< Back to FAFSA

Chloe Anderson

FAFSA only gave $5k + athletic scholarship still leaves us with $15k gap - loan options?

My daughter got accepted to her dream school with a $33,000 athletic scholarship for volleyball, but we're still looking at a $15,000 gap even after her $5,000 FAFSA aid. Her mom (my ex) handled the FAFSA application, and I'm completely lost trying to figure out the next steps. The financial aid office just sent us the award letter last week and fall semester starts in 2 months. Are there specific parent loans I should be looking at? Any scholarships still accepting applications this late? I'm worried because my credit isn't great after some medical bills last year, but I want to help cover this gap somehow. This is our first child going to college and I feel completely unprepared.

Diego Vargas

•

First, check if that $5,000 from FAFSA is just grants or if it includes federal student loans. Many award letters include Direct Subsidized/Unsubsidized loans as part of the "aid package" but don't clearly label them as loans. If there are already federal student loans in that $5k, your daughter can accept those first - they have the best terms. For the remaining gap, you have several options: 1. Parent PLUS loan - but as you mentioned, credit check might be an issue 2. Private student loans (your daughter would need a co-signer with good credit) 3. Payment plan through the school (usually splits the bill into 10-12 monthly payments) 4. Outside scholarships - check sites like Fastweb and Scholarships.com Also, did your ex report both of your incomes on the FAFSA? If you're divorced and she's the custodial parent, only her income should have been reported, which might increase aid eligibility.

0 coins

Thank you! I just checked and you're right - the $5,000 includes $3,500 in subsidized loans and only $1,500 in actual grants. So we really have a $18,500 gap, not $15,000. I didn't realize the loans were counted in that total. And no, my income wasn't reported since my ex has primary custody. Would it help to ask for a financial aid appeal? Or is it too late for that?

0 coins

My daughter got a volleyball scholarship too and we still had like $10k left to pay. We did the Parent PLUS loan and it was really easy jsut had to do a credit check. The interest rate kinda sucks tho.

0 coins

Did you have any issues with the credit check? That's my main concern with the Parent PLUS loan. My credit score is around 620 after some medical collections last year.

0 coins

StarStrider

•

CALL THE FINANCIAL AID OFFICE DIRECTLY AND ASK FOR MORE MONEY!!! I cannot stress this enough!! My son's package was $8k short and I literally called and explained our situation and they found him another $4k in institutional grants. They have discretionary funds but you have to ASK FOR THEM!! Don't just accept what they first offer!

0 coins

Sean Doyle

•

This is good advice but calling financial aid offices can be a nightmare right now. I spent THREE WEEKS trying to get through to my daughter's school about a verification issue. Finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a human in about 10 minutes instead of waiting on hold forever. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ. Totally worth it for important financial aid calls where you need to actually speak to someone who can help.

0 coins

Zara Rashid

•

have you considerd a home equity loan if u own a house? the intrest rates are better than PLUS and privat loans usually.

0 coins

I rent, unfortunately. Otherwise that would be a good option.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

Financial aid professional here! A few things that might help: 1. For your credit concerns with Parent PLUS loans: if you're denied due to credit, your daughter automatically becomes eligible for additional Unsubsidized Direct loans (up to $4,000 more for freshman year). This won't cover the full gap, but it helps. 2. Many colleges have payment plans that break the bill into monthly payments with minimal fees. This can make the remaining amount more manageable. 3. Have your daughter contact the athletic department directly. Sometimes coaches have discretionary scholarship funds they can allocate, especially if they really want to keep a recruit. This is particularly true if other schools offered her more substantial athletic scholarships. 4. File a Special Circumstances appeal with the financial aid office if there have been significant changes to your financial situation since the tax year used for FAFSA (2023 taxes for 2025-2026 aid year). Finally, the average SAI (Student Aid Index, formerly EFC) can change significantly when calculated with the new FAFSA. Your ex should check if all contributors were properly listed.

0 coins

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I didn't know about the additional unsubsidized loans if I get denied for PLUS. That would definitely help. And I'll have my daughter talk to her coach about any additional athletic funds. They were really recruiting her hard, so maybe there's some flexibility there.

0 coins

Nia Jackson

•

not trying to be mean but i think its weird ur ex handled all the fafsa stuff and now ur stuck with the bill??? maybe she should be the one taking out the parent plus loan since she did the application? just saying

0 coins

We're actually splitting the costs - she's covering half the remaining gap. I'm just trying to figure out my portion and what options make sense for my financial situation. Sorry if that wasn't clear.

0 coins

Diego Vargas

•

One thing to consider: your daughter should look into becoming a Resident Assistant (RA) after freshman year. My son saved over $12,000 per year in room and board costs as an RA his sophomore through senior years. That made a huge difference in our overall costs. Also, look into work-study options for this year if they weren't included in her aid package.

0 coins

The RA suggestion is brilliant. I'll definitely mention that to her as an option for next year. And I just checked - there's no work-study in her current package, but I'll ask the financial aid office if that could be added.

0 coins

StarStrider

•

DID YOU SEE IF THE COLLEGE OFFERS MERIT SCHOLARSHIPS????? Some schools have additional academic scholarships that aren't automatic!!! My daughter got a $5k merit scholarship just by filling out an extra application!!! Ask about this IMMEDIATELY!!!!!

0 coins

Zara Rashid

•

most merit scholrships have deadlines in like february or march tho. probly too late for this year but good for next year maybe

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

Update on the Special Circumstances appeal I mentioned: make sure to document everything. If you're submitting an appeal based on your medical expenses, provide copies of bills and proof of payment. Schools typically want to see that medical expenses exceeded 11% of your AGI to consider it a special circumstance. Also, ask specifically about the school's Professional Judgment process - some schools use this term instead of "appeal.

0 coins

Thank you - I'll gather all my medical bills from last year. They were definitely over 11% of my income, so maybe that will help with an appeal.

0 coins

Don't forget to check if your daughter's school participates in any tuition exchange programs or has partnerships with other institutions that might offer additional funding opportunities. Also, some schools have emergency aid funds for students who demonstrate sudden financial need - these are often overlooked but can provide a few thousand dollars. Another option to consider: some employers offer tuition assistance programs that extend to employees' children. Check with both your and your ex's employers to see if this benefit exists. Even if it's just $1,000-2,000 per year, every bit helps close that gap. Finally, don't overlook local scholarships from community organizations, rotary clubs, or businesses in your area. Many of these have later deadlines because they're smaller and less competitive than national scholarships.

0 coins

Leo Simmons

•

This is really comprehensive advice, thank you! I hadn't thought about employer tuition benefits - I'll check with my company's HR department tomorrow. And you're right about local scholarships having later deadlines. I found a few through our local community foundation that are due in May. It's worth applying even if they're smaller amounts. Every little bit helps when you're looking at this big of a gap. I really appreciate everyone's suggestions in this thread - feeling much more prepared to tackle this now!

0 coins

I'm in a similar situation with my son starting college this fall. One thing that really helped us was setting up a meeting with the financial aid counselor (not just calling the general office). They walked us through all our options and helped us understand the timeline for different types of aid. Also, if your daughter hasn't already, make sure she accepts those federal loans in her portal ASAP - there are deadlines for accepting aid, and you don't want to miss out on the subsidized portion. The unsubsidized loans don't have the same urgency but it's good to get everything locked in. For the Parent PLUS loan with credit concerns, you might want to apply sooner rather than later. If you do get denied, it opens up those additional unsubsidized loans for your daughter that someone mentioned, plus it gives you more time to explore other options. The whole process felt overwhelming at first but breaking it down step by step made it much more manageable.

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today