ESD identity verification fraud determination appeal while waiting for verification to finish
So here's my situation and I'm honestly at a loss. I work in construction and got laid off back in January when the project wrapped up earlier than expected. Filed my UI claim right away, went through the whole ID.me verification process, uploaded my documents, did the video call — the whole thing. Then about two weeks later I get this letter saying my account has been flagged for a fraud determination. Not suspected fraud, an actual fraud determination. While I'm still waiting for the verification to fully process. I don't understand how they can make a fraud determination while identity verification is still pending. Isn't the whole point of verification to establish that you're a real person who is who you say you are? How can they decide fraud before that's even done? My weekly claims are just sitting there unpaid and I'm burning through my savings. I called the number on the letter and couldn't get through after trying for two days straight. My claim on the ESD portal just shows a hold with no explanation beyond the letter I already have. Has anyone dealt with this overlap — getting a fraud determination at the same time verification is still in progress? Do I appeal the fraud determination now, or wait for verification to finish first, and what happens to my weekly claims in the meantime? Really need guidance here because the bills are not waiting around.
78 comments

Samantha Howard
Claimyr got me through to an actual ESD agent when I was in almost this exact tangle. I had a hold on my account and kept hitting dead ends calling on my own. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ — once I got an agent on the line they were able to flag my verification and fraud hold as linked issues and escalate both at once. Worth knowing that option exists before you spend another week redialing.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
The video — does it show the actual call happening or just the sign-up? Trying to figure out if this is legit before I put my info anywhere.
0 coins
Samantha Howard
My browser history from that day — I watched the demo first, it shows the actual callback process. The agent call I got lasted about 22 minutes and they resolved the hold flag same day.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
Gonna try this. I've been calling since Tuesday and not once got past the automated menu.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
Wait, they sent you a fraud determination letter before ID.me finished? That's the part that's messed up here. Mine came after verification completed and it was still a nightmare — but at least the sequence made sense. ESD shouldn't be closing the loop on fraud while the verification loop is still open.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorExactly what's throwing me off. The letter is dated four days before my ID.me verification status changed to 'completed' in my account. So either they're running these processes in parallel without connecting them, or something got crossed internally.
0 coins
Avery Saint
That date discrepancy could actually help your appeal. Keep that letter and screenshot the ID.me completion date — that's a paper trail showing the determination came before verification closed.
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
My own claim folder right now — that's solid advice. Timestamps on everything. ESD's internal systems don't always talk to each other which is how these overlaps happen.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Ran into something similar last spring. Got hit with what I thought was just a verification hold but turned out to be two separate flags — one from ID.me and one from ESD's internal fraud filter. I didn't know they were different things and spent three weeks trying to fix only one of them. What you need to know: a fraud determination and an identity verification hold are handled by completely separate teams at ESD. Fixing your verification won't automatically lift the fraud determination, and vice versa. You have to pursue both tracks. The appeal for the fraud determination goes through ESD's Office of Administrative Hearings process — you have 30 days from the determination letter date to file. Do not wait for verification to finish before filing that appeal because the clock doesn't pause for verification.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
Author30 days from the letter date — okay that changes things. My letter is dated February 14th so I need to move on this. Is the appeal filed through the ESD portal or by mail?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
My experience with the portal last year — the appeal option should appear under your claim's correspondence section if ESD has properly logged the determination. If it's not there, you can also fax or mail directly to OAH. I'd try the portal first and if it's not visible call ESD directly to get them to log it, which is part of why having a live agent is so important here.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
This is real. I lost nine days on my own appeal because I assumed verification finishing would trigger the fraud review to reopen. Nope. Completely separate.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
does anyone know if the weekly claims you file while this is all pending just get held or do they disappear? like if he wins the appeal does he get all the back pay?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Weekly claims filed during a hold period don't disappear — they queue up and if the hold is lifted through appeal or ESD correction, the payments release retroactively. Keep filing every week no matter what. Missing a week breaks your payment record and can complicate the back pay calculation.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
okay good because I'm in a similar spot and was about to stop filing thinking it was pointless
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
Same question crossed my mind when my account got frozen. Keep filing. I found out about Claimyr during my own hold — claimyr.com — and the agent I got through confirmed that every week I'd filed was queued and eligible once the hold cleared. That confirmation alone was worth the call.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Can I jump in with something that confused me when I was dealing with this last fall? I kept seeing 'fraud determination' and thought it meant ESD had evidence I actually committed fraud. That's not what it means in most cases. What actually happened to me — I had a name that partially matched a flagged identity in their system and the automated filter tripped. The determination is generated automatically, not by a human reviewing your actual case. That matters for your appeal because you're not fighting an accusation built on evidence, you're correcting a system mismatch. My appeal letter focused on showing I am who I am — matching documents, consistent employment history, the ID.me completion — not on defending against specific accusations. Appeal was resolved in about 19 days.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorMine seems similar — nothing in the letter points to anything I actually did wrong, no specific transactions flagged, nothing. Just the determination and a reference number.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
My determination letter when I went through it — look for a code or reason category near the top or bottom. Mine said something like 'identity consistency flag' which told me exactly what category of issue it was and I could address that directly in my appeal statement.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
19 days is actually fast. Mine took 34 and I thought I was doing something wrong.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
The automated flag thing is wild to me. So basically a computer decided fraud before a human even looked at it?
