


Ask the community...
anybody know if this effects your SAI calculation?? my brothers fafsa had the same issue and his SAI was way higher than expected when it finally went through. not sure if its related but just a warning.
This issue with the IRS data transfer doesn't directly affect the SAI calculation. The SAI (Student Aid Index) is calculated based on the data itself, not how it was entered. If your brother's SAI was higher than expected, it's more likely due to how income and assets were reported, not the transfer delay. Common reasons for unexpectedly high SAI include: - Reportable assets that weren't excluded (some retirement accounts should be excluded) - Multiple family members in college not being properly reported - Income from tax-exempt interest not being correctly handled - Untaxed income being counted that wasn't anticipated If you believe there's an error, your brother can contact his school's financial aid office to request a professional judgment review.
UPDATE: The IRS data finally came through today! Interestingly, as soon as it did, I got a completely different notification saying "New information has been added to your FAFSA" instead of the incomplete reminders. We were able to finish the rest of the application in about 20 minutes. For anyone else facing this issue - it took exactly 6 business days for the IRS data to transfer. Thanks everyone for your help and suggestions!
That's great news! Glad it worked out. Now make sure to check her Student Aid Index (SAI) once it's calculated (usually 3-5 days after submission) and have her watch for communications from her schools about any additional information they might need. Some schools also require the CSS Profile in addition to FAFSA, so double-check her school's financial aid websites for all requirements.
I'm an academic advisor who's been helping students with FAFSA issues this cycle. What you're experiencing is part of the redesigned FAFSA process. Your tax information includes both you and your husband when you file jointly, so the system now skips redundant entry fields. However, there IS a technical issue affecting some applications where the summary page doesn't display all contributor information correctly. Before signing and submitting: 1. Download or screenshot the entire summary page 2. Verify BOTH parents' information appears in the contributor section 3. Check that income figures match what you'd expect from your tax return If anything is missing or incorrect, DO NOT SUBMIT until resolved with FSA. Fixing issues after submission is much more complicated than getting it right initially.
is that why my son's confirmation page showed weird income numbers? our AGI was different than what showed up on the final page even tho we used the IRS tool thing.
Yes, that could definitely be related. The new FAFSA is applying the Simplified Needs Test to more families, so certain income types might be excluded from your SAI calculation. However, if your entire AGI is wrong, that's a technical issue that needs correction. I recommend calling FSA to verify exactly what income was pulled from your tax return. Just be persistent - their phone lines are swamped right now.
After dealing with this exact issue, I finally got through to an FSA agent who explained what's happening. The system IS pulling your husband's data through the IRS function, but there's a display bug in the UI that makes it appear like you're skipping required sections. The agent confirmed that as long as: 1. Both you and your husband appear in the contributor section of the summary page 2. Your income figures roughly match what you filed on taxes (allowing for the new formula adjustments) Then your application IS complete and will be processed correctly. That said - I'd still absolutely review everything before submitting. The new system is much more automated but also has some serious technical issues they're still working through.
One more important point - when your ex-husband does get his FSA ID working, make sure he logs in and completes the IRS Data Retrieval Tool authorization ASAP. For the 2025-2026 FAFSA, this is required for both student and contributing parents before the application can be fully processed. Many families are experiencing delays because they submitted the FAFSA but didn't complete the IRS authorization step, which causes the SAI calculation to be delayed.
We finally got it resolved! The direct FSA ID recovery line + asking for a tier 2 specialist did the trick. Turns out my ex-husband had an account from a community college class he took in 2018 (which he completely forgot about!). They were able to recover that account and reset everything. Now working on the actual FAFSA application with proper access. Tell your brother to call the direct recovery line first thing!
My daughter wanted to go to college so I told her to get a job instead. No FAFSA headaches, no student loans. She's been working at the mall for 6 months now and seems happy enough. Maybe college isn't worth all this trouble anyway?
This isn't helpful at all. The OP is trying to complete a FAFSA so their son can get financial aid for college, not debating whether college is worthwhile. Please stay on topic.
UPDATE: We tried creating a completely new FSA ID with a different email address for my husband, and IT WORKED!! We had to wait 3 days for the SSN verification to process, but we finally got in and completed the FAFSA last night! Thank you to everyone who suggested solutions. The email address change seemed to be the key for us - I guess his old email was somehow linked to an account in the system even though he couldn't access it. For anyone facing similar issues: definitely try the different email approach before resorting to paper forms. And I'm going to check out that Claimyr service for future reference since we'll have to do this all again next year.
Fantastic news! I'm glad the new email address solution worked. That's typically the best fix when the system is showing the "invalid SSN" error but the number is actually correct. One tip for next year: have your husband write down ALL the information for this new FSA ID and store it somewhere secure. Even small variations in the information next year could trigger these same problems again.
Dmitry Petrov
dont bother with fafsa appeal they NEVER help anyone!!!
0 coins
Fatima Al-Maktoum
•This information isn't accurate. The issue isn't that FAFSA "doesn't help" - it's that FAFSA itself isn't designed to handle appeals. The Federal Student Aid office calculates your SAI based on the information provided, but it's the individual schools that have the authority to make adjustments based on special circumstances. So your appeal should always go to the schools, not to FAFSA directly.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
One more important point: make sure you document the specific dates of your unemployment period (7.5 months in 2023) and calculate the total income difference between 2022 and 2023. Financial aid offices appreciate when families provide clear, organized information that shows exactly how significant the change was. Some offices even have specific income threshold changes they look for (often 20% or more) to qualify for adjustments.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
•This is really helpful. Our income dropped by about 35% because of my unemployment period, so it sounds like that should definitely qualify. I'll make sure to clearly highlight that in our documentation.
0 coins