Fired for misconduct for unemployment - will Arizona DES deny my claim?
So I got let go from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and my former employer is claiming it was for misconduct. I've been filling out everything on the CACTUS portal and when it got to the part asking why I was separated from my employer, I put that I was terminated, and now my claim is sitting in adjudication. I honestly don't even know what qualifies as misconduct for unemployment purposes in Arizona because my situation is complicated. What happened was I had a documented medical issue that caused me to miss several shifts, I gave my supervisor a heads up each time and thought I had it covered. HR told me verbally that it was fine, then out of nowhere I got a letter saying my attendance violated company policy and I was let go. Now DES is basically going to decide whether what my employer is calling misconduct actually counts as misconduct under their definition. I have my medical records, my texts to my supervisor, and even a note from HR saying absences for medical reasons are handled case by case. Does any of this help my case? Has anyone fought a misconduct determination and won?
66 comments

Ravi Gupta
Week three of my own adjudication right now so I feel this deeply. The employer misconduct angle is tricky because Arizona DES has a pretty specific bar for what actually counts. From what I went through, they look at whether you deliberately violated a known policy, not just whether you broke a rule. If your absences were medically documented and your supervisor knew about them, that's going to be hard for your employer to frame as intentional wrongdoing. Keep every scrap of documentation you have.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorMy doctor visits all happened within the last two months so I should have records for all of them. My worry is whether HR saying it was case by case is enough or whether DES is going to default to the employer's version.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Just got through something similar last month. DES does contact the employer directly and ask them to explain the basis for the termination. If your employer can't show you intentionally disregarded a clear policy, they usually don't win the misconduct argument.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
I'd also upload any written communication you have with that supervisor into the portal. Even screenshots of texts can help fill in the picture.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
Waiting on my determination letter for almost a month now and while I was stuck trying to reach someone at DES I ended up using Claimyr - basically it stays on the line with Arizona DES for you so you're not the one burning hours on hold, and I actually got through to a live agent who pulled up my file and walked me through exactly what the adjudicator was looking at. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see how it works before trying it. For a misconduct situation especially, talking to an actual agent made a real difference because I could ask specific questions about my case.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorHonestly I've been trying to get through on the phone for days with zero luck. I'll check that out, thank you. Did the agent you spoke with tell you anything about how they weigh employer statements vs. documentation you submit yourself?
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Got my own denial reversed earlier this year and I second this. Actually speaking to someone at DES who can see your file is completely different from just reading the portal messages. The adjudication process for misconduct cases really needs a human explanation.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
Same week, same boat, couldn't reach anyone for two straight weeks before I found something that worked. The hold times on the DES main line are absolutely brutal right now.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Thirty days is the number that caught me completely off guard - that's how long you have to appeal once DES mails your determination letter, not from when you see it in the portal. If you get a denial on the misconduct question, start your appeal immediately because that clock doesn't pause while you're gathering documents. The appeals process is separate from adjudication and goes before a hearing officer.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorThat thirty-day window is genuinely stressful to hear. My determination hasn't come yet but I'm going to be watching the mail constantly now.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
My determination letter showed up in the portal three days before the physical mail arrived so keep checking your CACTUS account too. Also, for anyone who can't get through to DES to ask questions before the determination, Claimyr worked for me when I needed to talk through my appeal options before that window closed.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
The gap between portal notification and mail delivery tripped me up too. I almost missed a deadline because I was waiting for the paper letter and it was already in my portal.
0 coins
Luca Romano
Step one for me in my own misconduct case was writing out a detailed timeline of every absence, what I told my supervisor each time, and what their response was. DES adjudicators are essentially asking: did this person know the rule, did they intentionally break it anyway, and was there a legitimate reason. Medical issues generally fall outside that intentional category, especially when you gave notice each time.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorMy texts to my supervisor actually show him responding with 'got it' or 'ok' every single time I messaged about being out. That feels like implied approval to me but I don't know how DES reads it.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Six months ago I fought a very similar one and won. Supervisor acknowledgment texts were specifically mentioned in my determination as evidence that the absences weren't unauthorized. Submit those for sure.
0 coins
NebulaNova
HR's case-by-case comment is gold if you can get it in writing somehow. Even an email chain referencing that conversation would help.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
The portal has a document upload section under your claim details. I uploaded a whole PDF packet with my timeline, texts, and medical note and the adjudicator referenced all of it in my determination letter.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
I work in HR at a completely different company now and I want to flag something - the way most employers document a misconduct termination for DES purposes follows a pretty standard script. They'll say you violated attendance policy despite being warned. What breaks that script is showing that any warnings were conditional or that the policy itself was applied inconsistently to you vs. other employees. If HR said absences were handled case by case, that inconsistency argument is actually available to you.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorThey did give me a verbal warning once but it was before the medical situation even started. After I told them about the health issue the warnings stopped. Does that timeline matter?
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
In my case the timing of warnings relative to when the employer knew about my circumstances came up in the adjudication. DES seemed to care a lot about whether the employer's response changed once they had additional context.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
The inconsistency point is so underused. I've seen people lose appeals where they clearly had a case just because they didn't frame it as 'this rule wasn't applied the same way to me as to others.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
My claim hit adjudication for misconduct back in the spring and I ended up talking to a DES agent through Claimyr before my determination even came out, which let me find out what documents the adjudicator was actually waiting on. I sent in what was missing and my claim was approved without needing to go to appeal. Worth it just for that conversation.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorFinding out what they're waiting on before the determination sounds huge. I keep second-guessing whether I uploaded enough.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Two weeks into my adjudication right now and I had no idea you could contact them mid-process to find out the status of what they've reviewed. That changes my whole approach.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
My adjudicator actually left a note in my portal about a missing document but I didn't see it for days because the portal notification system is not obvious. If you can reach someone by phone they'll tell you right away.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Something a lot of people miss is that your weekly certifications should keep going even while you're in adjudication for misconduct. If your claim is ultimately approved, you'll get back pay for all the weeks you certified. If you stop certifying you lose those weeks permanently, no exceptions. File every week no matter what.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorI've been certifying every Sunday, so at least I've got that covered. The job search requirement while in adjudication was confusing to me at first though - do you still have to log contacts even when the claim is pending?
0 coins
Diego Vargas
Yes, four employer contacts per week is still required in Arizona even during adjudication. I made the mistake of skipping a week thinking my pending status paused the requirement. It doesn't.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Just confirmed this with a DES agent last week. The job search log and weekly certification are completely separate from whatever the adjudicator is deciding. Keep doing both.
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
Genuinely baffled by how DES communicates during all of this. My portal just says pending with zero explanation and I've been in adjudication for misconduct for five weeks. No letters, no portal messages, nothing. How are you supposed to know if they even received your documents?
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorMine at least shows the documents I uploaded as received but there's no status on what they've actually reviewed. The silence is awful.
0 coins
Luca Romano
The document received confirmation in the portal is about all you get. The adjudicator doesn't reach out unless something is specifically missing or they need a statement from you directly.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Five weeks is on the longer end for misconduct adjudication but not unheard of when the employer is submitting their own documentation. The more complicated the separation, the longer it tends to take.
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
My sister went through almost this exact misconduct situation last year - terminated for attendance, had medical records, the whole thing. She got denied initially, appealed, and won at the hearing. At the hearing stage she used Claimyr to reach a DES agent beforehand and got clarification on exactly what documents to bring to the hearing. The hearing officer actually commented that her file was unusually well-organized.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorIf it comes to an appeal hearing I want to be that prepared. What kind of documents made the biggest impression at her hearing?
0 coins
Jamal Wilson
Her work was the medical records clearly dated before the termination, the supervisor texts, and a written statement laying out the full timeline in her own words. The hearing officer asked about the HR case-by-case statement and she had emails that referenced that conversation.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Hearing officers are surprisingly thorough. Mine asked follow-up questions I didn't expect at all. Having everything organized and knowing your own timeline cold is essential.
0 coins
Mei Lin
Just want to throw in that I completely misread the misconduct definition when I first filed. I thought any termination meant automatic disqualification, so I almost didn't file at all. The actual standard is way narrower than that. Getting fired doesn't mean misconduct under DES rules, and even being fired for a policy violation doesn't automatically qualify either.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorI had the same misunderstanding for about a week. I thought I had no shot until I actually read the DES information about what they define as misconduct.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
This misconception stops so many people from filing. The employer saying misconduct and DES finding misconduct are two completely different things. File and let the process work.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Even if you get denied, the appeal process exists for a reason. The initial determination is not the end of the road.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
The $1,000 figure threw me completely - that was my weekly benefit amount once everything was calculated and I had no idea I qualified for that much until I actually filed. Anyway, on the misconduct question specifically, make sure you respond to any requests for a statement from DES quickly. They give you a window and if you miss it the determination goes forward without your side of the story.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorHas anyone had DES request a phone interview as part of the misconduct adjudication? I've heard this can happen and I'm not sure how to prepare.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
Got a phone interview for mine. They called the number on file so make sure yours is current. They basically ask you to explain the circumstances of the termination in your own words. Be factual and specific about dates.
0 coins
NebulaNova
They asked me if I ever received a written warning and what my response was. Having the actual documents in front of you during that call helps a lot.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
In week seven of waiting on a misconduct adjudication here and I want to know if anyone has had DES actually reach out to the supervisor directly rather than just the HR or legal department. My supervisor would absolutely back my account but I don't know if DES contacts individuals or just the company.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
In my experience DES goes through the employer's designated representative, usually HR or whoever handles separations. If you want your supervisor's statement in the mix, you'd need to get it in writing and submit it yourself as a supporting document.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
A written statement from your supervisor, even informal, submitted through the portal could be really useful. DES can't compel individual employees to participate but they will consider a statement you provide.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
That's actually really helpful. I'm going to ask my former supervisor if they'd write something up. We're still on good terms which is the whole irony of this termination.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
My determination came back as a non-disqualifying separation even though my employer called it misconduct, so they don't always side with the employer. The key in my case was that the policy I supposedly violated had never been shown to me in writing and I could prove it. No written policy, no signed acknowledgment, nothing.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorI actually don't think I ever signed the attendance policy specifically. I signed a general onboarding packet but I don't know if the attendance rules were in there. Worth looking into.
0 coins
Mei Lin
If you have your original onboarding documents or can get them from HR you should check whether the attendance policy is specifically in there with your signature on it. That could be a real factor.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
DES weighs knowledge of the policy pretty heavily. If you can show you didn't know the specific rule you were allegedly breaking, that undercuts the intentionality argument.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Just got my approval after a misconduct fight that took almost two months. Filed in late winter, employer contested, went through adjudication, got denied, appealed, won at the hearing in late spring. The whole experience was exhausting but it worked. Stick with it.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorTwo months is sobering but good to know the system can work eventually. What was the biggest thing that made the difference at your hearing?
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Honestly it was showing up completely prepared with a folder for the hearing officer. I had a one-page summary of my timeline at the top, then all the supporting documents tabbed behind it. The hearing officer said in her ruling that the documentation was clear and credible.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
The hearing stage is where a lot of people finally win cases they should have won at the initial adjudication. The hearing officer gets more context than the adjudicator typically sees.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
This thread is genuinely the most useful thing I've read about this whole process. Bookmarked.
0 coins
NebulaNova
The part about the appeals deadline came up for me in an unexpected way - I didn't realize the thirty-day window runs from the mailing date on the letter, not the date I actually opened it. My letter sat in a pile for a week before I saw it. If I'd waited another week I would have missed my window entirely.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorThat is terrifying. I'm going to check the mail every single day now.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
I set a calendar reminder the minute I knew my determination was close. As soon as it showed up in my CACTUS portal I looked at the mailing date and counted from there.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
The portal notification usually comes the same day or the day after the letter is mailed. Use the portal date as your starting point and you'll have a little cushion by the time the paper copy arrives.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
Something no one seems to mention is that you can request a copy of the employer's statement to DES as part of the appeals process. Once you're at that stage you have the right to see what your former employer actually told them. I found out my employer had described the situation in a way that was factually inaccurate and I could directly rebut it at the hearing.
0 coins
StarStrider
AuthorI had no idea you could request that. If I get to the appeal stage that's the first thing I'm doing.
0 coins
Luca Romano
This is correct and underused. The appeals packet you receive before the hearing includes the employer's submitted documentation. Read every word of it because that's what the hearing officer has seen.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
In my hearing I was able to point to specific things in the employer's statement that contradicted the texts I had submitted. The hearing officer picked up on that inconsistency immediately.
0 coins