FAFSA: Got Pell and SEOG grants but still $4586 short for dorm costs - alternatives to Parent PLUS loan?
Just found out my son qualified for a Pell Grant ($3698 per term) and SEOG based on our negative SAI of -1500. He also received a small institutional grant from his college. The problem is we're still coming up $4586 short PER TERM if he lives in even the cheapest dorm option! We weren't expecting this gap and I'm really worried about taking out a Parent PLUS loan since my credit isn't great and I'm already stretched thin financially. Are there other options we should be looking at? State grants? Private scholarships? Work-study? I'm feeling overwhelmed and don't know where to turn next. Any advice would be so appreciated!
18 comments


KaiEsmeralda
have u looked into work study? my kid got that along with his pell grant and it helps cover abt $2000 per semester. also check if the school has payment plans so u dont have to pay all at once
0 coins
Millie Long
•Thanks for the suggestion! He wasn't offered work-study on his initial package. Do you know if he can still apply for it separately or does it have to be part of the original financial aid offer?
0 coins
Debra Bai
You definitely have options beyond Parent PLUS loans. Here's what I suggest: 1. Contact the financial aid office about a professional judgment review if you've had any change in finances since filing FAFSA 2. Ask specifically about work-study - with your negative SAI, he should qualify if funds are available 3. Check for state grants - many have deadlines later than FAFSA 4. Look into outside scholarships - FastWeb and Scholly are good resources 5. Consider a monthly payment plan through the school (usually has minimal fees compared to loans) 6. Emergency student loans from the school (typically low-amount, short-term) Also, run the numbers on commuting if that's geographically possible - living at home for the first year can save thousands.
0 coins
Millie Long
•This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I didn't know about professional judgment reviews. My hours were cut at work after we submitted the FAFSA, so maybe that would qualify. I'll definitely call the financial aid office tomorrow.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
WHY IS COLLEGE SO EXPENSIVE?!?! This is ridiculous! My daughter got "full financial aid" too and we still had to come up with $6000 per term. The whole system is BROKEN. They tell you you're getting all this "free money" and then hit you with thousands in housing costs. It's a scam.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
•Yuuup! And then they act like Parent PLUS loans are "aid"... it's just debt they're putting on parents who already can't afford college! The system is totally rigged.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Have you considered private loans instead of Parent PLUS? With a good cosigner, your son might qualify for better rates than Parent PLUS. Also, look into resident advisor positions for sophomore year - free housing plus stipend at most schools.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
•Just be careful with private loans - they don't have the same forgiveness options or income-driven repayment plans as federal loans. My sister got private loans and has been struggling for years because there's no flexibility when she lost her job.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
Try calling the Federal Student Aid office directly to see if there are additional grant programs your son might qualify for with your negative SAI. I was on hold for HOURS trying to speak with someone until I found Claimyr (claimyr.com). They got me connected to a real person at FSA in under 10 minutes. They have a video demo showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ The agent helped me understand additional grants my daughter qualified for that weren't automatically included. Definitely worth checking!
0 coins
Millie Long
•I hadn't heard of this service before. I'll check it out - I've been avoiding calling because I don't have hours to waste on hold. Did they explain any specific grants beyond Pell and SEOG that might help?
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
my son was in the exact same boat last year!!! what ended up working for us was appealing directly to the financial aid office and explaining our situation. they found an additional $2000 per semester in institutional funds. also applied for like 25 local scholarships and he got 3 of them totaling $1500. every bit helps!! also check if your employer offers any education benefits for dependents - mine had a $1000 scholarship i didnt even know about until someone mentioned it
0 coins
Millie Long
•Thank you! I never thought about checking with my employer. And 3 out of 25 scholarships is actually a good success rate from what I've heard. Did you just Google local scholarships or is there a better way to find them?
0 coins
Laura Lopez
Have u considered looking at a cheaper school? Not trying to be harsh but sometimes the prestige isn't worth the debt. My kid transferred after freshman year to our state university and saved over $15k/year with basically the same education quality.
0 coins
Millie Long
•We did look at several schools and this was actually one of the more affordable options with his major. But you make a good point - maybe we should reconsider some of the state schools for transfer after freshman year if the finances don't work out.
0 coins
Debra Bai
After seeing your responses to other comments, I want to follow up with some additional advice. Since you mentioned your hours were cut after FAFSA submission, that's EXACTLY what professional judgment reviews are designed for! Make sure to: 1. Document the reduction in hours/income (pay stubs, letter from employer) 2. Calculate the projected annual income difference 3. Submit a formal appeal letter specifically requesting "professional judgment review due to income reduction" With your already negative SAI, further reduction could potentially qualify your son for increased institutional aid or additional state grants. Don't be discouraged if your first request is denied - persistence often pays off with financial aid offices.
0 coins
Millie Long
•This is exactly what I needed to know! I'll start gathering documentation today and draft that appeal letter. Should I call first or just submit everything in writing? I want to make sure I'm doing this the right way.
0 coins
Debra Bai
It's usually best to call first to learn their specific process - some schools have forms while others want a letter. Mention specifically that you've had an "income reduction since FAFSA filing" and ask about their "professional judgment review process." This uses their terminology and signals you understand the system. One more option: see if your son can get on the housing waitlist for the lowest-cost dorm options. Sometimes spots open up last minute when other students decide not to attend.
0 coins
Millie Long
•Thank you so much. I just called and they're sending me their special circumstances form. They said decisions typically take 2-3 weeks, so at least we have some time before deposits are due. I really appreciate all your help!
0 coins