Virginia VEC unemployment appeal hearing fired for leaving work to get dinner
So I got terminated two months ago and I've been fighting this thing ever since. My former employer told Virginia VEC I was fired for cause because I left the building during my shift to grab food from a drive-thru nearby. I was on a 12-hour shift with no scheduled break given to me, it was hour 9, and I literally stepped out for maybe 15 minutes. They had no written break policy posted anywhere, nothing in my employee handbook about leaving the premises for food, and my supervisor had done the same thing multiple times himself. Virginia VEC initially denied my claim saying it was misconduct and disqualified me from benefits. I appealed immediately and now I have my appeal hearing coming up in about 10 days. I have no idea what to expect at this hearing or what kind of documentation I'm going to need. I've been filing my weekly claims throughout the whole adjudication process like I was told to, but I haven't received a single payment yet. The examiner letter I got just said 'misconduct connected with work' and cited the company policy I supposedly violated, except that policy was never actually given to me in writing. Has anyone gone through a Virginia VEC appeal hearing for something like this? What am I walking into?
73 comments

Chloe Green
Two weeks before my own appeal hearing I was sitting in almost this exact same spot, completely lost about what to expect. The hearing itself is done by phone usually, a deputy commissioner or hearing officer calls you at the scheduled time and both you and your employer's rep are on the line together. You'll each get to give your side. The thing people don't realize going in is that they treat it almost like an informal court proceeding - you can present documents, you can have witnesses, and the other side can challenge what you say. For the misconduct angle specifically, the burden is actually on your EMPLOYER to prove you committed misconduct, not on you to prove you didn't. That's a really important distinction. If they can't show there was a clear known policy that you violated, that works heavily in your favor.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorOkay so the burden being on them is something I didn't know and that actually helps me calm down a little. My whole case is basically that there was no documented policy - do I need to bring proof of that absence or is it enough to just state it at the hearing?
0 coins
Lucas Adams
Tried to find this burden of proof info on the Virginia VEC website and it's buried so deep you'd never find it without already knowing what to look for. The hearing officer explained it to me during mine but by then I hadn't prepared for it properly and kind of fumbled my response.
0 coins
Harper Hill
The absence of a written policy IS your evidence in a way. If they try to present a policy document at the hearing that you've never seen, you can challenge when it was created and whether it was distributed to employees. Ask for the date on any document they submit.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
Week 6 of my own appeal process when I finally figured out the phone situation. Getting through to a Virginia VEC agent before my hearing was nearly impossible - I tried calling the main line probably 30 times over two weeks, kept getting the 'high call volume' message and getting disconnected. I eventually found Claimyr at claimyr.com and it was the thing that actually got me through to someone. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k - basically it navigates the phone system and holds your place so you don't have to keep redialing. I needed to talk to someone before my hearing about some paperwork questions and once I actually got through, the agent was helpful. Just sharing because I know how maddening that phone queue gets.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThe phone situation has been a nightmare honestly, I've probably burned 4 hours total just sitting on hold or getting cut off. I'll check that out, I definitely need to talk to someone about whether my weekly claims are going to be held until after the hearing or what.
0 coins
Avery Flores
Spent 3 days trying to call before my appeal and just kept hitting walls. This thread is making me realize I should have been more aggressive about getting through to someone because there were questions I had going in that I never got answered.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
the hold times at vec are genuinely criminal, three hours one time just to get a busy signal at the end of it
0 coins
Ashley Adams
The 30-day window to appeal caught me completely off guard when I first got my disqualification letter - I almost missed it. Once you're past that window they won't reopen it without extraordinary circumstances, so the fact that you're already filed and have a hearing date means you cleared the most dangerous part. For the actual hearing, bring or have ready: any written communications from your employer about the incident, your original offer letter or employment contract, the employee handbook if you have it (and if the break policy isn't in it, that's gold), any texts or emails about the day in question, and if you have coworker witnesses who saw your supervisor do the same thing, ask them in advance if they'd be willing to speak or provide a written statement.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorMy offer letter and handbook are both saved in my email from onboarding. Neither mentions anything about leaving premises during shifts. My former supervisor leaving to get food is something I saw but never documented, so that's going to be my word against theirs.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
Former line manager here who went through an appeal on the other side of the table once, employer rep perspective. We actually lost because we couldn't produce a signed acknowledgment showing the employee had received the policy. Virginia VEC takes the position that if you can't prove the employee knew the rule, you can't prove they broke it knowingly. If you can get anyone to submit even a brief written statement saying that leaving for food was common practice, that helps establish a pattern of condoned behavior.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
The handbook thing is so key. I had a harassment policy case and the company tried to cite something that was added to the handbook six months AFTER I was hired. The hearing officer actually asked when the policy was last updated and the employer rep fumbled it completely.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
Just got my determination letter this morning after a hearing last week so this is very fresh. The 'misconduct connected with work' disqualification is one of the harder ones to fight but not impossible, and your situation actually sounds like it has some real legs. Virginia treats misconduct as requiring that you deliberately violated a known, reasonable workplace rule. 'Leaving to get dinner' doesn't fit neatly into deliberate misconduct unless they can show you knew it was forbidden and did it anyway. The fact that there was no documented policy and that your supervisor did the same thing is essentially an argument that the behavior was implicitly condoned, which undermines the misconduct finding.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThe word 'implicitly condoned' - is that something I should actually use at the hearing or does that sound too legal? I don't want to come across like I'm reading from a script.
0 coins
Michael Adams
Went through mine three months ago and my hearing officer actually used that exact phrase herself when summarizing my case. She seemed to respond better when I just told my story naturally rather than when I tried to sound formal. Just describe what happened, what you saw your supervisor do, and let the officer draw the conclusions.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
my hearing officer was completely different and very formal, made me feel like i was actually in a courtroom. depends on who you get i think
0 coins
Natalie Wang
Eight days out from my hearing when I finally managed to speak with someone at Virginia VEC who could clarify my situation. Claimyr was what made that happen - I'd been trying the CSS portal messages and the main phone line for two weeks with nothing. Once I actually got an agent on the phone she was able to tell me that my pending weekly claims would be released retroactively if I won the appeal, which was a huge relief because I'd been worried those weeks were just going to disappear. Worth knowing that detail if you're in the same boat.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorRetroactive release of the held weekly claims was actually one of my biggest questions. So they stack up and get paid out all at once if you win? That changes my financial planning a lot to know that.
0 coins
Noah Torres
Had the same situation and yes mine came through in one lump payment about a week after the determination was issued. It wasn't instant but it did come. Make sure you've been filing every single week even during the appeal because if you stop filing those weeks don't get backdated.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
Nobody told me this during my appeal and I actually missed two weeks of filing thinking it didn't matter during the review. Lost those two weeks of benefits even when I won. Don't be like me.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
The thing that tripped me up at week one of my appeal - I didn't realize I could submit documents ahead of the hearing rather than just presenting them verbally during the call. The hearing notice should have instructions for submitting evidence in advance. Check your hearing notice carefully because there's usually a deadline a few days before the hearing date to get documents in. If you're mailing anything, the postmark date matters but cutting it close is risky.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorMine says I can email documents to a specific address before the hearing date, it doesn't give a specific cutoff other than 'before the hearing.' I'm going to send everything I have by end of this week just to be safe.
0 coins
Chloe Green
Sending early is smart. I emailed my documents at 9pm the night before my morning hearing and while it technically got there, I think it would've been better to give the officer time to actually review them beforehand.
0 coins
Ryan Young
fax is still an option too if u can find one lol. I actually used a UPS store to fax my documents and it went through, confirmed by calling the hearing office. old school but it worked
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Got my disqualification letter for a totally different reason but followed this same thread when I was going through it and wanted to come back and add something. The hearing officer is not your enemy. That sounds obvious but I was so stressed going in that I was defensive and terse and it didn't help my presentation. When I answered questions, I tried to give the shortest possible answer, which actually made things sound more suspicious. Just talk through it like you're explaining what happened to someone who wasn't there.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThe 'explain it like they weren't there' framing is actually helpful for how I'm going to prepare. I've been rehearsing almost like a cross-examination and it's making me sound cagey even to myself.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Walked out of my hearing thinking I'd totally bombed it because I rambled and went off on a tangent about my commute. Won anyway. The hearing officer was clearly used to nervous people and focused on the substance.
0 coins
Harper Hill
The employer rep at mine was extremely polished and confident and I thought for sure they were going to destroy me. The officer basically ignored the presentation style and focused entirely on whether they could actually document the policy violation. They couldn't. I won.
0 coins
Avery Flores
Just passed the six-week mark since my own hearing and still waiting on the written determination. The wait after the hearing is brutal, nobody tells you it can take several weeks after the hearing itself before you get the written decision. Virginia VEC says they aim for 30 days from the hearing date but I've seen people on here wait longer. Keep filing your weekly claims during this time regardless.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorSeveral weeks AFTER the hearing is not what I expected at all. I thought the hearing was basically the end of the process. So I need to budget for potentially 6-8 more weeks of waiting after the hearing date?
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
Mine took 23 days from the hearing to get the written determination letter in the mail. The online CSS portal updated a couple days before the letter arrived so check that too.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
My written decision came in 19 days. But I know someone who waited 47 days. There's really no reliable timeline, just keep filing and try not to obsess over it.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Right at the two-week mark before my hearing I hit a wall trying to get any information out of Virginia VEC by phone. Claimyr at claimyr.com is what finally cracked it - the demo at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k explains how it works better than I can but basically it got me into the phone queue in a way that actually produced a callback instead of endless busy signals. The agent I finally reached confirmed my appeal was properly registered and that my employer had submitted their response, which I hadn't even known they had to do. Finding out the other side had already filed their version of events before my hearing meant I could request a copy of it.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorWait - you can request a copy of what the employer submitted? I had no idea that was possible. I want to see what they're claiming because I might need to prepare responses to specific things they said.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
Requested mine and it was eye-opening. The employer's written response had a couple of factual errors about the timeline that I was able to directly contradict with a text message I had saved. Never would have thought to look for those discrepancies if I hadn't read their version first.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
This is actually a really underutilized thing. I've seen people go into hearings completely blind to what the employer filed and then get caught off guard by specific claims. The hearing officer usually reads from it and you need to be ready to respond.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
About halfway through my own appeal process when I discovered you could actually request a copy of the employer's submission and the original claim file. Calling Virginia VEC directly is the only real way to get this rolling quickly - I ended up using Claimyr because trying to get through on my own was taking forever, and once I had an agent they walked me through the records request process. The employer's statement had them claiming I 'left the facility without authorization' but their own termination paperwork said 'violation of attendance policy' - those aren't the same thing and the hearing officer noticed the inconsistency.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThe inconsistency between their termination paperwork and what they tell VEC - that's something I should look for in my own situation. My termination letter says 'insubordination' but the VEC determination says 'misconduct in connection with work for leaving premises.' Not sure if that matters.
0 coins
Michael Adams
Showed up to my hearing with the exact same kind of inconsistency and the hearing officer brought it up herself before I even had a chance to mention it. Those discrepancies do register.
0 coins
Noah Torres
My employer's written statement to VEC and the reason on my termination notice were different too. I think they sometimes wing the VEC response without really coordinating it with HR. That sloppiness can work in your favor.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Exactly 10 days before my hearing I realized I hadn't thought about what to do if the employer brings up something at the hearing that I'm not prepared for. You are allowed to ask the hearing officer to clarify a question before answering. You can also say 'can I have a moment to look at that document' if they reference something you weren't expecting. You don't have to blurt out the first response that comes to mind. Take your time, the officer isn't timing you on individual answers.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThe 'ask for a moment to look at the document' thing is something I genuinely didn't know was okay. I was imagining it like a live deposition where hesitating looks bad.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
Paused like four times during my hearing to collect my thoughts and nobody commented on it. The officer just waited. I'd psyched myself out thinking any pause would make me look guilty.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
The hearing officer in mine actually encouraged me to slow down when I was rushing through my answers nervously. They said something like 'take your time, I want to make sure I understand.' That made me realize they're trying to get the facts right, not catch you out.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Three weeks post-hearing and while I'm waiting on my determination I keep second-guessing everything I said. Can I ask - for people who have been through Virginia VEC misconduct appeals, does the specific reason they give for the disqualification usually stay the same in the final determination, or do they sometimes change the category of why you're denied?
0 coins
Chloe Green
Got my determination letter and the finding was under the same disqualification category as the original. What changed was the analysis - they laid out in writing exactly why the misconduct standard was or wasn't met. In my case it was overturned but they kept the same section of the law, just found the facts didn't support it.
0 coins
Chloe Mitchell
The category stayed the same in mine but the conclusion flipped. It went from 'misconduct disqualifies claimant' to 'claimant's actions did not rise to the level of misconduct as defined' - same section, opposite result.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
Somewhere around week four of my appeal I started worrying that if I lost I'd have to pay back the benefits I hadn't even received yet. That spiral got weird. For anyone else who goes down that rabbit hole - if you haven't received payments because they're on hold during the appeal, there's nothing to pay back if you lose. The 'overpayment' situation only arises if you received payments and then it's determined you weren't eligible for them.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorI had the exact same irrational fear and it was eating at me. This actually clarifies it - since nothing has been paid out to me yet, losing would mean I just don't get the money rather than owing money back.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
this confused me too and i asked my cousin who works in HR and she said the same thing. the hold during appeal is exactly to prevent an overpayment situation
0 coins
Avery Flores
The overpayment thing is real when you've RECEIVED payments though. My neighbor got approved, got several weeks of benefits, then the employer appealed the approval and VEC found in the employer's favor on second level review. She had to repay everything. That's a different situation than OP's.
0 coins
Ryan Young
Finished my appeal two months ago now and coming back to this thread just to say - the preparation matters a lot more than people expect. I went in thinking I'd just tell my story and the truth would be obvious. I didn't bring any documentation, I had no witnesses lined up, and when the employer rep started citing specific policy documents I had nothing to counter with. I lost on what was honestly a pretty winnable case. Gather every scrap of documentation you have, even things that seem unimportant.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorThis is maybe the most useful warning I've gotten in this whole thread. I was also planning to 'just tell my story' and not over-prepare. I'm going to spend this week collecting everything I can find.
0 coins
Harper Hill
The employer reps are often HR professionals who do these hearings regularly while claimants are going through it for the first time. Preparation is the only thing that levels that field a bit.
0 coins
Michael Adams
My employer sent an actual employment lawyer to represent them at the hearing. I had nothing but my story and my documents. Won anyway, but it was really uncomfortable going up against someone who clearly knew the process inside out.
0 coins
Noah Torres
Just got my own determination letter yesterday after 6 weeks of waiting. Wanted to share one more thing that helped me - the morning before my hearing I wrote out a one-page timeline of exactly what happened the day I was terminated. Date, time, what I did, who saw me, what was said. Having that document in front of me meant I didn't have to reconstruct the sequence from memory when I was nervous and stressed. I could just follow the timeline.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorWriting the timeline is such a good practical idea. I'm going to do that this weekend. What level of detail did you go into - like minute by minute or more general?
0 coins
Noah Torres
My timeline had maybe 8-10 entries for the whole day, specific enough to anchor each key moment but not so granular that it became confusing. 'Around 2pm, supervisor left building, returned approximately 2:20pm' type of entries.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
I did the same thing and also jotted down the names and titles of anyone relevant, because under stress you can blank on a name you know perfectly well and it looks strange.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
The timeline doc also becomes something you can offer to email to the hearing officer before the call, which gives them a structure for the questions they're going to ask. Mine actually referenced my timeline during the hearing itself.
0 coins
Aaron Lee
One thing nobody mentioned yet - if you lose the appeal at this first level, there's a second level of review available through the Virginia VEC Commission itself, and after that you can appeal to circuit court. Most cases resolve at the first appeal level but it's not necessarily the end of the road if the initial hearing doesn't go your way. That said, each additional level takes more time and resources, so winning at this stage is obviously preferable.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorKnowing there are more options if this doesn't go well actually makes me feel less like everything rides on this one phone call. What's the timeline like for the second level review if it comes to that?
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Second level Commission review usually takes longer than the first appeal - I've heard anywhere from 6 to 16 weeks. It's also more formal and entirely in writing rather than a phone hearing. The first level appeal is definitely the one you want to win.
0 coins
Chloe Green
Someone I know went all the way to circuit court and ultimately won, but it took over a year and she'd already found another job by that point. The practical value of winning at the first level is enormous because the second and third levels are so drawn out.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
Quick check-in since we're getting close to your hearing date - have you confirmed the phone number they'll call you at and that you'll be somewhere quiet with good signal? I didn't think about this and took my hearing call in my car in a parking lot and kept having to ask the officer to repeat questions because of background noise. Have the quiet room ready, have your documents in front of you, have water nearby because a 45-minute phone hearing with your stomach in knots is drying.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorI hadn't thought about the logistics of the actual call at all. I was planning on taking it at home but now I need to make sure nobody else is going to be there making noise.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
My dogs started barking about 20 minutes into mine because someone walked by outside. I had to ask to put the hearing briefly on hold to put them in another room. The officer was fine with it but I was mortified and lost my train of thought.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
also make sure u have the case number and your ssn or claimant ID somewhere visible because they verify your identity at the start before anything else
0 coins
Michael Adams
My hearing was scheduled for a Wednesday morning and I'd been dreading it for two weeks. By the time it actually happened it was almost anticlimactic - the officer was businesslike, went through the facts, asked targeted questions, let the employer rep speak, let me respond, and said she'd be issuing a written determination. Total time about 35 minutes. All that anxiety for a 35-minute phone call. Won about 3 weeks later.
0 coins
Logan Scott
AuthorOkay genuinely this is what I needed to hear. It's hard to put the anxiety in proportion when it feels so high stakes but framing it as a 35-minute phone call that you just have to get through is actually helpful.
0 coins
Ryan Young
Mine was similar in length. The anticipation is somehow worse than the thing itself. I think I'd built up some dramatic confrontation in my head and the reality was much more procedural and calm.
0 coins
Harper Hill
The hearing officer in mine seemed almost bored, honestly. Very matter-of-fact, working through a checklist. I think they do several of these a day. We're all internally catastrophizing over what is to them a routine part of their job.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
My employer rep got a little heated at one point trying to push back on something I said and the hearing officer shut it down immediately and reminded everyone to stay focused on the facts. The officer controls the room, or the call I guess.
0 coins