Got an unemployment telephone hearing notice after being approved fired for poor performance
So this is kind of a bizarre situation and I'm not sure what to do with it. Back in February I lost my job at a distribution warehouse - my supervisor had been documenting every little thing for months, late arrivals, missed quotas, that kind of stuff - and they finally let me go. When I filed with Arizona DES I was totally honest about everything, said it was a termination for performance reasons, and somehow they still approved me. I was relieved and just moved on, started filing my weekly claims, doing my job searches, everything by the book. Then out of nowhere last week I get this notice in the mail saying there's going to be a telephone hearing scheduled. The letter references my original claim determination and says an interested party requested a review. I'm guessing my former employer is contesting the approval. What I don't understand is how I can go through the whole adjudication process, get approved, and THEN have a hearing scheduled afterward? I thought adjudication was the review process. Now I'm reading that this is actually a separate appeals level entirely? I'm panicking a little because I don't know what to prepare, whether I keep filing weekly claims during this, or whether my benefits could actually be clawed back if the hearing doesn't go my way. The notice doesn't explain much, just gives a date and a call-in number. Has anyone dealt with a telephone hearing at this stage? What actually happens on the call?
60 comments

Royal_GM_Mark
The part about your employer filing after you were already approved is what I want to make sure I understand correctly - that timeline confused me too when it happened with my claim last year. What's going on is that the initial adjudication decision Arizona DES makes can be appealed by either side within a certain window. Your former company had something like 15 calendar days from when they received notice of your approval to file a protest, and it sounds like they did exactly that. So yes, you were legitimately approved, but that decision isn't final until the appeal window closes or any hearing gets resolved. The telephone hearing itself is handled through the Arizona Office of Appeals, not directly through Arizona DES. An appeals referee will run the call - think of it like an informal court proceeding over the phone. Both you and a representative from your former employer will be on the line, you'll each get to present your side, and the referee asks questions. For a fired-for-poor-performance situation specifically, the main thing they're examining is whether the employer can show the termination met the legal standard for misconduct. Poor performance alone usually doesn't - there's a meaningful difference between someone who couldn't do the job versus someone who willfully violated a workplace rule. That distinction almost always ends up mattering a lot in these hearings. Keep filing your weekly claims no matter what. If you stop and you end up winning, you lose those weeks permanently.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorWhether my former employer actually has documentation strong enough to clear that misconduct bar is what I'm still unsure about. They had a whole paper trail of write-ups and performance improvement plans. Does a PIP count as evidence of willful misconduct or is it still just performance?
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
PIPs by themselves are almost never enough to establish misconduct in a UI hearing. I went through this exact thing in Maricopa County two years ago - my employer brought a stack of documentation and the referee still sided with me because the write-ups were all about metrics and output, not about me breaking a rule intentionally. The standard Arizona DES uses is basically whether you knew there was a rule and chose to break it anyway. Missing sales targets doesn't fit that.
0 coins
Chris King
just here to confirm you 100% keep filing weekly claims while this is pending. do not stop. i made that mistake and lost like 6 weeks of payments even after i won my hearing
0 coins
Rachel Clark
While you're sorting out what to prepare for this hearing, please don't underestimate how hard it is to actually reach someone at Arizona DES by phone if you have specific questions about your case. I spent almost two weeks trying to get through on my own claim and kept hitting the automated system or getting disconnected. A coworker told me about a service called Claimyr - you use it at claimyr.com and it essentially holds your place in the phone queue and connects you once an agent is available. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. I was skeptical but it got me talking to an actual DES agent within the same day, and I was able to ask specific questions about my pending appeal status before my hearing. Given that your situation involves a hearing scheduled on top of an already-approved claim, talking to an agent directly could really help you understand what's in your file.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorReaching an actual agent to look at my specific file is something I hadn't thought to do before the hearing - I've been trying to piece everything together from the notice letter alone. Is there anything specific I should ask them when I get through?
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
When I spoke to an agent before my hearing I asked them to confirm exactly what documentation the employer submitted during the original adjudication. That way I knew what I was going to be responding to before I ever got on the call with the referee. Made a huge difference not being surprised.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
claimyr worked for me too fwiw. got through on a monday morning which is supposedly the worst time to call and was talking to someone within like 2 hours
0 coins
Carter Holmes
The hearing format tripped me up when I went through mine last spring and I wish someone had explained it better beforehand. What actually happens is the referee opens by swearing everyone in - yes, you're under oath - and then typically lets the employer go first since they're the appellant in a situation like yours. They'll present whatever they're claiming justifies a misconduct finding. Then you get your turn to respond and present your own version of events. The single most important thing I'd tell anyone in a fired-for-performance case is to come with specific examples of how you were following whatever process or instructions you were given, even if the results weren't meeting targets. Things like emails showing you responded to your supervisor's feedback, any documentation that you completed training they required, or records showing you did ask for help or resources. The employer is trying to show you willfully failed. You're showing you genuinely tried. Those are two completely different stories and the referee is specifically listening for that distinction.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorWhether my communications with my supervisor would actually count as useful evidence is something I'm now wondering about - I have a bunch of texts and emails where I was asking for more training and they kept saying they'd schedule it and never did. Would that kind of thing help?
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Those messages are potentially very valuable. My referee specifically asked me whether I had made efforts to address the performance concerns before being terminated, and I had emails showing I requested additional support twice. The employer's rep had no good answer for why the company never followed through. That sequence of asking for help and not getting it was a big part of why I won.
0 coins
Sophia Long
screenshots of texts work too, printed out or even just having them on your phone ready to reference on the call. the referee usually lets you describe what you're looking at if you can't fax or email things in before the hearing date
0 coins
Angelica Smith
Something that tripped a lot of people up - including me initially - is thinking this telephone hearing is just a formality because you already got approved. It is absolutely not a formality. The employer filed specifically to overturn your approval and the referee genuinely can side with them. I had a friend who was super confident going into his hearing for a similar situation and he lost because he didn't take it seriously enough to prepare. He ended up owing back a significant chunk of benefits. That said, the fired-for-poor-performance angle really does work in your favor as long as you stay focused on the right framing during the call. Don't volunteer information about what you could have done differently or apologize for anything on the call. Just respond to what's asked and keep bringing it back to the fact that performance issues and misconduct are legally different things under Arizona UI law.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorNot volunteering extra information is something I really needed to hear because I tend to over-explain when I'm nervous. I'd probably end up talking myself into trouble.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
same advice a paralegal friend gave me - treat it like a deposition basically. answer what's asked, don't expand, don't apologize. referees have heard everything and they're pretty good at cutting through it
0 coins
Charlotte Jones
Just want to add - my sister went through a similar hearing and was able to actually talk to a DES agent ahead of time through Claimyr to get a clearer picture of what was in her file before the call. Having that info going in made her much less nervous because she knew exactly what her employer had claimed and what she needed to respond to. The site is claimyr.com if you want to look into it.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
My ex-employer had a whole HR rep on the line during my hearing and I was just sitting alone in my apartment, and I want to tell you that the referee was completely fair about it. They interrupted the HR rep twice to ask clarifying questions when she was overstating what the documentation showed. These referees do this all day and they can tell when an employer is trying to dress up a performance issue as misconduct. One practical thing - call into the hearing number a couple minutes early and make sure you're on a stable phone connection, not driving, somewhere quiet. The referee will note if the connection keeps cutting out or if there's a ton of background noise, and you want them focused on what you're saying, not on asking you to repeat yourself. Write down the main points you want to make on paper in front of you because it's easy to freeze up when the adrenaline hits.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorThe fact that the referee actually pushed back on the employer rep is reassuring - I'd pictured it being one-sided since they have an HR department and I'm just one person.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
referees are pretty no-nonsense in my experience. mine cut off both me AND the employer rep when we started going in circles. they know exactly what info they need and once they have it they move on
0 coins
Harper Thompson
This is a really good point about the phone setup. I did my hearing from my car because it was the quietest place I had and the connection was fine, but I should have been somewhere I could also take notes more easily
0 coins
Caleb Stark
I went into my hearing thinking I was totally unprepared and was going to lose, and I ended up winning. For context mine was also a termination - retail, they said I wasn't meeting customer satisfaction scores - and the employer brought their whole regional manager on the call. What helped me most was that I had asked Arizona DES to send me everything in my file before the hearing date. You can request your claim documents and I'd recommend doing that as soon as possible. Reading through what your employer actually submitted during adjudication tells you exactly what arguments they're planning to repeat at the hearing.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorRequesting the file is something I had no idea I could do - how exactly do you do that, through the CACTUS portal or do you have to call?
0 coins
Caleb Stark
You submit a written request to the Arizona Office of Appeals, not through the portal. There should be contact information on the hearing notice itself. I faxed mine but you can mail it too. Ask for all documents associated with your appeal case number.
0 coins
Chris King
yes do this ASAP because they need processing time and you want it before your hearing not after
0 coins
Jade O'Malley
okay so i got confused reading this thread because i thought adjudication was the appeals process?? like isnt that what happens when they review your claim? someone help me understand the difference lol
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
So adjudication is basically Arizona DES internally reviewing your claim to decide if you qualify - it happens before any determination is issued. The appeal is a separate process that either side can trigger AFTER a determination is made. Completely different stages.
0 coins
Jade O'Malley
ohhhh okay that makes so much more sense. so OP already got through adjudication and the employer is now appealing that decision. got it
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
yeah the terminology on Arizona DES communications is genuinely confusing, i had to have my sister explain the difference to me too. they don't do a great job of making it clear in the letters they send out
0 coins
Ella Lewis
Since this thread has a lot of good prep advice I want to add the specific point about what happens to your weekly benefits during the hearing process because a few people mentioned it but didn't get into the mechanics. Arizona DES continues paying your approved weekly claims while the appeal is pending - you are not cut off during the hearing process. HOWEVER, if the referee ultimately reverses the original decision and finds in the employer's favor, any benefits paid during that pending period can become an overpayment that you'd have to repay. So it's not money you can count on as definitely yours until the hearing resolves in your favor. File the weekly claims, yes absolutely, but keep that in mind financially.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorThe overpayment risk during the pending period is something I hadn't fully connected - so the weekly claims I'm filing right now could potentially have to be paid back if I lose the hearing?
0 coins
Ella Lewis
Technically yes, though Arizona DES does have a process for waiving overpayment repayment in cases where you were acting in good faith and have genuine financial hardship. It's not automatic but it exists. The stronger play is just to win the hearing, which based on what you've described sounds very possible.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
Overpayment waivers are real but honestly just focus on the hearing. Win that and there's nothing to worry about. The waiver process is its own whole thing you don't want to have to navigate.
0 coins
Andrew Pinnock
Something nobody's said yet that I think is worth mentioning - when my hearing got scheduled I was a nervous wreck and tried calling Arizona DES to ask a few pre-hearing questions but couldn't get anyone on the line for days. I ended up using Claimyr to actually get through, the website is claimyr.com and the walkthrough video is at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. What I specifically asked the agent was whether there were any additional notes or flags on my claim from the employer that weren't in the original determination letter. Turns out there were, and knowing that before the call meant I had an answer ready when the referee brought it up. Worth doing before your hearing date if you can.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorFinding out there might be additional employer notes that didn't make it into the determination letter is kind of alarming - I'd assumed the letter was the full picture.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
The determination letter is a summary, not the complete file. Employer submissions, notes from the adjudicator, any additional documentation they provided - that stuff can all exist in your file without being spelled out in what they mailed you.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
This happened to me too. The letter said basically nothing and when I finally talked to an agent before my hearing there were multiple employer documents I had no idea about. Definitely get into your full file somehow before the call.
0 coins
Brianna Schmidt
I want to circle back to the documentation strategy because I think people undersell how much this matters. When I prepared for my own hearing - mine was a customer service role, employer claimed insubordination but it was really about my numbers - I made a simple timeline on paper. Every relevant date, what happened, what the employer said, what I said or did in response. Referees move fast and having a written timeline meant I could answer date-specific questions immediately without fumbling. Also Claimyr is what finally got me through to Arizona DES to confirm my hearing details when the notice I received had a couple things that weren't totally clear. Having a confirmed understanding of the format before I got on the call removed a lot of the uncertainty. That's what tipped the balance for me going in prepared rather than scrambling.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorMaking an actual written timeline hadn't occurred to me and that sounds like exactly the kind of concrete thing I could do this week before the hearing date.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
Timelines are great and I'd add - if any dates on your employer's documentation are wrong, that's worth noting specifically. I caught a discrepancy where they listed the date of an alleged incident incorrectly and that ended up raising credibility questions about their whole account.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
the credibility thing is real. once a referee sees one factual error they tend to look at the rest of the employer's account more skeptically in my experience
0 coins
Harper Thompson
There's a thing that happens in a lot of these hearings where the employer tries to introduce documentation during the hearing itself that they didn't submit during adjudication - stuff they found later or just didn't bother including before. The referee may or may not allow it depending on the circumstances, but you're allowed to object to new evidence being introduced late. I didn't know that going into mine and my employer brought up a whole additional report on the call that I'd never seen. If I had known I could object I might have handled that differently.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorBeing allowed to object to new evidence on the call is something I definitely would not have known - is this something you need to say in a specific way or just raise it?
0 coins
Harper Thompson
Just say clearly that you weren't provided this document prior to the hearing and you'd like to note an objection. The referee knows the procedure and will make a ruling. You don't need legal language.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
good to know this. i always assumed these hearings were totally informal and you couldn't really object to anything. filing this away for whenever i need it
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
Not to derail this thread but reading about the fired-for-performance situation brought back my whole experience getting laid off and then finding out my former company contested my claim anyway. I genuinely didn't even know employers could do that. Mine said I had resigned which was completely false - I have texts proving otherwise. Went through the whole hearing process and won, but it took almost three months from filing to final decision and I was stressed out of my mind the whole time. Just want OP to know the process is long but it does resolve and people do win these things.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorThree months from start to finish is longer than I'd hoped but good to know it doesn't go on indefinitely. Did you receive benefits throughout that whole period?
0 coins
Hunter Edmunds
Yes, I got paid the whole time the appeal was pending. When I won, everything stayed and there was nothing to pay back. The timeline was rough emotionally but financially I was okay.
0 coins
Angelica Smith
The timeline varies a lot based on case complexity and how backed up the Office of Appeals is. Simple cases can resolve faster. But three months is a reasonable expectation to set so you're not caught off guard.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
something worth asking about that i haven't seen mentioned - what happens if you can't make the scheduled call time? like is there any way to reschedule a telephone hearing through Arizona DES or the Office of Appeals? asking bc my work schedule is unpredictable and when i got a hearing notice i genuinely didn't know if i'd be able to take the call
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
You contact the Arizona Office of Appeals directly and request a continuance before the hearing date. They don't grant them automatically but legitimate scheduling conflicts are taken seriously. You'd need to explain the reason and request it as soon as you know there's a conflict - don't wait until the day of.
0 coins
Logan Greenburg
okay good to know there's at least a process. i ended up making the original date work but it was stressful not knowing if i had options
0 coins
Sophia Long
i missed a hearing notice once and didn't see it in time to request a continuance and my appeal was dismissed automatically. it took weeks to get it reopened. do not let the date pass without acting on it one way or another
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
My employer brought a whole team to their side of the hearing - HR manager, direct supervisor, and their unemployment claims vendor - and I was completely alone. I want to say something about that because I almost panicked when I heard multiple voices on the line. The referee acknowledged each person, explained who could speak and when, and controlled the whole thing very tightly. Having three people on the other side doesn't mean they win. It just means they're taking it seriously. You should take it seriously too but it's not an ambush.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorWhether they're allowed to have multiple people on the call without telling me in advance is something that caught me off guard reading this - is that standard?
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Employers often use third-party unemployment management services that specialize in contesting UI claims. These companies do hearings all day every day. That's why your preparation matters as much as it does - you're not just up against an HR person who does this occasionally.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
This is real and worth taking seriously. The employers who contest claims aggressively usually have professional help. That doesn't mean you lose, it means you need to be as prepared as they are.
0 coins
Sophia Long
I just want to put a final note in here for anyone reading later who is in this same situation. After my hearing resolved - mine took about six weeks - I got a written decision mailed to me. The decision letter explains the referee's reasoning in detail and if you disagree with it, there's another level of review you can request through the Arizona UI Board of Appeals. So if the telephone hearing somehow doesn't go your way, it's not the final word. There is still a next step.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
AuthorKnowing there's still a Board of Appeals level after this if something goes wrong is actually really calming - I'd thought this hearing was the absolute last chance.
0 coins
Ella Lewis
The Board of Appeals review is primarily on the record - meaning they typically look at the transcript of the hearing rather than taking new testimony. That's another reason why what you say and what gets documented during the telephone hearing itself matters so much.
0 coins
Lucas Bey
and beyond the board there is actually an option to appeal to superior court but at that point most people are talking to an attorney. hopefully you won't need any of that
0 coins