has an appeal form attached and I have about three weeks left before the deadline. Has anyone dealt with this before? Did you just pay it back or did you appeal it?
79 comments

Sophia Russo
Reporting your hours and still getting an overpayment notice is more common than it should be. Before anything else, I'd pull out every pay stub from those part-time weeks and line them up against what you reported on your claim forms. Sometimes the discrepancy is a data-entry mismatch, not an actual error on your part, and having the paperwork in order makes the appeal much cleaner.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorDid you have to gather anything else beyond the pay stubs, or was that enough to make your case?
0 coins
Sophia Russo
The notice itself matters too. It will show exactly which weeks EDD says were overpaid and the amounts, so you can compare those weeks one by one to what your stubs say.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorOkay that makes sense. I think I still have everything, I'll lay it all out tonight.
0 coins
Evelyn Xu
Appeal it. You've got 30 days from the date on that notice. Use the DE 1000A that came with it and write out exactly what you reported and when. Don't let that deadline slide.
0 coins
Dominic Green
What if the 30 days is already close? Can you still send it?
0 coins
Evelyn Xu
Mail it before the deadline, postmarked counts. If you're past 30 days you can still send it but you'd need to explain why it was late and an administrative law judge looks at that.
0 coins
Hannah Flores
Didn't know a late appeal was even possible. Good to know.
0 coins
Kayla Jacobson
Receipt number on my claim had an issue early on that I didn't catch until weeks in, which is a different problem but still ended up affecting my payment record. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD's disability line after trying the number myself every morning for about two weeks straight with nothing but a busy signal. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my provider had used didn't match the one SDI Online generated for my file, which is why things looked off. Once they corrected it the payment record straightened out.
0 coins
William Rivera
When you got through, did the agent actually fix it on the spot or did they just flag it and tell you to wait?
0 coins
Kayla Jacobson
She updated the receipt number right there while I was on the phone and said a corrected record would show in SDI Online within a few days. I checked and it was there.
0 coins
Grace Lee
Three weeks of hitting redial every morning before work and I haven't gotten a human once. That line is impossible.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
On the question of how much EDD can withhold from a future claim, EDD's own materials say they can offset future benefits to recover an overpayment, but the offset amount is something to confirm directly with EDD because the specific percentage isn't something I've seen stated as a fixed rule in their public FAQs. The appeal is still worth filing either way, especially if your reporting was accurate.
0 coins
The Boss
Does filing the appeal pause any collection action while it's pending, or does EDD keep trying to recover the money at the same time?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
EDD's published guidance doesn't specify that the appeal freezes collection. That's a good question to put through Ask EDD in writing, or raise it on the phone with an agent so you have something concrete.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
I didn't know you could ask EDD questions in writing like that. I've just been trying to call and getting nowhere.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My SDI claim ran into something similar after I cut back my hours for a few weeks. The overpayment notice came out of nowhere and I was so confused because I thought I had reported everything. Ended up writing out a full timeline of my hours and what I reported each week, attached the pay stubs, and mailed it with the appeal form. Still waiting to hear back but at least I did something.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorHow long ago did you mail yours? I'm trying to figure out how long this process usually takes.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
About six weeks ago and nothing yet. I know that's not what you want to hear but I figure no news means they're still reviewing it.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Six weeks isn't unusual from what I've seen in this thread. The administrative hearing process takes a while.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
you def want to appeal before that deadline hits. once it passes its so much harder to do anything about it
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorYeah the deadline is what's stressing me out most right now.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
just get the de 1000a in the mail before that date and youre at least in the system
0 coins
Nora Bennett
The 30-day window on the appeal runs from the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it. If the notice is dated a week ago, you've already used some of those days. Worth checking the date tonight if you haven't already.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorThe date on the notice is from last week, so I should still have around three weeks. But I'm going to get this in the mail by Friday to be safe.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Friday is smart. Gives you a paper trail and gets it out of your hands.
0 coins
Sophia Russo
Sending it via certified mail is worth the small cost so you have proof of when it was mailed.
0 coins
Dominic Green
Payment date question came up on my own claim after a week just disappeared from my payment history with no explanation. Ended up talking to an EDD agent using Claimyr and she found that the week in question had been held pending a wage crossmatch. She said once that cleared the payment would process normally, and it did show up a few days later.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My extension has me wondering if there's a hold on a specific week too. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when they pick up?
0 coins
Dominic Green
Have your claim ID and Social Security number right in front of you. The agent asked for both right away and then pulled everything up fast.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Wage crossmatch held your payment for a whole week? That's a long time to just sit there without any notice in SDI Online.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
EDD collecting 100 percent of a future claim to cover an overpayment is not something I've seen happen in practice, but that doesn't mean it can't. The appeal is the right move regardless of what they'd actually take.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorHave you been through an overpayment situation yourself or is that more from watching what happens to others?
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
Watched a few people go through it. The ones who appealed with solid documentation came out better than the ones who just paid without questioning it.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
That tracks. Even if the overpayment turns out to be valid, the appeal can sometimes lead to a repayment arrangement instead of a lump sum.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Filing the appeal doesn't cost anything and it doesn't hurt your chances if the overpayment does turn out to be correct. The worst case is that the appeal is denied and you still owe the same amount. Best case, the amount is reduced or reversed.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorThat framing actually helps a lot. I've been treating the appeal like it's risky but there's really nothing to lose.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Exactly. Send it, include everything you have, and let them review it.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Keep copies of absolutely everything before you mail it! I made that mistake on a different EDD issue and deeply regretted not having a copy of what I sent in.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorI would not have thought to do that. Definitely scanning everything before it goes out.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Yes! Scan or photograph every page including the envelope if you send it certified!
0 coins
Grace Lee
EDD's disability line is a nightmare. I've tried calling at opening, mid-morning, right after lunch, and I get the same result every time. Either a busy signal or a recording that just disconnects. It's genuinely one of the most frustrating systems I've ever dealt with.
0 coins
Dominic Green
Mornings were the worst for me too. No difference what time I tried.
0 coins
Grace Lee
And it's not like you can just wait it out. When there's a deadline on an overpayment notice you actually need answers fast.
0 coins
Hannah Flores
The disconnect recording is the most demoralizing part. At least a busy signal means they know you're calling.
0 coins
The Boss
There's some confusion in a few comments about what happens to your appeal if EDD starts collecting in the meantime. Worth clarifying: the appeal is about whether the overpayment amount is correct, not necessarily a pause on collection. Those are two separate things, and if you want to know how EDD handles collection during an appeal you'd need to ask them directly.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
So you can be appealing and paying at the same time? That feels really unfair if the appeal hasn't been decided yet.
0 coins
The Boss
It does feel that way. The appeal still matters though because if it's decided in your favor you'd get that money back or credited. Asking EDD through SDI Online or Ask EDD about collection timing is the safest way to get a straight answer.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
The SDI Online message feature is underused for exactly these kinds of procedural questions. You pick the claim, go to Request Claim Update, and type your question. It's not instant but it's documented.
0 coins
William Rivera
my coworker had an overpayment from going back part time and she said edd only took like half her future benefit not the whole thing, so they dont always do 100 percent lol. but that was her specific situation so idk if its a rule or not
0 coins
Sophia Russo
Individual situations can vary, and the percentage isn't something EDD publishes as a fixed number from what I've seen. What actually happened on her claim would depend on the specifics. Asking EDD directly is still the safest way to know what they'd do in any particular case.
0 coins
William Rivera
yeah makes sense, i was just saying it doesnt seem automatic that theyd take everything
0 coins
Anthony Young
The DE 2593 caught me completely off guard on a previous claim. Had no idea it was coming, missed the 20-day window, and benefits stopped. Ended up getting a live EDD agent through Claimyr after my own week of trying the number. She looked up my claim and confirmed the DE 2593 had been mailed but told me I'd need to return it right away to restart payments.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
My own DE 2593 is sitting on my table right now. I've used Claimyr too, actually. After the agent confirmed the form was what was holding things up, I sent it back that same day express mail and payments came back through in about a week. The waiting is so stressful when you're depending on those checks.
0 coins
Charlotte White
been trying that disability line for four days now and still nothing. no person, no option, just the recording.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
The part that gets me about overpayment notices is that EDD expects you to know exactly how reporting part-time wages works, but the instructions on the forms are genuinely confusing. It's not always clear what counts as a partial week versus a full week.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
The reporting instructions were confusing to me too. I went back and re-read the forms and even then I wasn't certain I was doing it right.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
And then months later you get a notice saying you owe money. At that point you're supposed to remember exactly what you reported and when. It's a lot to ask.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorThis is exactly what happened to me. I reported what I thought was correct but something didn't match up on their end and now I'm dealing with this.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
The administrative law judge process, if it gets to a hearing, actually gives you a real chance to explain your side. It's not just paperwork. You can speak and present your evidence in person or by phone. A lot of people don't know that part.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
AuthorIs there anything specific you should prepare for a hearing beyond the pay stubs and the reporting forms?
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
A written timeline of your hours and what you reported each week, in your own words, is really useful. The clearer and more specific the better.
0 coins
Sophia Russo
Organizing it chronologically, week by week with dates, makes it easier for the judge to follow along.
0 coins
The Boss
Notice of Determination came in the mail on a previous claim of mine and I honestly had no idea what I was looking at. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent about it because the online message system hadn't gotten me a response in two weeks. The agent explained that the DE 2517 was a denial and that the appeal form, the DE 1000A, was attached to it. She said I had 30 days from the date on that notice to send the appeal back.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
30 days from the notice date sounds straightforward but I've tried that disability number so many times I stopped counting. Never once got a person. What made you think calling would actually work this time?
0 coins
The Boss
Honestly I'd tried the same number the same way and gotten nowhere. What was different was using Claimyr to stay on the line so I didn't have to. When a person picked up I was already there.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
The 30-day deadline the agent mentioned is accurate. The notice itself says it, and the DE 1000A is the right form for the appeal. What matters most is that the appeal goes to the return address on the notice itself, not EDD's general mailing address.
0 coins
Charlotte White
does anyone know if you can send the appeal through sdionline or does it have to be physical mail
0 coins
Mia Roberts
The DE 1000A is a physical form that goes to the address printed on the notice. EDD's guidance says to mail it there. The SDI Online message tool isn't the right channel for a formal appeal.
0 coins
Charlotte White
ok physical mail it is. thanks
0 coins
Evelyn Xu
Certified mail so you have the postmark date. That date is what matters if the deadline is close.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
If EDD really can take 100 percent of a future claim to recover an overpayment, that seems like it would leave someone with nothing while they're recovering from something serious. Is there any protection against that or is it really just whatever EDD decides?
0 coins
Daniel Washington
That's worth asking EDD directly, either through Ask EDD in writing or by phone. The appeal is still the first step because if the overpayment amount is wrong or reduced, the collection amount changes too.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
I guess fighting the amount first makes the most sense before worrying about how they'd collect it.
0 coins
Sophia Russo
That's the right order. Appeal first, understand the final amount, then if needed ask EDD specifically about how repayment would work.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
Sending the appeal out tomorrow morning. Certified mail, copies of everything scanned before it goes. I've got the pay stubs for every week I worked part time, my claim forms, and a written timeline like a few people suggested. Really appreciate everyone who explained the process here, I feel a lot less panicked than I did when I first posted.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
That's the right move. Having everything organized before it goes out is about all you can do from here.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
You've done everything you can do at this point. Now it's EDD's turn.
0 coins
Evelyn Xu
Let it land, see what they say. You've got your documentation, that's what matters.
0 coins