ESD job search audit from 2 years ago - do I really need to reimburse for missing job logs?
Just got really concerned after talking to a colleague yesterday. They said WA ESD contacted them for an audit of their job search activities from almost 2 years ago! Apparently because they couldn't provide documentation for all their listed job search activities, ESD is making them pay back thousands in benefits. I was on unemployment for about 5 months in 2023 and honestly didn't save all my job search info after I found work. Has anyone actually experienced this personally? Did you really have to pay everything back? I'm freaking out that I might get an audit letter next and have no way to prove my job searches were legit.
18 comments


Marcus Williams
Yes, this is 100% real and happens regularly. ESD can audit your job search activities for up to 6 years after you receive benefits. I got audited 14 months after my claim ended and had to provide documentation for every single job search activity I reported. I was lucky because I kept detailed records with dates, company names, position titles, contact info, and application confirmation emails. If you can't provide adequate proof during an audit, they can determine you didn't meet job search requirements and demand repayment of all benefits received during those weeks.
0 coins
Lily Young
•holy crap 6 YEARS??? thats insane
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
My brother-in-law went thru this last yr. Couldnt prove some of his job searches from 2021 and they made him pay back like $4k. He tried appealing but no luck. Said he should have kept better records.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
•$4k?! That's terrifying. Did he have to pay it all at once or did they at least work out a payment plan?
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
I'm so confused about this. I thought we just had to enter the info in the weekly claim portal? Nobody told me I needed to save actual PROOF of every application for years afterward! What exactly counts as acceptable proof? I don't have confirmation emails for half the places I applied to, especially the ones where I walked in and filled out paper applications.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
•For online applications, you need confirmation emails or screenshots showing your name, the employer, position, and date. For in-person applications, you should have contact information of the person you spoke with, their title, and specific details about the position. Phone calls need similar documentation. This is all clearly stated in the ESD handbook that claimants agree to when filing. Most people just don't read it carefully or forget the retention requirements once they're back to work.
0 coins
Justin Chang
I went through an audit in January for a claim from 2022. It was a nightmare trying to track down proof of all my job search activities. I had to contact companies asking for application confirmations, search through old emails, and piece together what I could. In the end, I was able to prove about 80% of my activities, which was enough to avoid repayment. My advice is to start organizing whatever documentation you might still have access to - check your email archives, job site accounts, etc. Being proactive helped my case.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
•That's good to know! I might still have some emails buried in my accounts. How did the audit process work? Did they just randomly select you or was there something that triggered it?
0 coins
Justin Chang
•I think mine was random, but I've heard they also target claims with higher amounts or ones where people found work quickly after claiming. The process started with a letter requesting documentation for specific weeks. I had 10 days to respond with evidence for each job search activity I'd reported. They then reviewed everything and made a determination. The whole process took about 8 weeks and was incredibly stressful.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
If you're worried about getting through to ESD to ask questions about this, I recently used a service called Claimyr that really helped. I was on hold with ESD for hours trying to ask about a similar situation, but Claimyr got me connected to an actual person in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3. Their website is claimyr.com if you want to check it out. It saved me a ton of time and stress when dealing with my ESD issues.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
•Thanks for the tip. I might need that if I get an audit notice. Did ESD tell you anything helpful about documentation requirements?
0 coins
Grace Thomas
•Yes, the agent I spoke with confirmed they can audit up to 6 years back and said they're doing more audits than usual right now. She recommended keeping all job search records for at least 6 years after your claim ends. She also mentioned they're more lenient if you can show good faith effort to provide documentation, even if it's not perfect. The key is responding quickly to any audit notice and providing whatever evidence you can gather.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
this is all government BS trying to claw back money from regular people while corporations get away with billions in fraud. my neighbor got audited and they said his job searches weren't "quality" enough whatever TF that means. system is rigged!!!!
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
•Yea my bro-in-law said same thing. ESD told him some of his applications didnt count as "active job searching" because he applied to similar positions at multiple companies. Like how does that even make sense????
0 coins
Lily Young
wait so do we need to keep the actual job posting too? or just proof we applied? i deleted all that stuff ages ago
0 coins
Marcus Williams
•You don't need the full job posting, but you need enough information to prove the job was real and that you actually applied. At minimum: company name, position title, date of application, and some form of confirmation (email receipt, screenshot of confirmation page, contact info of person you spoke with). For in-person networking, you need date, contact info, and notes about what was discussed regarding employment.
0 coins
Justin Chang
For anyone dealing with this now, I recommend creating a spreadsheet with all the information you can remember about your job searches. List the company, position, date, application method, and any contact info you have. Then start gathering whatever documentation still exists. During my audit, having this organized information made a big difference, even for the few cases where I couldn't find the original confirmation. Also, don't panic if you get an audit notice - respond promptly and work with them. They're mainly looking for people who completely fabricated job searches, not honest mistakes in record-keeping.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
•This is really helpful, thanks. I'll start creating that spreadsheet this weekend.
0 coins