Virginia VEC waiver of overpayment letters two amounts file only one - which one?
Okay so I'm in a pretty confusing situation and hoping someone here has dealt with something similar. I got laid off from my warehouse job back in February and collected unemployment for about four months. Everything seemed fine until last week when I opened my mail and found not one but TWO separate letters from Virginia VEC both talking about overpayments. The weird part is they show different dollar amounts - one says I owe $1,840 and the other says $2,615. Neither letter explains why there are two separate amounts or what the difference between them is. Now here's the thing - both letters mention I can apply for a waiver of overpayment if I meet certain hardship criteria. I really can't afford to pay back either of these amounts right now, I'm still job hunting and my savings are basically gone. My question is do I need to file a separate waiver for each letter, or is there one waiver that covers both amounts? I've been going back and forth on this for days and I can't get a clear answer from anyone. The letters don't reference each other at all which makes me think they might be for two completely different issues but I'm not sure. Has anyone gotten two overpayment letters at once and figured out what to do about them?
68 comments

Ravi Malhotra
Ran into something similar a few months back and the first thing I'd tell you is don't wait on trying to reach Virginia VEC by phone because that phone situation is genuinely brutal. I spent almost two weeks hitting redial before I finally used a service called Claimyr - it's at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. Basically it holds your place in the phone queue and calls you back when an agent picks up. I used it specifically to ask about an overpayment letter I'd gotten and had a live person on the line within the same day. For your situation where you've got two separate letters with two different dollar amounts, you really do need to talk to an agent because filing the wrong waiver or filing only one when you needed two could mess things up badly.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Jumping on this to add - does Claimyr actually work for Virginia VEC specifically? I've seen it mentioned for other states but wasn't sure.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
Yeah it worked for me with Virginia VEC, that's exactly who I used it for. The agent I got was able to pull up both items on my account and explain them separately.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Gonna try this tomorrow morning. I've got a pending adjudication issue on top of an overpayment question and I genuinely cannot get through on my own.
0 coins
Chloe Davis
Two letters with different amounts usually means two separate overpayment determinations, not one split into pieces. Virginia VEC will sometimes issue them separately if the overpayment comes from different benefit weeks or different eligibility issues. Like one might be from a period where they say you weren't able and available for work, and the other might be from weeks where your reported earnings didn't match what your employer reported. They're treated as separate debts in their system.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorReading what you wrote - so each one would need its own waiver application? That's what I was afraid of. Do both waivers go through the same process or are they handled differently depending on what caused the overpayment?
0 coins
Chloe Davis
Same basic process for each - you fill out the waiver request form and demonstrate financial hardship. But the reason for the overpayment can affect whether VEC is likely to grant it. Non-fraud overpayments have a better shot at being waived than ones where VEC thinks you intentionally gave wrong information.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
This matches what I went through. I had two separate overpayment letters from different claim periods and had to submit two waiver packets with the same financial documents attached to each one. It was annoying but that's how they processed it.
0 coins
Diego Chavez
$1,840 and $2,615 are oddly specific numbers. Did either letter mention which weeks the overpayment covers? That would tell you a lot about whether these are truly separate issues or if maybe one is a correction of the other.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorPulling out the letters right now - yes actually, they DO reference different date ranges. One covers March through mid-April and the other is from late April through June. So it sounds like these are genuinely two separate overpayment determinations from different parts of my claim period.
0 coins
Diego Chavez
That confirms it then. Different date ranges almost certainly means different issues triggered each one. You'll want to file a waiver for both. I'd also suggest requesting the determination records for each period so you know exactly what VEC says went wrong - that helps you write a stronger waiver statement.
0 coins
Anastasia Smirnova
Got hit with something like this last year and the date ranges were the key to figuring out what happened. Mine turned out to be one from a part-time job I reported wrong and one from a week I forgot to certify my job search activities properly. Completely different problems, completely different waiver arguments.
0 coins
Sean O'Brien
What I'd add to everything already said here - the deadline on those waiver requests is not forgiving at all. I didn't realize you typically have around 30 days from the date on the letter to request a waiver, and I nearly missed it because I kept waiting to get through to VEC on the phone first. File the waiver paperwork as soon as you can even if you're still confused, because you can always follow up with questions after. Missing the deadline basically closes the door on the waiver option entirely.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorChecking the dates on both letters now - one was mailed 11 days ago and the other 9 days ago. So I still have time but not a ton. Is the waiver form something I can find on the Virginia VEC website or do they mail it to me?
0 coins
Sean O'Brien
There's a waiver request form you can submit through the CSS portal at uidirect.vec.virginia.gov, or you can call and have one mailed to you. Given your time crunch I'd go with the online version. If you use Claimyr to reach an agent (claimyr.com) they can also walk you through filing it while you're on the phone with them, which is what I ended up doing.
0 coins
Zara Shah
The deadline thing is real - I lost my chance to appeal an overpayment because I waited too long trying to understand it first. File first, ask questions after, that's the lesson I learned the hard way.
0 coins
Luca Bianchi
Honestly the reason you got two letters probably has something to do with how VEC processes audits. Sometimes when an employer submits wage records late or corrects them, it triggers an overpayment review for the weeks covered by those wages. If your employer filed an amendment for one period and original records for another, VEC might have run two separate reviews and generated two separate notices.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorThat actually makes a lot of sense. My old employer was kind of a mess with paperwork. Is there a way to request what information VEC received from my employer that caused these?
0 coins
Luca Bianchi
Yes, you can request your complete claim file through VEC - it'll include any wage records submitted by your employer. This is worth doing because if the employer submitted incorrect information, you have grounds to dispute the overpayment rather than just request a waiver. Disputing is actually better than a waiver if you can show the underlying determination was wrong.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Wait disputing vs waiver - these are different things? I always thought waiver was the only option when you get an overpayment letter.
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
something nobody's mentioned yet - when u fill out the waiver form there's a section where you list all your monthly expenses and income. make sure you fill that out COMPLETELY because half-filled financial sections are the #1 reason waivers get denied from what i've seen people say online. like list every bill even the small ones. they want to see that paying back the overpayment would genuinely cause you hardship
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorWriting this down - fill out every single expense line, don't leave anything blank. Got it. Does the financial hardship section apply the same way to both waiver forms or do I fill it out differently for each?
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
same info both times basically. youre showing the same financial picture for both. some people attach one copy of their bank statements and bills and reference it in both forms, that seems to work
0 coins
Nia Harris
Seconding the complete financial disclosure point. I helped my sister with her waiver and we listed everything - her car payment, phone bill, groceries estimated monthly, her kids school supplies costs, all of it. VEC approved the waiver within about 6 weeks. The completeness really does seem to matter.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
One thing I want to flag because I made this mistake: the two letters probably each have their own reconsideration rights on top of the waiver option. These are different tracks. The waiver says 'yes I owe this but please forgive it due to hardship.' Reconsideration says 'actually I don't think I owe this at all.' You can pursue both at the same time on the same overpayment, but the deadlines might be different for each. Worth reading the letters carefully for both types of deadlines.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorRereading both letters carefully - one mentions a 30-day window to request reconsideration and separately mentions the waiver option with what looks like the same 30-day window. The second letter only mentions the waiver, nothing about reconsideration. Does that mean reconsideration isn't available for the second one?
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
Not necessarily - it might just mean VEC didn't include that language in the second letter template. I'd call and ask specifically whether you have reconsideration rights on both. This is exactly the kind of question where getting a live agent matters because the written letters aren't always complete.
0 coins
Aisha Ali
Calling in to ask about reconsideration rights is worth it and I know the phone situation is frustrating but Claimyr (claimyr.com) really does solve that specific problem. Used it myself when I needed to ask VEC a nuanced question about an overpayment - they got me to an agent way faster than I ever managed on my own. For something like this where you need a yes or no answer from VEC directly it's the move.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
i got one overpayment letter not two but mine was for like $3,200 and i panicked and just paid it immediately without even looking into waiver options because i didnt know that was a thing. wish someone had told me sooner. dont do what i did, definitely look into the waiver process first especially if you cant afford it
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorThat's genuinely painful to read. I'm sorry that happened to you. That's exactly why I'm trying to understand all my options before I do anything.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
yeah live and learn i guess. the worst part is i borrowed the money from my brother to pay it and that caused a whole thing in my family. definitely exhaust every option before paying anything back.
0 coins
Yuki Nakamura
This is so common and VEC doesn't exactly advertise the waiver option loudly on those letters. The language is buried and vague. Most people assume they just owe it and that's that.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Former eligibility worker here (not at VEC but similar agency) so take this with appropriate salt. When you file the waiver for each overpayment, write a brief personal statement along with the financial forms. Something like two to three paragraphs explaining your circumstances - job loss, current job search, any dependents, medical expenses, anything relevant. The form itself is just numbers but the statement gives the reviewer context. Approvals go up significantly when reviewers can see the human situation behind the numbers.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorStarting to draft both statements today. Should the statement for each letter reference the other letter at all, or should I keep them completely separate?
0 coins
StarSurfer
Keep them separate but you can note in each one that you're also dealing with a concurrent overpayment determination, just so the reviewer knows the full financial burden picture. Something like 'I am simultaneously addressing a second overpayment determination' - it adds context to your hardship argument without muddying the waters of the specific waiver you're requesting.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
The personal statement tip is excellent. I included details about my spouse's medical bills and our combined income and I'm pretty sure that's why mine got approved. The numbers on the form alone didn't tell the full story.
0 coins
Carmen Reyes
Has anyone had a situation where VEC denied a waiver for one overpayment but approved the other one from the same claim period? I'm dealing with something similar and scared about partial outcomes like that.
0 coins
Chloe Davis
Yes this can happen. Each determination stands on its own merits. If one overpayment has stronger fraud indicators than the other, VEC might approve one waiver and deny the other. That's actually another reason why keeping the two waiver filings completely separate and tailored to each issue is important.
0 coins
Carmen Reyes
That's both reassuring and terrifying. At least if one gets approved that's something. I think I've been treating them as one big problem when they're really two separate problems that need separate strategies.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorGoing through this same mental shift myself reading this thread. These are two distinct issues that just happened to arrive in the same week. Treating them separately for the waiver filings makes a lot more sense now.
0 coins
Andre Moreau
Something I noticed when I went through the waiver process - there's a difference between Virginia VEC saying they'll waive the overpayment and them saying they'll put it in a repayment plan. Both letters might result in different outcomes. A waiver completely forgives the debt. A repayment plan just spreads out the payments. Make sure you're specifically requesting a full waiver based on financial hardship, not just a payment plan, if that's what you need.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorUsing very specific language on both forms - 'waiver of overpayment due to financial hardship' not just 'help with repayment.' That's an important distinction I hadn't thought about.
0 coins
Andre Moreau
Exactly. And if they deny the waiver they may automatically offer a repayment plan as an alternative, so you're not stuck with nothing if the waiver gets denied. But lead with the waiver request.
0 coins
Zara Shah
This distinction caught me off guard too. I thought I was filing for a waiver and I ended up in a repayment plan because the form language I used wasn't specific enough. Had to follow up and explicitly request reconsideration for a full waiver.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
Quick practical thing - make copies of everything before you submit. Both letters, both completed waiver forms, your financial documents, your personal statements. VEC has been known to lose paperwork and if that happens you want to be able to resubmit quickly without starting from scratch. I'd also note the submission date somewhere because if they miss their own review deadline it gives you grounds to follow up.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorPhotographing everything with my phone as I fill it out. Good call on noting the submission date too.
0 coins
Omar Farouk
If you submit online through the CSS portal it'll generate a confirmation number - screenshot that immediately and save it somewhere safe. That's your proof of submission.
0 coins
Yuki Nakamura
The losing paperwork thing is unfortunately real. I had to resubmit an appeal once because VEC claimed they never received it. Learned to always use the portal when possible because at least there's a digital trail.
0 coins
Anastasia Smirnova
Just want to circle back and say - for the original poster's situation specifically, talking to an actual VEC agent before filing either waiver would be really valuable if you can manage it. The two separate letters with two separate amounts and two different date ranges is unusual enough that an agent might be able to tell you something the letters aren't making clear, like whether one determination is actually supposed to supersede the other. I managed to get through using Claimyr after about three weeks of failed attempts on my own - the site is claimyr.com - and the agent I spoke to caught an error in my overpayment calculation that I never would have found just reading the letters.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorSetting this up tonight actually. The idea that one determination might supersede the other hadn't even occurred to me and that could completely change what I need to file. Really don't want to file two waivers if one of these letters is redundant or already rolled into the other.
0 coins
Anastasia Smirnova
That's exactly the kind of thing only an agent can tell you, and it took me asking directly before they looked into it. The letters genuinely don't always tell the full story of what's in the system.
0 coins
Nia Harris
This is good advice. My situation resolved much faster once I actually got a human on the phone rather than trying to interpret the letter language on my own. Those letters are written by lawyers for lawyers, not for regular people trying to understand what happened to their claim.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Does the waiver process pause any debt collection activity VEC might start? Like if I file both waivers tomorrow is that enough to stop them from withholding future benefits or referring it to collections while they review?
0 coins
Chloe Davis
Filing a waiver request generally does pause collection activity during the review period - at least VEC shouldn't be offsetting future benefits while your waiver is pending. But I'd confirm this with an agent because I believe there are exceptions if VEC has classified the overpayment as fraud-related.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Okay that's slightly reassuring. Mine is definitely non-fraud, it was a reporting error on my end that I didn't even realize I was making.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
Non-fraud overpayments are much more likely to have collection paused during review and much more likely to get the waiver approved. Fraud-related overpayments are a different and harder road. Sounds like you're in the better category.
0 coins
Yuki Nakamura
Reading this whole thread because I literally got a single overpayment letter yesterday and I'm already overwhelmed, I can't imagine getting two at once. OP you're handling this way more calmly than I would be. Following this thread for updates.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorHonestly not calm at all, just channeling the panic into research mode. But this thread has genuinely helped me understand what I'm dealing with. If you got a single letter the waiver process is more straightforward - the two-letter situation is confusing because of the question of whether to file separately.
0 coins
Yuki Nakamura
My letter is for $4,100 which is making me sick to think about. Going to look into the waiver option for sure. Thanks for asking the questions you asked OP.
0 coins
GalacticGuardian
4k is scary but definitely waiveable if you can show hardship. dont panic, just document everything and fill out the form completely
0 coins
Nia Harris
One more thing worth mentioning - even if both waivers are denied, you have appeal rights on those denial decisions. So the process is really: file waiver, if denied appeal the denial, if appeal fails then you're looking at repayment or further escalation. It's a multi-step process and the first no is not necessarily the final answer.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorKnowing there are multiple steps if the first answer is no makes this feel a lot more manageable. I've been acting like filing the waiver is my one shot.
0 coins
Nia Harris
It's definitely not your one shot. Each step in the process has its own rights and deadlines, so stay organized and keep track of every date and every piece of correspondence.
0 coins
Diego Chavez
The appeals process for waiver denials is handled through a formal hearing before a VEC appeals examiner. It's more involved than the initial waiver request but people do win at that level, especially for non-fraud overpayments where there are legitimate hardship factors.
0 coins
Zara Shah
Just want to validate that this situation - two overpayment letters, different amounts, unclear if you file one waiver or two - is genuinely confusing and the VEC letters do a terrible job of explaining it. You're not missing something obvious. This is actually complicated and you were right to ask.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
AuthorThank you for saying that. I've been second-guessing myself wondering if the answer was obvious and I just wasn't seeing it. Sounds like it's actually a legitimately unclear situation.
0 coins
Zara Shah
Definitely not obvious. Even people who've been through the process once get confused when two letters show up with different amounts. You've gotten really good information in this thread though.
0 coins
Luca Bianchi
Agreed that the letters are genuinely poorly written. I work in HR and even I found VEC correspondence hard to parse when I personally went through a claim. The bureaucratic language is not designed for the people receiving it.
0 coins