
California Disability
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm in a frustrating situation with EDD and hoping someone has gone through something similar. I had knee replacement surgery back in February and properly transitioned from UI to SDI. I notified UI to stop my payments before my surgery date, and my disability payments began after my UI ended - with zero overlap between the two. Now, 3 months later, EDD is claiming I was overpaid by $2,450 during that transition period! I've already filed an appeal since this is clearly their error (I have confirmation numbers and dates proving nothing overlapped). My local assembly member's office is helping me and assured me I filed the appeal correctly within the timeframe. Here's my concern: my original SDI claim just ended, and I started a brand new claim two weeks ago for ongoing recovery complications. The representative said I should be able to certify and receive payments on this new claim despite the pending appeal on my old claim, but she couldn't guarantee it. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment appeal while starting a new claim? Did your payments come through normally, or did EDD hold them until after the appeal hearing? I'm worried about bills piling up if they withhold payments until my appeal date in July.
I'm in a really tough spot. My doctor initially estimated I'd be out for 12 weeks following my spinal surgery, but recovery is taking longer than expected. I've been on SDI since January 2025 and my benefits are set to run out in early April, but my orthopedist said I'll need at least 6-8 more weeks before I can return to work (even with restrictions). I work in construction and there's no light duty option. I'm starting to panic about how I'll cover bills when my disability benefits end. Does anyone know what happens when SDI runs out but you're still not medically cleared to return? Are there extensions available? Do I need to file a new claim? Should I apply for something else? This is my first time on disability and I'm completely lost.
to answer your question from earlier - yes i did eventually get my benefits extended but there was a 10-day gap before payments started again which SUCKED. make sure u start the process early!!!
I went through something similar with my back injury last year. The key is getting your doctor to submit that updated medical certification (DE 2501 form) as soon as possible - don't wait until the last minute! I made that mistake and had a 2-week gap in benefits while they processed everything. Also, if you're in construction like me, make sure your doctor is very specific about your work restrictions in the certification. They need to clearly state that you cannot perform your regular job duties, not just that you're "recovering." EDD scrutinizes construction workers more closely since they assume we can do light duty (even when we can't). One more tip - if your doctor's office is slow with paperwork, offer to pick up the completed form yourself and submit it directly to EDD. That saved me time when I needed my extension processed quickly.
I've been on California SDI for 4 months due to a back injury with complications, and my employer is now pushing me to come back early with what they call a 'reasonable accommodation.' My doctor has me cleared to return on March 15, 2025 (about 3 weeks from now), but my employer's HR called yesterday saying they have an immediate position with 'modified duties' they want me to take. When I explained I'd rather follow my doctor's RTW plan and return on the 15th, the HR rep said if I don't accept the accommodation and return now, they'll consider it 'job abandonment' and terminate me. I understand my 12 weeks of FMLA/CFRA protection ended a while ago, but can they really call this 'job abandonment' when I'm actively on disability with a specific return date? Feels like they're setting things up to fight an unemployment claim if I end up terminated and my disability benefits run out. Anyone dealt with something similar or know my rights here?
In addition to the excellent advice already shared, I'd suggest requesting the accommodation offer in writing as well. Ask them to clearly outline what specific duties they're proposing, hours, and how they believe it accommodates your medical restrictions. Compare this directly with your doctor's written restrictions. Regarding unemployment after SDI - if they do terminate you, California EDD generally considers you eligible for UI benefits if you're terminated because you're unable to work due to a disability but become able to work later. The key is documenting everything and demonstrating you were willing to return on your doctor-approved date. Also, consider filing a complaint with DFEH (Department of Fair Employment and Housing) if they terminate you for following medical guidance. While they can legally terminate after FMLA/CFRA exhaustion, there are still protections against disability discrimination.
I just got the accommodation offer in writing, and you're right - it's completely inconsistent with my medical restrictions. I've forwarded it to my doctor to review, but they want me sitting at a computer 7 hours a day with 'flexible breaks' which doesn't match my no-sitting-more-than-20-minutes restriction at all. I'll look into the DFEH angle too, thank you.
Document everything and stay strong! Based on what you've shared, their "accommodation" offer is clearly not reasonable if it contradicts your medical restrictions. The fact that they're calling it job abandonment when you're following doctor's orders and communicating with them shows they're either uninformed about the law or deliberately trying to create grounds to deny future unemployment benefits. A few additional thoughts: - Keep copies of ALL communications (emails, texts, voicemails) - Consider sending a certified letter to HR reiterating your position and medical restrictions - If you have an employee handbook, review the job abandonment policy - I bet it requires lack of communication for multiple days - Contact your state representative's office if you need help navigating EDD - they often have constituent services that can cut through red tape You're doing everything right by following medical advice. Don't let them bully you into returning before you're medically cleared. Your health comes first, and the law is on your side here even if they're trying to make you think otherwise.
Hi everyone, I'm facing a decision about disability benefits and really need some advice. I've been on CA State Disability Insurance for about 2 months now (recovering from back surgery - ruptured L4/L5 disc). My doctor just told me recovery will take longer than expected, probably another 3-4 months total. Here's my situation: My employer offers a private long-term disability plan that kicks in after 90 days, which I'll hit in about 3 weeks. The state SDI is paying me about 60% of my salary, and the company LTD plan supposedly covers up to 40% of salary. My question is: Can I receive BOTH benefits simultaneously? Would this essentially give me 100% salary replacement? Or would enrolling in my employer's plan reduce or eliminate my state SDI benefits? I can't find any clear info on the EDD website about how private disability plans interact with state benefits. I'm trying to figure out if it's worth going through all the paperwork and medical documentation again for the private plan. The forms look complicated and my HR department hasn't been very helpful. Has anyone been in this situation before? Any insights would be greatly appreciated!
California SDI benefits are not subject to CA state income tax. For federal taxes, it depends on how you paid into the system. If your SDI contributions were taken from your paycheck after taxes, then your benefits would be tax-free federally. If your contributions were pre-tax, then your benefits would be subject to federal income tax. Most employee contributions in California are post-tax, meaning most people's SDI benefits are completely tax-free, but you should verify your specific situation.
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now and wanted to share what I've learned from my research. First, definitely apply for both - you're entitled to whatever benefits you've earned through your premiums and employer contributions. One thing I discovered that might help you is to request a "benefit estimate" from your employer's LTD carrier before you actually apply. Most insurers will provide this if you call them directly. This way you'll know exactly how much they plan to pay after the SDI offset, so you can decide if the paperwork is worth it. Also, timing matters! Since you're close to the 90-day mark, make sure you understand your LTD plan's definition of "elimination period." Some plans require you to be continuously disabled for 90 days, while others just require 90 days of disability within a certain timeframe. If there's any gap in your SDI claim, it could affect your LTD eligibility. Good luck with your recovery - back surgery is no joke! Take the time you need to heal properly.
I just had my 31-week pregnancy appointment and due to some complications, my OB is putting me on bedrest and disability. They handed me the disability form (DE 2501?) and said to fill out my portion, then bring it back with $25 and they'll complete their section and submit it for me. This is my first time dealing with pregnancy disability and I'm confused - does having the doctor submit it make the EDD process faster? Or would I get my benefits just as quickly if I apply online through SDI Online myself? I'm worried about delays since my doctor's office seems busy and I've heard horror stories about EDD wait times. Has anyone gone either route and can share how long it took to get approved? I need to figure this out ASAP since I wasn't financially prepared to stop working this early!
One additional point about pregnancy disability through SDI: make sure you understand how the benefit periods work. You can typically receive SDI benefits for up to 4 weeks before your due date and 6 weeks after vaginal delivery or 8 weeks after cesarean delivery (longer if there are complications). Since you're going on disability earlier (at 31 weeks), your claim will be based on medical necessity rather than the standard pregnancy period. After your SDI pregnancy disability benefits end, you may be eligible for Paid Family Leave (PFL) to bond with your baby for an additional 8 weeks. This requires a separate application but uses the same online system. I recommend applying for PFL about 2 weeks before your SDI benefits end to avoid gaps in payment.
Just wanted to add my experience from last month - I was in a similar situation at 29 weeks and chose to file online myself. It was honestly pretty straightforward, even though I was nervous about messing something up! The SDI Online portal walks you through each step and you can save your progress if you need to take breaks. One tip: have your employer's information handy (full company name, address, your employee ID if you have one) because they ask for detailed work history. Also make sure you're clear on your last day worked vs. first day disabled - those dates matter for your benefit calculation. I got approved in about 8 days total, but like others mentioned, the key was staying on top of my doctor's office to submit their part quickly. I called them the day after I filed online to confirm they got the electronic request. Save yourself the $25 and do it online - you've got this! And congratulations on your pregnancy, hope the rest of your bedrest goes smoothly. 馃挄
Aurora St.Pierre
wait are u sure its actually a brand new claim and not just a continued claim?? those are different and might be treated differently with the appeal stuff going on
0 coins
Olivia Evans
AuthorYes, it's definitely a new claim. My original benefit year ended completely (it was for the knee replacement) and this new claim is for a different condition that developed during my recovery. I had to submit a completely new application with new medical certification from my doctor.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
I'm going through something very similar right now! EDD claimed I had a $1,900 overpayment when I transitioned from UI to SDI for my shoulder surgery in January. Like you, I have all the documentation proving there was no overlap - I even have the confirmation number from when I called to stop my UI payments before my surgery date. My appeal hearing is scheduled for August, and I just filed a new SDI claim last week for complications from the surgery. The EDD rep I spoke with said the same thing - that my new claim should process normally despite the pending appeal. I'm supposed to certify for the first time on my new claim this Sunday, so I'll know soon if the payments actually come through. One thing that helped me feel more confident was calling my local assemblymember's office like you did. They told me that in their experience, most of these transition overpayments are EDD errors and usually get overturned at the hearing. Having that political pressure seems to help keep things moving. I'll update this thread after I certify this weekend to let you know if my payments come through normally. Hopefully we both get this resolved quickly!
0 coins