FAFSA divorce situation - Can my daughter use her disabled father instead of me for better aid?
I'm recently divorced and my daughter only included me on her FAFSA application for 2025-2026. Her father receives disability benefits and honestly can't contribute much financially. I've heard rumors that you can choose which parent to list on the FAFSA when parents are divorced - is this actually true? If so, wouldn't using her father's financial information result in a better SAI score since his income is substantially lower than mine? I'm looking at a tuition bill of $27,800 per year and feeling completely overwhelmed trying to handle this alone. Any advice on whether we should resubmit with her father's information instead? The financial aid office at her school wasn't very helpful when I called.
23 comments


Carmen Diaz
you can only use the custodial parent on fafsa. whoever she lives with more than 50% of the time. they changed the rules this year i think
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Thank you for responding! She technically splits time between us, but has her permanent address at my house for school purposes. Does that automatically make me the custodial parent for FAFSA?
0 coins
Andre Laurent
The FAFSA rules for divorced parents are specific. It asks for information from the parent the student lived with more during the past 12 months. If equal time, then it's the parent who provided more financial support. It's not about choosing the parent with lower income strategically. However, if your daughter truly does spend more time with her father, or he provides more financial support despite his disability, then yes, you could update the FAFSA to reflect this. But be aware that providing false information on FAFSA is considered fraud and carries serious penalties.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•This is really helpful information, thank you! She actually does spend slightly more time at his place during school breaks since it's closer to her work. I wasn't trying to game the system - just wasn't clear on the rules. I'll have a conversation with her about updating the FAFSA to accurately reflect her living situation.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
•my daughter had this EXACT situation!!! they made us provide court docs proving custody arrangement and even asked for calendar showing days at each house! be prepared for verification!!
0 coins
Liam Mendez
Can't you just put the parent who makes less money? That's what my neighbor told me they did for their son's FAFSA. They're divorced too and they only used the mom's info cause she makes like half what the dad does. They got way more aid that way.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•That's actually incorrect information your neighbor shared, and could potentially be considered FAFSA fraud. The selection of which parent to include isn't based on income levels but on where the student primarily resides (custodial parent). Financial aid offices regularly verify this information, especially in divorced situations, so providing accurate information is extremely important.
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
When my ex and I were navigating this with our son, we found that the FAFSA's definition of "custodial parent" isn't necessarily the same as legal custody from divorce papers. It's literally about where your daughter physically lived more nights during the 12 months prior to filing the FAFSA. If she genuinely lives with her father more (or exactly 50/50 and he provides more financial support), then yes, using his information would likely result in a better Student Aid Index (SAI) and potentially more financial aid. I would recommend documenting her living situation carefully before making any changes - the financial aid office can request verification, especially if the numbers look significantly different from a previous application.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•This is so helpful! Thank you for explaining the difference between legal custody and the FAFSA definition. I need to sit down with my daughter and actually count the days/nights from the past year. Since her father lives closer to her part-time job, she does stay there quite often during breaks.
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
I went through this exact situation last year with my son. Let me tell you what we learned the hard way: the new FAFSA (2024-2025 and beyond) cares about where your daughter physically lived more nights during the previous year. It's not about legal custody or which parent claims her on taxes. Here's what I suggest: 1. Actually count the nights she stayed with each parent over the past 12 months 2. If it's truly 50/50, then the tiebreaker is which parent provided more financial support 3. Document everything - the financial aid office might ask for verification 4. If you realize her father should be listed instead, submit a correction to the FAFSA And yes, if her father's income is significantly lower due to disability, it would likely result in a better SAI calculation, which could mean more aid. Just make sure you're following the rules exactly - financial aid offices are scrutinizing divorced parent situations more carefully with the new FAFSA.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Thank you so much for sharing your experience! This is exactly the practical advice I needed. I'll start documenting her living situation right away. Did you have to provide any specific evidence when you went through verification?
0 coins
Jacob Smithson
•Yes, we had to provide a signed statement from both parents confirming the living arrangement, our informal custody calendar we used for the year, and some documentation showing our son's presence at each residence (school mail, medical appointments scheduled from each home, etc.). It was pretty thorough!
0 coins
Isabella Brown
I work in financial aid. Here's the thing - the FAFSA rules are clear but verification can be a nightmare. If you update the FAFSA and the SAI changes dramatically, it WILL trigger verification. You'll need documentation. Has your divorce decree specified a custody arrangement? That's usually the first thing we ask for.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Our decree actually says joint physical custody with a flexible schedule based on our daughter's needs and activities. There's no formal schedule written into it. Would that be a problem?
0 coins
Isabella Brown
•That makes it more complicated, but not impossible. You'll need to document the actual time spent at each residence. Keep text messages about pickups/drop-offs, calendar entries, anything showing where she was staying. Some schools are more stringent than others with verification.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
OMG they made this SOOO COMPLICATED with the new FAFSA!!! My daughter had to redo her entire application because we put the wrong parent. didnt even know until the SAI score came back wrong. Then we couldnt get ANYONE on the phone at the federal student aid number for like 3 weeks!!!
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•That sounds incredibly frustrating! Were you eventually able to get it sorted out? I'm worried about making any changes and then not being able to reach anyone if there's a problem.
0 coins
Maya Patel
•When I was dealing with customer service issues with FAFSA last semester, I used Claimyr to get through to a live agent without waiting on hold. Their website (claimyr.com) has a video demo showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ It saved me hours of frustration when my daughter's FAFSA got flagged for verification and we couldn't get answers online. Worth considering if you're making changes that might need follow-up calls.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
•YES we finally got it fixed but it took forever!!! if I had known there was a service to skip the phone wait I totally would have used it lol. we ended up having to submit so many extra documents
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
its not worth the risk to lie on fafsa just to get more money. my cousins friend got caught and the kid lost all financial aid and had to pay everything back
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Oh, I definitely don't want to provide false information! I just want to make sure we're following the rules correctly. If she legitimately spends more time with her father, I want to make sure that's reflected accurately.
0 coins
Sophia Nguyen
One important thing to consider - if you do need to correct the FAFSA to list her father instead of you, do it ASAP. Many schools have priority deadlines for financial aid, and late FAFSA corrections can sometimes mean less institutional aid, even if the federal aid increases. Also, be prepared for the verification process to take 3-4 weeks, sometimes longer with the new FAFSA system delays.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•That's a really good point about timing. Her school's priority deadline was February 1st, but they said they're still processing financial aid packages through April. I'll try to get this figured out this week.
0 coins