Back to USCIS

Ava Williams

USCIS RFE duplicate notice after new I-693 medical exam submitted F2A green card — what does this mean?

Filed my I-485 as an F2A beneficiary about eight months ago and things were moving along okay until I got hit with an RFE asking for a new medical exam — my I-693 had expired. Fair enough, I went back to the civil surgeon, got everything redone, and mailed the whole package to the lockbox within the response window printed on the RFE. Then things got strange. About six weeks after I sent the new I-693 in, I got what looks like a second RFE asking for the exact same thing — a current medical exam. The envelope and the notice number are different from the first one, so it isn't a duplicate mailing of the same letter. It looks like a brand new request, generated after I already responded. I honestly don't know what to make of this. Did my response to the first RFE not get logged before the second one generated? Is there a timing issue where both requests were in the pipeline at once? I responded to the first one on time and have proof of mailing. Has anyone dealt with a situation like this where a second RFE came out for the same document after they'd already sent it in?

Two addresses were on file for my case at one point — the old apartment and the forwarding address I'd updated — and I was getting notices routed to both, which created some real confusion around where things stood. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to a live person at the Contact Center, and the representative pulled up my file and confirmed which address was actually current. Video on reaching someone live at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. She also told me what the last notice sent was and its date, which helped me figure out if anything had crossed in the mail. Worth noting that your situation with a second RFE on the I-693 sounds like it might be a cross-in-the-mail issue too — the second request may have already been in the queue when your response arrived.

0 coins

Checked my online account just now after reading this and the case status hasn't updated to show a response received for the first RFE. That's what's worrying me — if they haven't logged it yet, do I need to respond to the second RFE separately with another copy of the I-693, or would doing that cause even more confusion?

0 coins

Proof of mailing matters a lot here. If you sent the first response by certified mail you have a tracking number showing it arrived. Keep that in a safe place because the Contact Center rep can note it on the case. The second RFE's date and the first response's delivery date will tell you a lot about what happened.

0 coins

Had a similar timing mess with my I-765 renewal — a second request came out while my first response was still in transit. The representative at the Contact Center confirmed receipt of both and told me the first response was what mattered since it was within the original window. Different form but the same kind of overlap.

0 coins

Sent my own I-693 response in for an I-485 RFE last spring and was nervous about exactly this. The key thing I didn't know at first: when USCIS issues an RFE, everything they're asking for has to go in together in one submission — you can't send part of it and follow up with more later. A partial response gets treated as asking for a decision on whatever is already in the file. So if the second notice is truly a separate RFE, it has its own response deadline printed on it, and you'd have to decide whether to respond to it as well. But before doing anything, I'd contact the Contact Center to find out whether your first response was actually received and logged before that second notice went out.

0 coins

The deadline on the second notice is about five weeks out. So I do have some time, but not a ton. My plan is to call the Contact Center this week and ask whether the first response is in the system before I decide how to handle the second notice.

0 coins

Responding to both just to be safe sounds like it could create more problems — if they receive two full I-693 packages they might not know which one to use. I'd get confirmation first on whether the first response was logged, then decide.

0 coins

The rule about everything going in together is really important and I didn't know it either until I got burned. Sent in what I had on an RFE for my I-485 and said I'd follow up with the rest — the case moved toward denial before the second batch even arrived. Attorney had to file a motion to reopen. Now I always respond complete or not at all.

0 coins

Eight months into an F2A I-485 and dealing with an RFE is already stressful — getting a second one for the same document is a whole other level. I've seen a few threads here where people got what looked like a second RFE but it turned out to be a delayed notice that crossed with the original response. The notice generation and the mail processing don't always line up neatly. What does the date on the second notice say compared to when you mailed your first response?

0 coins

The date on the second notice is about two weeks after I dropped the first response in the mail. So depending on how fast it traveled, it's possible the second notice was already printed before my package arrived at the lockbox.

0 coins

Two weeks is right at the edge of where this kind of thing happens. Priority Mail usually gets there in a few days but lockbox processing after arrival can add more time before the response is officially logged to the case. The notice might have generated before they even opened the envelope.

0 coins

Lockbox processing time is a real wild card. Even if something arrives quickly USCIS doesn't immediately log it to the case — there's a gap between physical receipt and when it shows as received in the system. That gap is probably what you're dealing with.

0 coins

My I-485 got an RFE for the I-693 too and I panicked when I saw it because I thought my civil surgeon had filled something out wrong. Turned out it was just that the exam had been done more than two years before USCIS got to reviewing the application, so the form had expired on them. Had to do a full redo. The civil surgeon sealed the new envelope and I sent it directly in my RFE response package — made sure not to open the sealed envelope. If you're responding to a second RFE with a fresh I-693, the same rules apply: civil surgeon seals it, you include it sealed.

0 coins

Went back to the same civil surgeon for the redo and they sealed it properly. That part I'm confident about. It's the administrative side — whether USCIS logged the first response — that's the open question right now.

0 coins

Civil surgeons vary a lot on how well they know the USCIS packaging requirements. Good that yours did it right. Some people have gotten a second RFE because the first submission had a procedural issue with how the form was submitted, not a timing issue at all — worth ruling out.

0 coins

Sealed envelope from the civil surgeon is the right move. I made the mistake of opening mine thinking I needed to check it and had to go back and have a whole new exam done. The form is invalid if the seal is broken.

0 coins

Approval notice for a sibling's I-485 never showed up even though the online account said it had been mailed. Filed a case inquiry through USCIS's site first, then ended up using Claimyr to speak with someone at the Contact Center directly. The representative opened an inquiry for the missing approval notice and gave me a reference number for it. We're still waiting on the reissued notice but at least there's a record of the inquiry now.

0 coins

How long did the inquiry take to get a response after you opened it? Trying to decide whether to file a case inquiry for the first RFE response or just wait until I can get someone on the phone.

0 coins

Haven't heard back in writing yet — the representative said to watch the online account for a message. It's been about three weeks. Phoning first if you have something time-sensitive like an RFE deadline makes more sense than waiting on a written response.

0 coins

Case inquiries through the site are slower than phoning, in my experience. For anything with a deadline on it, the Contact Center is the faster route. You can always file the written inquiry too as a paper trail but don't wait on it if you have a clock running.

0 coins

Got an RFE on my I-485 and completely misread the response deadline — I thought the date on the notice was when USCIS had to respond to me, not when I had to respond to them. By the time I figured out the mistake I had about ten days left. Scrambled and got everything in on time but it was way too close. For anyone reading: the date printed on the RFE is YOUR deadline to send everything back, not theirs. And you can't get more time beyond what the notice allows.

0 coins

Had to triple-read my RFE when it first arrived because of exactly that confusion. The language is a bit formal and it's not immediately obvious who has to do what by when. Definitely confirmed: the date is mine to meet, not USCIS's.

0 coins

Honestly the wording on those RFEs is confusing to a lot of people. I thought the same thing at first — that USCIS was giving itself a deadline. The officer has up to 84 days to give you to respond, and that's already the maximum they're allowed. No extensions past that.

0 coins

Ten days left with an I-693 to gather would have been a nightmare. Civil surgeons sometimes have weeks-long waits. Really glad you made it in time.

0 coins

April of this year my online account went from 'case is being actively reviewed' to no update for three months, and I had no idea if an interview had been scheduled without the notice reaching me. Claimyr got me to a representative at the Contact Center who found the interview notice date in the system and confirmed it had been mailed to the address on file. Turned out the notice was sitting at a neighbor's address — wrong apartment number on the envelope. Got it sorted before the interview date passed.

0 coins

Wrong apartment number on the envelope sounds like a USCIS data entry issue — did you have to do anything on your end to fix the address before the interview, or did the representative handle it on the call?

0 coins

Address on the account was correct — the error was in how they printed the envelope. The representative noted the discrepancy and I went to the interview as scheduled. Brought extra ID just in case, and the officer had the correct address in the file so it wasn't an issue at the door.

0 coins

Mailing issues with interview notices are more common than people realize. If your account shows the right address but a notice seems to be missing, phoning the Contact Center to verify what's actually on the envelope versus what's in the system is worth doing before assuming it was lost entirely.

0 coins

F2A category means priority date movement matters a lot to how fast any of this resolves. Some people in F2A have been waiting years from petition approval just for a visa number to become available, so an I-485 that's actually at the interview stage or close to it is already further along than many in that category. The RFE on the I-693 is frustrating but it's also a sign that someone looked at the application.

0 coins

Priority date was current when I filed, which is part of why the I-485 was possible at all. The F2A backlog is brutal depending on where you're from and I'm well aware others have been waiting much longer. The RFE just caught me off guard after things had been quiet for months.

0 coins

F2A moving faster than F2B still doesn't mean it's fast. Especially for certain countries the wait is long even after a visa number is available. Having an I-485 pending is genuinely the best spot to be in if you have a current date.

0 coins

Looked at my own account after reading this — I have a pending I-485 too and I'd been ignoring the status page for a few weeks. No RFE yet but reading about the medical exam expiration issue made me check when my I-693 was done. Might be getting close to the two-year mark. Is there a way to proactively send in a new one before they ask?

