< Back to CalWorks

Marcelle Drum

CalWORKs sending child support payments I don't want - how to stop collection without losing benefits?

I'm so confused right now... I just received an envelope with child support money from my daughter's father, and I honestly don't want it. I NEVER asked the county to collect child support from him! We have our own arrangement that works for us, and now this official child support thing is going to cause problems between us. He's already texting me all upset thinking I went behind his back. Does anyone know if I can tell CalWORKs to STOP collecting child support? Will this affect my Cash Aid if I refuse the payments? I'm worried that if I don't cash this check they'll cut my benefits, but if I do accept it, it's going to create a huge mess with my daughter's dad. Help please!! Has anyone dealt with this before?

Yes, you can stop child support collection, but it WILL affect your CalWORKs benefits. When you applied for CalWORKs, you automatically assigned your rights to child support to the county unless you claimed good cause. This is mandatory - they don't really make this clear during the application process. You have a few options: 1. Accept the child support payments and your Cash Aid will be reduced by that amount (minus the first $100 which you get to keep as a "disregard") 2. Request a "good cause" exemption if collecting support puts you or your child at risk 3. Close your CalWORKs case completely Unfortunately, you can't receive full CalWORKs benefits AND stop the child support collection. It's one of the requirements.

0 coins

Omg they never explained this to me when I applied! So even though I said I didn't want child support they're still going to collect it?? What if my daughter's dad loses his job because of this garnishment? He's already helping me with diapers and stuff directly.

0 coins

The same thing hapend 2 me hun and it was a MESS. my kids dad was so mad he stopped seeing the kids for 3 months!!! ugh. they take the money no matter what u say when u get calworks. something about the county has 2 collect from the dad 2 pay back the benifits they give u.

0 coins

That's exactly what I'm afraid of! Did you ever figure out how to fix it? Our situation is complicated and this could really mess things up for my daughter.

0 coins

This is a standard part of receiving CalWORKs. When you sign up, there's a section about child support cooperation that requires you to assist with establishing paternity and collecting child support from the absent parent. This money primarily goes to reimburse the county for your Cash Aid, except for the first $100 per month. The only way around this is to request a "good cause" exemption, which requires proving that pursuing child support would be harmful to you or your child (physical danger, rape cases, domestic violence situations, etc.). You can contact your caseworker to discuss your options, but be prepared for possibly reduced benefits if you want to stop the collection process without a good cause determination.

0 coins

I tried calling my worker 5 times this week and keep getting the automated system. Can I apply for this "good cause" thing online or do I have to talk to someone?

0 coins

Try using Claimyr to get through to your CalWORKs worker. I was in a similar situation last month needing to explain my own child support situation - called for days with no luck. Used claimyr.com service and got a callback within 45 minutes. There's a video demo at https://youtu.be/jzISHxCPLwE showing how it works. It's the only way I could actually get a real person to talk to about my case. Good luck! Child support stuff is seriously complicated with CalWORKs.

0 coins

Thank you! Never heard of this but I'm desperate at this point. I'll try anything to get this fixed before my daughter's father gets more upset.

0 coins

Hate to be the bearer of bad news, but when u sign the calworks paperwork u literally ASSIGN your child support rights to the county. I found this out the hard way!!! I dont have contact with my sons father anymore bcuz of this exact thing. The county garnished his wages without warning and now he wont even talk to me.

0 coins

YUP!!!! They do this to everyone and don't explain it clearly! My worker acted like I had a CHOICE about child support when I really didn't! So messed up.

0 coins

This sucks but its NOT as bad as everyone's saying. call ur worker and ask for the GOOD CAUSE form RIGHT AWAY. they shud have explained this but they never do smh. the form lets u explain why collecting support wud be bad for u or ur kid. u can say it will damage ur co-parenting relationship or something. they might approve it they might not but WORTH TRYING. also the check u got, u can keep $100 of it without it affecting ur cash aid but anything over that they take back anyway. so cash it and just explain to ur daughters dad that u didnt ask for this its just calworks policy

0 coins

Thanks for explaining it so clearly! Does the $100 disregard apply per kid or just total? And do you know how long the good cause determination takes? I'm worrying this will mess up my recertification next month.

0 coins

To answer your follow-up questions: 1. The $100 disregard is per FAMILY not per child (it used to be $50 but increased to $100 a couple years ago) 2. Good cause determinations typically take 20-30 days but can be expedited if there's an urgent situation 3. This shouldn't affect your recertification as long as you're cooperating with the process Also, important to note - if you get good cause approved, you'll still receive the full CalWORKs grant. You're not penalized for having a valid good cause exemption from child support collection.

0 coins

This is so helpful. One last question - if I already cashed the check, can I still apply for good cause? I was confused and deposited it yesterday before understanding all this.

0 coins

Yes, you can still apply for good cause even if you cashed the check. What matters is going forward. But be prepared - good cause exemptions aren't automatically approved. You'll need to provide a statement explaining why collecting child support would be harmful to you or your child's physical/emotional wellbeing. Common approved reasons include: - History of domestic violence - Risk of physical/emotional harm to you or child - Child was conceived due to rape/incest - Adoption proceedings in process - Working with family services agency on family reunification "We have our own arrangement" unfortunately isn't usually considered good cause by itself. You might need to explain how the formal collection would damage your co-parenting relationship to the point it harms your child.

0 coins

Thank you for this information. I'll definitely apply for good cause and explain how this would damage our co-parenting setup. I just wish the county would have explained this clearly from the beginning!

0 coins

I went through this exact same situation about 6 months ago! It's SO frustrating that they don't explain this clearly when you apply. Here's what I learned: The county is required by federal law to pursue child support when you receive CalWORKs - it's called "cooperation with child support enforcement" and it's automatic unless you get a good cause exemption approved. A few things that might help: - You can explain to your daughter's father that this wasn't your choice - show him the CalWORKs paperwork if you still have it - The county keeps most of the child support to reimburse themselves for your benefits, so he's basically paying the state, not you directly - If your informal arrangement was working better, document how much he was helping you before (diapers, formula, etc.) to show the caseworker I ended up getting good cause approved by explaining that the formal collection was damaging our ability to co-parent effectively, which was hurting my son emotionally. It took about a month but was worth it. Don't give up - you have options!

0 coins

I'm so sorry you're going through this - it's one of the most confusing and poorly explained parts of CalWORKs! I had a similar shock when I first got benefits and suddenly my ex was getting wage garnishments he didn't expect. Here's what I wish someone had told me earlier: when you sign up for CalWORKs, you're legally required to "assign" your child support rights to the county. It's buried in all that paperwork they rush you through. The county then collects support to pay themselves back for the cash aid they give you. A few practical tips: - Call your caseworker ASAP and ask for the "good cause" form (CF 8572) - Document how this is affecting your co-parenting relationship - Be specific about how formal collection could harm your daughter (like if dad might reduce his informal help or visits) - Keep records of what he was already providing voluntarily The good news is that if you get good cause approved, you keep your full CalWORKs grant AND the child support collection stops. It's not a penalty situation. Also, try explaining to your daughter's dad that this is county policy, not something you requested. Show him this thread if it helps! Many parents don't realize this is automatic with CalWORKs. Hang in there - this can be fixed but you need to act quickly to get the good cause process started.

0 coins

This is incredibly helpful - thank you for breaking it down so clearly! I'm definitely going to ask for that CF 8572 form right away. It's so frustrating that they make this process so confusing and don't explain the child support assignment upfront. I really appreciate you sharing your experience and giving me hope that this can be resolved. Going to start documenting everything about our current arrangement and how the formal collection is already causing problems. Thank you again!

0 coins

I'm really sorry you're dealing with this frustrating situation! As someone new to CalWORKs, I'm learning so much from this thread about how the child support assignment works. It sounds like you have several people here who've been through similar experiences and are giving you solid advice. From what I'm reading, it seems like your best bet is to get that good cause form (CF 8572) as soon as possible and document how the formal collection is disrupting your co-parenting arrangement. Maybe you could also write down specific examples of how your daughter's father was helping before (like the diapers you mentioned) and how this change is affecting your daughter's relationship with him. It's really unfortunate that the county doesn't explain this child support assignment clearly during the application process - it seems like so many people get blindsided by this! I hope you're able to get through to your caseworker soon and get this sorted out. Your daughter's wellbeing and your co-parenting relationship are definitely worth fighting for. Good luck with everything, and please keep us updated on how the good cause application goes!

0 coins

Thank you so much for the encouragement! It really helps to know I'm not alone in dealing with this. You're right that documenting everything is key - I'm going to write down all the ways he was helping before (he was buying formula, diapers, and even helped with groceries sometimes) and how his reaction to this surprise garnishment is already affecting our daughter. She keeps asking why daddy seems upset when he comes to pick her up. It's honestly shocking how many people in this thread have been caught off guard by the same thing. You'd think they would make this a bigger part of the CalWORKs orientation or something! I'm definitely going to push for that CF 8572 form and be very detailed about how this is impacting our family dynamics. Fingers crossed the good cause determination goes in my favor. Thanks again for the support!

0 coins

I'm so sorry you're going through this stressful situation! As someone who's been on CalWORKs for about a year now, I can totally relate to feeling blindsided by policies they don't explain clearly upfront. From reading through all these responses, it sounds like you have a solid plan forming - getting that CF 8572 good cause form and documenting how the formal collection is disrupting your co-parenting relationship. I'd also suggest maybe taking screenshots of any texts between you and your daughter's father that show how this surprise garnishment caught both of you off guard and is causing tension. One thing that stood out to me is how you mentioned your daughter is already noticing that daddy seems upset during pickups. That kind of emotional impact on your child could actually be really important evidence for your good cause application - it shows this isn't just about convenience, but about protecting your daughter's wellbeing and her relationship with her father. I hope your caseworker is understanding when you finally get through to them. It's frustrating that so many families have to deal with this confusion, but at least you found this community to help guide you through it. Wishing you the best with the good cause determination!

0 coins

That's such a great point about documenting the texts and your daughter's emotional reaction! I hadn't thought about how her noticing daddy being upset could actually strengthen the good cause application. Kids are so perceptive - it really shows this isn't just an adult inconvenience but something that's genuinely affecting her wellbeing. I'm also new to navigating CalWORKs and this whole thread has been eye-opening about how many "automatic" policies they don't properly explain. It seems like the child support assignment should be highlighted in big bold letters during the application process, not buried in fine print! Your idea about screenshotting texts is smart too - having that real-time evidence of how the surprise garnishment blindsided both parents could be really compelling for the caseworker. I hope when you do get through to them, they recognize that protecting your daughter's relationship with her father is exactly what good cause exemptions are meant to address. Keeping my fingers crossed for you that this gets resolved quickly!

0 coins

I'm so sorry this happened to you! As someone who recently went through the CalWORKs application process myself, I'm honestly shocked reading all these responses about how they automatically assign your child support rights to the county. I definitely don't remember that being clearly explained during my intake - it sounds like this catches SO many families off guard! From everything everyone has shared here, it seems like your best path forward is definitely getting that CF 8572 good cause form ASAP. The fact that your daughter is already noticing tension between you and her dad during visits really shows this is affecting her wellbeing, which sounds like exactly the kind of situation good cause exemptions are designed for. I hope you're able to get through to your caseworker soon (maybe try that Claimyr service someone mentioned?) and get this sorted out before it damages your co-parenting relationship further. It's really frustrating that the county puts families in these impossible situations without proper warning. You shouldn't have to choose between getting help for your family and maintaining a healthy relationship with your daughter's father. Sending you lots of support - please keep us updated on how the good cause application goes!

0 coins

Thank you so much for the kind words and support! You're absolutely right that they really don't make this child support assignment clear at all during the application process. I feel like I signed away rights I didn't even know I had! I'm definitely going to try that Claimyr service someone mentioned earlier - at this point I'm willing to try anything to actually speak with a real person about this. The automated system has been useless and I need to get that CF 8572 form started ASAP. It's honestly heartbreaking seeing my daughter confused about why her dad seems stressed during visits. She shouldn't have to deal with adult drama, especially when this whole mess could have been avoided with better communication from the county upfront. I really appreciate everyone in this thread sharing their experiences - it's helping me feel less alone and giving me hope that the good cause exemption might actually work. I'll definitely update everyone once I hear back about the determination. Fingers crossed this can be resolved before it causes any more damage to our family situation!

0 coins

I'm really sorry you're dealing with this confusing situation! As someone who's new to this community, I'm learning so much from reading everyone's experiences here. It's honestly shocking how many people have been caught off guard by this automatic child support assignment - it really seems like CalWORKs should explain this policy much more clearly during the application process. From all the helpful advice people have shared, it sounds like your best bet is definitely to request that CF 8572 good cause form immediately and document how the formal collection is disrupting your co-parenting relationship. The fact that your daughter is already picking up on the tension and asking why daddy seems upset is really heartbreaking - but it also sounds like exactly the kind of evidence that could support your good cause application. I hope you're able to get through to your caseworker soon and get this resolved before it causes any more stress for your family. It's not fair that you have to choose between getting the support you need and maintaining a peaceful relationship with your daughter's father. Please keep us updated on how things go with the good cause determination - I think a lot of people here would benefit from hearing about your experience navigating this process!

0 coins

Thank you for the thoughtful response! As someone just starting to navigate this system, it's really reassuring to see how supportive this community is. You're absolutely right that the automatic child support assignment should be explained much more clearly - I had no idea this was even a thing until it happened to me! Reading through everyone's experiences has been both eye-opening and helpful. It's unfortunate that so many families get blindsided by this policy, but I'm grateful for all the practical advice people have shared about the good cause process and documenting the impact on co-parenting relationships. I'm definitely going to push hard to get that CF 8572 form and be very detailed about how this is affecting my daughter emotionally. Seeing her confused about why her dad is upset during visits just breaks my heart - no child should have to deal with that kind of tension. I'll absolutely keep everyone updated on how the good cause determination goes. Hopefully my experience can help other families who find themselves in similar situations. Thank you again for the encouragement - it really means a lot to know I'm not alone in dealing with this!

0 coins

I'm so sorry you're going through this - what a frustrating situation! As someone relatively new to CalWORKs myself, I'm honestly appalled reading through all these responses about how poorly the county explains the automatic child support assignment. It sounds like this catches almost everyone off guard, which is completely unacceptable. From everything I've learned in this thread, it seems like you have a really strong case for good cause, especially since your daughter is already being emotionally affected by the tension this has created. The fact that she's asking why daddy seems upset during visits shows this isn't just disrupting your co-parenting arrangement - it's actually harming your child's wellbeing, which is exactly what the good cause exemption is designed to protect against. I'd definitely recommend getting that CF 8572 form as soon as possible and being very detailed about: - How your informal arrangement was working before - The specific ways your daughter's father was helping (diapers, groceries, etc.) - How the surprise garnishment has changed his behavior/mood during visits - Your daughter's reaction to the tension It's really unfair that CalWORKs puts families in these impossible situations without proper warning. You shouldn't have to choose between getting help and maintaining a healthy co-parenting relationship. I really hope the good cause determination goes in your favor - please keep us posted on how it works out!

0 coins

This is such valuable advice - thank you for laying out exactly what to include in the good cause application! I hadn't thought about documenting the specific ways he was helping before (like groceries and other support beyond just diapers), but you're absolutely right that showing how the informal arrangement was actually working better for our family could be really compelling evidence. It's so frustrating that CalWORKs creates these situations where families have to prove that their own arrangements work better than the county's automatic processes. Like you said, no one should have to choose between getting help and maintaining healthy relationships that benefit their children. I'm definitely going to be very detailed in that CF 8572 form about all the points you mentioned. The emotional impact on my daughter really seems to be the strongest argument - it's heartbreaking that a 3-year-old has to witness adult stress that she doesn't understand, especially when it affects her relationship with her dad. Thank you for taking the time to break down exactly what to include. Having this kind of roadmap from someone who understands the system makes me feel much more confident about advocating for my family. I'll definitely update everyone once I hear back from the caseworker!

0 coins

I'm really sorry you're dealing with this stressful situation! As someone who's been on CalWORKs for about 8 months now, I can totally relate to feeling blindsided by policies they don't clearly explain during the application process. From reading through all the helpful responses here, it sounds like you have a really strong foundation for a good cause application. The fact that your daughter is already noticing the tension and asking why daddy seems upset is actually powerful evidence that this formal collection is harming her wellbeing - which is exactly what good cause exemptions are meant to protect against. I'd definitely recommend documenting everything as thoroughly as possible: - Screenshots of any texts showing how the surprise garnishment caught both of you off guard - A detailed list of how your daughter's father was helping before (diapers, formula, groceries, etc.) - Specific examples of how your daughter is being affected emotionally - Documentation of how your informal arrangement was actually working better for your family It's really unfair that the county puts families in these impossible positions without proper warning. You shouldn't have to choose between getting the support you need and maintaining a healthy co-parenting relationship that benefits your daughter. I hope you're able to get through to your caseworker soon and get that CF 8572 form started. Please keep us updated on how the good cause determination goes - your experience could really help other families who find themselves in similar situations!

0 coins

Thank you so much for this comprehensive advice! As someone new to navigating this system, I really appreciate you taking the time to break down exactly what documentation I should gather. You're absolutely right that having screenshots of the texts showing how shocked both of us were by the surprise garnishment could be really powerful evidence. I'm already starting to write down everything about how our informal arrangement was working - he was helping with so much more than I initially mentioned (formula, groceries, even gas money sometimes). It's actually making me realize how much this formal collection could disrupt, not just financially but in terms of our co-parenting dynamic. The part about documenting my daughter's emotional reaction really resonates with me. She's only 3 but she's definitely picking up on the tension, and that breaks my heart. No child should have to deal with that kind of stress, especially when it's caused by a policy that wasn't properly explained to begin with. I'm going to start working on getting all this documentation together while I try to reach my caseworker for that CF 8572 form. Thank you again for the encouragement and for sharing your experience - it really helps to know I'm not alone in dealing with these confusing CalWORKs policies!

0 coins

I'm so sorry you're going through this - it's really frustrating how CalWORKs doesn't clearly explain the child support assignment during the application process! As someone new to this community, I'm honestly shocked reading through all these responses about how many families get blindsided by this automatic policy. From everything I'm learning here, it sounds like you have several good options to explore. The CF 8572 good cause form seems like your best bet, especially since your daughter is already being emotionally affected by the tension this has created between you and her father. The fact that she's asking why daddy seems upset during visits is heartbreaking but also strong evidence that this formal collection is harming her wellbeing. I'd definitely recommend documenting everything thoroughly - the informal support your daughter's father was providing before, how the surprise garnishment caught both of you off guard, and specific examples of how this is affecting your daughter's relationship with him. It sounds like you had a working arrangement that was actually better for your family than this formal collection process. It's really unfair that you have to choose between getting the help you need and maintaining a healthy co-parenting relationship. I hope you're able to get through to your caseworker soon and get this sorted out before it causes any more stress for your family. Please keep us updated on how the good cause determination goes - your experience could really help other families facing similar situations!

0 coins

Thank you so much for the supportive words! It's honestly been overwhelming trying to navigate this, but this community has been incredible in helping me understand what's happening and what my options are. You're absolutely right that it's shocking how many families get caught off guard by this - it really seems like CalWORKs should make this child support assignment a much more prominent part of the application process instead of burying it in paperwork. I'm definitely going to focus on documenting everything thoroughly like you suggested. Looking back, our informal arrangement was actually working really well - he was consistent with help and our daughter had a great relationship with him without any of this legal/formal pressure. Now she keeps asking me why daddy looks sad when he picks her up, and it just breaks my heart that a 3-year-old has to witness this kind of adult stress. I've started writing down all the specific ways he was helping before (diapers, formula, groceries, even helping with car repairs once), and I'm going to screenshot the texts that show how blindsided we both were by the garnishment notice. Hopefully all of this will make a strong case for the CF 8572 good cause determination. Thank you again for the encouragement - I'll definitely update everyone once I hear back from my caseworker. This thread has given me so much hope that this situation can be resolved!

0 coins

I'm so sorry you're dealing with this confusing and stressful situation! As someone who's also navigating CalWORKs as a single parent, I can totally relate to feeling blindsided by policies they don't explain clearly upfront. Reading through all the responses here, it sounds like you have really solid grounds for a good cause exemption. The fact that your 3-year-old is already picking up on the tension and asking why daddy seems upset is heartbreaking - but it's also exactly the kind of evidence that shows this formal collection is harming your child's wellbeing, which is what the CF 8572 form is designed to address. I'd definitely echo everyone's advice about documenting everything thoroughly: - All the ways your daughter's father was helping informally (sounds like he was doing a lot beyond just diapers!) - Screenshots of texts showing how the surprise garnishment caught you both off guard - Specific examples of how this is affecting your daughter emotionally - Evidence that your informal co-parenting arrangement was actually working better for your family It's really frustrating that CalWORKs puts families in these impossible positions without proper warning. You shouldn't have to choose between getting help and maintaining the healthy relationship your daughter has with her father. Definitely try that Claimyr service someone mentioned to get through to your caseworker faster - getting that good cause form started ASAP seems crucial. I'm keeping my fingers crossed that this gets resolved quickly for you and your daughter. Please keep us updated on how it goes!

0 coins

Thank you for such a thoughtful and comprehensive response! As someone who's new to this community and still learning about CalWORKs policies, I'm really grateful for everyone's guidance and support here. You're absolutely right that documenting everything thoroughly is going to be key - I've already started making a detailed list of all the informal support he was providing, and it's honestly eye-opening how much our arrangement was actually benefiting our daughter. The emotional impact on her has been the hardest part to watch. She's too young to understand why there's suddenly tension during what used to be happy pickup times with her dad. That alone makes me feel like this good cause application is worth fighting for - protecting her relationship with her father should be the priority here. I'm definitely going to try the Claimyr service today to get through to my caseworker faster. The automated system has been completely useless, and I need to get that CF 8572 form started immediately. It's frustrating that families have to jump through so many hoops to fix a problem that could have been avoided with better communication from CalWORKs upfront. Thank you again for all the encouragement and practical advice. This thread has given me so much hope that we can get this resolved and get back to the co-parenting arrangement that was actually working for our family. I'll definitely update everyone once I hear back about the good cause determination!

0 coins

CalWorks AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today