Back to California Disability

Isaiah Thompson

California EDD SDI offset collect back — what actually happens to your payments?

Backstory: I was out for about six weeks earlier this year after a pretty rough recovery from abdominal surgery, and I had a short-term disability policy through my employer that also paid out during that time. My HR department told me before I left that SDI would be "offset" against what the private plan paid, and that I might owe money back once everything settled. I filed my California EDD disability claim like normal through SDI Online, got the medical certification in from my surgeon's office, and payments started coming. Now I'm back at work and I got a letter that seems to say EDD overpaid me because of that employer plan overlap and they want to collect back the difference. Has anyone dealt with this kind of SDI offset situation where they're trying to collect back what they paid you? I don't even totally understand how they calculated the number they're saying I owe. Do I appeal or just pay it? Really stressed about this.

Overpayment notices like the one you got — the amount on them and how they calculated it can be confusing to read. The first thing to do is look at the top of the notice for the issue date and count 30 days from that date. That's your appeal deadline, and it's hard and not something they extend easily. If you think the number is wrong or the offset was applied incorrectly, you file the Appeal Form DE 1000A that should have come with the notice, or write a detailed letter if you can't find the form, and mail it to the return address printed on the notice itself. Don't send it to some general EDD address.

0 coins

The notice came with a form attached, so at least I have that. The issue date was about 10 days ago so I still have time. My question is more about whether the calculation looks right — the overlap was only about three weeks but the amount they want back seems like more than three weeks of payments.

0 coins

Three weeks of overlap and an amount that feels too high — that is exactly the kind of discrepancy worth appealing. Pull out your Notice of Computation and compare your weekly benefit amount against what they're claiming was overpaid per week. If the math doesn't track over three weeks, write that out specifically on the form.

0 coins

Appealing doesn't mean you refuse to pay — you can note in your appeal that you're disputing the calculation while EDD sorts it out. Put every document you have in one folder now: the overpayment notice, the Notice of Computation, any stubs showing what the private plan paid you, and the dates you were out.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim got weird in a similar stretch — the schedule shifted by almost two weeks and I couldn't tell if it was an error or just how EDD processes things when there's another payer involved. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to an agent on the disability line after the hold music defeated me twice. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked up my claim and told me exactly which week the payment issued and that my next payment was pending the matching date — specific to my own account, not a general answer. Knowing the actual issued date helped me figure out whether the overlap calculation my employer sent matched what EDD had on file.

0 coins

The payment date piece is relevant to my situation too because I'm not sure which weeks EDD actually paid versus which weeks the private plan was also active. If those dates don't match what I reported, that might explain the discrepancy.

0 coins

Payment dates on the EDD side are also in SDI Online if you pull up your claim — sometimes the transaction history there lines up with what the agent would tell you anyway, so worth checking that first before spending time on hold.

0 coins

SDI Online showed the payment as issued but not the specific disbursement date to the card, which is what I needed. The agent had the actual date it hit the account history on EDD's side.

0 coins

The offset situation with employer short-term disability plans is one of those things where the private insurer and EDD are each doing their own calculation, and they don't always talk to each other the way you'd expect. Usually what happens is the private plan coordinates benefits and reduces what it pays once SDI kicks in — but if yours paid the full amount and EDD also paid the full amount for overlapping weeks, that's where the overpayment comes from EDD's perspective. The question is whether your private plan actually reduced its payments or not.

0 coins

My private plan paid a flat percentage and from what I can tell did not reduce it when SDI payments started. So yeah, there was real overlap — I'm just not sure the amount EDD calculated is accurate for the number of weeks.

0 coins

If the private plan didn't coordinate — meaning it paid the same amount regardless of SDI — then EDD's overpayment claim is probably real, it's just whether they calculated the right number of weeks and the right weekly amounts. That's worth verifying line by line before you pay anything.

0 coins

worth calling to ask exactly which weeks they're counting as overpaid, don't just assume the total on the notice is correct before you verify it

0 coins

DE 2593 deadline almost slipped past me when I was dealing with something similar — I was so focused on the overlap question from my employer that I missed the 20-day return window on the questionnaire EDD sends after the tenth week of payments. My agent straightened out which form they were waiting on after I got through on the phone, and the DE 2593 situation was actually separate from the offset question entirely. Using Claimyr to reach that agent sorted out which of the two issues was actually holding up my claim. The agent confirmed the questionnaire had been received and told me the return date EDD logged — that was the step causing the delay, not the overlap.

0 coins

Mine was only six weeks total so I don't think the DE 2593 applies in my case — I believe that one comes into play around week ten. But good to know that the questionnaire and an overpayment can be separate issues happening at the same time on a claim.

0 coins

Exactly right on the week ten timing — EDD sends it after five automatic payments, which works out to around ten weeks. If your claim was shorter than that you probably didn't see it at all.

0 coins

The DE 2593 caught me completely by surprise when it arrived because nobody told me it was coming. 20 days sounds like enough time but it went fast.

0 coins

30 days to appeal is the window you've got from the date printed on the notice — not the date you received it, the date on the notice itself. If you're within that, file the DE 1000A with as much detail as you can about why you think the number is wrong. Attach any documentation you have showing the actual overlap dates and what each source paid you per week. The more specific, the better.

0 coins

From the date on the notice, not when I got it — that's an important distinction. The notice is dated about 10 days ago so I should still be well within the window.

0 coins

Specific dollar amounts and dates for each week in dispute carry the most weight. Vague appeals that just say the total seems high are harder to win than ones that say week of X, SDI paid Y, private plan paid Z, offset should have been this amount.

0 coins

Also keep a copy of everything you mail — the appeal form, your documentation, everything. Send it in a way you can track.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on: when you got your Notice of Computation, it showed your potential weekly benefit amount. That's the number EDD uses to figure out what you were entitled to. If the overpayment notice is claiming a weekly amount that's different from what's on your Notice of Computation, that's a specific discrepancy you can point to in the appeal.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation weekly amount and what I actually received each week seemed to match, so the issue is specifically about the number of weeks they're calling an overlap, not the weekly rate.

0 coins

If the weekly amount is correct and your dispute is about the number of weeks, then your documentation strategy is straightforward — lay out the exact dates you were out, when SDI payments started versus when the private plan ended or reduced, and show which weeks genuinely overlapped.

0 coins

Employer short-term disability plans can be set up differently — some are Voluntary Plans that EDD actually administers, and some are completely private with no connection to EDD at all. If your employer's plan is a Voluntary Plan, the offset rules may work differently than with a fully private insurer. Worth asking HR which kind of plan yours is if you don't already know, before you finalize your appeal.

0 coins

I actually don't know the answer to that. I'll ask HR on Monday. Would not have thought to check whether it's a Voluntary Plan.

0 coins

If it is a Voluntary Plan, EDD can speak to that directly because they administer it. If it's purely private, EDD only deals with their side — the private insurer's coordination rules are between you and them.

0 coins

HR should have plan documents that spell this out — look for "Voluntary Plan" or "VP" in the plan name or summary. Some employers just call it short-term disability without specifying.

0 coins

Notice of Determination arrived on my claim after what I thought was a simple extension request — EDD denied the extended period and I had no idea the DE 2525XX even needed anything beyond what my doctor submitted. Got through to an agent to ask which weeks were covered and which weren't, using Claimyr. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the Notice of Determination number and the date it issued, then said to appeal with the DE 1000A within 30 days of that date if I disagreed. That date turned out to be sooner than I'd realized because I'd been waiting to hear something by mail.

0 coins

The 30-day clock running from the issue date rather than when you receive it keeps coming up. Good reinforcement — I need to act on this quickly.

0 coins

Issue date on the notice is the controlling date for appeals — the agent was clear about that on my call.

0 coins

For anyone dealing with a Notice of Determination on a denied extension: the DE 2525XX is what your physician submits for more time, and if EDD denies it, that denial notice starts the appeal clock the same as any other determination.

0 coins

The "collect back" piece of your situation is worth separating from the appeal. If you appeal and lose, or if the offset was genuinely applied to the right weeks, EDD will expect repayment. They do work out payment plans in some cases — but that's a separate conversation from the appeal itself, and you don't have to decide that now. Focus first on whether the calculation is accurate.

0 coins

Keeping those two things separate makes sense. First figure out whether the amount is right, then deal with payment if it is.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you do end up owing, don't just ignore the notice — that makes it more complicated down the line.

0 coins

My claim had a similar situation where multiple income streams were active at the same time and I wasn't sure what to report to EDD and what counted as an offset. The rule I finally got clear on is that going back to work, or any partial wages during the claim period, gets reported to EDD and they determine how the payments adjust. Private insurance is a separate lane but the overlap can still create an overpayment. Report everything and let EDD do the math rather than guessing what matters.

0 coins

In my case the SDI claim is already closed since I'm back at work, so the reporting period is in the past — it's really just about settling what happened during those six weeks.

0 coins

Closed claim, same principle — the records of what was paid during those weeks exist in EDD's system and they'll compare them against what they should have paid given the offset. Your documentation of the private plan's payment schedule is what you use to check their work.

0 coins

Closed claims can still be appealed within the 30-day window if there's a Notice. The fact that you're back at work doesn't change the appeal timeline.

0 coins

20 days is the return window on the DE 2593 — not 30, that's the appeal deadline on a denial or overpayment notice. Those two deadlines get mixed up a lot in these threads. DE 2593 is 20 days, appeal on a notice is 30 days from the date on the notice.

0 coins

Glad that got separated out — I'd been thinking both were 30 days.

0 coins

DE 2593 is the continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends after ten weeks of automatic payments. The 20-day return window is for that form. The 30-day window is for appealing a Notice of Determination or an overpayment notice. Two different deadlines, two different forms.

0 coins

Waiting period thing that comes up when people calculate their own overpayments: the first seven days of the claim are the non-payable waiting period, so EDD never paid anything for those days. If whoever calculated the overlap is counting from the first day you were out rather than the first day EDD actually paid, the overlap weeks they're counting could be off by that much.

0 coins

That's actually a really useful point. My surgery was on a Monday and I believe payments started the following Wednesday of the second week — so if someone is counting from the surgery date rather than the first actual payment date, that shifts things.

0 coins

Exactly — the first seven days are on you, no payment, no overlap possible. The overlap only exists in weeks where EDD actually issued a payment.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and your payment history in SDI Online will show the first date EDD actually paid. Use that date as your starting point for the overlap calculation, not your surgery date.

0 coins

Appeal Form DE 1000A is what you file — if you've lost it or it didn't come with the notice, EDD's site has it. Mail it to the return address on your overpayment notice, not to a general office. Write out specifically which weeks you believe the offset was miscalculated and why, with dates and amounts. Vague appeals get harder results.

0 coins

I have the form from the notice itself. The specific dates and amounts angle is what I need to build out before I mail it.

0 coins

Pull together: your surgery date, the first EDD payment date from SDI Online, the last EDD payment date, your private plan's payment dates and amounts for each of those weeks. Put them in a simple week-by-week table if you can. That format makes it easy for a reviewer to follow your argument.

0 coins

HR told me something similar when I was out — they said SDI would offset the private plan. What actually happened on my claim was that the private insurer reduced its payment once SDI started, so there was no real overlap in my case. The offset happened on the employer plan side, not on EDD's side. If your plan didn't do that, that's the discrepancy.

0 coins

Mine definitely did not reduce. The private plan paid the same flat rate the whole time and EDD also paid the full weekly benefit. So the overlap was real — I just think the number of weeks they calculated might be slightly off.

0 coins

If the overlap was real but the week count is off, you have a narrow appeal: you're not saying you don't owe anything, you're saying the number of weeks and the amount should be lower. That's usually easier to resolve than disputing the whole overpayment.

0 coins

Benefits calculator on EDD's site is worth running with your own wage data to verify the weekly benefit amount on your Notice of Computation is what it should be. If your base period wages were entered correctly and your weekly benefit amount is confirmed, then the dispute really is just about how many weeks of overlap existed — which is a factual question you can resolve with documentation.

0 coins

Running the calculator is a good idea — I haven't done that yet. If the weekly amount is confirmed right, then I know exactly what I'm disputing.

0 coins

The base period on a DI claim covers the highest-paid quarter in the 12-month period from 5 to 18 months before your claim started. If your wages fluctuated, make sure you know which quarter they used — it's on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Detailed letter works in place of the DE 1000A if for some reason the form is unavailable — EDD accepts a written letter explaining the dispute as long as it's specific and mailed to the return address on the notice before the 30-day deadline. The form is easier because it has the right fields, but you're not stuck if you don't have it.

0 coins

Good to know the letter is an option, but I do have the form so I'll use that.

0 coins

With the form you can attach extra pages — don't try to squeeze everything onto the form itself if you need more space. Number the pages and reference them from the form.

0 coins

Collecting back an overpayment and denying a claim are handled differently by EDD. Overpayment collection can sometimes be waived or put on a payment plan if you can't pay in a lump sum — that's a separate request you can make after the appeal is resolved. Don't confuse that option with the appeal itself though. Appeal first if the amount is wrong, then deal with collection terms if the amount is confirmed.

0 coins

The appeal-first approach makes the most sense at this point. I genuinely think the week count is wrong and I'd rather establish the correct amount before discussing any payment terms.

0 coins

If your appeal is successful even partially — say they reduce the overpayment from X weeks to Y weeks — that revised amount is what any future collection or payment plan is based on. Worth pursuing.

0 coins

Even a partial win on the appeal is worth filing for. The 30-day window exists specifically so you can challenge calculations that feel off, and the week-count discrepancy you're describing is exactly the kind of thing that appeals are there to resolve.

0 coins

SDI Online claim history also shows each payment that issued and the week it covers — log in through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and pull up your claim. Cross-referencing that history against the overlap dates your private plan shows is literally the documentation exercise you need to do before filing the appeal.

0 coins

I haven't looked at the SDI Online history in a while since the claim closed. Logging in now to pull the week-by-week payment list.

0 coins

Each payment entry should show the benefit period it covers. Add those dates to your week-by-week table alongside what the private plan paid in those same weeks and you have your comparison ready.

0 coins

The whole situation where both a private plan and SDI pay at the same time for the same period is more common than people realize — a lot of employers don't walk employees through how the coordination works before they go out, and then there's confusion when EDD comes back to collect. Not really a complaint about EDD specifically, more just an observation that the information gap is real.

0 coins

My HR basically said 'SDI will offset it' and left it at that. I didn't understand what offset meant in practice or that it could result in EDD wanting money back after the fact.

0 coins

Same here — 'offset' got explained to me as 'you'll get less from one source or the other' but not which one, and not what happens when both just pay the full amount anyway.

0 coins

The clearer thing to say would be 'if both pay at the same time for the same week, EDD will want their portion back.' That's just not what HR usually says on the way out the door.

0 coins

Mailing the appeal with some kind of tracking on it is worth doing — USPS Certified Mail is cheap and gives you a dated record that it was sent before the deadline. If there's ever a question about whether it arrived, you have proof.

0 coins

Doing certified mail is an easy step I definitely won't skip. Good reminder.

0 coins

The date that matters is the postmark date for mailed appeals — as long as it's postmarked within 30 days of the notice date you're within the window, even if EDD receives it a few days later.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure