


Ask the community...
Final piece of advice based on helping several clients with similar appeals: Practice explaining your situation concisely. The judges hear dozens of cases and appreciate when claimants can clearly articulate: 1) Why you had good cause to quit the first job (offer letter for better position), 2) That you were performing adequately at the new job, and 3) That you were terminated for reasons other than misconduct. Stick to facts rather than emotions, and when asked yes/no questions, answer directly then elaborate only if needed. Good luck with your appeal!
I'm in a very similar situation right now! Just got denied last week for the same "insufficient good cause" reason even though I quit my retail job because I got hired at a healthcare facility with better pay and benefits. Then they let me go after 3 weeks saying I wasn't "adapting quickly enough" to their computer system. It's so frustrating because we did everything right - we found better jobs, quit responsibly, and then got fired through no fault of our own! I'm filing my appeal this week too. Reading through all these responses is giving me hope that we can win these cases. The advice about continuing to file weekly claims is huge - I almost made that mistake. Good luck with your hearing!
For anyone else reading this thread, always check your pay stub first. It's the easiest way to determine which state you should file in.
I went through this exact situation a few years back - lived in Washington but worked in Oregon. The key thing to remember is that you always file where your employer paid unemployment taxes, which is typically where you worked. Since your employer was in Idaho, that's where their unemployment taxes were paid for your position. The Idaho Department of Labor website has a really clear section on this under their FAQ. Don't let the conflicting info online confuse you - your pay stub will show which state's unemployment taxes were deducted, and that's your answer right there!
This has been a really helpful thread. I'm bookmarking it in case I need to reference it later or share it with someone else who has the same question.
I just went through something similar! I live in Nevada but work remotely for a Washington-based company. When I got laid off, I was initially confused about which state to file with, but it's definitely based on where your employer is located and pays taxes. Since your employer is withholding Washington taxes and paying into Washington's unemployment system, that's exactly where your benefits should come from. The fact that Washington ESD approved your claim confirms you're on the right track. Your Oregon residency just means you'll need to report those unemployment benefits on your Oregon state tax return when tax season comes around, but it doesn't affect the actual unemployment claim process at all.
wait im confused... did the governors office actually confirm they sent your info to ESD? Sometimes they take your info but theres a delay before they actually send the request.
Just checking back - any updates on your situation? Did you try contacting the governor's office again or have any luck getting through to ESD?
That's such great news! I'm so glad you finally got through and found out what was happening. It's ridiculous that your case just sat there because of poor internal processes, but at least now you know it wasn't lost completely. Definitely keep us posted on whether you actually see movement in the next few days. This gives me hope for my own situation - I've been stuck for 3 weeks and thinking about trying Claimyr too. Thanks for the update!
That's such great news! I'm so glad the Claimyr service worked for you and that you finally got some answers. It's crazy that your case was just sitting there because of the adjudicator situation - no wonder nothing was happening for 6+ weeks. Hopefully they actually follow through on the 3-5 business day timeline. Keep us posted on what happens! This gives me hope that there are still ways to get through the system when it breaks down like this.
Amelia Martinez
One more option - if you're tech savvy, you can try using an auto-dialer app on your phone to keep calling repeatedly. Some people swear by this method but personally I'd rather just use something like Claimyr that does all the work for me.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
•Auto-dialers work but you still have to babysit your phone all day. At least with a service like that you can go about your business and they call you back when they get through.
0 coins
Amelia Martinez
•Exactly - time is money and I'd rather pay someone else to deal with the hassle while I focus on job searching or other important stuff.
0 coins
Carmen Reyes
Has anyone tried the early morning strategy on different days of the week? I'm wondering if certain days are consistently better than others for getting through at 8 AM. I've been trying randomly but maybe there's a pattern to when they're less swamped. Also curious if anyone knows what happens if you get disconnected while on hold - do you have to start completely over or is there any way to get back in the queue?
0 coins