Back to Virginia Unemployment

Vanessa Figueroa

Unemployment payments deposited after claim was denied what to do

So I'm in a genuinely bizarre situation and I cannot find anyone who's dealt with exactly this. My weekly claims were going through fine for about six weeks after I lost my retail management job in February. Then out of nowhere I get a determination letter saying my claim is denied — something about a question over whether I quit voluntarily or was actually let go. I disputed it immediately because I absolutely did not quit, but while that appeal was supposedly being processed, TWO more direct deposit payments hit my bank account. I'm talking $1,340 total just sitting there that VEC sent me AFTER the denial letter was dated. I have no idea if I'm supposed to spend this, send it back, wait for them to claw it back, or what. The CSS portal just shows my claim status as 'pending appeal' and there nothing indicating these payments were an error or that I owe anything yet. I've been terrified to touch the money. Has anyone actually been through this where deposits kept coming in after a denial? What ended up happening?

Week three after my own denial letter and I'm watching the same thing unfold. Mine was flagged over a separation issue too — former employer contested my claim. One payment came through after the denial date and I called my bank thinking it was a glitch on their end. It wasn't. The way my appeals coordinator eventually explained it to me: sometimes the payment processing cycle doesn't immediately sync with the determination system, so payments that were already queued can still push through. That doesn't mean you're in the clear though. Virginia VEC can and does issue overpayment notices later, sometimes weeks after the fact. Your best move right now is to document everything — screenshot the deposit amounts, the dates, your portal status, everything. Don't spend it if you can help it, keep it in a separate account if possible.

0 coins

Got my denial in March and had something similar — one deposit snuck through after. Keeping records of the portal status screenshots was actually really useful when I talked to someone at VEC later because I could show exactly what the system was displaying at the time.

0 coins

Retail industry, so my separation situation is complicated — I was technically listed as 'resigned' on paperwork even though my hours were cut to basically zero and I had no choice. That's the core of my appeal. The screenshot idea is smart, I'm going to start doing that immediately for every single day until this resolves.

0 coins

same thing happened to my cousin, payments came through 10 days after denial. VEC eventually sent an overpayment letter but it took like 2 months. she had already spent some of it by then and had to set up a repayment plan

0 coins

Just hit the 5-week mark fighting my own denial and reading this thread carefully. One thing I want to flag that I don't see mentioned yet — there's actually a distinction in Virginia VEC rules between an overpayment that happened because of YOUR error or fraud versus one that happened because of an administrative processing lag on their end. The second type is called a non-fault overpayment and it's treated differently in terms of whether they can waive it. If VEC's own system pushed those payments through after the denial date with no action from you, that works in your favor if you need to request a waiver later. The key is that you didn't do anything to cause the extra payments — the system just didn't stop in time.

0 coins

That non-fault distinction is genuinely the most useful thing I've read in days. I did absolutely nothing to trigger those extra payments — I didn't file additional weekly claims after getting the denial letter, they just appeared. Does that matter for how I document this?

0 coins

Two weeks into an overpayment dispute myself and my advocate at a legal aid org mentioned exactly this. If you have no pending weekly certifications you submitted after the denial date, that's strong evidence the payments were purely a system lag.

0 coins

wait does this mean if you spent the money you might not have to pay it all back? asking for a friend lol

0 coins

Eight months ago I was sitting exactly where you are, staring at deposits I wasn't sure I was supposed to have, couldn't get anyone at Virginia VEC on the phone to tell me what to do. I tried calling for literally three weeks straight. What finally worked was using Claimyr — it's a service that gets you connected to an actual VEC agent without you sitting on hold forever. I found it at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. The agent I finally talked to was the one who explained that my post-denial deposits were flagged internally already and that I should NOT return the funds unilaterally because doing so before an official overpayment determination could actually complicate my appeal. That piece of information was huge for me.

0 coins

First notice just arrived yesterday after my own week-long calling nightmare. Never heard of Claimyr before this thread. Going to look into it because getting an actual human at VEC feels impossible right now.

0 coins

Mid-appeal on a voluntary quit denial and the calling situation is absolutely brutal. Called 47 times in one day once. Not exaggerating.

0 coins

The part about NOT sending the money back before the official overpayment notice — that's actually something I was about to do. I was going to initiate a transfer back to VEC this week thinking it would show good faith. So this comment may have saved me from a real mistake.

0 coins

claimyr worked for me too when I was trying to get through about an adjudication issue. took way less time than I expected

0 coins

Approval letter finally in hand after a long fight, so let me try to give you the full picture on what happens procedurally. After a denial is issued and payments slip through anyway, VEC's overpayment unit typically does a reconciliation review — this can take anywhere from 30 days to several months depending on their backlog. During this period your account may show nothing unusual on the CSS portal. When and if they determine those payments constitute an overpayment, you'll receive a formal Notice of Overpayment by mail. That notice triggers your right to request a waiver or file another appeal. Crucially, if your underlying denial appeal succeeds first, the payments become legitimate retroactively and there's no overpayment at all. So your appeals outcome is actually the most important thing to focus on right now.

0 coins

Separation dispute still going on week five for me and this timeline matches what I've been told. The appeal outcome being the thing that makes the payments either legitimate or overpaid is a point I wish someone had explained to me at the start.

0 coins

So basically the two paths are: win the appeal and the deposits were fine all along, or lose the appeal and then deal with the overpayment process separately. That framing actually makes the situation feel a lot less chaotic. I need to focus all energy on the appeal itself.

0 coins

my determination letter came about 6 weeks after the payments stopped so the timing on that review process varies a lot

0 coins

Just got off a call that took forever to get through on and wanted to share what the agent told me about a situation almost identical to yours. She said that returning funds before receiving a formal overpayment determination is actually something they advise against because it creates an accounting discrepancy in their system that then has to be manually corrected. If your appeal wins, they'd technically owe you the money back and that creates a whole other mess. She specifically said to hold the funds, keep records, and wait for official written correspondence. Also — I used Claimyr to finally get through after weeks of failed attempts. If you haven't tried it yet, seriously worth looking at before you spend another month trying to get someone on the phone.

0 coins

Denial letter dated three weeks ago and I've been trying to get through ever since. The advice about not voluntarily returning the money before getting an official notice is something I've now heard from multiple people in this thread and that consistency makes me feel more confident about it.

0 coins

Okay at this point four different people with actual VEC experience have said the same thing about not returning the money proactively. I'm convinced. Funds are staying put until I get written correspondence.

0 coins

i feel like vecs system is just broken in so many ways that stuff like this shouldnt even be possible

0 coins

One payment got through after my denial in March and I want to add something about the appeal process itself since that's really the crux of what determines your outcome. For a voluntary quit vs. discharge dispute, the evidence that tends to matter most in Virginia is documentation of the circumstances around your separation. In your case — hours cut to near zero — that actually falls under a concept called constructive discharge, which means conditions were made so bad that any reasonable person would have left. You'd want written documentation of your reduced schedule, any communications with management about it, your earnings records showing the decline. If you have any of that, make sure it goes into your appeal packet.

0 coins

Had my hours cut from about 38 per week down to 9 over a two-month period with no explanation given in writing. I do have my pay stubs showing the decline and I have a text exchange with my manager where I asked about it. Does text message evidence actually hold up in a VEC appeal hearing?

0 coins

Constructive discharge cases are real and VEC does recognize them. Text messages can be submitted as exhibits in an appeal hearing — print them out and include them with a brief explanation of the context.

0 coins

Pay stubs showing a 75% reduction in hours over two months is actually pretty strong documentation for a constructive discharge argument. That's the kind of thing that shifts the burden back to the employer to explain the reduction.

0 coins

Repayment plan set up after my situation from last year finally got resolved and I want to give a realistic view of what happens if the appeal doesn't go your way. The overpayment notice when it comes will state the amount owed, the reason, and your options. You have 30 days from that notice date to either appeal it, request a waiver (if you meet the criteria), or set up a repayment arrangement. The waiver process requires showing that repayment would cause financial hardship AND that the overpayment wasn't your fault. If you can show both, VEC has discretion to forgive some or all of the amount. I had a non-fault determination on mine and got about 60% waived.

0 coins

Just got the overpayment notice yesterday on a separate older claim issue. The 30-day window for responding is a real deadline — I almost let it slip.

0 coins

If the appeal fails and I end up with an overpayment notice, knowing that waiver is actually a viable path and not just a theoretical option is genuinely helpful. Good to hear someone actually got a portion waived.

0 coins

the financial hardship documentation they ask for is pretty involved but it's worth doing carefully if you're going to apply for a waiver

0 coins

First claim ever filed in my life and I want to push back a little on the idea of just waiting passively. From what I've read in various places you can actually contact Virginia VEC proactively and ask them to flag your account with a note that you're aware of the post-denial deposits and are awaiting official guidance. That way if there's ever any question about your intent, you have a record of having been transparent about it. I'm not 100% sure how to do this in practice but it seems like it would create a paper trail showing you weren't trying to hide anything.

0 coins

This is a reasonable instinct but practically speaking getting through to VEC to make that kind of note is quite difficult. The CSS portal messaging system is probably the better route — sending a written message through the portal asking for guidance on the deposits creates a dated record without you needing to actually reach someone by phone.

0 coins

Using the CSS portal message function is something I hadn't thought of. Going to send a message today stating I'm aware of the deposits, that I haven't spent them, and that I'm awaiting official guidance. That's good proactive documentation without taking any premature financial action.

0 coins

Portal message creating a timestamp on your awareness is smart. Keep a screenshot of the sent message too.

0 coins

ok genuine question — if VEC sent you money they weren't supposed to, why do you even have to pay it back? like it was their mistake not yours. seems really unfair that the burden falls on the claimant

0 coins

Just finished my own appeals process and I understand the frustration but unfortunately that's how unemployment overpayment law works in basically every state — the obligation to repay exists even if the error was entirely the agency's. The difference is in whether they can waive it or set up favorable repayment terms when it was their administrative error rather than the claimant misrepresenting something.

0 coins

yeah it's pretty brutal honestly. my situation last year the overpayment wasn't my fault at all and i still had to fight to get a partial waiver. the system definitely puts the burden on the person who can least afford it

0 coins

that just seems fundamentally backwards but okay

0 coins

Forty-seven calls in one day at the worst point of my appeal and I want to add something about timing your contact attempts if you're still trying to reach VEC by phone. Tuesday through Thursday mornings right when they open at 8:30am tends to have slightly better odds than other times. Monday mornings are flooded from the weekend backlog. Friday afternoons are basically impossible. That said even the best timing still results in getting disconnected a lot — the volume is genuinely overwhelming for their call center.

0 coins

Denial notice came three weeks ago and I've been trying Tuesdays at 8:30 based on advice I found elsewhere. Got through twice in two weeks which is better than my previous zero. Still a long shot but the timing tip is real.

0 coins

Tried calling 11 times yesterday, all disconnected. Going to try the Tuesday 8:30am approach this week. At this point any marginal improvement in odds is worth trying.

0 coins

the 8:30 tuesday thing is real but i'd still say Claimyr is more reliable if you actually need to get through for something important. i used it for my adjudication issue and it was way less stressful than the roulette of calling

0 coins

Appeals hearing scheduled for next month in my situation and I want to talk specifically about what the hearing itself looks like for a voluntary quit vs. discharge dispute because that's where your case is likely headed. Virginia VEC hearings at the Appeals Unit level are conducted by telephone typically. Both you and your former employer will be given the opportunity to present evidence and testimony. The hearing officer is an impartial examiner. Former employers in retail often have HR representatives who do these routinely, so don't go in unprepared — have your documentation organized, know what points you want to make, and practice explaining the timeline of hour reductions clearly. The hearing is usually 30-60 minutes.

0 coins

Separation dispute on week seven and my hearing is next week. The fact that former employers sometimes have dedicated HR reps who do these hearings regularly is something I didn't fully appreciate until my pre-hearing prep. Really important to treat it seriously.

0 coins

The employer having an experienced HR rep is a little intimidating to think about but I appreciate the reality check. I'm going to compile every document I have and write out a clear timeline so I don't get flustered if the other side says something unexpected.

0 coins

Appeals hearings in Virginia are more formal than people expect even though they're by phone. Speaking slowly and clearly, sticking to facts and dates rather than emotions, and having your documents referenced by number helped me a lot.

0 coins

Overpayment resolved last year and coming back to add context on something I see confused a lot in these threads. There's a difference between the overpayment determination process and the appeal of the original denial — they run on separate tracks. You can appeal your denial, win, and have the payments retroactively legitimate. Or you can lose the denial appeal, then separately appeal or request waiver of the overpayment notice. These are two distinct administrative processes and the outcome of one doesn't automatically resolve the other — you have to actively pursue each one. A lot of people get tripped up thinking if they lose the appeal, the overpayment question automatically gets answered one way.

0 coins

This is an important clarification. The two tracks running independently is something that confuses a lot of people. Even if you lose your underlying denial appeal, you still have a separate opportunity to contest or seek waiver of the overpayment amount on its own merits.

0 coins

So I need to be prepared to potentially fight on two separate fronts. Appeal the denial AND if that fails, separately address the overpayment. Got it. That's a lot to manage but at least I understand the landscape now.

0 coins

yep that's exactly how it played out for me. lost the denial appeal but still got a partial waiver on the overpayment because the non-fault argument was separate

0 coins

Three weeks post-denial letter and still no movement on my appeal. I want to ask something that might be naive — if the CSS portal shows 'pending appeal' and there's no overpayment notice yet, is there any benefit to proactively contacting VEC to ask about the status of their internal reconciliation on those deposits, or does doing that somehow trigger a faster overpayment determination that you'd rather not have?

0 coins

Two weeks further along than you in the same situation and my understanding is that reaching out about the deposits doesn't trigger a faster overpayment process — their reconciliation runs on its own schedule. What it CAN do is create a record of your transparency which helps in a waiver situation later. Using the CSS portal message system rather than phone is probably the cleaner way to do it.

0 coins

Separation dispute still pending and I'd add that proactive communication through the portal is generally better than silence when you're worried about how the deposits might look. It's the difference between 'claimant was unaware' and 'claimant was transparent' in any future determination.

0 coins

Already sent a portal message this morning based on earlier advice in this thread. Stated clearly that I'm aware of the two post-denial deposits, haven't spent them, and am awaiting official written guidance before taking any action.

0 coins

Adjudication cleared six weeks ago on a different issue but I've been following this thread because I know people who've dealt with post-denial deposits. One thing I haven't seen mentioned: if your appeal is currently pending, you're in a gray zone where continuing to file weekly certifications is a question mark. Some people are told to keep filing to preserve eligibility if the appeal succeeds retroactively. Others are told to stop. Virginia VEC guidance on this is genuinely inconsistent depending on who you ask. But generally, maintaining a record of job search activities during the pending period can help if the appeal wins because it shows you remained eligible week by week.

0 coins

Appeals hearing next month and I was specifically told by an advocate to keep filing weekly claims and document job searches throughout the appeal period. If you win, those weeks become payable. If you don't file them, you can't claim them retroactively.

0 coins

I actually stopped filing weekly claims after the denial letter because I assumed I wasn't supposed to anymore. If I should have been filing this whole time I may have already created a gap. Is there a way to retroactively certify for weeks you missed during an appeal period?

0 coins

The retroactive certification question is a real one — in some cases VEC will allow backdated certifications if your appeal succeeds, but it's not guaranteed. Worth asking specifically in your next contact with them.

0 coins

the instructions on whether to keep filing during an appeal are genuinely confusing on the css portal. they should make this way clearer

0 coins

Letter in hand from a successful appeal six months ago, wanted to share one more thing about getting actual help navigating this. The CSS portal messages are good for creating records but they don't always get responded to quickly. When I really needed answers about my post-denial situation, I used Claimyr at claimyr.com to get through to an actual agent — there's a demo at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k that shows how it works. The agent I spoke to confirmed I didn't need to do anything with the deposits until I received a written notice AND specifically noted in my account file that I had called proactively to inquire. That notation actually came up favorably in my waiver process later.

0 coins

Three weeks into this whole mess and the idea that a phone contact creating an account notation could matter in a later waiver process is something I hadn't considered. The documentation angle makes the phone contact feel more important than just getting answers.

0 coins

First claim situation and I appreciate that the Claimyr mentions in this thread have come with specific useful outcomes rather than just 'it got me through.' The account notation detail is actually new information.

0 coins

Between the CSS portal message I sent this morning and the idea of also getting an account notation via a phone call, I feel like I'm building a solid paper trail showing I handled this in good faith throughout. That matters a lot to me regardless of how the appeal turns out.

0 coins

Just wrapped up a nearly identical situation two months ago — post-denial deposits, appeal fight, the whole thing. I'll give you the ending: my appeal won on the constructive discharge argument and the deposits became legitimate retroactively. No overpayment notice ever came. But the three months waiting and not knowing was genuinely brutal and I tried everything to get useful information from VEC during that time. The only thing that actually worked was using Claimyr — found it at claimyr.com — to reach an agent who could look at my actual account and tell me what was or wasn't flagged. The video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k explains it better than I can. Everything else was portal messages that went unanswered for weeks.

0 coins

Forty-seven calls in one day at my worst point and hearing that an appeal can fully resolve the deposit question is genuinely the best outcome scenario. Constructive discharge arguments do succeed — good to hear it firsthand.

0 coins

Your outcome is exactly what I'm hoping for. Same basic argument — hours cut to near zero, technically listed as a voluntary quit. Gives me real hope that the constructive discharge angle is viable. How long between the hearing and the final determination?

0 coins

Determination letter came about 18 days after the hearing for me. The wait after the hearing is somehow worse than the wait before it. Hang in there.

0 coins

Appeals hearing still pending and 18 days post-hearing for a determination is actually faster than I'd heard from other sources. Good to know the final step doesn't drag on as long as everything before it.

0 coins

Benefits reinstated three weeks ago after an almost identical situation and I keep coming back to this thread to see if I can help people. One practical thing I did during my pending appeal period that felt right: I created a simple spreadsheet logging every deposit date, amount, my portal status on that date, and what correspondence I had or hadn't received. When I ultimately spoke to an agent and when my waiver discussion happened later, having exact dates and amounts ready made everything go faster. The agent specifically said she appreciated that I wasn't estimating.

0 coins

Overpayment resolved last year and I wish I had done a spreadsheet from day one instead of scrambling to piece together a timeline later. Even rough notes with dates are way better than relying on memory.

0 coins

Already started a document with the two deposit dates, amounts, and my portal screenshots from each day. Adding the spreadsheet format with the correspondence column is a great idea — going to flesh that out today.

0 coins

Appeals hearing next month and organized documentation genuinely does change the dynamic in hearings and waiver discussions. Hearing officers and agents respond differently when you can cite exact dates rather than 'I think it was around early March.

0 coins

Waiting on week 11 of my own claim issue and something nobody has mentioned yet — the VEC appeals process has a few different levels. If your first appeal to the Appeals Unit doesn't go your way, there's a further appeal to the Virginia Employment Commission Board of Review, and after that you can appeal to circuit court. Most people don't know there are multiple levels and assume losing the first appeal means it's over. I've never had to go past the first level myself but I know people who have. Each level has its own deadlines so staying on top of correspondence is critical.

0 coins

This is accurate and worth knowing. The Board of Review level is underutilized — a lot of people give up after the first Appeals Unit decision without knowing the review board exists. The Board sometimes reverses Appeals Unit decisions, particularly in cases involving nuanced separation circumstances.

0 coins

Knowing there are multiple appeal levels actually changes my psychological approach to this. If the first hearing doesn't go my way, that's not the end of the road. Gives me a sense that the process has real checks built in rather than just one shot.

0 coins

Separation dispute week seven and I actually had to look up the Board of Review process recently as a contingency. The appeal timeline from the Board of Review decision is 30 days to circuit court if you want to continue — make sure you don't let that window pass if you get there.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure