Medi-Cal income went over limit during year do I owe share of cost
So I've been on Medi-Cal for about two years and earlier this year I picked up a lot of extra shifts at my job, like way more than usual, and my income went up for a few months. It came back down after the summer but during those months I was definitely making more than I normally do. Now I got a letter that says something about a share of cost and I honestly have no idea what that even means or if I owe money to Medi-Cal itself. Do I owe them money for those months? I already reported the income change in BenefitsCal when it happened but I'm not sure what comes next. The letter doesn't totally make sense to me and I don't know if I'm supposed to pay the county or my doctor or what.
70 comments

NebulaNova
The share of cost showing on your Notice of Action is not a bill from Medi-Cal and you don't send money to the county. The way it works is that in a month when you need care, you show your provider that you're committing to pay the first chunk of your medical costs yourself, up to that share of cost amount, and then Medi-Cal picks up the rest. If you don't get care in a given month, you don't owe anything at all for that month. It resets every month from scratch. So those extra-shift months when your income was higher, the county may have recalculated what your share of cost is based on that new income you reported. The notice should have the dollar amount printed on it.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorOk so the amount on the letter is what I'd have to pay the doctor, not Medi-Cal directly? That actually makes more sense. And if I don't go to the doctor that month I don't owe anything?
0 coins
NebulaNova
Exactly right. The provider is who you pay, not the county, and only in months you actually use a service. Months you stay healthy and don't need care, that share of cost sits there but you're not on the hook for it.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Wanted to add one thing: the share of cost amount the notice shows is for each month, and it can change if your income changes again. If your pay goes back down like you said, reporting that to the county might bring the amount down or even bring you back to no share of cost.
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Retroactive Medi-Cal came up on my own case around the same time I was trying to understand a share of cost situation, so I ended up phoning the county. BenefitsCal was showing one thing and my doctor's bill was showing something else for the same months. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I used to get through, letting it hold the line while I went about my morning, and I ended up talking to a county worker. The worker pulled up my case and confirmed the retroactive Medi-Cal request had been recorded and told me which month it covered. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorHadn't even thought about retroactive Medi-Cal for those earlier months. If the county decides my income did push me out of regular coverage during that stretch, could retroactive help cover bills from before I figured all this out?
0 coins
Paolo Conti
Retroactive can cover bills from up to three months before you applied, as long as you qualified in those months, and you have up to a year from the month of service to ask for it. The worker confirmed the month on my case, and that's how I knew which bills to bring to my doctor.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
The key on retroactive is whether you actually qualified in those months even with the higher income. If the extra shifts pushed you above the limit, you might not have qualified then, so retroactive wouldn't apply. If you stayed under, it's worth asking the county.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Reports I've made to BenefitsCal in the middle of the year always took a while to show up in my actual coverage. When your income went back down after summer, did you report that second change too? The county only knows what you tell them, and each change is a new 10-day window to report. If you didn't report the drop, they might still be calculating your share of cost based on the higher number.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorReported the raise but I honestly don't remember if I went back in and reported when it dropped again. Going to check BenefitsCal tonight.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Both directions matter, up and down. Missing the downward report is super common and it just means your share of cost stays higher than it needs to be until the county gets the new number.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
BenefitsCal at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login is where you can log in and report the income drop if you haven't yet. Do it as soon as you can, definitely within 10 days of when the pay went back to normal.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Went through almost this identical situation last renewal cycle with the extra summer income. I want to push back a little on something: the share of cost only applies under what they call Non-MAGI rules, which is usually people who are older or have a disability. For most working adults 19 to 64 on regular Medi-Cal through the income rules, the county doesn't assign a share of cost — instead, if your income goes too high, they'd move you off Medi-Cal entirely and toward Covered California. So what does your Notice of Action actually say about why you have this share of cost?
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorThe letter doesn't say MAGI or Non-MAGI anywhere that I can find. It just says share of cost and shows an amount. How do I figure out which one I'm on?
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Calling the county directly is the fastest way to find out which category your case is in. They can tell you exactly what rules are being applied to your case. The notice should also say the reason for the action somewhere in the fine print.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Agreed with the person above. For standard MAGI adults, income going over the limit usually triggers a letter sending you to Covered California, not a share of cost notice. If you're seeing a share of cost, it may mean your case is being handled under different rules, possibly because of something else on your case. Worth asking the county to clarify.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
SAME THING HAPPENED TO ME two summers ago and nobody at the county could explain it clearly over the phone. I sat on hold for literally over an hour twice and gave up. Eventually I just waited for my renewal and sorted it out then but I had no idea what I was supposed to do with that share of cost letter for months. The system is so frustrating when you're just trying to work extra and do the right thing by reporting it.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorThat's exactly where I am. I reported everything when I was supposed to and now I have this letter I don't understand and I don't know if I'm in trouble.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
You're not in trouble. You reported the change, that was the right move. The notice is just the county telling you what your Medi-Cal looks like given your new income. Figure out if the share of cost is from MAGI or Non-MAGI rules and go from there.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
The county lines are brutal right now. I've had luck going early in the week but even then it's not guaranteed you'll get through before they cut off the queue.
0 coins
Malik Davis
Appealing a share of cost amount was what I ended up doing last year because mine came out higher than I expected from a Notice of Action I didn't understand. The 90-day window to ask for a State Fair Hearing from the date on that notice is the deadline to watch, and it goes fast when you're waiting to figure out what's even going on. Claimyr is what I used to get a county worker on the line without burning my whole lunch break on hold. The worker looked up my State Fair Hearing request and confirmed it had been filed and was in the system. I still had to go through the actual hearing process, but at least I knew the request wasn't lost.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorDidn't realize the 90-day window applied to this kind of notice too. So if I disagree with the share of cost they calculated, I'd need to ask for a hearing within 90 days of the date on the letter?
0 coins
Malik Davis
Exactly. The date printed on the Notice of Action is what the 90 days runs from, not the day you receive it, so if the letter sat in the mail for a few days you have a little less time than you think.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
To ask for a hearing you can go through the county office, or call 1-800-743-8525, or do it online through the California Department of Social Services. The hearing is in front of a judge who isn't part of your county office, so it's a fair shot to explain what happened.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Filing the hearing request within the window is the important part. Even if you're still figuring out the details, get the request in and you can sort out your argument later.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
Income going up during the year and down again sounds like it could also affect your upcoming renewal, not just right now. At your renewal the county is going to look at your current income, and if it's back to the lower level, that might clear up the share of cost situation entirely or bring the amount way down. When is your renewal due?
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorBenefitsCal shows my renewal coming up in a few months. So if my income is back to normal by then I should report the lower number on the renewal form?
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
Exactly, put the current income on the renewal form, whatever it is at that time. The share of cost the county calculates at renewal will be based on what you report then.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Renewal is also a good time to double-check that you're on the right track with MAGI versus Non-MAGI. If your income is back under the limit and you're a standard adult under 65 with no disability coverage, you shouldn't have a share of cost at all, and the county should catch that at renewal.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Something that tripped me up when my pay changed: I thought the share of cost was what I'd owe every month no matter what, like a monthly premium. It's not. You only run into it in months you actually need care, and even then you only pay up to that amount before Medi-Cal steps in. If you have a healthy month, that share of cost number on the letter is basically just sitting there doing nothing.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorThat's such a relief honestly. I thought I was going to get a bill every single month.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Nope. No care that month, no payment that month. It's not like a plan premium where you owe it regardless.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
The provider you see is who collects it from you, not the county, and not all providers will bill you for it the same way. The first time you go in with a share of cost, ask the front desk how they handle it because every office does it a little differently.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Covered California is where the county usually points people when income goes above the Medi-Cal limit, but that's for people who go over the limit and stay over. For someone who went over for a few months and came back down, the county handles that as a reported change and adjusts accordingly. If the county had terminated your Medi-Cal and sent you to Covered California, your notice would say that pretty clearly instead of showing a share of cost.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorMine definitely says share of cost not terminated so at least I'm still on Medi-Cal. I just need to figure out whether the amount is right.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Keeping the notice and all the dates is important. If you do end up asking for a hearing or calling the county, the notice date and the amount printed on it are what everything is built around.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Does anyone know if the extra shift income would count the same as a raise? Like my hours went up not my rate, so the gross was higher for those months but each individual check was at the same hourly pay. Wondering if the county sees that differently or if it's all just gross income no matter how it got there.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Whether it comes from more hours or a higher rate, what the county looks at is the gross amount on your pay stub for the period. The same hourly rate with more hours in a month shows up as higher gross income and that's what counts.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Makes sense, just wanted to make sure they weren't going to get picky about the reason for it.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
The proof the county asks for is usually the most recent pay stub showing the gross, the pay period dates, and the hours. That's what tells the county what your income is, whatever caused it to go up.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Figuring out the date on the Notice of Action was what I needed to get sorted first on a share of cost situation I had a few months back. The letter had arrived late and I wasn't sure if the 90-day hearing window had already started ticking. Claimyr is what I used to reach the county worker, and the worker read me the exact date the Notice of Action was issued, which was different from the date I got it. That date was what I needed to know whether I still had time to file for a hearing.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorThat date difference matters more than I thought. Mine came in a pretty thick envelope with other stuff so I'm not sure exactly when it was actually sent.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
The date printed right on the notice itself is the one the 90 days runs from. The postmark on the envelope doesn't change that. Count from the date at the top of the letter.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Pulling that date from the notice and writing it down somewhere visible is the first thing I do with any NOA now. Lost track of a deadline once and it's not a mistake you want to make twice.
0 coins
StarStrider
My mom went through something similar and kept thinking the share of cost was like Medicare's deductible and that she owed the county the whole amount upfront each month. She was on Medi-Cal not Medicare but kept confusing them. The share of cost and the Medicare deductible are totally different things and completely separate programs.
0 coins
StarStrider
For anyone wondering: Medi-Cal is the state program run by DHCS and the county. Medicare is the federal program for people who are 65 or older or have certain disabilities. Some people have both, but they work separately and you don't confuse one's rules for the other's.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
That confusion is SO common. I've seen people at the county office lobby waiting to pay their Medi-Cal share of cost directly at the window and looking baffled when the clerk says that's not how it works.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
If you're still not clear on whether that share of cost was calculated correctly after reading all this, the Notice of Action itself should have a contact number or instructions for reaching your county. Reading it line by line and finding that section is worth doing before anything else because it tells you what to do if you disagree with the decision.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorGoing back through the letter again tonight. It's a few pages and I skimmed it the first time because it looked like junk mail almost.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
The page with the actual decision summary and the rights section is usually toward the back. That page has the amount, the reason, and the deadline to dispute.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Depending on how many months your income was higher, the county might have only adjusted the share of cost going forward from when you reported it, not for months already past. The 10-day reporting rule is there partly to set where changes take effect. Worth confirming with the county whether the share of cost applies from the month you reported or from some other date.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorI reported it pretty much within the week of getting the new pay stubs so hopefully that counts. But I didn't know there was a 10-day window, I just did it fast because it felt like the right thing to do.
0 coins
Amina Diallo
Doing it fast was absolutely right. The 10-day window is the rule and you beat it. Keep the confirmation from BenefitsCal showing when you submitted that report.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
The letter probably also says whether your Medi-Cal is now under a managed care plan or Fee-for-Service while this is all getting sorted. If you need to see a doctor before the share of cost situation is fully resolved, you'd still use whatever coverage is active, you just bring the notice so the provider knows your share of cost amount for that month.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorI do have a plan already, have had one since I first got approved. So my BIC should still work I guess?
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
As long as your Medi-Cal is still active and not terminated, your BIC should work and your plan should be good. The share of cost is an amount layered on top, not a reason coverage stops.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
If the BIC or the plan shows something unexpected when you try to use it, the county is the first call, not the plan. The county holds the eligibility and the plan just follows what the county has on file.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Has anyone ended up on Covered California after Medi-Cal adjusted for income? I've been in this situation where I worried every extra shift would kick me off and I'd have to scramble to get a Covered California plan started. How much runway does the county actually give you if your income pushes you over the limit for good?
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
If Medi-Cal terminates because your income is too high, the Notice of Action points you to Covered California at coveredca.com or 1-800-300-1506. The county sends the referral and Covered California can help you find a plan. How quickly that transition needs to happen and what's available is worth asking Covered California directly.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
Good to know there's an actual handoff rather than just a letter saying you're done. I'll keep Covered California's number saved just in case.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
The notice also matters because a termination for income going over the limit is different from a termination for a paperwork reason. Each one has different next steps, so reading which reason is stated on the notice helps you know exactly where to call.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
Filing your income changes in BenefitsCal is one thing, but keeping screenshots or notes of when you submitted them is something most people skip and then regret. If the county claims it didn't get a report on time, having a record of your submission timestamp is the only way to defend yourself.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
AuthorGoing to start doing this. I think BenefitsCal shows something when you submit but I never thought to save it.
0 coins
Oliver Schulz
After you submit anything in BenefitsCal, the confirmation screen is worth screenshotting. Some people print to PDF. Whatever your method, save it somewhere you can find it at renewal time or if anything gets disputed later.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Pulling this all together for anyone finding this thread later: share of cost is for certain Medi-Cal categories, not all adults qualify under it, and if you do have one it's paid to your provider in months you use care, not to the county. Reporting income changes within 10 days is the rule, both when it goes up and when it comes back down. The Notice of Action date starts the 90-day clock for a State Fair Hearing if you disagree. And if income stays too high and Medi-Cal ends, Covered California is the next step.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
Bookmarked this thread. I wish someone had laid it out this clearly when I was going through it.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
The 90-day hearing window being from the NOA date, not the date you receive it, is the detail that bites people most often. Really important to flag.
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
Coming back to say I found the section in the notice that explains the share of cost amount and also checked BenefitsCal. I do still have active coverage, the share of cost is there because apparently my case type changed temporarily when my income went up. I reported the income drop from after summer too, just did it tonight. Now I'm going to watch for a new Notice of Action that hopefully shows the share of cost is gone or lower. Thanks everyone for helping me understand what I was actually looking at.
0 coins
NebulaNova
Reporting the drop was the right move. Watch for the new notice and check that the amount changed. If it doesn't update after the county has had time to process it, that's when calling the county directly would be worth doing.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
Watching for that new NOA is exactly right. If the new income is below the limit and your case goes back to standard MAGI, the share of cost should drop off entirely. The notice will confirm it.
0 coins