Back to Virginia Unemployment

Brianna Schmidt

Old employer asking back to work while unemployment claim is pending - what do I do?

So I'm sitting here on week two of waiting for my claim to go through and I just got a call from my old job. They want me to come back. Here's the thing though - I didn't leave on great terms, they cut my hours down to almost nothing and I eventually just had to stop going because I couldn't afford gas to work 8 hours a week. Now suddenly they want me back full time and I don't even know what to tell them. My claim is still showing pending on the CSS portal and I haven't gotten any determination letter yet. If I go back, does my claim just disappear? If I say no, does that mess up my eligibility since they might report that I turned down work? I work in warehouse logistics and they're offering the same pay I had before the hours got cut, around $16.50 an hour. Honestly I could use the money but I'm also worried about what refusing or accepting means for my pending claim. Has anyone dealt with this exact situation where your old employer called you back while you were still waiting on Virginia VEC to process everything?

Just got my first weekly certification done yesterday so I'm kind of in the same waiting boat as you. From what I understand though - and I had to dig around on the VEC website for a while to piece this together - if you go back to work while your claim is pending, you're supposed to report those earnings on your weekly claims. The pending adjudication doesn't just vanish, it still gets resolved, but any weeks you worked you'd need to report the wages. The tricky part is if you go back full time, you probably won't qualify for benefits for those weeks anyway since you'd be earning above the threshold. The claim itself though, the determination about whether you were eligible to begin with, should still get processed.

0 coins

Two weeks into my own pending situation and I want to gently push back on one part of this - I've heard from someone at my local workforce center that if the original separation reason gets resolved because you returned to the same employer, VEC sometimes treats the whole claim differently. Not sure if that's accurate for everyone but it might be worth looking into before assuming the determination continues as normal.

0 coins

Yeah that's the part that's got me anxious - like what does returning to the same employer do to the original reason I filed? My separation was basically a constructive situation because of the hour cuts.

0 coins

About three weeks into adjudication myself when I hit a wall trying to get anyone on the phone to explain my specific situation. I'll be honest - I tried calling VEC for six days straight, mornings, afternoons, nothing. Someone in another thread pointed me to Claimyr, claimyr.com, and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k. It basically gets you connected to an actual VEC agent without you sitting on hold forever. I used it to ask about a job offer situation while my claim was pending and the agent walked me through exactly what I needed to do. For something like your situation with the old employer calling, talking to an actual VEC agent is really the only way to get a straight answer that applies to YOUR case specifically.

0 coins

Somewhere around day ten of trying to call VEC myself and I'm skeptical of these third party services in general - does it actually work or does it just eventually put you in the same queue?

0 coins

Fair question and I had the same doubt. What I can say is I got connected to a live VEC agent within the same day, which was more than I'd managed in almost a week of calling myself. The agent was real, answered real questions, looked at my actual claim.

0 coins

Honestly at this point getting through to anyone at VEC sounds like a miracle. I've called twice and both times it just cycled me back to the main menu.

0 coins

My determination letter came in last week after a five week wait so I'm through that part at least. Here's what I'd personally do first if I were you - I'd figure out whether going back would be full time or if there's any chance they'd pull the same hours reduction again, because that affects everything. The way Virginia VEC looks at it is basically this: if a former employer offers you a job that's considered suitable work - meaning comparable pay, hours, and conditions to what you had - and you turn it down without a good reason, that could be used against your claim. But if the job offer is for less than what you were doing before, or the conditions were the reason you separated in the first place, refusing it might not hurt you. The key is documenting everything about why you left and why going back might not actually be a suitable offer.

0 coins

Not sure I'd frame the documentation part that simply - I went through something similar and the definition of 'suitable work' that VEC actually applies involves your prior wages, your occupation, and how long you've been unemployed, it's not just about matching your old hours. The longer someone has been out of work the broader that definition gets.

0 coins

You're right that there's more nuance to it, I was simplifying. The duration piece is real - if you've only been out a few weeks, they generally expect you to hold out for comparable work.

0 coins

Got my adjudication notice last week and this thread is making me realize I need to understand suitable work way better than I do. Does going back to the original employer count differently than a brand new job offer?

0 coins

Filing my second weekly cert today and something nobody's mentioned yet - whatever you decide, you need to report the job offer contact on your weekly certification if there's a question about job contacts or offers that week. Some people think they only need to report if they accepted work but VEC wants to know about offers too. Don't skip over that section thinking it only matters if you accepted.

0 coins

Okay this is news to me - so even a phone call from my old employer that I haven't responded to yet, do I need to report that this week?

0 coins

My understanding is that if it's an actual offer of work you need to report it. A heads-up call without a formal offer might be different. When in doubt I'd report it and add notes.

0 coins

Three weeks waiting on a decision and I want to point out that the weekly certification questions are pretty specifically worded - it usually asks whether you refused work, not just whether someone called. Reading it carefully matters.

0 coins

Received my separation notice two weeks ago and just started filing claims. The hours reduction thing you described is actually kind of important for your original claim - if your hours were cut so severely that you basically had no choice but to stop working, VEC can consider that a type of involuntary separation in some cases. It's not guaranteed but if your determination is still pending, that context matters. If you go back to the same employer now, it could muddy that original narrative. I'd hold off on committing to anything until your claim has at least been adjudicated, if that's financially possible.

0 coins

I'm a little uncertain about the 'involuntary separation' framing for hour reductions - my understanding is that it falls under a constructive discharge or good cause quit category, which is handled differently than a layoff. The burden of proof lands differently depending on how it's classified.

0 coins

Yeah you're right that the terminology matters for how VEC processes it. The practical outcome can be similar though - if the hours reduction was significant enough, it can support a good cause finding. The claimant still has to demonstrate the reduction was substantial.

0 coins

Mine went from around 36 hours a week down to 8 over about six weeks. I have my old pay stubs showing the drop. Is that the kind of documentation that helps?

0 coins

Got a pending determination for going on four weeks now. I went through something similar last year - old employer wanted me back during the pending period. What I did was talk to them honestly, told them I had some things to sort out and asked if the offer had a deadline. They gave me a week. That bought me time to actually get information from VEC before making any decision. Might be worth asking your old employer how long the offer stands before you feel like you have to decide immediately.

0 coins

That's actually a smart approach. I've been treating it like I need to answer today but they didn't give me any specific deadline.

0 coins

Just had my claim approved after six weeks and I'd just add that some employers make it seem urgent when really they're not in that much of a hurry. Buying yourself a few days to get real information from VEC is completely reasonable.

0 coins

Waiting on week three of adjudication myself and after going in circles trying to get anyone at VEC to talk to me, I ended up using Claimyr to finally reach an agent. Same kind of question actually - had a callback from somewhere I'd worked before. The agent at VEC was really clear about what I needed to report and what my options were. claimyr.com has the info if anyone's struggling to get through on the phones.

0 coins

My appeal just got scheduled so I've been in this system for a while. First thing I'd personally do in your shoes is pull up your original separation documentation and write down in plain language why the hours reduction made the job untenable. Not for VEC necessarily, just so you're clear in your own head before you have any conversations. The rule about turning down work from a former employer while a claim is pending is that VEC looks at whether the offer restores you to substantially similar conditions as before - if the conditions that caused you to leave are still there or could come back, that factors in. Going back to an employer who already cut your hours once, without any written guarantee of stable hours, is not automatically disqualifying to refuse.

0 coins

Written guarantee of stable hours - that's something I hadn't thought about. They haven't offered anything in writing, just a phone call.

0 coins

I'd be a bit cautious about expecting any employer to put hours guarantees in writing, that's pretty rare. But what it does mean is you have no commitment from them either, which might actually support your reasoning if you decline.

0 coins

Somewhere in week five of waiting over here - the written vs. verbal offer piece matters for documentation. If you do decide to go back or decline, write yourself an email or text summary right after any conversation so you have a record of what was actually said and when.

0 coins

Just got through my first weekly certification this morning. Something I saw come up in another thread here that might be relevant - if your pending claim involves adjudication around the separation reason and you return to that employer before the determination comes out, the adjudicator may contact that employer as part of the investigation. If you've already gone back, the employer's account of events might shift. Just something to think about in terms of timing.

0 coins

About a month into waiting and I'm not entirely sure the adjudicator always contacts the employer - I think it depends on whether the employer filed a protest or if the separation circumstances are disputed. Does anyone know how often they actually reach out?

0 coins

My understanding is they contact the employer when the reason for separation is contested or unclear. If your former employer hasn't filed a response or dispute, the process might move faster without that back and forth.

0 coins

Mine definitely seems contested based on the fact that I'm still pending this long. The employer submitted something early on, I got a letter saying VEC was gathering information from both sides.

0 coins

Got my disqualification notice last month and am appealing it now so I've seen how this plays out from the wrong side. Here's what I'd tell a friend in your position: don't assume going back automatically fixes things or automatically ruins things. What actually matters is whether you can honestly say the offer was suitable given everything that happened. If you go back and your hours get cut again in three months, you'll be starting this whole process over. If you decline and you can clearly explain why the offer wasn't truly comparable to what you had before the reduction started, that's a defensible position. The error I made was not documenting my reasoning at the time I made decisions - everything felt obvious then and it wasn't so obvious months later trying to explain it.

0 coins

A few days into dealing with VEC on a new claim and I want to question one thing - does VEC actually ask you to explain your reasoning for declining an offer or do they just see a declined offer and make an adverse finding?

0 coins

In my experience they do ask you to explain, usually through a questionnaire or a phone interview with an adjudicator. That's your chance to lay out why you felt the offer wasn't suitable. If you have no documentation and your memory is fuzzy, that interview is a lot harder.

0 coins

Just finished week four of adjudication. I had a phone interview situation too and was not prepared for how specific the questions were. I ended up using Claimyr earlier in my claim to get an agent to tell me what that interview process even looked like - saved me a lot of confusion. For anyone dreading that call with VEC, claimyr.com and the video at https://youtu.be/GK1CFuX4p2k helped me figure out how to actually reach someone before the interview.

0 coins

Came through adjudication last week finally. The thing I'd do first if I were in your position is look at what your average weekly wage was before the hour reductions started, not what it was at the end. VEC uses your base period wages to determine your weekly benefit amount and what counts as suitable replacement work. If your old employer is offering to bring you back at the reduced rate or the conditions that created the problem in the first place, that's worth noting when you talk to anyone at VEC.

0 coins

Two weeks pending over here - does that mean if the wage offer is lower than your base period average, you might have more grounds to decline without it counting against you?

0 coins

Roughly yes, that's part of how suitable work is defined. The further you are from your base period wage, the stronger the argument that an offer isn't truly suitable. It's not a bright line though.

0 coins

The $16.50 they're offering now was actually what I earned before the cuts started. The problem was the hours, not the hourly rate. So does the rate matching but hours being uncertain change the suitable work calculation?

0 coins

My weekly cert is due tomorrow and I've been reading this thread while procrastinating. One thing I haven't seen mentioned - if your employer is reaching out to you personally, they may also be in contact with VEC about your claim. Former employers sometimes reach out to claimants directly as an informal way to resolve the situation before an adjudication goes against them. Worth keeping that possibility in mind when you decide how to respond to them.

0 coins

I'd soften that slightly - it's possible but it's also possible the employer is just short-staffed and reached out without thinking much about the VEC claim at all. Not every callback is strategically motivated.

0 coins

Fair point. I might be reading into it. Either way, keeping a record of any communication with the employer is smart regardless of their motivation.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about that angle at all. My ex-supervisor is the one who called, not HR, which makes me think it's more of an operational need than anything strategic.

0 coins

Got approved last week after almost seven weeks of waiting. What helped me understand my situation was actually calling VEC before I made any decisions during my pending period. I know that sounds obvious but I put it off for weeks because I dreaded the phones. When I finally got through, the agent was actually pretty helpful and clear. The phone situation is awful though - I went through the whole early morning strategy, hitting redial, everything. Eventually a family member told me about some tools that help you get through, which is how I found out about services like Claimyr. By that point I'd already gotten through on my own but I wish I'd known earlier.

0 coins

Seven weeks sounds like a nightmare. Did your employer contest the claim or was it just processing backlog?

0 coins

Both, kind of. Employer submitted a response late which apparently reset some internal timeline. Add that to general backlog and it just dragged.

0 coins

About a month into my wait here and hearing that employer responses can reset timelines is not what I needed to read today honestly.

0 coins

My situation is a few months behind me now. The resolution for me ended up being that I went back to a different job entirely, not the old employer, and my VEC claim was eventually approved for the weeks I was unemployed before that new job started. That's actually an option worth considering - is going back to this specific employer really what you want or is it just the first offer that came in?

0 coins

Honestly... it's the first offer that came in. And part of me is considering it out of anxiety about money, not because it's actually a good situation to return to.

0 coins

That's a really honest thing to realize. The pending claim pressure can make any offer look better than it is.

0 coins

About two weeks into pending here and this thread is weirdly therapeutic. Realizing the same thing about my own anxious decision-making.

0 coins

Coming back to add one more practical thing since I saw your follow-up about the employer submitting a response to VEC. Given that the claim is already contested, whatever you do about this callback absolutely needs to be reported accurately and timely on your weekly certifications. Any discrepancy between what you tell VEC on a weekly cert and what your employer tells them could become a whole separate problem. Keep everything consistent and documented.

0 coins

This is probably the most useful practical advice in the thread - whatever I decide I need to make sure what I report to VEC lines up with reality and with anything the employer might say.

0 coins

My pending claim hit the third week today and I want to second this hard. Consistency between what you report and what your employer reports is something VEC takes seriously. It's one of the things adjudicators look for.

0 coins

Worth adding that VEC can and does cross-reference employer wage records with what claimants report. Accuracy from the start protects you a lot more than trying to explain discrepancies later.

0 coins

Looking back at this whole thread from my spot on the other side of adjudication - the main takeaway seems to be that you have more time to decide than you think, talking to VEC directly about your specific situation is worth the effort it takes to get through, and whatever you decide needs to be documented and reported correctly. Your situation with the hours reduction is not simple but it's also not hopeless.

0 coins

Thanks for this. I've decided I'm going to try to get through to VEC before I respond to my old employer. If that takes a few days, it takes a few days. The employer hasn't given me a deadline.

0 coins

That sounds like the right call. Good luck - keep the thread updated if you can, it'd be helpful to know how this kind of situation resolves.

0 coins

Genuinely rooting for you on this one. The situation is complicated but you're asking the right questions.

0 coins

Virginia Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure