Covered Silver 70 deductible not counting toward out of pocket maximum — is this normal?
Picked a Silver plan through Covered California this year after getting financial help based on my income estimate. The plan level I landed on shows as Silver 70 on my insurance card and the summary of benefits. My issue is that whenever I get an EOB after a doctor visit or a lab, the amount I paid toward my deductible is not showing up as counting toward my out of pocket maximum at all. The two numbers just sit there separate, like they have nothing to do with each other. I called the insurance company and the person I spoke to said the deductible and the out of pocket maximum are tracked separately on this plan, which honestly made no sense to me. I always thought anything you paid toward your deductible automatically counted toward the out of pocket max. Is that actually a Covered California rule, or does each insurance company set that up differently? And if the deductible really doesn't roll into the OOP max, is there any point in even hitting the deductible? I'm on a pretty tight budget and I need to understand what I'm actually paying toward before I schedule anything else this year.
75 comments

Amina Toure
The renewal notice for my current plan had a plan listed that I never remembered picking, and the premium shown was different from what I paid all year. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold while I was at work, and when I ended up talking to a Covered California representative, she told me the renewal had defaulted to my existing plan with the income I had on file from last year, and the deadline to make a different choice before that locked in. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Covered California: https://youtu.be/9y0sXw7pbJU On your actual question: the deductible and the out of pocket maximum are both set by the insurance company, not by Covered California. Covered California decides what metal level you qualify for and what financial help you get, but the specific dollar amounts and what counts toward what are inside the plan itself. For something this detailed about how your EOBs are calculating, the insurance company is genuinely the right place to push back, not Covered California. Ask them to send you something in writing that explains how those two accumulators work on your specific plan.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
The part about the renewal defaulting to last year's income is exactly what I'm worried about heading into the next enrollment period. My income went up a lot this year and I never reported it mid-year the way you're supposed to. Does that just get corrected when I update it at renewal, or is there a problem I need to fix now?
0 coins
Amina Toure
Reporting a change in income is supposed to happen within 30 days of the change, in your Covered California account. If you didn't, the financial help you've been getting all year may not match what you actually earned, and that gets sorted out at tax time when you file with your 1095-A. Update it now in the account so at least the remaining months are right, and talk to a tax preparer about what happens on your return.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
The part about asking for it in writing from the insurance company is good advice. I asked mine to show me in writing which services were subject to the deductible and which weren't, and suddenly the numbers on my EOBs started making a lot more sense.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
What you're describing with the Silver 70 is actually something a lot of people don't realize going in. The Silver plan label — 70, 73, 87, 94 — refers to the actuarial value, meaning the share of average costs the plan covers. But how the deductible and the out of pocket maximum interact is in the plan documents, not in the metal level name. Some plans structure them so deductible payments feed directly into the OOP max. Others carve them out separately. Covered California requires plans to meet certain standards, but the internal math of how a deductible accumulates toward an OOP max is the insurance company's design. If you got a cost-sharing reduction because your income is at or below 250% of the FPL and you're on a Silver plan, your deductible and OOP max should both be lower than the standard Silver version — but whether deductible payments count toward the max is still the insurer's call on that plan. Push back on your insurance company and ask them to show you in the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage exactly how the OOP max accumulation works.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorThe income-based Silver levels hadn't even crossed my mind as a possibility here. My financial help notice did mention cost-sharing reductions but I didn't connect that to which version of Silver I was in. Would the number after Silver on my card — it says 70 — tell me which tier I'm in, or do I need to look somewhere else?
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
Silver 70 means you're on the standard Silver plan with the 70% actuarial value, not one of the Enhanced Silver tiers with deeper cost-sharing reductions. Those go higher — 73, 87, 94. At 70 you're getting the base cost-sharing reduction. The plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage will have the exact deductible amount and what it applies to, and the insurer can walk you through whether it counts toward the OOP max or not.
0 coins
Javier Morales
I didn't know there were different Silver levels at all. I thought Silver was just Silver. I'm going back to look at my own plan documents now because I have no idea which version I ended up with.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
The Enhanced Silver tiers are genuinely one of the least explained parts of Covered California enrollment. The Shop and Compare tool shows them when you're applying based on your income, but unless you read the small print carefully it's really easy to just see "Silver" and think they're all the same.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
Had an almost identical situation earlier this year. Lab work I paid for showed up on the deductible tracker but not on the OOP max tracker, and I went back and forth with the insurance company for weeks. Eventually what fixed it was asking them to send me the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage and going through it line by line together on a call. Turns out certain categories of services on my plan had a separate deductible that didn't roll into the main OOP max. It's a legal plan design, just confusing and not explained well at enrollment.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorSeparate deductible buckets that don't roll into the OOP max sounds like exactly what might be happening to me. Did your insurance company fix anything, or was it just a matter of understanding what was already in the documents?
0 coins
Malik Thompson
No change to how it worked — that was the plan design. What changed was I knew what I was paying toward and what I wasn't, so I could make smarter decisions about which appointments to schedule before the end of the year. Not a great situation, but at least I stopped being blindsided by EOBs.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
This is a really common design in some Silver plans and it catches people off guard every year. The rule of thumb I use is: if a service has its own copay listed separately in the Summary of Benefits, it probably also has its own cost-sharing bucket that may or may not roll into the main OOP max. Worth verifying every single line item you're likely to use.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
I just want to flag something for people reading this thread: Covered California itself can't tell you how your deductible accumulates toward your OOP max. That's an insurance company question. What Covered California can answer is whether you're on the right plan for your income, whether you're getting the right financial help, and anything about your enrollment or account. For everything about how your plan actually pays out — benefits, claims, EOBs — the insurance company is who you go to.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorThat distinction between what Covered California handles versus what the insurance company handles is something I genuinely didn't understand at first. I called the Covered California service center about this before I called the insurer, which wasted a few days.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
A lot of people make that same call in the wrong direction. Covered California = your enrollment, your account, your financial help. Insurance company = your benefits, your claims, your bill, your card. Once that clicks it saves a lot of frustration.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
Even the ID card and the bill come from the insurance company, not from Covered California. I didn't get that at all when I first enrolled. I kept wondering why Covered California wasn't sending me any paperwork after I enrolled.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
If you want to understand what's supposed to happen with deductibles and OOP max in Silver plans, the Summary of Benefits and Coverage is the document to read first. Every plan sold through Covered California is required to have one and it's usually downloadable from the insurer's website. There's a standard table in it that lists which services are subject to the deductible and what the out of pocket maximum applies to. If the plan design excludes certain deductibles from OOP max accumulation, it'll be in that table, even if it's not obvious.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorDownloading that now. I had been looking at the shorter plan summary instead of the full Summary of Benefits and Coverage. The shorter one doesn't have the level of detail I need to figure this out.
0 coins
Omar Mahmoud
The short summary is what Covered California shows in Shop and Compare for comparison purposes — it's useful for picking a plan but doesn't have the claims-level detail. The full SBC is what you need once you're enrolled and trying to understand how a specific visit is processed.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
I've been enrolled for three years and never read the full SBC until I had a billing issue. The difference in detail is significant. Some of the things that seemed like mistakes on my EOBs were actually in the plan design and I just hadn't read it.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Are you sure the plan is actually a Silver 70 and not a standard Silver with a different cost structure your insurer set up? I ask because I've seen people on this forum describe what sounds like a Silver plan with separate deductible buckets, and sometimes it turns out they were comparing two different covered services — one with a copay only and one that runs through the deductible. Those aren't tracked the same way and both are common in Silver plan designs.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorBoth card and Summary of Benefits say Silver 70. I checked after reading this thread. The specific thing I'm seeing is that prescription copays I paid are showing on a separate drug deductible and that's the one that doesn't seem to roll into the OOP max. Everything else runs through the main deductible.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Separate prescription deductible that doesn't roll into the main OOP max is a very common Silver plan design. Prescription costs sometimes accumulate toward a separate drug OOP max rather than the combined one. The combined OOP max may still be in play for medical services. Ask your insurer to confirm whether there's a separate drug OOP max on your plan and whether drug costs count toward the combined max or only the drug one.
0 coins
NeonNinja
The separate drug deductible situation is the one that bites people every year. You hit your medical deductible but your prescriptions keep piling up because they're in a different bucket entirely. Definitely ask the insurer to show you both maximums and what goes into each.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
The month I decided to cancel my Silver plan after getting employer coverage, the account showed a termination date that looked wrong to me — it was two months out rather than the end of the following month. Claimyr sat on hold with the service center for me and I spoke with a representative who confirmed the cancellation date that was actually on the account and explained that ending coverage on the last day of a month requires submitting at least 14 days before that date. The date I had seen in the account was correct. On the OOP max question from the original post: the insurer really is the only one who can explain how their plan accumulates costs. Covered California can't see your EOBs or override how the plan counts deductibles.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
The 14 days before the end of the month rule for cancellation is something I didn't know about. If you're trying to end coverage and start employer insurance on the first, you have to plan that more carefully than I thought.
0 coins
Anastasia Popov
Submitting too close to the end of the month is a real problem if you're trying to avoid either a gap or an overlap with new coverage. The 14-day window applies to getting the end date to fall on the last day of a month specifically. The Covered California cancel page lays out the example pretty clearly.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Mid-month cancellations also don't typically come with a refund of the days already paid in that month, which is another reason ending on the last day of the month is usually the cleaner option if you can time it.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
Something that helped me when I had a similar OOP max question: I called the insurance company and specifically asked them to walk me through one of my EOBs line by line while I had it in front of me. Not just a general explanation of how deductibles work, but that specific EOB for that specific date of service. It took about 20 minutes but I understood exactly what had happened and why the numbers looked the way they did. Worth requesting that if the standard explanations haven't helped.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorThat's a better approach than what I tried. I asked a general question about how deductibles and OOP max interact and got a general answer that didn't actually explain what was happening on my account. Going line by line through an actual EOB sounds like it would force them to be specific.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
General questions get general answers. Specific EOBs with specific dates get specific explanations. That's just how those calls go. Bring the EOB date and the amount in question and they have to actually look at the claim.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
The Silver 70 plan showing deductible and OOP max as separate trackers is actually pretty standard in California. The confusion usually comes from assuming the deductible always feeds directly into the OOP max, but that's not a rule — it's just how some plans work. What IS guaranteed by the ACA is that there's an overall OOP max that limits your total exposure in a plan year for covered in-network services, but how the separate buckets feed into it varies by plan.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
The overall OOP max guarantee is reassuring but the "varies by plan" part is exactly what makes this so hard to track without reading all the fine print. I didn't realize until this year that drug costs on my plan have their own cap that's different from my medical cap.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Drug caps versus medical caps is one of the more confusing parts of modern plan design. Some plans have them combined, some have them separate. The Summary of Benefits and Coverage will show it, but it requires reading the whole document carefully, not just the highlights.
0 coins
Zara Khan
I wish this were explained at enrollment. The Shop and Compare tool shows the OOP max but doesn't get into whether there are separate buckets inside it. You don't find out until you're mid-year and confused about your EOBs.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Covered California's financial help — the premium tax credit — reduces what you pay each month for the plan. The cost-sharing reductions that come with Enhanced Silver plans reduce the deductible and OOP max amounts themselves. But neither of those changes how the deductible and OOP max interact with each other mechanically. That's purely the insurer's plan design. So even if you're on an Enhanced Silver with a lower OOP max than a standard Silver, the question of whether deductible payments count toward that OOP max is still the insurer's call.
0 coins
Javier Morales
I always assumed cost-sharing reductions meant my deductible would just fold into my OOP max at a lower number. I didn't realize it only changes the amounts, not the structure of how they accumulate.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Cost-sharing reductions lower the amounts on paper. The structure — which costs go into which bucket and whether they roll into each other — stays as the insurer designed it. Two people could have the same Silver 70 plan but different experiences if one of them is getting cost-sharing reductions because their income is different.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
The date on the application receipt in my Covered California account didn't match the date I actually submitted it, and I needed that date confirmed for a special enrollment question. I had Claimyr take the hold for me and the representative looked up my case and gave me the exact submission date that was recorded on the application. For the deductible question: the insurer is definitely the right call, but if you get conflicting answers from different agents there, ask them to refer you to the plan's Evidence of Coverage document, which is the most detailed version of the plan terms and supersedes the Summary of Benefits when there's a conflict.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorEvidence of Coverage versus Summary of Benefits — I didn't know there was a hierarchy between those two documents. I'll ask for the Evidence of Coverage if the SBC doesn't answer my question specifically enough.
0 coins
Luca Ferrari
The Evidence of Coverage is the full legal plan document, usually much longer than the SBC. It covers every situation in detail and is what governs if there's ever a dispute. SBC is the shorter consumer-friendly version for comparison at enrollment. Both should be available from the insurer.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
The EOC is also what you cite if you ever need to file a grievance with the insurer. If the EOC says deductible payments count toward the OOP max and the insurer is tracking them separately, that's a billing issue you can escalate.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
Has anyone here actually successfully gotten their insurer to correct how deductible payments were being tracked toward the OOP max mid-year? Asking because I have a similar issue and I'm wondering if it's even worth pursuing or if I should just document everything for year-end.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
My insurer wouldn't change the plan design — that's what they kept saying, it's how the plan works. But in my case the design was correct, I had just misunderstood it. If you believe the plan design itself is being applied wrong, that's different — that's a claims error, and you can file a grievance with the insurer.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
If the insurer applies the plan terms incorrectly to a claim, that's a grievance. If the plan terms themselves are designed in a way you don't like, that's something to factor in when you pick a plan next open enrollment. Those are two different problems with two different paths.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Document everything regardless. EOBs, the calls you made, the dates. If you do need to escalate it's much easier with a paper trail from the beginning.
0 coins
NeonNinja
I went through Covered California's enrollment last year expecting my out of pocket max to cover everything once I hit it, and then found out some services — specifically out of network — weren't covered by the OOP max at all. That's not unique to Silver plans, it's how most plans work. The OOP max only applies to in-network covered services. Out of network can still run up costs even after you've technically hit your in-network maximum.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorOut of network is a whole separate issue from what I'm seeing. All the visits in question were in-network. But the out of network OOP max point is worth knowing — I hadn't even thought about whether there's a separate out of network tracker.
0 coins
NeonNinja
In-network only OOP max is by far the more common design in California plans. Some plans have a combined in and out of network max, but it's less common and usually more expensive. Worth confirming with your insurer which type your Silver 70 is.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
The in-network only OOP max was not something I understood until I got a bill I thought should have been covered. Reading the Evidence of Coverage after the fact is a painful way to learn.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
The frustrating part of all this is that none of it is explained clearly during enrollment. When you're on Shop and Compare looking at a Silver plan, the OOP max number is listed but it doesn't say anything about separate deductible buckets or whether prescription costs count toward it separately. You pick a plan based on the premium and the OOP max number and then spend the year figuring out what those numbers actually mean in practice.
0 coins
Zara Khan
The comparison display on Shop and Compare is built for shopping, not for understanding how claims process. Once you're enrolled, the insurer's documents are what govern. It would help if more of that detail were visible before you commit.
0 coins
Emma Anderson
Covered California has improved the plan comparison over the years, but the deductible structure details still live in the SBC and EOC rather than in the main comparison display. For a first-time enrollee especially, that gap between what shows in Shop and Compare and what shows up in EOBs is genuinely confusing.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
I picked my current plan primarily on the OOP max number because I knew I'd have significant medical expenses this year. If I'd known the drug costs had a separate tracker, I might have picked differently. That's a material piece of information for someone with prescriptions.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Quick clarification on something that came up earlier in this thread: cost-sharing reductions don't just mean you're on a Silver plan, they mean you're on a specific Enhanced Silver version — 73, 87, or 94 — based on your income relative to the federal poverty level. The original poster is on Silver 70, which is the standard Silver. You only get the deeper Enhanced Silver benefits if your income puts you in one of those tiers. Silver 70 still comes with some cost-sharing compared to Bronze, but it's the baseline.
0 coins
Javier Morales
How does Covered California decide which Enhanced Silver tier you land in? Is that something you choose or does it come out of the application?
0 coins
Oliver Weber
It comes out of your income relative to FPL. You don't choose a tier; your eligibility results from the application determine it. The Shop and Compare tool will show you which Silver version you'd qualify for based on the income you enter. The enhanced tiers have lower deductibles and lower OOP max amounts than Silver 70.
0 coins
Natasha Kuznetsova
And if your income changes during the year, your Enhanced Silver tier can change too — which is exactly why reporting income changes within 30 days matters. Someone who drops into a lower income tier mid-year could be eligible for a plan with better cost-sharing, but only if the change is on record.
0 coins
Chloe Harris
My EOB situation earlier this year turned out to be a data entry error on the insurer's side — they had coded one of my visits under a different benefit category than it should have been, and it went to the wrong deductible bucket as a result. I wouldn't have caught it without reading the EOB line by line and comparing it to the plan's SBC. So it's worth checking whether what you're seeing is plan design or actual claim coding error.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorClaim coding error versus plan design is a distinction I hadn't considered. How did you get the insurer to correct the coding error once you found it?
0 coins
Chloe Harris
Filed a formal grievance with the insurer with the specific EOB date, the service description, the billing code, and the SBC page that showed how that service was supposed to be categorized. They corrected it within a few weeks. If you just call and ask nicely you can get a runaround; the written grievance made them actually look at it.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
The grievance process is real and it works. I used it for a denied claim and the insurer reversed the decision. The key is citing the specific plan document language, not just saying the amount seems wrong.
0 coins
Zara Khan
What's the actual process if you're at the end of the year, you believe your deductible payments should have counted toward the OOP max but didn't, and you've already paid out of pocket amounts you think were wrong? Is there still a way to recover that money, or does it only matter going forward?
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
If you have a valid grievance about how claims were processed — meaning the insurer applied the plan terms wrong — you can file a grievance even after the fact, and it can result in reprocessed claims and a reimbursement. If the plan terms were applied correctly and you just disagree with the design, the grievance won't reverse anything but you have the option to escalate to the California Department of Managed Health Care, which oversees health plan compliance in California.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
The California Department of Managed Health Care is separate from Covered California. DMHC is the regulator for the insurers themselves. If you've exhausted the insurer's grievance process and believe there's a compliance issue, that's where it goes.
0 coins
Zara Khan
Thank you for naming DMHC — I didn't know there was a separate regulator I could go to after the insurer's own grievance process. That changes what I thought my options were.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
For what it's worth: going into next open enrollment, now that you've been through this, the Silver plan comparison in Shop and Compare lets you look at different plans side by side. The SBC download link is available for each plan in the comparison. Reading the deductible and OOP max section of the SBC before picking rather than after enrolling is the main thing I'd do differently if I were starting over.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
AuthorSpending more time on the SBC before choosing a plan is exactly the lesson I'm taking from this. I picked based on premium and the OOP max number without understanding the structure behind those numbers.
0 coins
FireflyDreams
The premium matters, obviously, but the OOP max structure matters just as much if you're going to have significant claims. Someone with predictable prescriptions every month should really understand whether drug costs count toward the combined OOP max before they pick.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Open enrollment starts November 1 for the following year, so that's the window to actually make a change. If your current plan's deductible structure is not working for you, documenting what you've learned now gives you a much clearer comparison framework when that period opens.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Just to close the loop on who to contact for what: if the deductible tracking question is about your enrollment, your financial help amount, or which plan you're in, that's a Covered California question. If it's about how your EOBs are calculating, what counts toward your OOP max, or whether a specific claim was coded correctly, that is entirely an insurance company question. No amount of calling the Covered California service center will change how your insurer processes a claim. Those are two separate lanes.
0 coins
Freya Nielsen
I've called Covered California about insurer questions more than once and each time they politely sent me back to the insurance company. Would save a lot of time to know upfront which lane a question falls in.
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
Covered California even has it on their site — contact Covered California for account, eligibility, enrollment. Contact your insurance company for bill, ID card, benefits, prescriptions. The line is pretty clear once you know it exists.
0 coins
Ravi Kapoor
The confusion about which one to call is probably the number one source of wasted time in the whole experience. Both have long hold times and neither one can answer the other's questions.
0 coins