0 coins

Proactively sending evidence outside of a request is tricky — USCIS may or may not attach it to the right case without a pending request to respond to. The safer move is usually to wait for the RFE rather than send unsolicited evidence. But if you're worried, a secure message through the USCIS online account asking about the status might at least get it on the record.

0 coins

Attorney I consulted told me the same thing — unsolicited evidence sometimes doesn't make it into the file. If the I-693 expires while the case is pending, USCIS will request a new one if they need it. Waiting is the standard advice.

0 coins

Okay, monitoring then. I'll check the account more often and make sure my civil surgeon's office is still operating in case I need a quick appointment.

0 coins

Had an I-693 get flagged on a previous application years ago for a minor vaccination issue, not a timing issue. The civil surgeon missed one line on the vaccination chart and USCIS sent an RFE. Had to go back for a supplemental exam rather than a full redo — the civil surgeon added the missing entry and issued an updated sealed package. Moral: always review what the civil surgeon gave you at the appointment, not to open the sealed package, but to ask them to confirm everything is complete before you leave.

0 coins

Checked the outer envelope carefully after my appointment to confirm it was sealed correctly. The civil surgeon handed me a checklist of what was inside which helped me feel like nothing was missing, without having to open it. That's a good practice.

0 coins

Wish I'd known to ask more questions at the appointment. For the redo I did ask the surgeon to walk me through what was included, and she confirmed the vaccination section was complete this time. At least if there's a third RFE it won't be for the same reason as the first.

0 coins

When my I-485 hit an RFE for missing financial documents I didn't know I had to respond to every single thing they listed in one shot. I sent in the affidavit of support first thinking the tax transcripts could follow once I had them pulled. The case flagged as incomplete response and an attorney had to step in. What the person above said about partial responses is correct — they treat anything short of the full package as a decision on what's already there.

0 coins

An immigration attorney or accredited representative is worth consulting on this kind of situation, especially when there's already one RFE plus what might be a second one. The stakes are high enough that professional eyes on the response before it goes out can avoid exactly the kind of mistake you're describing.

0 coins

Agreed. Had I consulted an attorney before sending my RFE response I probably would have avoided a lot of the panic I described earlier. The form instructions and the RFE language don't always make it obvious what 'complete response' means in practice.

0 coins

USCIS online account showed my case as 'response to RFE received' about three weeks after I mailed it — not immediately. So if yours doesn't show that update yet it doesn't necessarily mean they don't have your response. The lag between physical receipt and system update seems to run a few weeks on average, at least in my experience.

0 coins

Three weeks is kind of reassuring actually — mine's been about six weeks since I mailed it and still no update. At this point either it really hasn't been processed yet, or there's a bigger issue. That's why I need to get the Contact Center on the phone.

0 coins

Six weeks without a 'response received' update is longer than typical, based on what I've seen people report. Not necessarily a disaster but definitely a reason to phone in. The representative can tell you whether they have it in the system even if the online account hasn't caught up.

0 coins

Mailed a response in September and the account update didn't post until early November. So six weeks is within range but the outer edge of it. Calling the Contact Center to ask is the right call either way.

0 coins

USCIS RFE response deadlines are firm. What I didn't know before my own experience: the 87 days from mailing is the maximum — the notice itself may give fewer than that, and whatever's on the notice is what applies. I assumed I had a full 87 days and almost miscounted. Check the actual date on your second RFE, not what you assume the rule allows.

0 coins

Already noted the date on the second notice. Five weeks from now. That's what's on the paper, not what I'm calculating from some rule. No room for miscounting.

0 coins

Five weeks is tight if you're waiting on confirmation from the Contact Center before deciding whether to respond. I'd get that call in by end of this week.

0 coins

My I-485 was pending for about fourteen months before I got an RFE — the long wait with no news and then suddenly a time-sensitive request is a stressful pattern. If the Contact Center confirms your first response was received and logged before the second notice generated, you may be in a better position than it feels right now. The case is still moving, which is something.

0 coins

Fourteen months and then an RFE — yes, that's exactly the experience. Everything is quiet and then suddenly there's urgency. I'm trying to stay calm but the second RFE with a different notice number really threw me.

0 coins

Duplicate or near-duplicate RFEs with different notice numbers do happen, and they're not always a sign of a problem with the application itself. Sometimes it's a processing artifact. Contact Center can usually tell you pretty quickly whether both requests are linked to the same issue.

0 coins

A second RFE on the I-693 when you've already responded to the first would make me want to confirm I sent to the right lockbox. The address for RFE responses can differ from the original filing address depending on the service center and the form. Did you send the first response to the address printed on the RFE itself?

0 coins

Sent it to the address on the RFE, yes. That's the first thing I checked. The notice had an address and I used exactly that one. Didn't go back to the original filing address.

0 coins

Good. Some people mix those up and send to the original filing address out of habit. The address on the RFE is the right one, as you did.

0 coins

Service center addresses do change occasionally and USCIS has had issues where old addresses still received mail for a while after a move. Using the address on the actual RFE notice is the right approach and is what USCIS instructs.

0 coins

Read through this whole thread because I had a vaguely similar situation on an I-751 — got what looked like a second request for documents I'd already included in my original filing. Ended up being a notice about a different set of documents entirely but the form looked similar enough that I panicked thinking it was a duplicate. Turned out fine but the anxiety of getting that second envelope is very real.

0 coins

The I-751 is a different process but the feeling of getting a second notice for something you already addressed is exactly the same. Glad yours turned out to be a different document set — wish I knew whether mine is the same situation.

0 coins

Different notice numbers are a key indicator. If USCIS sends two notices with different notice numbers on the same receipt number, they're two separate requests and each has to be treated on its own. If it's the same notice number arriving twice that's usually a mail issue, not a new request.

0 coins

F2A green card cases go through the National Visa Center for applicants who are abroad, but for adjustment of status inside the US, it's entirely USCIS start to finish. I see people mix these up sometimes and try to contact the National Visa Center about their I-485 — NVC doesn't handle adjustment cases. Everything for your I-485 stays with USCIS.

0 coins

Exactly right, and worth repeating. A lot of F2A beneficiaries in the US are adjusting status and have nothing to do with the National Visa Center. Some mix it up because the petition was filed for them and they assume there are multiple agencies involved at the I-485 stage. For AOS it's USCIS only.

0 coins

Had a friend who kept trying to reach NVC about their I-485 and kept getting told their case wasn't there. Took a while to understand that the NVC only handles cases going through consular processing abroad, not adjustment of status filings.

0 coins

What happens if neither response is logged and both RFE deadlines pass? I want to make sure I'm reading the situation right — if USCIS treats a non-response as abandonment, is there any way to revive the application after that?

0 coins

A denial after non-response could potentially be addressed through a motion to reopen on Form I-290B, but whether that's available and whether it's the right move is a question for an immigration attorney. The denial notice itself will say whether a motion is available. That said, the goal here is obviously to respond before any deadline, not to plan for missing it.

0 coins

An immigration attorney or accredited representative is the right person to ask about what options exist after a denial. Nobody on a forum can tell you whether you qualify for a motion or whether it would work in your situation. The denial notice is the starting point for any of those decisions.

0 coins

Hoping the Contact Center confirms the first response was received before this becomes a question that needs an attorney to answer. But the I-290B question is fair to have in the back of your mind while there's still time to avoid needing it.

0 coins

Called the Contact Center on a Monday morning for my I-485 and got through to a Tier 1 representative in about twenty minutes. The representative was able to see that an RFE response had been logged and confirmed the date it was received by the lockbox. They couldn't tell me anything about when a decision would come but at least I knew the response was in the file. That kind of confirmation is exactly what you need right now.

0 coins

Twenty minutes on a Monday morning is actually not bad. I'll plan for that this week and have my receipt number and the RFE notice number ready before I dial.

0 coins

Having the receipt number and both RFE notice numbers written down before the call will help the representative find things faster. Worth having the proof of mailing details ready too in case they ask.

0 coins

Responded to two separate RFEs on the same I-485 in different months — they were for different documents, so the situation was clear. But the experience taught me to treat each notice as its own item with its own deadline, respond to each completely, and keep copies of everything sent with delivery confirmation. If USCIS sends two requests you respond to two requests unless the Contact Center tells you the second one is superseded or linked to the first.

0 coins

That's probably the safest framing — treat the second as independent unless USCIS tells me otherwise. I'll still try to confirm on the phone first, but if I can't get clarity in time, responding to both with the same I-693 package seems like the defensive move.

0 coins

Responding to both with the same sealed I-693 and covering letter for each notice, with each notice number referenced on each response, seems like the safest paper trail if the phone call doesn't give you a definitive answer.

0 coins

Each response package should reference its own RFE notice number clearly on the cover sheet so there's no ambiguity about which request you're answering. If you send two packages, label each one clearly.

0 coins

Related posts

USCIS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure