Back to California EBT

Luca Marino

Why does Kroger decline CalFresh EBT chip card when combining non EBT items

Tried to split my purchase at Kroger yesterday and it turned into a whole thing at the register. I had a cart with some regular groceries like dish soap and paper towels mixed in with food items. The cashier rang up the food stuff first and my chip card worked fine for that part, but the moment she tried to run the second transaction for the non-EBT items, the register kept throwing an error. Not declined for insufficient funds or anything like that, just some kind of error that wouldn't go through on the chip card. I ended up having to leave the cleaning supplies behind because I didn't have another way to pay right there. I got home and checked my balance in ebtEDGE and everything looks normal, the food balance is what I expected. So it doesn't seem like a card issue. Is this a Kroger thing where their system gets confused when you do two transactions back to back on the same card? Or is there some setting on the chip card that might cause this? Really frustrating because I need those household items too and I shop at that Kroger specifically because it's closest to me.

An ATM near my place gave me less cash than what it took off my card last week, so I had a reason to reach the helpline. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold and I ended up talking to a representative who confirmed the deduction on my account and told me to report it to the helpline directly, which I did right there on the same call. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at California EBT: https://youtu.be/iYFSA6RTlOI Anyway, while I had the rep on the line I asked about split transactions at stores like Kroger too, since I'd heard of similar issues. She said the EBT card itself doesn't block a second swipe or chip insert at the same register, so if the second transaction is erroring out it's most likely something on the store's terminal side, not the card. She said to try a different lane or ask a manager to reset the terminal before assuming the card is the problem.

0 coins

Does that mean the card is completely fine to run twice in the same visit? I always assumed there was some kind of daily limit on how many times you could use the chip at one place.

0 coins

The rep didn't mention any limit on the number of chip transactions per day or per store. She was pretty clear that the second error was on the terminal, not on my card's side. So I'd say yes, the card itself should be able to run more than once.

0 coins

I've split purchases at a Vons and a Ralphs with the chip card and never had an error on the second transaction, so it really does seem like a Kroger terminal thing in this case.

0 coins

Had the same issue a couple months ago at a Kroger, different city. What fixed it for me was asking the cashier to fully back out of the transaction, close out the register, and start fresh on a new lane. The terminal in my lane had gotten stuck in some state where it wasn't releasing after the EBT transaction. New lane worked perfectly for the second transaction with my regular debit card.

0 coins

Did you have to re-ring everything or did they just move the transaction to the other lane somehow? I want to know what to expect next time I try.

0 coins

They had to re-ring it. The cashier was annoyed about it but she did it. Worth the two extra minutes honestly.

0 coins

Cashiers at a lot of grocery stores don't seem trained on what happens after an EBT chip transaction closes out. The terminal gets into a weird state and they don't know the fix.

0 coins

Is the problem specifically with the chip, or does it also happen when you tap? My Kroger started accepting tap for EBT maybe six months ago and I've had fewer issues since switching to tap for the food portion. The terminal seems to clear faster after a tap than after inserting the chip.

0 coins

Tried tap once there and the reader said to insert instead. Maybe it depends on which register you're at.

0 coins

Yeah some of their lanes take tap and some don't. If the reader tells you to insert, the chip is your only option. Worth trying a different lane that shows the contactless symbol.

0 coins

My store is the same way, hit or miss on whether tap actually works. I just go straight to chip now and ask for a manager if the second transaction errors.

0 coins

Want to make sure I understand what's happening here, because there's a rule that matters. Food benefits on the EBT card can only pay for eligible food items. When you do a split transaction, the first part covers the EBT-eligible food and the second part covers everything else. The card isn't supposed to be used at all for the second transaction, that's paid another way. So if the register errored on the second transaction while trying to run the EBT chip card again, was the cashier accidentally trying to run EBT for the dish soap portion too?

0 coins

Actually I think that might be exactly what happened. She might have grabbed my card to run the second half and the register rejected it because soap isn't eligible. I didn't watch closely enough to see what card she swiped second.

0 coins

That would explain it completely. The EBT card declining non-eligible items is working exactly as it should. Next time you can hand the cashier your other payment for the second transaction before she reaches for the EBT card again.

0 coins

This is probably the most likely explanation honestly. I've seen cashiers at busy stores just grab whatever card is on the counter and try it without thinking.

0 coins

My sister used to work at a grocery store and she said the terminals do have to go through a reset cycle after an EBT transaction before they're ready for a different payment type. If the cashier jumps straight to the next payment method too fast, it can throw an error that looks like a card decline but is really just a timing thing. Waiting ten or fifteen seconds after the EBT receipt prints before starting the next payment usually helps.

0 coins

Ten to fifteen seconds feels long at a busy register but I'll try it next time and see if it makes a difference.

0 coins

It's annoying, yes. But it's usually faster than switching lanes and re-ringing everything.

0 coins

I've noticed the same thing at my Kroger. If I rush to hand over my debit card right after the EBT beeps done, it errors. If I wait for the receipt to actually print, it goes through fine.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had the chip card flat out not read on a second attempt at the same register, not an error on the non-food items but a genuine 'card not valid' message? I'm wondering if there's a difference between a terminal timing issue and an actual chip read problem.

0 coins

Those are two different things. A 'card not valid' message on the EBT card itself after it already worked once in the same visit is probably a terminal problem, not a card problem. CDSS says if a chip card gets rejected at a reader, you can try another register to see if the card is the issue or the terminal is.

0 coins

Good to know. I'd probably panic and assume my card was broken if I saw that.

0 coins

I got 'card not valid' at a register once and it turned out the chip reader in that lane had just stopped working that day. Different lane, no problem at all.

0 coins

Does your ebtEDGE show the transaction from the successful part of the split? I always check mine after a split purchase to make sure the right amount was deducted for the food portion and nothing weird got charged.

0 coins

Checked ebtEDGE when I got home and the food transaction is in the history with the right amount. Only the household items didn't go through, which lines up with what others are saying about the cashier possibly trying to run EBT for the ineligible stuff.

0 coins

That confirms the card itself worked. The error was definitely on the ineligible items being run on the wrong payment method or a terminal timing thing, not anything wrong with your chip card.

0 coins

ebtEDGE showing the correct deduction is really the clearest way to rule out a card malfunction. If the food portion went through and shows in the history, the card is doing its job.

0 coins

Two charges in my transaction history for a store I hadn't been to in weeks showed up out of nowhere, so I wanted to check what was going on. Reached out through Claimyr after getting nowhere with the automated menu, and the representative I talked to read out the transaction dates and amounts and confirmed both hits on the card's history. Told me to report it to my county office as electronic theft within 90 days, which I went ahead and did the same afternoon. On the split transaction issue here: the rep also mentioned that the EBT card will reject any attempt to pay for non-eligible items, so if the cashier tried to run the chip card for the soap and paper towels, that rejection is the system doing what it's supposed to, not a malfunction.

0 coins

Sorry to hear about those unauthorized transactions. At least the rep could confirm what happened on the account so you knew exactly what to report to the county.

0 coins

Exactly. Having the specific dates and amounts made the report to the county office much more straightforward than if I'd just gone in saying 'something looks off'.

0 coins

The 90-day window for reporting electronic theft is important. Good you went the same day, some people wait too long and complicate things.

0 coins

Can I ask whether you had your out-of-state transaction block turned on in ebtEDGE? I know that's a different thing than what you're describing, but I'm curious if any of the security settings in ebtEDGE could affect how the card behaves at an in-state terminal.

0 coins

The out-of-state block in ebtEDGE only affects transactions attempted outside California. It wouldn't do anything to a transaction at a Kroger in California. The internet purchase block is also separate and only applies to online orders.

0 coins

That makes sense, was overthinking it. So the ebtEDGE security settings are pretty targeted and wouldn't interfere with a normal in-store split transaction.

0 coins

Mine doesn't have the out-of-state block turned on anyway. I checked ebtEDGE and everything under my security settings looks standard.

0 coins

Genuine question: does the chip card have to be physically re-inserted for each separate transaction in a split, or does the terminal keep it active until the full purchase is done? I've never actually done a split at a register with the chip card before.

0 coins

At every store I've been to, you insert or tap for each transaction separately. The terminal closes out after the first payment and then you start a new transaction for the rest of the items. So yes, two separate chip inserts.

0 coins

That's what I figured but wasn't sure. So the terminal resetting between the two is really the key step.

0 coins

The cashier probably didn't ring the food and non-food items separately to begin with. Some stores let you tell the cashier at the start that you're splitting payment and they'll separate the eligible items in the system before ringing. Have you tried asking them to do it that way before anything gets scanned?

0 coins

I told her upfront I was splitting, and she said she could do it, then tried to run the EBT card for everything at the end. I think she rang it all up together and then tried to separate it at the payment screen, which some registers handle fine and some don't.

0 coins

That's the gamble. Some Kroger lanes can split at the payment screen and some definitely can't, it depends on how their system is configured at that location.

0 coins

Asking for the split before scanning is way more reliable than trying to split at the payment screen. I've had registers flat out tell me they can't split at that point.

0 coins

Frozen card? Not suggesting yours is, but I once had ebtEDGE freeze my card by mistake when I was testing the settings and then forgot about it. Card worked for the first transaction because freezing in ebtEDGE blocks new transactions but I'm not totally sure how it handles a transaction already in progress. Might be worth checking if the card is frozen in the app.

0 coins

Worth a quick look but if the food portion of the split went through fine, the card almost certainly wasn't frozen. A frozen card would have declined the very first transaction too.

0 coins

You're right, I didn't think that through. If the food part worked, frozen card is off the table.

0 coins

Had a cashier at a different grocery chain tell me EBT can't be used in the same transaction as other payment methods at all. That was completely wrong, split transactions are totally normal and stores do them all the time. Just flagging that some cashiers have really bad information about how the card works.

0 coins

This kind of misinformation at the register is so frustrating. Split transactions where you pay part with EBT and part with another form of payment are standard. The cashier that told you that probably just hadn't done one before.

0 coins

She was insistent about it, too. I ended up leaving items behind because she wouldn't even try. Went back another day with a different cashier and it worked fine the first time.

0 coins

The confident wrong answer at the register is a whole genre of EBT problems.

0 coins

Replacement card I ordered through ebtEDGE three weeks ago still hadn't showed in the mail, so I wanted to know if the order had actually gone through. Used Claimyr to get past the automated menu at the helpline, and the representative looked up my account and confirmed the replacement card was ordered and gave me the date it was processed. She also pointed out that the five-day estimate doesn't count Sundays or holidays, which explained why it was taking longer than I expected. For the register issue being discussed: the chip card's expiration date printed on the front is only for the card itself, not the benefits. So an expired card would explain a chip read failure even if the balance is there, but that's separate from what sounds like a terminal or cashier error in this case.

0 coins

How long did it end up taking for your replacement to arrive after the rep gave you the order date?

0 coins

It came two days after I talked to the rep, so the card was closer than I thought. The Sunday exclusion added almost a full extra day to my count.

0 coins

The card expiration point is good to flag. A lot of people don't realize the expiration date is on the card now and forget to check it when troubleshooting a chip read failure.

0 coins

People keep mentioning asking for a manager when the terminal errors, and that's solid advice, but you can also just ask to move to the service desk. The service desk register at most Krogers is a different terminal entirely and is usually better maintained because it handles returns and exchanges all day. I've had better luck there for tricky transactions.

0 coins

Never thought to try the service desk. That's a genuinely useful workaround.

0 coins

It's not obvious, but service desk cashiers also tend to be more experienced with unusual payment situations since they deal with all kinds of edge cases already.

0 coins

Tried the service desk at my Kroger last month for a chip issue and it worked on the first try. Regular lane had been throwing errors all morning according to the cashier there.

0 coins

Register at a Kroger near me told me 'card not valid' twice in a row, once on the chip and once after trying to swipe. Went to Claimyr to reach the helpline because the automated menu wasn't getting me anywhere, and I ended up speaking with a representative who pulled up my account and confirmed the card was active and in good standing. She said to try another store's terminal before assuming anything is wrong with the card itself, and that if it fails everywhere I should ask about getting a replacement. And for anyone confused about chip vs. swipe order: CDSS says to try the chip first, and only fall back to swiping if the reader prompts you to.

0 coins

Did the card work fine at a different store after that? Curious whether it was a Kroger-specific terminal problem or something else.

0 coins

Tried a different store that same evening and the chip read fine on the first attempt. Definitely a Kroger terminal issue.

0 coins

The chip-first rule is worth repeating. Some people go straight to swipe out of old habit and then wonder why the chip gives them trouble when they finally try it.

0 coins

Is there any way to tell from the transaction history in ebtEDGE whether a failed transaction attempt even shows up? I'm wondering if the error at the register left any trace on the account.

0 coins

Declined or errored transactions don't show in the ebtEDGE history, at least not in my experience. Only completed transactions appear. So a failed second transaction wouldn't leave a trace.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. I worried a failed attempt might look like a suspicious transaction to whoever reviews the account.

0 coins

A declined transaction has no effect on your balance either. Nothing moves until the transaction actually completes, so an error at the register doesn't touch what's in the account.

0 coins

The timing issue between EBT and the second payment method is real. I asked a cashier about it once and she explained their terminal sends a 'close' signal after the EBT portion but the register screen doesn't update immediately. If she or I jump to the next card before the register catches up, it spits out an error. She said she now counts to five after the EBT approval before touching anything else.

0 coins

Counting to five is a lot more practical than explaining the terminal reset thing every time. I'm going to suggest that to cashiers from now on.

0 coins

It made the whole thing feel less random too. Once I understood what was happening, I stopped panicking whenever the second transaction hiccupped.

0 coins

Does CDSS or anyone official say anywhere what to do if the chip card genuinely doesn't work at a specific store? Like is there a formal process or is it just 'try another store'?

0 coins

Ask yourself first whether the reader is taking chip EBT cards at all, because not every terminal is set up for it. CDSS's guidance is to ask the cashier or store about the terminal, then try a different register. If the card fails everywhere, that's when you'd look at getting a replacement through ebtEDGE, the helpline, the county's online account or the county office.

0 coins

So there's no escalation path with CDSS for a specific store being a problem? It's all handled through the card replacement side of things if the card itself is the issue.

0 coins

Pretty much. A store that has a consistently broken terminal is a problem the store owner would need to fix. CDSS can tell you if your card is valid and working, but they can't fix a store's hardware.

0 coins

Coming back with an update: went to Kroger again this morning and talked to the customer service manager before even getting in line. She said their chip terminals have been having intermittent issues with split transactions and they're aware of it. She walked me to the service desk lane and the whole thing went through perfectly, food portion on the EBT chip card first, then dish soap and paper towels on my debit card with no error at all. So it really was a Kroger terminal issue, not anything wrong with the card or my account.

0 coins

Glad the service desk worked out. And useful to know the store management was already aware of the terminal issue.

0 coins

Going to the manager first saved you so much trouble. Good call.

0 coins

The fact that the manager knew about it and didn't warn cashiers or put up a sign is frustrating, but at least you got what you needed.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later with the same problem: the EBT chip card itself is not causing the split transaction error at Kroger. Try the service desk lane, let the terminal fully close out before handing over your second payment method, and if the cashier tries to run the EBT card for the non-food items like soap or paper towels, that rejection is correct because food benefits can't pay for those things. Keep those two separate scenarios in your head because they look similar at the register but have different fixes.

0 coins

This is a really clear summary. The 'EBT trying to pay for ineligible items' scenario and the 'terminal timing error' scenario both produce an error but need completely different responses.

0 coins

Exactly. One is the card working correctly and one is the terminal being slow. Easy to panic and think the card is broken when it's really neither of those things.

0 coins

Saving this explanation. I've confused these two scenarios before at the register and ended up standing there looking lost while the line backed up.

0 coins

California EBT AI

Expert Assistant
Secure