Back to Virginia Unemployment

Paolo Bianchi

Virginia VEC outstanding issue deputy review new claim old claim - what's happening?

So I'm completely lost and honestly a little panicked. I filed a brand new unemployment claim two weeks ago after getting laid off from my warehouse supervisor job, and right away my portal started showing something about an 'outstanding issue' that needs deputy review. Here's the weird part - I had a totally separate UI claim back in 2022 that I thought was completely closed out and done with. Now I'm wondering if that old claim is somehow tangled up with my new one and causing this whole mess. I never had any issues with the 2022 claim that I know of - I certified every week, reported my earnings correctly when I picked up some part-time shifts, and eventually just found a new job and stopped filing. Never got any notice saying anything was wrong. So why would a deputy suddenly need to review my new claim because of something that old? My CSS portal just shows the outstanding issue status but doesn't tell me what it's actually about. I've tried calling Virginia VEC but I genuinely cannot get through to a live person. I sit on hold for 45 minutes and then it just disconnects me. I need to know if I'm going to get any benefits at all because rent is coming up fast. Has anyone dealt with this specific situation where an old claim seems to be affecting a brand new one?

Wait, is the outstanding issue flag definitely connected to the 2022 claim, or could it be something else entirely with the new one? Just asking because there are a few different things that can trigger deputy review and they don't always relate to past claims. That said, yeah, old claim issues absolutely can carry over. Virginia VEC can go back and revisit a prior claim if they think something wasn't resolved properly the first time around. A deputy basically acts like a first-level investigator - they look at whatever the system flagged and make a determination before your new claim can move forward. The frustrating thing is the CSS portal almost never tells you what specifically triggered it. You kind of have to either wait for a letter or actually talk to someone at VEC to find out what they're looking at.

0 coins

Hmm, I'm not totally sure the deputy is always investigating past claims though - when I had a deputy review flag last year it was just because my employer contested my separation and had nothing to do with any old claims at all.

0 coins

No you're right, that's a good point. I should have been clearer - the deputy review trigger can be a bunch of different things. Employer contests, eligibility questions, earnings discrepancies. It doesn't automatically mean the old 2022 claim is the issue.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes me feel a little better. I've been assuming the worst. But I still have no idea how to find out which specific issue triggered it without being able to get anyone on the phone.

0 coins

Ugh the CSS portal is so useless when it comes to actually explaining what's wrong. It's like they designed it specifically to give you just enough information to stress you out but not enough to actually do anything about it. Have you checked your correspondence section? Sometimes there's a letter in there that explains the issue even if you didn't get a physical copy in the mail yet. Also check if there are any scheduled interviews listed - when deputy review is involved they sometimes schedule a phone interview with you and it shows up in the portal without any notification.

0 coins

I looked in correspondence and there's nothing there yet. And no scheduled interviews showing up either. The portal just has that outstanding issue flag and nothing else useful.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me, the letter showed up in my portal like four days after the flag first appeared. Give it a couple more days before you assume there's nothing there.

0 coins

Yeah it can lag a bit. The physical mail is even slower obviously. The thing that gets me is that if there's a deadline to respond to something, the clock is already running even if you haven't received the notice yet. That's what surprised me when I went through this - found out I had maybe 10 days left to respond after waiting almost a week for the letter to show up.

0 coins

Honestly when I was stuck in this exact limbo trying to figure out what my deputy review was about, calling VEC directly was the only real way to get answers. But getting through is a nightmare. Someone in another thread pointed me toward Claimyr - claimyr.com - and it basically handles the hold time for you and connects you when an agent is actually available. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. I was skeptical but after two days of getting disconnected I tried it and finally talked to an actual VEC rep who told me exactly what triggered my outstanding issue. Turned out it had nothing to do with my old claim at all.

0 coins

Wait, is this something you have to download or is it just a website thing? Not sure I want to install something on my phone right now.

0 coins

It's just through the site, nothing to install. And yeah it really did work for me - the agent I finally reached was actually helpful and walked me through the whole deputy review process.

0 coins

I'm a little skeptical of anything that promises to get you through to VEC faster tbh. Their phone system is a disaster and I've heard of people trying various things with no luck. But I might look at that video at least.

0 coins

Okay I'm going to look into this. At this point I've been disconnected so many times I'll try basically anything to actually talk to someone.

0 coins

35 days. That's what caught me completely off guard when I finally got someone from Virginia VEC on the phone - the deputy only has 35 days from when the issue was flagged to make a determination, but those days are running whether or not you even know about it yet. So the longer you sit waiting to find out what's going on, the shorter your window gets for the whole process to play out before it escalates to something more complicated. When I was dealing with an outstanding issue on a new claim that had some connection to an older one, Claimyr was genuinely the fastest way I found to actually reach a live person at VEC to get the clock situation explained. Because once I understood the timeline I stopped just waiting around.

