dont forget to check if you qualify for pandemic benefits those are still happening i think

Hey just checking in - did u have any luck with WorkSource or finding some temp work? The construction industry usually picks up in spring so maybe things will get better soon???

so any updates??? did ur status change yet or r u still stuck?

update us when u finally get through!! im about to reapply again soon and im dreading the whole process ugh

One thing to be aware of: While you're not responsible for your employer's tax obligations, if it turns out they misreported your wages (showing you earned less than you actually did), ESD might issue an overpayment if they later correct those wage records and it affects your benefit calculation. If you're concerned, I'd recommend keeping good records of all your paystubs, W-2s, and any communication about your layoff. Also, double-check that the wage amount shown on your ESD monetary determination letter matches what you actually earned.

hey just wondering did u get paid under the table at all?? cuz thats a whole different issue than just the tax withholding thing

I'm dealing with this RIGHT NOW! Had taxes taken out all last year, thought everything was fine. Then in February 2025 got a notice saying I had an overpayment from weeks in August 2024 because my employer contested my claim saying I quit instead of being laid off. Now I owe $2,750 back even though I spent that money months ago on rent and food. Is anyone here good at writing appeals? I have 30 days to respond and I'm panicking!!!

To wrap up the original question: Tax withholding only addresses the tax liability on legitimate benefits. It won't protect you from overpayment determinations. For peace of mind, I recommend: 1. Keep detailed records of all weekly claims and job search activities for at least 3 years 2. Save copies of any ESD correspondence (take screenshots of online notices) 3. Set aside a small emergency fund if possible to cover potential overpayments 4. Make sure your wife responds immediately to any ESD requests or questionnaires Most people who diligently follow the rules never experience overpayment issues, but having documentation ready just in case is always smart.

Sorry about your situation pal but I'm confused about something. You said you were "overqualified" and "proved your worth" but then you also said you resigned to avoid a "toxic environment with drug users in new construction"? That part doesn't make sense with the pay reduction story. Were you in construction? Was that why the pay was lower? The commissioner might have been confused by mixed explanations too. Just saying you might want to keep your story straighter for the judicial review.

One more critical thing - for judicial review, you need to file in the county where you lived at the time of application OR in Thurston County. The filing fee is around $240, but you can request a fee waiver if you're low income (use the GR 34 form). Make sure to: 1. Name the correct parties (Commissioner and ESD must be named) 2. Properly serve all parties (you need to serve the Commissioner, ESD, and the Attorney General's office) 3. Include the complete agency record The standard of review is super important - the court will only overturn if: - Decision is outside the agency's authority - Decision is based on an error of law - Decision is not supported by substantial evidence - Decision is arbitrary and capricious Focus on the error of law aspect - specifically that the Commissioner failed to properly apply WAC 192-150-120 regarding substantial reduction in pay. With a 42.8% reduction, you're well above the 25% threshold that typically constitutes good cause.