Can I remove baby from employer plan outside open enrollment with Medi-Cal approved?
My daughter was born in August and I added her to my job's insurance right away because I wasn't sure what else to do. A few weeks later I applied for Medi-Cal just for her since the premium on my work plan is honestly pretty steep for a dependent. The county approved her last week and her BIC arrived yesterday. Now I want to take her off the work plan to save money each month, but open enrollment at my job doesn't open until January. HR said I'd have to wait. Someone told me Medi-Cal approval counts as a qualifying event that lets you drop her outside open enrollment, but I'm not 100% sure that's a Medi-Cal rule or just something my coworker thought was true. Has anyone actually done this? Do I need to report the work coverage to Medi-Cal either way?
75 comments

Sasha Reese
HR departments don't always know every qualifying life event, so it's worth pushing back a little. Gaining coverage under a government health program like Medi-Cal is what a lot of employers recognize as a special enrollment trigger — but whether your specific plan allows it depends on your employer's plan documents, not on Medi-Cal's rules. Medi-Cal itself doesn't tell your job's HR what to do. What Medi-Cal does say is that you have to report other health coverage to the county within 10 days. So even if you keep your daughter on both for now, the county needs to know about the work plan.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThe 10-day thing — does that apply now that she's already approved, or only at application? The county never asked about the work plan during the application.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
It applies ongoing, not just at application. Any time her coverage situation changes, or if she has coverage you didn't mention before, you report it. BenefitsCal lets you submit a change, or you can call or go in person to your county office.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
HR told me the same thing last year for my son and I went to our benefits person specifically and showed them the government coverage letter and they let me drop him mid-year. The HR person at the front desk didn't know the rules but the actual benefits administrator did.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Your coworker is thinking of a federal HIPAA special enrollment rule, which is a different thing from anything Medi-Cal controls. Under that rule, gaining eligibility for Medicaid or a state program like Medi-Cal can let you drop employer coverage outside open enrollment. But it's your employer's plan that decides whether to honor it, and you'd need to give them written notice within a certain window — usually 30 days of the qualifying event. Your HR might not be familiar with that side of it. The person to ask is your benefits administrator or whoever handles your company's group health plan.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorSo Medi-Cal itself has nothing to do with whether my job lets me drop her? I thought the county could send something official.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
The county doesn't issue a letter telling your employer to remove her from the plan. The Notice of Action you got when she was approved is what you'd show HR as proof of the qualifying event. Whether they accept it is between you and your employer's plan.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
This is exactly what happened to us. I showed them the NOA and my benefits person said yes, that counts, and processed it. But my company is pretty big. Smaller employers sometimes just say no because they don't want the paperwork.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
BenefitsCal still showed my old county's plan assigned to my case three weeks after I moved, and Health Care Options had no record of the transfer either. I tried the Medi-Cal line a few times and it was ringing forever. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line so you actually get a live agent on the phone. Video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my case and confirmed the inter-county transfer was filed but the new county hadn't processed the plan enrollment yet, and that I'd get a packet in the mail from Health Care Options to pick a plan in the new county. That was what I needed to know so I could stop guessing.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorGlad you got that sorted. The plan transfer piece is something I hadn't even thought about — my daughter is already assigned to a plan here so I'm hoping we don't have complications if I ever move.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Inter-county transfers trip people up all the time. Good to know that Health Care Options is the right number to follow up on the plan side of things once the county handles the transfer itself.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
The hold times on the Medi-Cal line lately are brutal. Might look into that option for my own renewal situation.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
You said you need to report other health coverage to the county — does that mean if I drop my daughter from the work plan after getting her on Medi-Cal, I also have to report THAT change? Like do I have to tell the county every time her coverage changes in any direction?
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Yes, any change in coverage counts as something to report. If she's on the work plan and you drop her, you report that. If she gains coverage somewhere else later, you report that too. The county wants to know about other health coverage because it affects how Medi-Cal coordinates with it.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Ok that makes sense. So basically I report when she gets it, report when she loses it, and report anything else that changes. Got it.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Your daughter being added to Medi-Cal is the qualifying event from Medi-Cal's side. From the employer plan's side, the question is whether their plan documents list 'gaining eligibility for Medicaid or a state children's health program' as a special enrollment event. Federal rules do require group health plans to allow this under certain circumstances, so your employer's plan has to comply. I would go back to HR with that framing, specifically ask about the Medicaid special enrollment provision in your plan documents, and ask them to look it up rather than giving you an off-the-cuff answer.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThis is really useful framing. I'm going to ask HR to actually pull the plan documents instead of just saying 'wait for open enrollment.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
My employer's HR also gave me a flat no the first time I asked. Second time I sent an email asking specifically about the plan document language around Medicaid enrollment as a qualifying event and they came back a week later saying they would process the removal. Email leaves a paper trail too.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Exactly, ask in writing. And keep the NOA from the county because that's your documentation that the qualifying event happened.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
wait does the baby need to be covered under BOTH at the same time or is medi-cal enough on its own once it's approved
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Medi-Cal is enough on its own once approved — there's no requirement from Medi-Cal's side that she stay on the employer plan. The question is just whether your employer will let you remove her outside of open enrollment.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
ok so its really just an HR problem not a medi-cal problem got it
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Yep the county doesn't care whether she's also on the work plan. It's your employer's rules that are the sticking point here.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
The piece about reporting the work plan to Medi-Cal is real and people skip it all the time. When a Medi-Cal member has other health coverage, the county coordinates benefits — meaning the other plan is supposed to pay first and Medi-Cal second. That's why they need to know. If you end up dropping her from the work plan, you report that change too so the county knows she only has Medi-Cal going forward.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorSo I should report the work plan now even though I'm hoping to drop her from it soon? Or wait until I know whether I can actually remove her?
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Report now. The 10-day clock starts from when you knew about the coverage, not from when you decide what to do about it. You can report again later when she's removed from the work plan.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
This is the thing that gets people in trouble — they wait to see what happens and the county already knew about the other plan from some database, and then there's a question about why it wasn't reported. Better to report it yourself first.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
I went through almost this same situation in spring except it was my husband. I added him to Medi-Cal first and then tried to drop him from my employer plan. What nobody tells you is that the window to request the mid-year removal at your job can be short. Some employers say you have 30 days from the qualifying event. If your daughter's Medi-Cal approval was a few weeks ago, you might be running up against whatever window your plan uses. Worth asking HR specifically what date they'd count as the qualifying event and how many days you have from that date.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThe NOA was dated about 12 days ago. So if the window is 30 days I still have some time, but I need to move on this soon.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
12 days out is good. I'd email HR today with the NOA attached and ask them to confirm the deadline. That starts the paper trail and shows you asked within the window.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
The timing really does matter. My wife's renewal form had a due date I didn't notice until it was almost past, and dealing with that while also sorting out coverage questions was stressful. Just get the email to HR today and sort the Medi-Cal reporting piece through BenefitsCal so both are handled.
0 coins
Payton Black
Two pay stubs and a copy of a disconnection notice were what my county had been sitting on for six weeks, and BenefitsCal just said 'pending' with no detail. Tried calling my county office twice but the line rang and rang. Used Claimyr to get through to a live agent at the Medi-Cal line, and she told me the county was still waiting on a utility bill as a second address document — the two pay stubs weren't enough for my situation. Once I uploaded the utility bill in BenefitsCal the status moved within days.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Six weeks of pending with no explanation is so frustrating. At least you found out what was actually holding it up instead of just waiting and wondering.
0 coins
Payton Black
Exactly. Knowing the specific document that was missing made all the difference. Without that call I'd probably still be waiting.
0 coins
Harold Oh
Address verification seems to trip up a lot of people. I had a similar situation where the county needed a document I didn't expect — found out from calling the county office directly.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
Does having the work plan affect what health plan the baby gets assigned to for Medi-Cal? Like does Medi-Cal give a different plan to kids who also have private insurance?
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Your daughter still gets assigned to a Medi-Cal managed care plan in your county. The coordination of benefits — the other plan paying before Medi-Cal — happens at the billing level when she uses services, not by giving her a different Medi-Cal plan.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
ok so her BIC and her Medi-Cal plan stay the same regardless, the other insurance just factors in when a provider bills
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Right. Her BIC is still her BIC either way. And if you eventually drop her from the work plan, nothing changes on the Medi-Cal side — she stays in her plan.
0 coins
Summer Green
Honestly HR at a lot of companies just default to 'wait for open enrollment' because it's less work for them. The fact that federal rules require group plans to allow a Medicaid special enrollment event doesn't mean every HR person knows about it. I had to send my benefits department an actual excerpt before they believed me. Keep your NOA, ask in writing, and be specific about the federal requirement. You are probably going to have to educate them a little.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThat's kind of what I'm expecting at this point. I'll put together a written request with the NOA attached and ask them to point me to the plan document language.
0 coins
Summer Green
That's the right move. If they still push back, you can also check whether your employer is subject to ERISA and what your summary plan description says — but start with the direct written ask and see what they come back with.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
The summary plan description is the document that matters. If the federal requirement is in there and HR is still saying no, that's a different problem. But most of the time once you ask the right question in writing they find the right answer.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
My HR situation from last year — they made me submit a form along with the NOA and it took about a week to process. The effective date they used was the first of the month after I submitted, not the date of the NOA. So my son was on both for a few extra weeks while the paperwork processed. For us that was fine, but worth knowing the effective date they give you might not be immediate.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorGood to know. I'll ask HR what the effective date would be when I submit so I know what to expect and can plan the reporting to Medi-Cal accordingly.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Exactly — coordinate the reporting. If the work plan ends on a certain date, report that date to the county so the records match.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Seeing a few people mention the 10-day reporting window and I want to flag one thing people get confused about: reporting the coverage change to Medi-Cal and asking your employer to remove her from the plan are two separate things you do in parallel, not one after the other. You tell the county about the work plan now, and you ask HR to remove her now. Then when she's actually removed, you tell the county that too.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThat framing helps a lot. I was thinking of it as a sequence but it's actually two separate tracks happening at the same time.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
This is exactly right and I wish someone had explained it to me that way when I went through a similar situation. I kept waiting to hear from HR before doing anything with the county and ended up reporting late.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
The county doesn't wait for your employer to decide before it needs to know. Report what you know when you know it.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
My daughter has Medi-Cal and was also briefly on my employer's plan when she was first born. We did the same thing — applied for Medi-Cal because the work premium was too high for a dependent. Dropped her from the work plan after the Medi-Cal approval came through. HR processed it in about two weeks once I submitted the NOA. The whole process was less complicated than I expected once I had the documentation in hand.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThis is reassuring. Did you have to do anything specific with the county after the work plan ended, or did BenefitsCal handle it?
0 coins
Diez Ellis
I reported the change through BenefitsCal and also called my county office to confirm they received it. No issues after that.
0 coins
Harold Oh
People keep saying 'report to the county' — does that mean the county Medi-Cal office or do you call the health plan? I always get confused about which one handles what.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
County Medi-Cal office handles eligibility — that's where you report changes like income, address, or other health coverage. Your health plan handles the clinical side — finding a doctor, getting a referral, billing questions. For reporting that your daughter has or no longer has the work plan, you go to the county, not the health plan.
0 coins
Harold Oh
ok so eligibility stuff like coverage changes goes to the county, care and doctors stuff goes to the plan. that's the split
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Exactly. BenefitsCal is the easiest way to submit a change to the county. In person or by phone to your county office also works.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
The renewal on my daughter's case had a due date that BenefitsCal was showing but I wasn't sure if the form had actually been received by the county after I mailed it in. I'd been trying the Medi-Cal line on and off for two days with no luck — just long holds that dropped. Tried Claimyr and ended up talking to a worker who confirmed the form had been received and gave me the date it was logged. Huge relief because I was worried the mail had failed.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThe uncertainty of not knowing if something was actually received is the worst part. Good you got confirmation.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Mailing something to the county and then not knowing if it arrived is stressful. Worth a phone call to confirm any time something important goes in by mail.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Going forward I'm doing everything through BenefitsCal so there's a timestamp I can see myself.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
There's a question buried in here that I don't think got fully answered: what happens to her Medi-Cal if you can't get HR to agree to remove her from the work plan? The answer is nothing — Medi-Cal stays active. Having the employer plan at the same time doesn't disqualify her from Medi-Cal. The county just needs to know about it so they can coordinate billing properly.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThat's genuinely reassuring to hear. I was worried that if she stayed on the work plan it would somehow jeopardize the Medi-Cal.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Nope, doesn't jeopardize it. The county handles the coordination on their end. Your job is just to report it.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
I had the same worry and was relieved when I found out it doesn't work that way. The county coordinates, they don't disqualify.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Buried in all of this but worth making sure you have: your daughter's BIC is her Medi-Cal identification for providers. Doctors and pharmacies need it to bill Medi-Cal. Keep it somewhere safe and if she ever needs care before you sort out the employer plan question, that BIC gets her in with any Medi-Cal provider.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorGot it, yes, the BIC came in the mail last week and I've already tucked it away. Her first well-baby visit is next month so that timing worked out.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Good. If the BIC ever gets lost or the information on it needs to change, you contact your county office to get a replacement sent.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
I've been going back and forth on a similar situation with my nephew — he's on my sister's employer plan and she's trying to figure out whether to keep him on it now that he qualified for Medi-Cal. The piece about reporting the other coverage to the county is something she didn't know about. I'm going to pass this whole discussion along to her.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Tell her to report it sooner rather than later. The 10-day window applies from when she knew about it, and if the county finds out about unreported coverage it creates complications she doesn't want.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Will do. I think she assumed she'd just handle it at renewal time, which is exactly the wrong approach from what I'm reading here.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
The original question — can I remove baby from employer plan outside open enrollment with Medi-Cal — the short answer is probably yes, but it's your employer's group health plan that makes that call, not the county. Medi-Cal gives you the qualifying event documentation (the NOA) and requires you to report the other coverage. HR gives you the removal. Those are two different boxes to check and you need both.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThat's a clean summary. HR email is going out today with the NOA attached. And I'm putting the work plan into BenefitsCal as a reported change tonight.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
That's the right order. Let the paper trail do the work on both sides.
0 coins
Laila Prince
And if HR comes back confused, ask them to review the plan's summary plan description for the Medicaid special enrollment provision. That's the document that settles it.
0 coins