0 coins

Okay wait, I'm not sure I fully understand the 35-day thing - does that mean I have 35 days to respond, or the deputy has 35 days to decide? Those seem pretty different.

0 coins

The deputy has the 35 days to issue a determination. Your part is responding to whatever they send you, and you usually get a specific shorter window for that - sometimes 10 days, sometimes a bit more depending on what they're asking about. The 35 days is their deadline to wrap up the investigation on their end.

0 coins

I never knew there was any kind of deadline on their end honestly. I always assumed they could just sit on it forever and there was nothing you could do about it.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be obvious - when you filed the new claim, did you have to answer any questions about previous Virginia VEC claims? Because there's a part of the initial application where you're supposed to disclose prior claims and sometimes if the system finds a discrepancy between what you reported and what's in their records from the old claim, it automatically flags for deputy review. It's not necessarily that anything is wrong, just that the system wants a human to verify things match up.

0 coins

Yeah I did answer those questions. I listed the 2022 claim. I wonder if something in the records from that claim just doesn't line up with what I entered on the new application.

0 coins

That could be exactly it. And honestly if that's all it is, a deputy review for that reason tends to resolve pretty quickly once they manually verify the records. It's the more complicated flags - like actual overpayment investigations or fraud concerns - that drag on.

0 coins

This is actually really useful context. I had no idea the system automatically cross-references prior claims. I thought each claim was basically looked at fresh.

0 coins

My cousin went through something almost identical - new claim, old claim from like three years ago, suddenly an outstanding issue flag out of nowhere. She waited almost two weeks before anything happened and then got a letter asking her to participate in a phone interview with a deputy. The interview itself was pretty low-key from what she told me, just them asking her to explain the timeline of her prior claim and confirm some details. She got approved about a week after that. So it's not necessarily a worst-case scenario even when old claims are involved.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring to hear. Did she have to do anything special to prepare for the phone interview or just answer their questions?

0 coins

She just pulled up her old records and had her work history handy. The deputy asked about separation reasons from the old job, whether she'd received all the payments correctly, stuff like that. Pretty straightforward apparently.

0 coins

The phone interviews can go differently depending on what they're actually investigating though. If it's just a records verification thing that's one experience but if they're looking at a potential overpayment from the old claim it gets more serious.

0 coins

Okay this is probably a dumb question but when they say 'outstanding issue deputy review' does the word outstanding mean like it's really important, or does it mean unresolved? Because I've been reading posts about this for a while and I honestly never thought to ask and now I'm not sure.

0 coins

Ha, not dumb at all - it means unresolved, like the issue is still standing, still open, hasn't been dealt with yet. Same way you'd say an outstanding balance on a bill means you still owe it.

0 coins

Oh okay that makes so much more sense. I've been mentally reading it as like a priority issue this whole time lol.

0 coins

Honestly the VEC portal uses so much confusing language that this kind of mix-up makes complete sense. Half the status messages on there don't have plain English explanations anywhere.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I had a deputy review situation - I sent a written inquiry through the CSS portal messaging system asking for a written explanation of what the outstanding issue was. It took about five business days but I did eventually get a response that actually named the specific issue they were looking at. It's slower than calling but if you absolutely can't get through on the phone it's at least something in writing.

0 coins

I didn't even know you could send messages through the portal. I've only been using it to check claim status. Where is that feature exactly?

0 coins

Log in and look for a 'contact us' or 'send a message' type option in the menu - it's not super obvious but it's there. Keep the message short and specific, just ask what triggered the outstanding issue on your claim and reference your claim ID number.

0 coins

I tried this once and got a totally generic response that didn't answer anything. But maybe I wasn't specific enough in how I asked. Worth trying though if you can't get through by phone.

0 coins

Three weeks. That's how long I sat in outstanding issue limbo before I finally got any actual information, and the whole time I was going out of my mind wondering if I'd made some kind of mistake on my old claim. When it finally got resolved it turned out to be a name discrepancy between my old claim and my new one because I'd gotten married in between and changed my name. The whole deputy review was just to match up my identity across the two claims. I want to say that upfront because if you have any kind of life change between claims - name, address, whatever - that alone can trigger a flag.

0 coins

Oh interesting - I didn't change my name or anything but I did move to a different city between the 2022 claim and now. I wonder if an address change could trigger the same thing.

0 coins

Honestly it might. The system is pretty sensitive to any kind of inconsistency between claim records even if it's totally explainable. The deputy review process exists partly just to verify that stuff.

0 coins

This is actually a really useful thing to know. I never would have thought a simple address change could cause a flag but I guess from the system's perspective it looks like it might be two different people.

0 coins

Has anyone here dealt with a situation where the old claim had an actual unresolved issue - like a determination that was appealed but never fully finalized - and then a new claim gets filed? I'm asking because I think that might be what's happening with my own claim right now and I'm not finding much info on how that plays out.

0 coins

Hmm, an unresolved appeal from a prior claim that's still technically open when you file a new one is a different situation than just a records check. That's the kind of thing where talking to an actual VEC rep becomes really important rather than just waiting it out.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I figured. The problem is I genuinely cannot get anyone on the phone. I've tried calling at different times of day and I either get a busy signal or sit on hold forever and get cut off.

0 coins

The appeal complication is real. I had something vaguely similar and the deputy review had to involve whoever was handling the appeal on the other side too. It slowed everything way down.

0 coins

When I went through a deputy review situation last year that had to do with my old claim, I want to be honest - I was not getting anywhere on my own. Couldn't get through on the phone, portal wasn't giving me information, I was just stuck. A friend told me about Claimyr and I finally used it after about a week of frustration. The agent I reached actually looked at both my old claim and the new one side by side while we were on the phone and explained specifically what the deputy was reviewing. I would not have known any of that without that call. The site is claimyr.com if you want to try it.

0 coins

This keeps coming up and I finally watched that YouTube video someone linked earlier. I think I'm going to try it today because I can't keep just checking my portal and hoping something changes.

0 coins

Not to be that person but is it weird that multiple people in this thread are recommending the same service? Just wondering.

0 coins

I mean I get the skepticism but I'm just describing what I actually did. The VEC phone situation is bad enough that when something works people talk about it.

0 coins

I tried it after seeing it mentioned in a different VEC thread and it worked for me too. I think it just comes up a lot because getting through to VEC on your own is genuinely that difficult.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - have you been continuing to file your weekly certifications even while the outstanding issue is pending? Because you're supposed to keep certifying every week regardless of the flag. If you stop certifying because you're waiting for the issue to get resolved, you lose those weeks and even if the deputy eventually approves everything you won't get paid for the weeks you didn't certify. That was a really expensive lesson for someone I know who assumed she should wait.

0 coins

Yes, I have been certifying every week - someone warned me about this early on. But I'm glad you mentioned it because I'm sure other people reading this might not know.

0 coins

Good, honestly so important. The benefits are just held pending the determination but the weeks still have to be certified or they're gone.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb follow-up - when you certify during an outstanding issue period, do you still have to list your three job search contacts for each week? Or is that waived while the claim is in review?

0 coins

Following up on what I asked above because I actually looked this up - you do still have to meet the weekly job search requirements even when your claim is in adjudication or deputy review. The rule is still in effect, three qualifying employer contacts per week that you have to be able to document if asked. I found this out the hard way when my claim finally got resolved and they asked me to verify my job search activity during the pending weeks. Keep your records current even when nothing seems to be moving on the claim itself.

0 coins

Wait, they can go back and audit your job search contacts from weeks that were held pending? That's not something I would have thought to worry about.

0 coins

Yeah apparently. When the pending weeks get released and paid, those weeks are still subject to the normal eligibility requirements including job search activity. It makes sense when you think about it but it definitely caught me off guard.

0 coins

Okay this is exactly the kind of detail I would have missed. I've been keeping my job search log but I want to make sure I'm documenting it in enough detail.

0 coins

Just want to throw in a data point from my own experience - I had an outstanding issue flag on a new claim and it turned out my previous employer from the 2022 claim had filed some kind of late paperwork with VEC that created a discrepancy in my separation record. The employer basically filed something after my old claim closed that contradicted what was originally approved. Virginia VEC had to reconcile the two things before they could approve the new claim. I didn't even know this was possible until it happened to me.

0 coins

This is wild, I had no idea a previous employer could file paperwork after a claim was already closed. How did you even find out that was what happened?

0 coins

Only found out by actually getting someone on the phone at VEC who could look at the notes on my claim. The portal showed nothing useful. That's why I keep saying the phone is the only real way to understand what's actually going on with something complicated like this.

0 coins

This is a legit thing that happens. Employers technically have ongoing obligations to report certain changes even after a claim closes and sometimes they do it really late, which can cause exactly this kind of problem for future claims.

0 coins

Can I ask how long everyone's deputy review situations actually took to resolve? Like start to finish from when the flag first appeared to when you actually got a determination? I'm on day 19 of my own outstanding issue situation and I'm trying to gauge whether I should be more worried than I am.

0 coins

Mine was 11 days from flag to determination letter, but that was a pretty simple records verification thing. I've heard of them taking the full 35 days or even going a bit over when the situation is complicated.

0 coins

My name change situation took 23 days total. It felt like forever but it did resolve.

0 coins

I'm at day 27 and still waiting so unfortunately I don't have a resolution to report yet.

0 coins

Okay so 19 days is not necessarily alarming. That helps. Still stressful but at least I'm not at some point where I should be panicking more than I already am.

0 coins

One thing worth knowing - if the deputy review results in a disqualification rather than an approval, you have appeal rights and the disqualification notice itself will explain what you're contesting and give you a deadline to appeal. That deadline is strict, so read whatever comes in the mail the day it arrives. The window is usually 30 days but it feels like it goes fast when you're stressed and not paying close attention to the calendar.

0 coins

I really hope it doesn't come to that but it's good to know there's a next step if it goes badly.

0 coins

The appeal process is not fun but it's real and it works. And importantly, you can keep filing weekly certifications during an appeal period too - you don't stop just because there's been a disqualification. Those weeks still count if the appeal eventually goes your way.

0 coins

This is good practical info. The idea that you just keep certifying through the whole process even during appeals and disqualifications is counterintuitive but apparently correct.

0 coins

UPDATE from someone who went through this recently: my outstanding issue deputy review involving an old claim finally resolved last month. The deputy found that my previous employer from the old claim had reported my wages slightly differently than I had in the original filing, and the system flagged it when I filed the new claim. The deputy basically looked at both records, determined it was a simple discrepancy rather than any intentional issue, and approved my new claim. Total time was 26 days. So it can work out.

0 coins

This is so helpful to read. Genuinely relieved to hear it resolved okay. Did you have to participate in any interview or did they just review the records and send you a letter?

0 coins

Just a letter asking me to submit a wage statement from my old employer to verify earnings for a specific pay period. I faxed it in - yes, faxed, apparently VEC still uses that for document submission - and about a week later got the approval notice.

0 coins

Wait they actually use fax?? I would have no idea how to even send a fax in 2025.

0 coins

Okay random but to the person asking about faxes - most UPS stores and libraries still have fax machines you can use for a couple dollars a page. Also there are online fax services where you can upload a document and send it as a fax from your phone. This is weirdly relevant Virginia VEC knowledge because yes they do still request faxed documents sometimes.

0 coins

I literally did not know online fax was a thing. Learning something new today.

0 coins

Bookmarking this information for if they ask me to submit anything. Good to know ahead of time rather than scrambling when you get a letter with a deadline.

0 coins

The fax thing is so bizarre but yeah it comes up. I've also seen people say they can submit documents in person at a VEC local office if you're within driving distance of one.

0 coins

Coming in late to this thread but just want to add one more Claimyr note since we're talking about how to actually get information during deputy review - when I used it to reach a VEC agent during my outstanding issue situation, the agent was able to tell me not just what the issue was but also which deputy had been assigned to my claim and approximately where it was in the queue. That kind of specific information makes the waiting so much more manageable. Site is claimyr.com, there's also that YouTube demo at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. It made a real difference for me.

0 coins

Okay I actually used Claimyr yesterday after seeing it mentioned a few times in this thread and I did get through to a live agent. She confirmed the outstanding issue is about a wage reporting discrepancy between my 2022 claim records and what I entered on the new application. Nothing fraud-related, just a records mismatch. She said the deputy should have a determination within the next week or two. I feel so much better just knowing what I'm actually dealing with.

0 coins

So glad you got some actual answers. A records mismatch is about as low-stakes as these things get - should resolve without too much drama.

0 coins

This is a good resolution update. The uncertainty really is the worst part and knowing specifically what they're looking at makes the waiting a lot more bearable.

0 coins

For anyone finding this thread through search later - the short version of everything here seems to be: outstanding issue deputy review can be triggered by a lot of different things, old claims can affect new ones, keep certifying every week and doing your job search contacts no matter what, check your correspondence section in CSS regularly, and actually getting someone from VEC on the phone is the most reliable way to find out what's going on. The portal by itself is basically useless for understanding why a flag was triggered.

0 coins

This is a pretty solid summary honestly. I'd add - don't assume the worst before you know what the actual issue is. Mine turned out to be way less scary than I'd built it up to be in my head.

0 coins

Agreed on all of this. And the job search log thing that came up earlier - seriously keep detailed records even during pending weeks, that one surprised me too.

0 coins

Bookmarking this whole thread. Really useful discussion even for situations that are slightly different from the original post.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure