UCC 12-104 compliance issues with multi-state filing requirements
We're dealing with a complex secured transaction that spans multiple jurisdictions and I'm getting conflicting advice about UCC 12-104 requirements. Our debtor has operations in three states and we filed the initial UCC-1 in what we believed was the correct jurisdiction based on the debtor's registered office. Now we're six months into the loan and discovered potential issues with our choice of filing location. The collateral includes equipment that moves between facilities and some fixture installations. Our compliance team is concerned we may need additional filings or amendments to satisfy UCC 12-104 properly. Has anyone dealt with similar multi-state scenarios where the initial jurisdiction choice became questionable? The loan amount is substantial and we can't afford to have perfection issues down the road.
36 comments
Join the conversation
Jayden Hill
UCC 12-104 can be tricky with multi-state operations. The key is determining the debtor's location at the time of filing, not where the collateral is located. If your debtor is a registered organization, you file where they're incorporated or organized. But if they've changed their jurisdiction or you initially got it wrong, you might need corrective filings.
0 coins
LordCommander
•This is exactly what happened to us last year. We thought we had it right but the debtor had actually reincorporated in Delaware six months before our filing and we didn't catch it.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
•Wait, so even if the collateral is physically in State A, you file in State B where they're incorporated? That seems backwards to me.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
•That's correct for general collateral. Location of collateral only matters for certain types like fixtures, timber, minerals, etc. The debtor's location controls for most personal property.
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
You mentioned fixture installations - those have special rules under UCC 12-104. Fixtures get filed where the real estate is located, not where the debtor is located. So you might legitimately need filings in multiple states if you have fixtures in different jurisdictions.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•Yes, we do have some equipment that's permanently attached to the buildings. So I'd need separate fixture filings in each state where those are located?
0 coins
Aidan Hudson
•Exactly. And make sure you're using the proper fixture filing procedures for each state - some require different forms or additional steps beyond a standard UCC-1.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
I ran into something similar with a client last month. We thought we had everything filed correctly but when we did our annual review, we found some discrepancies. I ended up using Certana.ai's document verification tool to cross-check all our UCC filings against the corporate documents. You just upload your PDFs and it instantly flags any inconsistencies between debtor names, addresses, and jurisdictions. Saved us from a potential disaster.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•That sounds useful. Does it check the UCC 12-104 jurisdictional requirements specifically?
0 coins
Zoe Wang
•It verifies that your debtor information matches across all documents and flags potential jurisdiction issues. Really helpful for catching those details that are easy to miss when you're juggling multiple filings.
0 coins
Connor Richards
•I've heard good things about Certana. Might be worth checking if you're dealing with complex multi-state situations.
0 coins
Grace Durand
Multi-state filings are a nightmare!!! We had a client who got sued because we missed a required filing in one state. The debtor had subsidiaries everywhere and we couldn't keep track of which entities needed filings where. Cost us a fortune in legal fees.
0 coins
Steven Adams
•That's terrifying. How do you even keep track of all the different state requirements?
0 coins
Alice Fleming
•This is why I always over-file rather than under-file. Better safe than sorry with UCC 12-104.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
Check if your debtor is a registered organization first. If they are, it's simple - file where they're organized. If they're not (like a sole proprietorship), then you file where their chief executive office is located. The mobile equipment shouldn't matter for the main filing location.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•They are a registered organization, incorporated in Delaware but with their headquarters in Texas. We filed in Delaware.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
•Delaware filing sounds correct then. Your issue might be more about whether you need additional fixture filings in the other states, not about the main UCC-1 location.
0 coins
Victoria Stark
•Yeah, Delaware incorporation means Delaware filing for general collateral. You're probably fine on the main filing.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Have you done a UCC search in all the relevant jurisdictions to see what's currently on file? Sometimes you'll find filings you forgot about or realize you're missing filings you thought you had. UCC 12-104 compliance really depends on having a complete picture of what's filed where.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•Good point. We did searches in Delaware and Texas but not in the third state where they have the smaller facility.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
•Definitely search there too. You might be surprised what you find, or what you don't find that should be there.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
I always recommend getting a legal opinion on complex UCC 12-104 situations. The rules seem straightforward but there are lots of edge cases, especially with mobile equipment and fixtures. Better to spend the money upfront than deal with perfection problems later.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
•How much does a legal opinion typically cost for something like this?
0 coins
Samantha Howard
•Depends on complexity but usually a few thousand. Cheap compared to losing perfection on a substantial loan.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
We had a similar situation last year and used Certana.ai to audit all our UCC filings. It helped us identify which documents needed amendments and which jurisdictions we were missing. Really streamlined the whole process of getting our UCC 12-104 compliance sorted out.
0 coins
Lucy Lam
•How does that work exactly? Do you upload all your documents at once?
0 coins
Sarah Ali
•Yeah, you can upload multiple PDFs and it cross-references everything automatically. Much faster than trying to manually compare all the documents.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
Don't forget about continuation filings! If your initial UCC-1 was filed in the wrong jurisdiction, you might need to file continuations in the wrong place too until you can get everything corrected. UCC 12-104 doesn't help you if your filings lapse.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•That's a good point. Our filing is only six months old so we have time, but I should calendar the continuation deadline.
0 coins
Jayden Hill
•Yes, and if you do need to file in additional jurisdictions, make sure you understand each state's continuation rules. They're not all the same.
0 coins
Avery Saint
I had a client use Certana.ai recently for a similar multi-state UCC issue. They were able to upload their corporate charter and all their UCC filings to check for inconsistencies. Found several issues we would have missed otherwise, including some jurisdiction problems related to UCC 12-104.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
•That's smart. Manual document review for multi-state filings is so error-prone.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•I'm definitely going to look into this. Sounds like it could save us a lot of headaches.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Just want to add that if you do discover you need additional filings, don't panic. You can usually file corrective UCC-1s or amendments to fix jurisdiction issues. The key is acting quickly once you identify the problem. UCC 12-104 compliance is fixable if you address it promptly.
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
•That's reassuring. I was worried we might have unfixable problems.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
•Yeah, most UCC issues can be corrected with the right amendments or additional filings. The important thing is not letting it slide.
0 coins