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Something no one's said yet — have you logged into your ID.me account separately from the ESD portal and confirmed what ID.me itself shows? Because sometimes ESD's portal shows verification as pending even after ID.me's own dashboard shows complete. Those two systems sync on a delay. If ID.me shows complete, you can reference that in your fraud appeal as evidence the verification resolved — you don't have to wait for ESD's portal to catch up.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorJust checked — ID.me shows 'Identity Verified' with a date of February 10th. ESD portal still shows pending as of this morning. So there's actually a four-day gap where ID.me had me verified before ESD caught up, and the fraud letter is dated February 14th. This is getting clearer.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
That ID.me verified date is gold for your appeal. It shows the verification was complete before the fraud determination was issued, ESD's portal just hadn't updated yet. Screenshot that ID.me page right now.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
I had no idea ID.me had its own dashboard you could log into separately. I thought it only lived inside the ESD portal.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
JUST want to say that the ESD phone situation is completely broken right now. I've tried calling at 8am, tried at noon, tried random times in the afternoon and I cannot get a human. The automated system just loops or disconnects. This is not okay when people's money is frozen over computer errors.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
8am is what everyone says to try and it still doesn't work half the time. The volume is just too high.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Two hours Tuesday morning — that's how long I sat on hold before the call dropped. I've started documenting every attempt with timestamps because at this point I want a record.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
The calling situation has been bad for months. Even when you get through the first queue there's a second wait before an actual agent.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
For anyone filing the actual OAH appeal — a few things that made mine go faster. Write your appeal statement in plain chronological order: when you filed, when verification started, when the fraud letter arrived, what date verification completed. Don't use legal language, just facts in order. Attach everything that shows your timeline: the determination letter, your ID.me completion screenshot, your pay stubs or employment records from the job you were laid off from. The appeals examiner is looking for a coherent story that contradicts the fraud flag. Give them one.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorShould I address the fact that verification was still technically pending on ESD's end when the determination was made, or just let the dates speak for themselves?
0 coins
Keith Davidson
My own appeal statement from last year — I called that out explicitly in one sentence. Something like 'the determination was issued on X date while ESD's system had not yet reflected the completed verification, as shown by the attached ID.me screenshot dated Y.' Short and factual, not accusatory. It worked.
0 coins
Lily Young
Does the appeal statement have a length limit? I wrote like four pages for mine and I'm not sure if that hurt or helped.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Mine was two pages and got resolved. I've heard longer ones don't get rejected but the examiner has to read a lot of these so clear and short is better than thorough and overwhelming.
0 coins
Avery Saint
I want to flag something that could save you headaches. When you file the OAH appeal, also submit a separate written request directly to ESD asking them to review and correct the verification sync issue. These are two different asks going to two different places — the appeal goes to OAH, the correction request goes to ESD directly. If ESD corrects the verification record on their end before OAH hears your appeal, it can actually simplify or even resolve the appeal. My situation got cleared before my hearing date because ESD fixed their internal record first.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorSo file both simultaneously? Not wait to see if one resolves it first?
0 coins
Avery Saint
My timeline from that period — I filed both on the same day. If ESD corrects it fast, great, you can let OAH know and they may withdraw the determination. If ESD doesn't, you still have the appeal moving forward. Waiting on one before doing the other just costs you time.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Is the separate ESD correction request something you do through the portal message system or does it need to be in writing by mail?
0 coins
Avery Saint
Both work but I'd do both — send the portal message and also mail a brief letter so you have documented proof of the request. ESD's portal message system doesn't always generate a confirmation you can reference later.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Had a really frustrating stretch with ESD last winter that sounds like yours. What actually broke the logjam for me was getting a live agent through Claimyr — claimyr.com — who was able to pull up both my verification flag and the fraud determination on one screen and note them as related. She put an internal note linking the two cases which sped up the review. I don't think I would have known to ask for that without talking to someone directly.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
An internal note linking the cases — is that something any agent can do or does it have to be a supervisor?
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
My call notes from that day — the agent did it without escalating. She said it was a standard notation for 'related claim issues.' Whether all agents know to do this I can't say but it's worth asking for explicitly.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
So if I call I should ask them to link the verification and fraud cases? Good to know exactly what to request.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
How long does the OAH appeal process actually take start to finish? I see people say 19 days and 34 days but is that the hearing date or the final decision?
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Those are days to resolution, meaning the decision. The hearing itself gets scheduled somewhere in the middle. For straightforward cases like identity mismatches the whole thing can resolve without a formal hearing if ESD concedes before it gets that far. For contested cases with an actual hearing it can be 45 to 60 days total.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
That feels like forever when your claims are frozen.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
It is a long time. Which is why the parallel track of also asking ESD directly to fix the verification record matters — sometimes that resolves it faster than waiting for OAH to work through its queue.
0 coins
Lily Young
Genuine question — if ESD issued the fraud determination while verification was pending, doesn't that mean the determination itself is procedurally flawed? Like couldn't you argue they made the determination without having the information they needed?
0 coins
Sophia Carson
That's exactly the angle I'd use. When I looked at my situation that way — the determination was made without complete information — the appeal became less about defending myself and more about pointing out a process gap. That framing got less defensive and more factual.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Procedural argument works as a supplement but I wouldn't hang the whole appeal on it. Lead with the factual evidence that you are who you say you are, then add that the determination came before verification completed as a secondary point showing the process was rushed.
0 coins
Lily Young
Makes sense to layer both rather than relying on just the procedural angle alone.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
okay wait I'm confused about something. the fraud determination letter — does everyone get this or is it just for certain claim types? I filed regular UI after a layoff and got a letter that looks like this but I thought it was just part of the normal verification process
0 coins
Ryan Vasquez
My first ESD letter of this kind — I thought the same thing initially. They're separate. Normal verification is a standard part of filing. A fraud determination is a specific adverse action that requires a separate response. If your letter mentions appeal rights and has a determination date, it's the second type. Check whether it says 'fraud determination' explicitly.
0 coins
Sarah Ali
just checked mine and yeah it says 'fraud determination' right at the top. so this is not normal. oh no.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorIf yours also has a letter date, start counting from that date toward your 30-day appeal window right now. Don't wait to fully understand it before you at least note that deadline.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
this thread just made me realize I need to go reread every letter ESD has sent me
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Something that happened to me that might be relevant — when I finally got an agent on the phone and they looked at my account, they found a second flag I had no idea about that was connected to the first. The determination letter only mentioned one issue but there were actually two separate holds. If you get through to an agent ask them to read you everything active on the account, not just what the letter mentions.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorHad not thought about asking for a complete account audit rather than just asking about the letter. That's a smart move.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
My call transcript from that week — I literally said 'is there anything else active on my account I should know about' and that's how the second hold came up. The agent wouldn't have mentioned it otherwise.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
That's kind of alarming that there could be hidden holds you don't even know about.
0 coins
Avery Saint
Not hidden intentionally, just the letters and the system don't always surface everything that's flagged. Always worth asking for the full picture when you have an agent.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Have you tried the ESD secure message system while you're waiting to get through by phone? I know it's slow but I've gotten substantive responses in 3 to 5 business days and sometimes the written response is actually more useful because it's documented.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorSent a message through the portal on day one but nothing back yet. It's been six days. At this point I'm going to pursue the phone and the appeal simultaneously and not wait for the message response.
0 coins
Megan D'Acosta
Six days is on the longer end. Secure messages about fraud or holds seem to get slower responses than general questions in my experience.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
I've had secure messages go unanswered for over two weeks on complex issues. For anything urgent don't rely on that as your only channel.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Wait can I ask something basic — when you file the appeal do you stop filing weekly claims or keep going? I always get confused about what to do with the weekly claims when something complicated is happening with the account.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
Keep filing every single week without exception. The weekly claim filing is completely separate from the appeal process. Stopping would create gaps in your payment record that could reduce your back pay even if the appeal goes your way.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
My ESD portal page right now — it's still letting me file even with the hold showing. So I'm going to keep doing it then.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Yes always keep filing. The hold freezes payment, it doesn't freeze the filing window. Missed weeks are almost impossible to retroactively add.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
For what it's worth I went through the full OAH process last year for a different reason and the examiner was actually reasonable to deal with. I'd built it up in my head as this formal scary thing but it was a phone hearing that lasted maybe 25 minutes. Having my documents organized and my timeline clear made it straightforward.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorGood to hear it's not as intimidating as it sounds on paper. I've been dreading the hearing part specifically.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
My hearing notes from last year — the examiner asked me to walk through the timeline in my own words first before referring to any documents. Having practiced saying it out loud a couple times beforehand helped a lot.
0 coins
Lily Young
Did you have a lawyer or representative for yours?
0 coins
Marcus Williams
No, I represented myself. For identity and verification-related issues that's usually fine. Might be different for more complex cases.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
One more practical thing — if you do get through to ESD by phone and they say they'll escalate your case or add a note, get a reference number for the call and the name of the agent if they'll give it. ESD doesn't always document calls the way you'd expect and having that reference number has saved me twice when follow-up calls showed no record of a previous conversation.
0 coins
Benjamin Kim
AuthorReference number and agent name — writing that down right now as a checklist item. Thank you.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
My own call log going back eight months — I have dates, times, reference numbers, and brief notes on what was said. Sounds extreme but when ESD has no record of a call it's the only thing that proves it happened.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
This is unfortunately very necessary advice. I had an agent tell me my hold was being reviewed and when I called back a week later there was zero record of that conversation.
0 coins