Back to Arizona Unemployment

Atticus Domingo

Unemployment denied employer said never showed up seasonal job appeal - what are my options with Arizona DES?

So I'm sitting here staring at this denial letter from Arizona DES and honestly I don't even know where to start. I had a seasonal landscaping position that ran from March through mid-October this year, and when I filed my UI claim after the season ended, the employer apparently told DES that I abandoned the position and never showed up for my final two scheduled weeks. That is completely false. I showed up every single day. I have coworkers who can verify this. The denial says I was separated from employment due to misconduct specifically job abandonment and now my benefits are being withheld entirely. The thing is this employer does this EVERY year with seasonal workers apparently, I found out from two other guys who worked the same crew. They told me the owner has a habit of contesting seasonal unemployment claims by just saying workers didn't show up during the final stretch of the season when it's hard to track hours. I work in construction and landscaping seasonally, so I genuinely depend on these UI payments between contracts. My bills don't pause just because my employer decided to lie to Arizona DES. I filed an appeal on the DES CACTUS portal but I honestly don't understand what happens next. Do I need to show up somewhere? Is it just paperwork? I have text messages from my supervisor confirming my final days on site and I took photos of myself at the job location with timestamps. Does any of this count as evidence? Has anyone actually won an appeal where it was their word against the employer's?

Week three of my own adjudication mess here so I've been lurking this forum a lot lately. Your situation sounds really stressful but I want to say first - yes, timestamped photos and text messages from a supervisor absolutely count as evidence in a DES appeal. That's actually strong documentation. The appeals process through Arizona DES goes to the Office of Appeals and you will get a scheduled hearing, usually by phone, where both you and the employer can present your sides. You'll receive a notice with the date and dial-in instructions. Bring every piece of evidence you have to that hearing - the texts, the photos, statements from coworkers if you can get them in writing.

0 coins

Just pulled up my own appeal paperwork from last year - the coworker statements don't have to be notarized or anything official, right? I had the same question when I was going through mine.

0 coins

From what I went through, nope, no notarization needed. Written statements signed by the coworkers work fine. The hearing officer just wants to see corroborating information. Get as many as you can.

0 coins

This is the first actually useful thing I've read since getting this letter. I didn't realize it was a phone hearing - I was dreading having to take time off a current contract to drive somewhere. That changes things a lot for me.

0 coins

My appeal got scheduled back in September and I was going crazy trying to reach anyone at DES to ask questions about the process beforehand. Spent probably four days straight redialing and getting busy signals or getting disconnected mid-hold. Someone on a different thread mentioned Claimyr - claimyr.com - and I was skeptical but I tried it. They basically get you connected to an actual DES agent without you sitting on hold all day. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. I was able to talk to someone who confirmed my hearing was still scheduled and explained what documentation I should prepare. If you need to actually speak to someone at DES before your hearing, that's how I'd do it now.

0 coins

Checked my call history after reading this and I genuinely called DES 31 times in one week before giving up. I wish I'd known about this earlier.

0 coins

Four days of redialing sounds exactly like what I went through. The phone system is just broken for regular people trying to get answers.

0 coins

Saving that link. I've got questions specifically about whether I need to submit my evidence in advance or just bring it to the hearing and I cannot get anyone on the phone to tell me.

0 coins

Last November my claim got denied for almost the exact same reason - previous employer in warehouse work claimed I had attendance issues that led to my separation. Here's what I learned the hard way going through it: the burden in these appeals isn't on you to prove you showed up, it's actually on the employer to prove you didn't. That's how Arizona DES structures misconduct cases. So your photos and supervisor texts are great but even without them, the employer has to bring documentation - time records, written warnings, that kind of thing. If a seasonal employer can't produce actual time records showing your absences, that works heavily in your favor.

0 coins

Read through my own denial letter again after seeing this comment - mine had similar language about misconduct but the employer only provided a one-paragraph statement with no records. I won that appeal.

0 coins

That reframing actually helps my anxiety about this. I've been thinking I need to prove a negative but you're saying the employer has to actually document the absences they're claiming? That makes my evidence even stronger if they're just making it up.

0 coins

This is true from everything I've seen in these forums. Seasonal employers sometimes assume workers won't bother appealing and just file whatever they want with DES. When someone actually shows up to the hearing with documentation the employers often don't have anything solid.

0 coins

Exactly right. The misconduct standard under Arizona unemployment law is pretty specific - it's not just bad performance or not showing up once, it has to be a willful disregard of the employer's interests. Without documented warnings or time records showing a pattern, a last-minute claim of job abandonment is a weak case for the employer.

0 coins

Appeal number two for me right now, different job than last time. Something that caught me off guard the first time was that you can request a continuance if you need more time to gather evidence before the hearing. If you get your hearing notice and the date feels too soon to get coworker statements together, you can ask the Office of Appeals to push it back a bit. Don't just scramble and go in underprepared.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know that was an option. The letter I got didn't mention anything about requesting a different date.

0 coins

Yeah the letters are pretty bare-bones. Everything the letters don't tell you is in the UI claimant handbook which is on the DES website but most people never read it.

0 coins

My first appeal hearing was rescheduled twice - once by me and once by the employer. It delayed everything but honestly having that extra time meant I had way better documentation when it finally happened.

0 coins

Step two of my appeal process when I went through mine was figuring out whether to get a lawyer or representative. For what it's worth, you are allowed to bring a representative or even an attorney to the phone hearing. Legal aid organizations in Arizona sometimes help with unemployment appeals at no cost if your income qualifies. The hearing is relatively informal compared to actual court but having someone in your corner who knows the process can make a difference especially when the employer has an HR person on their side.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about legal aid. I'll look into what's available in my area. My income right now is basically zero so I'd probably qualify.

0 coins

Before my hearing I actually used Claimyr to get through to DES and they told me exactly what to expect in the hearing format - what order people speak, how questions get asked, all of it. Way more helpful than anything I found online. It's at claimyr.com and there's a demo video too: https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y - understanding the format ahead of time made me way less nervous going in.

0 coins

The legal aid angle is real. Southern Arizona Legal Aid and Community Legal Services both handle unemployment cases. Worth calling them before your hearing date.

0 coins

Got my disqualification reversed about eight months ago in a situation that had some similarities. One thing that really mattered in my case was the actual wording in my employer's response to DES. When I finally got copies of what the employer submitted - which you can request through the appeals process - there were inconsistencies between what they told DES initially and what they said at the hearing. Employers sometimes give vague initial statements and then try to add details later. If the story changes between the initial DES report and the hearing, the appeals officer notices that.

0 coins

How do I request copies of what the employer submitted? Is that something I can do online through CACTUS or do I have to contact the Office of Appeals directly?

0 coins

You contact the Office of Appeals directly - there's a number on your hearing notice. Tell them you want to review all documents in your case file before the hearing. They're required to give you access.

0 coins

This is a great point. I've seen people come to hearings totally blindsided by what the employer claimed because they never looked at the case file. Always review it.

0 coins

Three weeks into waiting for my own appeal decision right now so I know the anxiety of this process. Something nobody told me going in: keep filing your weekly claims on CACTUS even while your appeal is pending. I almost stopped because I figured why bother if everything was frozen. But if you win your appeal, you get back pay for the weeks you certified. If you stopped certifying you lose those weeks forever.

0 coins

Found out about this the hard way my first time - didn't file for two weeks thinking it was pointless and those two weeks were gone even after I won. Never skip weekly certification during an appeal.

0 coins

Okay this is critical information that I would have missed. I slowed down on certifying because I thought the whole thing was on hold. Going to log in right now.

0 coins

This comes up constantly in these forums and people keep getting burned by it. The certification and the appeal run on completely separate tracks.

0 coins

Just logged into my own CACTUS account to double-check my certifications after reading this thread - glad I did, I was showing one week that hadn't processed correctly.

0 coins

Somewhere around week six of my job search requirements period I got tangled up trying to reach DES and couldn't get anyone live on the phone for over a week. A friend told me about Claimyr - the website is claimyr.com - and I ended up using it when I had a question about documentation for my own appeal. Got connected to an actual agent in a reasonable amount of time instead of spending another week redialing. The video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y shows the basics of how it works. Especially relevant if you need to talk to someone about the evidence submission process before your hearing date.

0 coins

Got this bookmarked now. The DES phone situation has been a problem for years and knowing there's a workaround is genuinely useful.

0 coins

Funny you mention this - I've been trying to reach someone about my current appeal and getting nowhere. Going to try it.

0 coins

In the appeals system, the hearing officer's job is specifically to figure out what actually happened, not just rubber-stamp whatever the employer said. The initial DES determination leans heavily on the employer's statement because DES doesn't investigate deeply at first - they basically take what the employer reports and issue a decision. The appeal is where the full picture comes out. I've seen plenty of cases where the initial denial got reversed completely because the claimant came prepared and the employer either didn't show up or had no documentation. Seasonal employers in particular often don't keep tight records.

0 coins

This context about why the initial determination went against me is actually helpful. I was taking the denial really personally but it sounds like DES just goes off the employer's first report without much scrutiny.

0 coins

Yep this is basically right. The first determination is almost like a summary judgment based on whoever filed first. The appeal is the real process.

0 coins

Worth adding - if the employer doesn't show up to the hearing at all, which apparently happens more than you'd think with seasonal work, the hearing officer may rule in your favor almost by default if you have any documentation at all.

0 coins

My denial letter came in mid-July for a situation involving a construction contractor who claimed I quit without notice. At the actual hearing I had my final paycheck stub showing I worked through the last day, plus a text chain with my foreman. The employer rep who showed up had literally nothing - just read from the original statement they'd given DES. The hearing officer asked her for documentation and she said she didn't have any. Decision came back in my favor about ten days later. The documentation you have sounds at least as strong as what I had.

0 coins

Ten days for the decision - is that typical? I've been reading some people wait weeks or months.

0 coins

Mine was on the faster end. I've seen people say anywhere from a week to six weeks depending on how complicated the case is and how backed up the Office of Appeals is.

0 coins

My decision took 23 days after the hearing. It varies a lot but they do eventually come through.

0 coins

About a month into my current claim and already I've seen three people in my area dealing with this exact same landscaping contractor situation. Something sketchy is going on with how some of these seasonal employers are reporting separations to DES. If you know other workers from the same company who got the same denial, it might be worth mentioning that pattern to the hearing officer. Multiple workers getting denied for the same claimed reason from the same employer is a pattern that could be relevant.

0 coins

This is exactly what I mentioned in my original post - two other guys from my crew told me this happens every year with this owner. I hadn't thought of framing it that way in the hearing but that makes sense.

0 coins

If those coworkers are willing to provide statements that they experienced the same thing in prior seasons, that could be powerful. It shifts this from one person's word against an employer to a documented pattern of behavior.

0 coins

There's also potentially a wage claim or labor board angle here if the employer is systematically doing this, but that's a separate process from the unemployment appeal. Worth knowing about though.

0 coins

Sixth day after my hearing and still waiting so I've been reading everything I can in the meantime. One thing I want to flag: the job search requirements don't pause during your appeal. You still have to log four employer contacts per week in Arizona as far as I understand it, unless you're on standby status. Don't let the appeal situation make you forget about the weekly requirements or you could create a new problem on top of the existing one.

0 coins

I genuinely forgot about this. I've been so focused on the appeal that I've been sloppy about logging job contacts. Need to fix that immediately.

0 coins

Technically if you're disqualified and not receiving benefits you may still need to maintain those records to get back pay when the appeal resolves. It's one of those things DES doesn't explain clearly upfront.

0 coins

The job search log requirement stays active throughout the appeal in most cases. Keep detailed records with dates, company names, positions, and how you applied. Hearing officers sometimes ask about this.

0 coins

Right around the same point in my claim I found out about something called a written hearing option - I'm not sure if this applies to every type of appeal but in some cases you can submit a written statement and evidence instead of participating in the phone hearing. Might be worth asking about if the phone format is a problem for your schedule. Though honestly for a disputed facts case like yours where it's your word against the employer's, the phone hearing is probably better because you can respond to what the employer says in real time.

0 coins

The phone hearing actually works better for me since I can do it without missing work. I just want to make sure I know what I'm walking into.

0 coins

For anything involving disputed facts - like who actually showed up - the live hearing is almost always better. Written submissions are more useful when the question is about policy interpretation rather than what actually happened.

0 coins

Two appeals behind me at this point. The thing about seasonal work denials specifically is that employers often can't produce actual time records because seasonal operations sometimes keep sloppy attendance documentation. When DES first gets the employer's report they just file a denial because that's the default when misconduct is claimed. But in a hearing, 'we didn't keep detailed attendance records but we're sure he stopped showing up' is not strong evidence. That's the employer's credibility against yours plus your timestamped photos plus supervisor texts. That math works out pretty clearly in your favor.

0 coins

Putting it that way makes me feel significantly better about this. I've been catastrophizing since the letter arrived.

0 coins

Honestly the evidence you described in your original post sounds better than what most people walk into these hearings with. A lot of people come in with nothing but their own statement.

0 coins

Just got my own denial letter this week for something completely different and reading this thread is actually making me less panicked about the process. Good luck on your hearing.

0 coins

Partway through my second round with Arizona DES and I want to address something that sometimes trips people up: at the hearing, don't just submit your evidence, explain what each piece shows. Walk the hearing officer through the timestamp on each photo, explain who the supervisor is in the texts and their role, make the connection explicit. Hearing officers process a lot of cases and sometimes evidence gets less attention than it deserves if the claimant just says 'I have texts' without contextualizing them.

0 coins

This is practical advice I can actually use. I'll prepare a brief outline connecting each piece of evidence to the specific dates the employer claims I wasn't there.

0 coins

Good point. Treat it less like 'here's my evidence' and more like telling a coherent story where the evidence fills in specific details. Hearing officers appreciate clarity.

0 coins

Just opened the DES website to check my own claim status and saw an update on my pending issue. While I was there I noticed there's actually a checklist in the appeals section for what to bring to your hearing that I'd never seen before. It includes things like contact information for witnesses, organized copies of any written communications, and a brief timeline of events. Might be worth pulling up before your hearing date.

0 coins

I'll look for that tonight. I didn't know that resource was there.

0 coins

I never found that either during my first appeal and I really could have used it. Good find.

0 coins

The DES website buries a lot of actually useful information. The appeals section specifically has way more in it than the main claimant page.

0 coins

Near the end of my appeal waiting period I had a question about whether the decision would automatically trigger my back payments or if I had to do something to initiate that after a favorable ruling. Couldn't get anyone at DES on the phone no matter when I called. Someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr so I tried it - claimyr.com - and finally got through to an agent. They confirmed that after a favorable appeal decision back payments process automatically for the weeks you certified, within a few business days usually. No extra step needed. That was such a relief to find out. The service info and a quick walkthrough video are at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you need to reach someone before your hearing.

0 coins

The automatic back payment thing is actually one of my big questions - glad to know it doesn't require another step. And I'll definitely use that if I can't get answers on the phone.

0 coins

Looked up my own account after reading this - good to know the back pay triggers automatically. I had no idea and was planning to call about it after my decision came through.

0 coins

This is something DES really should state clearly in the appeal decision letter but they don't. Good to have confirmation from an actual agent.

0 coins

Last week of my standby period right now and thinking back to when I was at your stage. One more thing to think about: if you win the appeal, the employer technically has the right to appeal the appeal decision to the Arizona DES Board of Review. This rarely happens with seasonal labor disputes but it's possible, so don't spend the back pay immediately if there's any indication the employer is aggressive about fighting this. Usually though a seasonal landscaping company isn't going to pursue a Board of Review appeal over one worker's claim.

0 coins

I hadn't even considered that possibility. Good to be aware of it even if it's unlikely.

0 coins

In my experience employers generally let it go after the first appeal decision especially in seasonal work. The ones who push it to the Board are usually larger companies with dedicated HR teams who fight everything on principle.

0 coins

Even if they do appeal to the Board your certified weeks still stay in the system. You wouldn't lose those even during a further appeal process.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure