Back to Virginia Unemployment

Connor O'Reilly

Virginia VEC letter will not hold benefits during deputy review back pay owed

So I got this letter in the mail from Virginia VEC last week and I'm completely lost on what it means for my situation. The letter says they're doing a deputy review on my claim but here's what's killing me - it also says they will NOT hold my benefits during that review period. I thought the whole point of a deputy review was that everything gets paused until they make a decision? My employer contested my claim about six weeks ago saying I quit voluntarily, which is completely wrong - I was let go because the entire department got eliminated. So now I've been certifying my weekly claims every week like I'm supposed to, logging my job search activities, all of that. But if they're not holding benefits during the deputy review, does that mean I'm accumulating back pay that I'll eventually get? Or does it mean something else entirely? I've called the Virginia VEC number probably nine or ten times and either get the endless hold music or get cut off after waiting forever. I really need someone to explain what this letter actually means because the language in it makes no sense to me.

The wording on those VEC letters is genuinely terrible, they write them in a way that confuses everybody. What that letter is telling you is basically the opposite of what you think - when they say they will NOT hold your benefits during the deputy review, it means they aren't going to withhold your payments while the investigation is happening. So your weekly certifications you've been filing should be processing and potentially paying out, not sitting frozen. The back pay question depends on whether any weeks got flagged before you received that letter.

0 coins

Six weeks of certifications submitted and I haven't seen a single payment go through. My CSS portal just shows pending on everything. So if they're not supposed to be holding it, why is nothing coming through?

0 coins

Pending on the portal doesn't always mean frozen, sometimes it's just the system being slow to update. Did you check if there's a separate issue flag on your account besides the deputy review?

0 coins

Okay three weeks ago I was in basically this same mess, employer said I resigned when I absolutely did not, deputy review notice showed up and my portal went to pending on everything. I spent two full days trying to get through to Virginia VEC on the phone with zero luck. Someone in another thread mentioned Claimyr and I was skeptical but I tried it - claimyr.com - and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. Got connected to an actual VEC agent within the same day and she was able to tell me exactly which weeks were flagged and why the payments weren't releasing. Turned out there was a secondary hold on my account that had nothing to do with the deputy review, never would have known without talking to someone.

0 coins

A secondary hold separate from the deputy review - that's honestly what I'm afraid of. Did the agent you spoke with actually do anything to fix it or just explain the situation?

0 coins

This matches what happened to my cousin, she had two separate flags running at the same time and the deputy review letter made it look like one issue when it was actually two things blocking her payments.

0 coins

How long did it take after you talked to the agent before money actually hit your account?

0 coins

I used to think the deputy review and the disqualification determination were the same step, like I genuinely believed for my entire first claim that if a deputy was reviewing it, that meant I was already disqualified. Took me embarrassingly long to figure out they're separate. The deputy review is just an investigation phase - the deputy gathers info from both you and the employer, then makes a determination. You're not disqualified until there's an actual written determination letter saying so. If your letter says benefits won't be held, that's actually a relatively good sign for your situation.

0 coins

Wait so the determination letter is a completely different document from this letter I got? I assumed this was the determination.

0 coins

Completely different letters. The letter you got sounds like a notice of investigation. Determination comes later and it will be very specific about whether you're eligible or disqualified and for which weeks.

0 coins

Yeah and if you get a disqualification determination you have 30 days to appeal it, that clock starts from the date on the letter not when you receive it so watch that date carefully.

0 coins

My situation last year had a similar letter and I was completely wrong about what back pay meant in this context. I thought back pay meant VEC owed me money automatically. What actually happens is the weeks you certified during the deputy review period either get approved and paid or get denied depending on the outcome. If the deputy decides in your favor, those pending weeks pay out. If not, they don't, and there's no automatic back pay just from the review existing.

0 coins

Okay that changes everything about how I understood this. So all those weeks I certified aren't guaranteed, they're just sitting there waiting on the determination outcome?

0 coins

Exactly right. And that's why it matters so much to keep certifying every week without gaps even during a review, because those weeks are your evidence of active job search and continued eligibility.

0 coins

What happens if someone missed certifying during the review period because they assumed payments were frozen anyway?

0 coins

The job search log piece of this is something people mess up during deputy reviews. During the review period you absolutely still need your four job search contacts per week documented, employer name, contact method, date, position applied for. I've seen people assume the review pauses that requirement and then find out the hard way that it doesn't. Your eligibility for each week is evaluated independently.

0 coins

I've been keeping up with all four contacts per week and logging everything in the system, so at least that part I've been doing right.

0 coins

Four contacts is current requirement yes. And keeping detailed records matters because if this goes to a hearing you'll want documentation showing you were compliant the whole time. I went through a full appeals hearing last year and having my job search log organized week by week made a real difference. Also for anyone reading this who can't reach VEC to check on their review status - Claimyr worked well for me, claimyr.com, helped me get through to an agent when I couldn't get anyone on the phone for weeks.

0 coins

The appeals hearing process is worth reading up on even before you get a determination, just so you know what you'd be dealing with if it goes that direction.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet is that your employer has a specific window to respond to the deputy's information request. If your employer doesn't respond in time the deputy can make a determination based only on your information. I found that out when I was going through my own review last spring and the employer actually missed the deadline, which ended up being a factor in how my case went.

0 coins

The employer in my case seems pretty motivated to fight this since they're contesting it, so I doubt they'll miss a deadline. But good to know that's a possibility.

0 coins

Employer response deadlines being missed happens more than people think, especially if the company uses a third-party unemployment management firm and there's a communication gap somewhere.

0 coins

Is that employer deadline information something Virginia VEC publishes anywhere publicly or do you only find out about it by talking to someone?

0 coins

Reading this whole thread because I got a similar letter two months ago. Mine ended up with a determination in my favor but it took almost five weeks from the letter to the determination and then another week before the pending payments actually released. So from letter to money in account was about six weeks total in my experience.

0 coins

Six weeks total - that's actually useful to have as a rough timeline. Did you do anything specific to move it along or did it just resolve on its own?

0 coins

Five weeks for determination is pretty typical from what I've heard, can be shorter or longer depending on how complicated the fact pattern is and how backed up the deputies are.

0 coins

my claim took 7 weeks and i did nothing except keep certifying every week, never got through to anyone on the phone, eventually got paid all at once

0 coins

One thing I want to flag here because it trips people up - the CSS portal status showing pending does not update in real time. I used to refresh mine like every hour thinking something would change and it wouldn't update for days at a time even when things were actually moving on VEC's end. The portal is not a reliable real-time indicator of what's happening with your claim.

0 coins

Every hour is exactly what I've been doing, feeling relieved to know that's not a useful strategy.

0 coins

Honestly the portal is mostly useful for submitting certifications and checking payment history once payments actually release. For anything about claim status during a contested period it's pretty much useless without talking to someone.

0 coins

This is exactly why getting through to an actual agent is so important when something is contested. The portal just doesn't tell you enough.

0 coins

Went through a deputy review situation about four months ago where my employer claimed misconduct and I was terrified I'd lose everything. I know you said you've tried calling and can't get through - before my review wrapped up I found Claimyr at claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that explains it. I was able to actually talk to a Virginia VEC agent and get clarity on where my review stood and what documents the deputy still needed from me. That conversation let me submit additional documentation before the determination was made.

0 coins

Submitting additional documentation before the determination is made - I didn't even know that was possible. What kind of documentation did you submit?

0 coins

Documentation during an active review can include things like emails from your employer, pay stubs, organizational charts showing your department elimination, anything that supports your version of the separation facts.

0 coins

Getting ahead of the determination by providing documentation proactively is genuinely one of the best moves you can make in a contested claim.

0 coins

ok so i had this exact situation and the letter confused me too but honestly it worked out. the NOT holding thing is actually the VEC saying they wont freeze ur account while they investigate. some people get letters that say they WILL hold benefits which means nothing pays til its resolved. yours sounds like the better version of that letter

0 coins

Both versions of this letter exist and mine is apparently the better one - wish that had been explained clearly in the actual letter instead of the confusing language they used.

0 coins

The holding vs not-holding language in those letters is genuinely one of the most confusing things about the VEC process and you're right that there are two different versions with very different implications.

0 coins

The department elimination piece of your situation is actually pretty significant for how the deputy evaluation goes. I used to think any employer contest automatically meant a long drawn-out fight, but layoffs and position eliminations are typically viewed differently than firings for cause. When a whole department gets cut that's harder for an employer to frame as voluntary quit because there's usually documented evidence like severance paperwork, org announcements, that kind of thing.

0 coins

I do have an email from HR announcing the department elimination to everyone in it. I haven't submitted that anywhere yet because I didn't know I could during the review.

0 coins

That HR email is exactly the kind of thing you'd want to get in front of the deputy, it directly contradicts the employer's claim that you quit voluntarily.

0 coins

Gather everything - that email, any communication about severance or final pay, any documentation showing you were included in a group layoff. Build the file now while you remember where everything is.

0 coins

I had a coworker who went through a similar fight and thought her case was hopeless because her former employer was a large company with an HR department and lawyers basically. Turned out the deputy process is based on facts and documentation not on who has better resources. She won her determination and got paid for all the pending weeks.

0 coins

Large employer with resources is exactly what I'm dealing with. Genuinely good to hear the deputy process is about facts rather than which side has more people.

0 coins

yeah big companies actually sometimes lose these bc they have so many employees they dont always respond to VEC stuff in time or give generic answers that dont hold up

0 coins

The deputy is specifically trained to evaluate the facts of the separation, not to favor employers. The process has protections for claimants built in.

0 coins

Something I mixed up for the longest time before I actually learned better - I kept thinking that if an employer contests a claim, the burden of proof falls on the employee to prove they should get benefits. Actually the way it's structured in Virginia, if an employer claims misconduct or voluntary quit, they have to establish that with evidence. The employee doesn't start from a position of having to prove innocence. I learned this the hard way on my first claim when I overprepared in a panic and then discovered I'd been thinking about it backwards.

0 coins

That is completely backwards from what I assumed. I've been panicking thinking I need to prove I didn't quit, but the employer needs to prove I did?

0 coins

This is correct specifically for misconduct and voluntary quit claims. The employer is the one making the affirmative claim so they have to back it up. Your role is basically to show your version of events was different.

0 coins

Knowing this going in changes how you should frame your own responses to the deputy if they contact you for your side of the story.

0 coins

For anyone still reading this - the weekly certification calendar does not stop, pause, or reset during a deputy review. Miss a week and you permanently lose eligibility for that week even if you win the determination. I've seen multiple people in various forums make this mistake and lose weeks of benefits they would have otherwise received. Keep certifying, keep logging four job searches, don't stop.

0 coins

I haven't missed a single week yet but I've definitely been tempted to stop since nothing seems to be processing. Really glad I didn't.

0 coins

The temptation to stop certifying when nothing is paying is real and it costs people real money when they give in to it.

0 coins

Yep. And this is also why being able to reach VEC during a review matters - when you're in limbo and not seeing payments and not knowing if certifying is even doing anything, it helps enormously to talk to someone who can confirm your certifications are actually being received and queued.

0 coins

Just want to add from the standby angle in case it's relevant - if you're in a job search requirement situation during this review and you're on regular UI rather than standby, those four job search contacts per week are non-negotiable. Some people hear about standby status and think it applies to their regular claim, then don't do job searches, then get hit with an eligibility issue on top of their existing deputy review. Very different situations.

0 coins

I'm on regular UI not standby so the four contacts per week applies to me and I've been doing them. Good clarification though because I had been wondering what standby even meant.

0 coins

Standby is specifically for people whose employer has indicated they'll be called back to work within a defined period. Very specific situation and you'd know if it applied to you because VEC would have approved it explicitly.

0 coins

The job search exemption on standby confuses a lot of people into thinking they don't need to do searches when they're not actually on standby. Good thing to clarify.

0 coins

Has the deputy actually reached out to you yet to get your statement? In my experience the deputy contacts both parties pretty early in the review and your response to their questions is your main opportunity to put your version of the separation on the record. If they haven't contacted you yet it might mean the review is in an earlier stage.

0 coins

No contact from a deputy yet. The letter just said the review was initiated but gave no timeline or contact information for anyone specific.

0 coins

No contact from a deputy yet just means you're in the queue, not that anything is wrong. When they do contact you respond quickly because there's usually a short window to give your statement.

0 coins

Is the deputy contact usually by phone or mail? I went through this last year and got a letter asking me to call a specific number within five business days.

0 coins

the whole CSS portal not updating thing is so true, i watched mine for weeks and nothing changed and then one day i logged in and there was just money in there. no explanation, no update to the status, just funds available. the system is really not built to communicate anything useful to the person filing

0 coins

This is both reassuring and incredibly frustrating to hear at the same time. So I might just log in one day and it'll be there?

0 coins

thats basically how it went for me too. nothing nothing nothing then suddenly there it was. the portal status still said something vague even after the money was there

0 coins

The gap between when VEC processes something internally and when it shows on the claimant portal can be several days. The payment hits your bank account faster than the portal updates sometimes.

0 coins

I went through a deputy review last fall with a voluntary quit allegation just like yours and the determination came out in my favor. What helped me most was being very specific and factual in my statement, no emotion, just dates, names, what was communicated to me by whom, what the department elimination meant for my specific position. Treated it like writing a timeline of events.

0 coins

Dates and specific communications rather than emotional narrative - that's really useful framing for when the deputy does contact me.

0 coins

The timeline format for statements is legitimately more effective than a narrative explanation. Deputies are evaluating facts against specific eligibility criteria, not reading a story.

0 coins

Keep a copy of everything you submit to VEC during this process. If the determination goes against you and you file an appeal, having records of what you submitted during the review stage is valuable.

0 coins

Coming back to the original question about back pay - if the determination comes out in your favor, all those pending certified weeks pay out in a lump sum. It doesn't come in installments matching each week, in my experience it hits as one or two large payments covering the whole pending period. So if you have six or seven weeks pending that's potentially a substantial amount landing at once.

0 coins

Six weeks of pending certifications, so if this goes my way it'll be a larger deposit than I've been mentally preparing for. Good to know.

0 coins

Lump sum releases can sometimes trigger a secondary review if the amount is unusually large, worth knowing just so you're not surprised if there's a brief additional processing delay even after the determination.

0 coins

This is exactly why it's worth fighting through the determination process rather than giving up when you see pending everywhere. The back pay when it comes can cover a significant period and it's money you're legitimately owed if the determination is in your favor.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure