ESD put me in adjudication over 75 cents of jury duty pay - will this affect my benefits?
I'm freaking out over what seems like a tiny mistake. Three weeks ago, I reported my jury duty pay on my weekly claim but I estimated it at $43.25 (they told us the per diem + mileage rate). When I finally got the actual check last week, it was for $44.00 - so I was off by 75 cents because they calculated my mileage slightly differently than I expected. I immediately called ESD to let them know about the mistake, waited on hold for 2.5 hours, and the agent just said "I'll make a note on your account" and told me to check back. Now I've gotten an alert that I'm in adjudication for that week! I had to fill out this whole earnings questionnaire and answer questions about a possible overpayment. Is ESD seriously going to penalize me over 75 CENTS that I voluntarily reported to them? Has anyone dealt with something similar? I'm worried they'll disqualify me for weeks or say I committed fraud when it was an honest mistake that I tried to fix.
16 comments


Daniel Rivera
dont worry!!!!!! this is just ESD being their usual burocratic selves, they put EVERYTHING in adjudication. i had something similar happen when i worked 1 hour overtime but didnt notice till after i filed my weeky claim. took them 3 weeks to clear it up but they did eventually. the system is set up to catch ANYTHING that dosent match and flags it automaticaly
0 coins
Owen Devar
•Thanks, that makes me feel a little better. How long did your adjudication last? Did you keep getting benefits while they were reviewing your case?
0 coins
Sophie Footman
This is actually a standard procedure when there's any earnings discrepancy, even a small one. Since you self-reported the error, that works in your favor. What will happen is that an adjudicator will review your case, confirm the discrepancy amount, and likely just adjust your benefit payment for that week by the additional 75 cents. During adjudication, keep filing your weekly claims as normal. The fact that you proactively contacted them shows good faith. Document the date and time of your call and the agent's name if you have it, as this proves you weren't trying to hide anything.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
•this is good advice, always keep filing!!! i didnt file during my adjudication and then had to do a bunch of backfiling and it was a NIGHTMARE
0 coins
Connor Rupert
omg i had almost the exact same thing happen but with babysitting money! i reported $50 but actually got paid $60 and they put me in adjudication for like 4 weeks. so frustrating but they eventually just made me pay back the difference. keep calling them though!
0 coins
Owen Devar
•Did you have to pay any penalties besides the difference? That's what I'm worried about - that they'll say I committed fraud or something.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
I'm sorry, but this experience doesn't surprise me at all. ESD's system is INTENTIONALLY designed to flag people for the smallest discrepancies so they can deny benefits. They're not there to help you - they're there to find any excuse to cut you off. I made a $5 error on reporting my self-employment income and ended up fighting with them for MONTHS. Their whole "we'll make a note on your account" is just their way of covering themselves while still putting you through the bureaucratic nightmare. I hope your experience goes better than mine did, but don't hold your breath.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
•While I understand your frustration, I don't think the system is designed to deny benefits - it's automated to catch discrepancies because they have legal obligations to ensure accuracy. Many people successfully resolve adjudication issues, especially with small amounts and self-reported corrections. The key is documentation and persistence.
0 coins
Brady Clean
When I ran into a similar situation last month trying to report a pay adjustment, I couldn't get through to ESD on the phone at all after trying for days. I finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an ESD agent in about 20 minutes. They have a video demo that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3 The agent I spoke with explained that small discrepancies under $5 are usually resolved quickly in adjudication without penalties as long as you've been transparent. They told me the most important thing is to keep filing weekly claims during the process and answer any questionnaires completely and honestly.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
•i've heard about claimyr but wasn't sure if it was legit! might try it next time i get the dreaded adjudication notice...
0 coins
Skylar Neal
From my experience working with unemployment cases, I can clarify a few things: 1. Adjudication is automatic for ANY earnings discrepancy, regardless of amount 2. Small discrepancies (especially under $1) that were self-reported are typically resolved with a simple adjustment, not penalties 3. The legal definition of fraud requires intent to deceive, which you clearly didn't have since you contacted them 4. Keep all documentation of your jury duty payment and note the date/time of your call to ESD 5. Continue filing weekly claims during adjudication In 2025, ESD is required to resolve adjudications within 21 days, though they sometimes take longer. If it goes beyond that, you can contact your state representative's office, as they often have liaisons who can expedite ESD cases.
0 coins
Owen Devar
•This is incredibly helpful information, thank you! I didn't know about the 21-day requirement. I have documentation of everything, including my jury duty summons, the check stub showing the exact amount, and a note about when I called ESD (though I didn't get the agent's name unfortunately). I'll keep filing my weekly claims and hopefully this will be resolved soon.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
Not jury duty but I had something similar with a temporary gig. I estimated my earnings and was off by like $12. They put me in adjudication but it was actually resolved pretty fast - like 10 days. As long as you keep answering their questions and filing your claims you should be fine. The fact that YOU contacted THEM about it is hugely in your favor! They're not going after you for fraud over pennies when you literally tried to fix it yourself.
0 coins
Owen Devar
UPDATE: Just wanted to let everyone know that my adjudication was resolved yesterday! They adjusted my payment by the 75 cents and everything is back to normal. Thanks for all the reassurance and advice - especially about continuing to file my weekly claims during the process. For anyone finding this thread later, it took exactly 18 days for them to resolve my case.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
•yay! glad it worked out for you!! the ESD system is so stressful sometimes
0 coins
Skylar Neal
•This is a great outcome and typical for small, self-reported corrections. Thanks for updating the thread - it will help others who find themselves in similar situations.
0 coins