Back to Virginia Unemployment

Emma Davis

Virginia VEC waiver of overpayment statement which income and expenses to list

So I'm sitting here with this Virginia VEC overpayment waiver form in front of me and I genuinely have no idea what I'm supposed to put down. Got hit with a notice saying I owe back $4,200 from claims filed earlier this year - apparently there was some earnings reporting issue that VEC flagged during a review. I requested the waiver because honestly I cannot pay that back, I've been living on a really tight budget since my hours got cut at my warehouse job before I eventually got fully laid off. The financial statement section is what's killing me. It asks for income AND expenses but I don't know what level of detail they actually want. Like do I list every single bill I pay? Do I include my car payment, groceries, utilities, phone? What about irregular stuff like a medical bill I'm slowly paying off? And for income - do I put my new part-time job wages, or also my partner's income if we share expenses? I had a small tax refund this year too, does that count? I've been searching everywhere and can't find a clear breakdown of what VEC actually wants on that statement. If I leave something out, will they deny the waiver automatically? If I include too much income, will that hurt my chances? I really need this waiver to go through because there's no way I can repay $4,200 right now. Has anyone actually been through this process and knows what to put on that financial statement?

Week 3 of waiting on my own waiver decision so I've been deep in this exact research - let me share what I figured out. For the income section, you want to list everything that comes into your household regularly. That means your part-time wages, yes. If your partner contributes to shared household expenses, their income typically goes on there too because VEC is looking at your household's ability to repay, not just your individual earnings. The small tax refund is a one-time thing so I'd list it in a note but it's not regular income - check if the form has a spot for 'other income' vs a recurring income line. For expenses, go through every single monthly obligation: rent or mortgage, car payment, car insurance, utilities (electric, gas, water), phone, internet, groceries (use a realistic monthly average), any medical bills you're paying down, prescriptions, childcare if applicable. The more complete your picture, the better VEC can see that your monthly outgo genuinely eats up what comes in. The key thing people miss is they low-ball their grocery and utility estimates because they feel weird writing down realistic numbers. Write down what you actually spend. If your electric bill spikes in summer, average it out. VEC is trying to determine if repayment would cause you genuine financial hardship - give them the real picture.

0 coins

The partner income part is what I wasn't sure about - we're not married, just living together. Does that change anything? I'd hate to include his income if it's not required and tank my chances.

0 coins

Unmarried cohabitant is a gray area honestly. Some people include it, some don't. If you share household bills and he contributes to rent/utilities, there's an argument either way. I'd lean toward listing it but then also showing all shared expenses clearly so the picture is accurate either way.

0 coins

My cousin went through this and she said the VEC reviewer actually called her to clarify income sources, so they do look at this stuff carefully. Better to be thorough upfront.

0 coins

Two months ago I was stuck trying to reach anyone at VEC to ask exactly this question before I submitted mine - couldn't get through on the phones at all, kept getting the busy signal or getting disconnected after 45 minutes on hold. Somebody in a different thread mentioned Claimyr and I was skeptical but I tried it. They basically get you connected to an actual VEC agent without you sitting on hold forever. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. I got through to someone at VEC who walked me through exactly what their financial statement reviewers look for - way more useful than trying to guess from the form itself. For a $4,200 waiver decision it's worth making sure you fill the form out right.

0 coins

Hadn't heard of Claimyr before - honestly getting to actually speak with a VEC agent about this before I submit would be huge. I'll check out that video.

0 coins

45 minutes and then disconnected is unfortunately the standard VEC experience lol. I've had that happen three times in one day.

0 coins

Does Claimyr work for the waiver-specific questions or just general unemployment stuff? I have a similar overpayment situation and want to know if it's worth trying.

0 coins

The agent I reached handled overpayment questions - it's the same general VEC line, you just actually get a person to talk to instead of hold music.

0 coins

Step one for me when I did my waiver was pulling three months of bank statements first, then filling out the form from those rather than trying to remember everything. That way I had receipts for every number I put down. The form is basically asking VEC to map out whether, after your real monthly obligations are met, there's money left over to repay them. So every legitimate expense belongs on there. Groceries are an expense. Gas for your car is an expense. That medical bill payment you make monthly is absolutely an expense - those matter a lot because medical debt is exactly the kind of hardship VEC considers. For income, wages from current employment, any other regular money coming in. If your partner's name isn't on the VEC claim and you're documenting that the household expenses require both incomes just to cover basics, include both sides of that equation. Reviewers aren't trying to catch you in something, they're doing a genuine hardship assessment - but you have to give them enough to work with.

0 coins

Bank statements first - that's genuinely smart, I hadn't thought to approach it that way. It would also just make the numbers more accurate.

0 coins

Three months is a good window. I'd actually do six months if you have irregular expenses like car repairs or medical stuff that don't show up every month - shows the realistic average.

0 coins

Pulling statements is exactly right. When I was dealing with my own overpayment mess I actually used Claimyr to get a VEC agent on the line while I had all my documents in front of me - claimyr.com if anyone needs it. Being able to ask 'does this specific expense count' in real time was way more efficient than guessing.

0 coins

Just got my waiver APPROVED last week so jumping in here with what worked for me. I was dealing with a $3,800 overpayment and the financial statement I submitted was extremely detailed. I mean line-item detailed. I didn't just write 'utilities' - I broke it out as electric $94, gas $67, water $38. I didn't write 'food' - I wrote groceries $340 (average of last 3 months per bank statements). For income I listed my part-time wages and noted that my partner contributes $600/month toward shared rent - I listed that as 'household contribution from co-resident' and then showed the full rent expense. That way the picture was accurate without it looking like I had a hidden income stream. Medical expenses were huge for my case. I had a physical therapy copay I was paying monthly and an outstanding dental bill I was making payments on. Both went on the form. The reviewer's approval letter actually specifically mentioned 'medical obligations' as a factor. Bottom line: err on the side of more detail not less. If you're unsure whether something counts as an expense, include it and label it clearly.

0 coins

Approval last week - that's exactly what I needed to hear. Breaking utilities out line by line instead of lumping them is a great tip, makes it feel more real and documented.

0 coins

The 'household contribution' framing for partner income is clever - accurately represents the situation without implying a combined household income that might look higher than your actual obligation-to-income ratio.

0 coins

Congrats on the approval! Did they ask for any supporting documents with the financial statement or just the form itself?

0 coins

They didn't ask upfront but I attached copies of my lease, one utility bill, and my pay stub anyway. I figured supporting it voluntarily was better than them requesting it and causing a delay.

0 coins

Honestly the income section tripped me up too when I did mine. Here's the thing that cleared it up for me: think about it from the VEC reviewer's perspective - they're asking 'can this person realistically pay us back without not being able to eat or keep the lights on.' So income is everything that comes in, expenses are everything that must go out. For irregular income like a tax refund - I listed mine in a 'notes' section and explained it was non-recurring. For expenses, I included things people forget: renters insurance, streaming services I need for my kids' schoolwork, the monthly minimum on a credit card I ran up during my unemployment period. All of it painted the picture of someone who is genuinely stretched. One thing I wish someone had told me: don't underestimate transportation costs. If you need your car to get to work, that car payment, insurance, gas, and even estimated maintenance is a legitimate living expense.

0 coins

Transportation costs - I completely would have undersold that. I drive 40 minutes each way to my job, the gas alone is significant.

0 coins

Credit card minimums are interesting - I wouldn't have thought to include those. Makes sense though, they're a real monthly obligation.

0 coins

Minimum payments on debt absolutely count. It's money that legally has to leave your account each month. That's exactly what VEC is measuring.

0 coins

Filing the waiver in the first place was the right move - too many people just panic and try to set up a repayment plan without even asking for the waiver first. To answer your specific question about income vs expenses at a more detailed level: VEC's financial statement is modeled on a pretty standard hardship assessment. Income = all money your household receives, gross not net usually though some forms ask for net take-home. Expenses = all fixed and recurring financial obligations. The gap between those two numbers is what VEC uses to assess repayment ability. Fixed expenses: rent/mortgage, car payment, insurance premiums, loan minimums, childcare, medical payment plans. Variable but regular: groceries, gas, utilities, prescriptions. Irregular: medical bills, car repairs - estimate a monthly average or list the total and note it's being paid down. Your partner's income situation - if you're not married, VEC guidance on this varies. Some reviewers consider household income, some focus only on the claimant. If you're unsure, calling VEC to clarify before you submit is worth doing.

0 coins

Gross vs net is something I hadn't even thought about - my part-time take-home is noticeably different from my gross. I'll look at the form language carefully on that.

0 coins

Most VEC financial statements I've seen ask for net take-home specifically since that's what actually hits your account. But yes check the form - the wording varies.

0 coins

The 'gap' framing is really useful. It's basically a cash flow statement - does money in exceed money out, and by how much.

0 coins

Eight weeks into my own overpayment situation so I've had time to research this thoroughly. I want to add something about the expense documentation that hasn't come up yet: if you have any out-of-pocket medical expenses that aren't regular payments - like you had an ER visit or needed a specialist - include those too with documentation. VEC considers medical hardship pretty seriously. Also, if you have dependents (kids, elderly parent you help support), those living costs should be reflected in your expense totals. Food, clothing, school supplies if you're listing those things - it all factors in. For the income side, I've seen some people ask about unemployment benefits themselves - if you're currently receiving UI benefits, yes those are income and go on the form. VEC already knows about those obviously, but including them shows you're being transparent and complete. Claimyr was actually how I finally got to ask a VEC agent about my specific situation before I submitted. Got connected through claimyr.com - saved me from submitting something incomplete. The agent confirmed for me that dependent-related costs are absolutely fair to include.

0 coins

No kids but I do help my mom with some expenses occasionally - hadn't considered whether that counts. Probably worth asking a VEC agent directly about that.

0 coins

Eight weeks is a long time to be in overpayment limbo - are you still waiting on a waiver decision or is yours resolved now?

0 coins

Still waiting on mine - submitted 5 weeks ago. The VEC agent I spoke with said waiver decisions can take 6-10 weeks depending on caseload.

0 coins

6 to 10 weeks is brutal when you're stressed about whether you're going to owe thousands of dollars. I hope yours comes through.

0 coins

Got my denial letter two months ago and appealed it - currently waiting on the appeal hearing. Sharing this because I think knowing what NOT to do is as useful as knowing what to do. What hurt my waiver was that my financial statement was vague. I wrote things like 'transportation: $200' without breaking it down, 'food: $300' without showing I'd calculated from actual spending. When VEC denied it, the reason letter said the statement didn't provide sufficient documentation of claimed expenses. So in hindsight: specific numbers, documented where possible, explained where not. If you're estimating groceries, say 'estimated based on average monthly spending.' If you have a bill statement, attach it. I also didn't include my partner's income at all and didn't explain why - I just left that area blank. The reviewer flagged that as incomplete. If you're leaving something out intentionally, write a brief note explaining why that field doesn't apply to your situation.

0 coins

Denial because of vagueness is exactly what I'm afraid of. The 'explain when you omit something' tip is really important - I would have just left blanks without thinking about how that looks.

0 coins

Appealing a denial is definitely doable but it adds so much time and stress. Getting the initial submission right is worth every extra hour of prep.

0 coins

Exactly - I wish I had spent another day on the original form instead of rushing it. The appeal process is its own whole ordeal.

0 coins

Sorry you're dealing with the appeal process - that's stressful. For what it's worth, I actually found out about Claimyr from someone who'd been denied a waiver and used it to get VEC guidance before their appeal hearing. The site is claimyr.com - there's a walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k showing how it works for getting through to a live VEC agent.

0 coins

Currently at the stage where I'm deciding whether to even bother requesting a waiver or just set up payments - reading this thread is convincing me to go the waiver route first. One thing I'm unclear on: if VEC denies the waiver, can you still set up a repayment plan? Or does requesting the waiver and getting denied somehow make the repayment situation worse?

0 coins

Requesting a waiver and being denied doesn't hurt your repayment options - you can still set up a payment plan after a denial. VEC processes those separately. The waiver is basically 'can you forgive this debt' and the payment plan is 'how will you pay it back' - they're not mutually exclusive in terms of what you can try.

0 coins

That's really reassuring - I was worried that asking for a waiver and being denied would somehow flag my account or make them less willing to work with me on payments.

0 coins

Always try the waiver first. The worst case is they say no and you're back to where you started. The best case is they forgive thousands of dollars of debt.

0 coins

About 6 weeks post-submission on my waiver and still waiting - anxiety is real. But this thread is making me feel better about the detail level I included. One thing I want to flag for OP: make sure you keep filing your weekly claims during this whole process if you're still eligible. The overpayment situation and your ongoing UI claim are separate tracks and you don't want to mess up your current benefits while sorting out the overpayment.

0 coins

Good catch - I actually stopped my claims thinking the overpayment froze everything. Need to look into whether I should restart.

0 coins

Definitely look into it quickly. If you stopped claiming when you were still eligible you might have weeks you can backdate, but that has its own process. VEC keeps those things separate in their system.

0 coins

This is a really important point - a lot of people think an overpayment notice means their whole account is frozen. It doesn't, the two things run independently.

0 coins

Just over 4 weeks since I mailed my waiver form in - no update on the portal yet. For the OP's specific question about irregular expenses like a medical bill being paid off monthly - yes, include it. Put the total balance you owe AND the monthly payment amount. Something like 'Medical debt (doctor's office): $1,100 total, paying $75/month.' That gives the reviewer context for both your monthly cash flow hit and the overall financial burden.

0 coins

Total balance AND monthly payment - that's a format I hadn't considered. Much clearer than just one or the other.

0 coins

Right, the monthly payment shows the cash flow impact, the total balance shows the magnitude of the burden. Both matter to the assessment.

0 coins

Is this for a form you mail in or is there an online portal for the waiver? I haven't been through this yet and don't know how to submit one.

0 coins

Somewhere around week 2 of my waiver wait and I've been compiling everything I learned researching this. Specifically on the income question for unmarried partners: what matters to VEC is whether the household relies on combined income to meet basic expenses. If you can demonstrate that your share of household expenses (your portion of rent, your utilities, your personal costs) is not coverable by your income alone, that's the hardship case - regardless of what your partner earns. Some reviewers will want to see household income, others focus on your individual picture. The safest approach is to show your income, show all household expenses, and note what percentage or dollar amount you personally contribute. That way the reviewer can assess it either way.

0 coins

Framing it as 'my portion of household expenses vs my income' rather than trying to combine everything - that's a cleaner approach I think.

0 coins

This framing also avoids the weird situation where your combined household income looks high but after expenses you're both stretched thin.

0 coins

Exactly. Two people making decent wages but paying rent in a high cost area plus car payments plus medical stuff can genuinely be unable to absorb a $4,000 repayment demand. The form needs to show that reality.

0 coins

First week after submitting my own waiver so the stress is fresh. Something I haven't seen mentioned here yet - if you have any upcoming expenses that are significant and certain (like a medical procedure you've scheduled, or a car repair your mechanic says is necessary), you can include those as anticipated expenses with a brief explanation. VEC reviewers can consider financial circumstances that are imminent, not just current monthly averages.

0 coins

Anticipated expenses is interesting - I have a dentist appointment I've been putting off that's going to be expensive when I finally go. Probably too speculative to include though?

0 coins

If you have an actual estimate from the dentist - like you've had a consultation and they told you the work will cost $800 - that's specific enough to include with a note. Pure speculation wouldn't be appropriate but a real anticipated cost with a basis is different.

0 coins

I didn't know you could include anticipated expenses. Does that mean if my lease is up and I'm expecting my rent to increase I could note the new expected amount?

0 coins

Three days since getting my overpayment notice and I'm still figuring out the process, so this whole thread is helpful. Dumb question maybe: for the expenses section, does auto insurance count? Like I pay it every 6 months as a lump sum, not monthly. How do I represent that?

0 coins

Divide the 6-month premium by 6 and list it as a monthly expense - 'auto insurance $X/month (billed semi-annually).' That's standard practice for any expense that isn't billed monthly. Same goes for annual subscriptions, yearly fees, etc. - just convert to monthly equivalent.

0 coins

That makes total sense, I don't know why I was overthinking it. So basically convert everything to a monthly number.

0 coins

Exactly - the form is building a monthly snapshot of your finances. Everything goes through that monthly lens, even if the actual billing cycle is different.

0 coins

Fifth month dealing with VEC stuff overall so I've seen a few situations in this forum. For OP and anyone else wondering: the financial statement for a waiver is not a tax return - you're not going to get in trouble for including an expense that VEC decides doesn't qualify. The worst case is they don't count that line. So when in doubt, include it. Medical copays, prescription costs, the minimum payment on a credit card you maxed out during unemployment, the monthly fee for a storage unit you can't afford to empty - all of that is fair to list. What you don't want to do is list fictional expenses or inflate numbers. That's the only way this goes badly for you. Honest and complete beats vague every single time.

0 coins

Honest and complete beats' vague -'that s basically the summary of this entire thread and'I m going to write it on a sticky note while I fill this formout.

0 coins

Cannot agree more with this. My denial came from being vague, not from including too much. Include everything real.

0 coins

Exactly - VEC reviewers do this all day. They've seen overstated expense lists and they've seen incomplete ones. An incomplete one makes their job harder and suggests you're not giving them the full picture.

0 coins

Just passed the 7-week mark waiting on my waiver outcome - at this point I'm just trying to stay calm. One thing I wanted to add to this thread: for the income section specifically, don't forget any income that comes in that isn't a paycheck. Side gig payments even if they're small, money from selling things occasionally, any government benefits like SNAP (some forms ask about this), any interest or investment income. VEC wants to understand total resources. Most of these will be small and won't sink your waiver, but omitting them and having a reviewer notice an inconsistency is worse than just listing them.

0 coins

SNAP benefits as income - I would have definitely overlooked that. I do receive those right now.

0 coins

SNAP is in kind assistance so it may actually be treated differently than cash income depending on the form - worth noting it and asking if you get a chance to speak with VEC about it.

0 coins

Side gig income is a good one too - even occasional income like $200 from a one-time freelance thing. If you got it in the relevant period, it probably belongs on there.

0 coins

About 10 days into the waiver request process and trying to get the financial statement right. I noticed this thread hasn't touched on housing much beyond 'list your rent or mortgage.' If you're renting, your monthly rent is an expense obviously. But also renter's insurance if you have it. If you own and have a mortgage, your property taxes (monthly escrow amount) and homeowner's insurance also count. And if you're in a situation like I am where I'm staying with family and paying informal rent or contributing to household costs without a formal lease, you can still document that - just describe it accurately: 'informal housing cost sharing with family: $X/month.

0 coins

I'm renting and have renter's insurance that I always forget counts as a real bill - good reminder to include that.

0 coins

Those small regular bills add up and they're totally legitimate expenses. $15 renter's insurance, $12 phone insurance, whatever you actually pay - it all belongs on there.

0 coins

The informal housing arrangement note is useful for people in non-traditional living situations - shows VEC you're not trying to hide living expenses but that your situation is a bit different than a standard lease.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure