EB-2 I-485 cross chargeability not applied spouse rest of world retrogression — what do we do?
Filed our I-485s together last spring, both of us on the same package. My priority date is current for my category but my spouse's country of birth hit retrogression around the same time our case was receipted. We're in an EB-2 petition and my spouse was born in a country that's currently backlogged. I was born in a country with no backlog at all, so the way I understood it, my spouse could use my charge country instead — that's cross chargeability. We specifically noted this in the cover letter and even included both our birth certificates. Fast forward to now and my spouse got a Request for Evidence asking her to show she has a current priority date, as if nobody even looked at the cross chargeability claim. My own case status hasn't changed and shows no RFE. Did the RFE mean they flat out rejected the cross chargeability or could it just be that the officer reviewing her file didn't connect it to mine? We respond to the RFE together or separately? And if there's a way to make them look at this again, what do we include? We've been in adjustment of status for over a year already and I really don't want her case to get stuck while mine moves forward.
76 comments

Sasha Reese
Receipt date on our case was last February, and the online account still showed 'case received' for months with nothing else. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at the Contact Center — ended up talking with a representative who confirmed the receipt date, told me the office that had the case, and noted the last notice sent on the file. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. That call at least told me where things stood so I wasn't just guessing at what the account was showing.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorWhich office did they say has your case? Ours has been with the same service center since we filed and I keep wondering if the cross chargeability claim even made it into the right hands.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Nebraska Service Center had it for us. The representative didn't say anything about why it was there or how the case was moving, just confirmed it and read back the last notice.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Two cases filed together don't always get reviewed by the same officer even at the same center. Cross chargeability is a specific thing someone has to actively apply; it doesn't flag itself automatically in the system.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Cross chargeability lets a derivative beneficiary use the principal applicant's country of chargeability when that derivative's own country is backlogged. The way it works: both of you have to be filing for the same underlying immigrant visa category, you have to be legally married, and the principal's priority date has to be current for the derivative's country of birth. USCIS needs to see that spelled out — the cover letter helps but the evidence that actually does the work is showing the qualifying relationship and both birth certificates. If the RFE on her case is asking about priority date, the response should explain cross chargeability explicitly, cite the relevant basis, include your birth certificate again, include proof of your marriage, and reference your receipt number so the officer can connect both files. Everything goes in one response by the deadline on the notice — you can't send a partial response and add more later.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorAre the deadlines on both our cases the same even though only she got the RFE? Or does mine have a separate clock I should be watching?
0 coins
Noland Curtis
The RFE deadline is only on her case — yours doesn't have an RFE, so there's no separate clock running on your file right now. The deadline printed on her notice is what controls. The RFE allows up to 84 days from the date on the notice, or 87 when it was mailed. Everything she needs to submit has to go in together in one package by that date. Missing it or sending pieces at different times is treated as asking for a decision on whatever is in the file already.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
87 days from mailing is not a standard number you just give yourself — the date is on the RFE notice itself. Use what's printed there, not a count you calculate on your own.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Agreed, the date on the notice is what you go by. The 87-day rule is just what explains why the printed date might look slightly longer than 84 days from the issue date — the notice itself has the number that matters, not any calculation.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
We went through something similar and what I wish we'd done differently was attach a cover sheet specifically titled for cross chargeability in the response, with a clear paragraph at the top saying 'this response includes a cross chargeability claim under [her] receipt number and relies on the principal applicant's chargeability under [your] receipt number.' Officers are dealing with a lot of files. Making the connection obvious is the whole game.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorDid you file your original I-485s at the same time, or was hers a separate filing? Trying to figure out whether the fact that we filed together should already be in their system or whether we need to re-establish that in the response.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Ours were filed together in the same envelope. When we responded to the RFE we still re-stated everything from scratch — marriage certificate, both birth certificates, both receipt numbers side by side — because we couldn't assume the officer pulling her file had already looked at mine.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Filing together helps but it doesn't guarantee the two files land on the same desk. The re-stating-everything approach is the safer call.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Is there any chance the RFE is just asking for updated evidence on the marriage rather than actually challenging the cross chargeability? I've seen people get these on spousal cases where they're asking for something routine, and sometimes the cross chargeability question is separate from whatever the RFE is actually requesting.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThe RFE literally says she needs to demonstrate that her priority date is current as of the cutoff date in the relevant Visa Bulletin. It doesn't ask for marriage evidence. So it feels like a direct challenge to the priority date, not a background documentation ask.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
That's a priority date challenge then, not a document request. The whole response needs to establish that her priority date is current through your chargeability, not hers.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
The Visa Bulletin cutoff language is exactly the kind of thing that trips up these responses when the applicant's country and the principal's country are different. The response needs to name your country of birth, name hers, and state which cutoff date applies to your charge country and why her case falls under it.
0 coins
Laila Prince
November of last year my biometrics notice never showed up in the mail even though the online account updated. Ended up talking to a live USCIS representative after using Claimyr — they confirmed the biometrics appointment date and the Application Support Center on file for my case. The representative also confirmed the notice had been sent. I went to the ASC on that date and everything was fine. For the cross chargeability question here: bring both birth certificates, the marriage certificate, and both I-797C receipt notices into one response package.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorWhen you went to the ASC, did you need to bring the physical notice or was knowing the date and location enough to get in?
0 coins
Laila Prince
You're supposed to bring the notice and a valid photo ID — the notice has the appointment details they verify at check-in. Knowing the date mentally doesn't substitute for having the paper.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
The ASC check-in process asks for the notice and a government-issued photo ID. Some people have had issues when they only bring one or the other.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
The RFE asking her to prove a current priority date without mentioning cross chargeability doesn't necessarily mean the claim was rejected — it may just mean it wasn't seen. Officers issue RFEs on what's in the individual file; if the cross chargeability documentation was in the cover letter and not formally part of her I-485 package in a way that made it easy to find, it might have been overlooked rather than denied. A denial would look different from an RFE.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorHow would a denial on cross chargeability grounds look compared to an RFE? I want to make sure I'm reading this right.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
A NOID — Notice of Intent to Deny — is different from an RFE. An RFE asks for more evidence; a NOID is USCIS telling you they're inclined to deny and giving you a chance to respond. What you have is an RFE, which means the door is still open. The response window on a NOID is much shorter — 30 days from the notice date, or 33 when it was mailed.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Worth underlining: an RFE is not the same as a denial and it's not a NOID. The case is still pending and responding fully by the deadline is the entire next step.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
I confused RFE and NOID for so long. Spent two weeks panicking over an RFE thinking it was basically a denial. It's not — it's a request for more information and you have time to respond.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Both people need to be adjusting through the same underlying petition for cross chargeability to apply. If she's listed as a derivative on your petition and you're the principal, that should be established already in your I-130 or the underlying EB-2 approval. Pulling that approval notice into the RFE response would help demonstrate the qualifying relationship at the petition level before you even get to the I-485 details.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorWe do have the underlying EB-2 approval and both of us are named in it. Would a copy of that notice go in as an exhibit in the RFE response, or is there a different way to reference it?
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Including a copy of the approval notice as an exhibit is exactly right. Label it, refer to it in the response letter, and explain what it shows in a sentence or two so there's no ambiguity about why it's there.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
If the EB-2 approval names both of you, that's strong evidence for the underlying relationship. The RFE response can build from that document outward to the chargeability argument.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
EB-2 cases are ROUGH right now for certain countries. My spouse's country hit retrogression too and we weren't in a cross chargeability situation so we're just waiting out the bulletin. The whole thing with dates moving forward and then backward is a lot to keep track of.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorWhen you say the bulletin moves, are you checking the cutoff dates every month or just when USCIS sends you something?
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Every month when the State Department releases it. The cutoff date changes month to month and so does whether you'd be current under either column — the Final Action Date or the Date for Filing. Watching it monthly is the only way to know where things stand.
0 coins
Payton Black
The Date for Filing and the Final Action Date are two different columns and they don't both apply to I-485 filers automatically. USCIS announces each month whether the Date for Filing is available for adjustment of status — not every month does that column open up.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
The response to the RFE needs to be one complete package. Include: a response letter that names the receipt numbers of both I-485 cases, explains that cross chargeability applies and why, cites your country of birth as the charge country, states that your priority date is current for that country as of the relevant cutoff date, and attaches as exhibits the marriage certificate, your birth certificate, her birth certificate, and the EB-2 approval notice naming both of you. Don't split this across two filings.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorShould the response go to the same address the RFE was sent from, or is there a different submission process?
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
The RFE itself tells you where and how to respond — there's usually a specific address or instructions for the online account if the case is filed there. Follow exactly what's on the RFE notice, not a general USCIS mailing address.
0 coins
Harold Oh
If the case was filed online in the USCIS online account, the evidence upload option in the account is typically how you respond to an RFE filed that way. The RFE notice for an online case would specify that.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Is the EB-2 priority date one you got from a labor certification or from an advanced degree petition? The underlying basis can sometimes matter for how the case is coded at the service center, though for the chargeability question it's really the country of birth on the petition that's doing the work, not the basis of the EB-2 itself.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorLabor certification route. The underlying PERM was approved and then we got the I-140 approval before we filed the I-485 together. Does the PERM date factor into the cross chargeability analysis at all?
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
The PERM approval date is what establishes the priority date — that's the date that needs to be current under your charge country's cutoff in the Visa Bulletin. So yes, it's the PERM date that the cross chargeability argument has to show is current, applied against your column, not hers.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Exactly right. The priority date is the PERM date, the charge country for the cross chargeability analysis is yours, and the cutoff date to check is the one that applies to your country of birth in the EB-2 row of the Visa Bulletin.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
RFE response on our I-485 had been sitting at the service center for almost two months with no update in the account. After using Claimyr, I had a representative from the Contact Center on the line who confirmed they had received our RFE response and noted the date it was recorded as received in the system. That was what I needed to know — the response wasn't sitting lost somewhere.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorDid the representative say anything about how long after they confirm receipt things typically move, or just that it was received?
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
Just that it was received and the date. No timeline given, nothing about what comes next — the representative said decisions come by notice and to watch the account.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
That's about all anyone can get from a Contact Center call on a pending RFE response — confirmation it arrived. The decision itself comes separately.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Something I want to flag for the original poster: if your case ends up moving to interview stage while hers is still stuck on the RFE, there are situations where USCIS will interview both of you together if the cases are linked. But that only happens if the cross chargeability question is resolved by then. Getting the RFE response in correctly is what unlocks any next steps.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorAre you saying the interview for both of us would be at a field office together, or that USCIS schedules them separately even on linked cases?
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Linked spousal I-485 cases usually get a joint interview at the field office if interviews are required. The cases need to be in sync for that to happen — which is another reason her RFE response matters for your case progression too, not just hers.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Whether an interview is required at all varies by case. Not every I-485 adjustment gets an interview notice. When they do schedule one, the I-797C is what comes in the mail or shows in the online account.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Can you even file cross chargeability on a case that's already been receipted and is pending? I thought this was something you established at filing and couldn't add after the fact.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Cross chargeability can be raised in an RFE response — it's not a one-shot thing that only applies at filing. If USCIS asks for evidence of a current priority date, the response explaining the chargeability basis and providing supporting evidence is exactly the right way to put it before the officer. The claim was arguably made at filing through the cover letter; the RFE response is the chance to formalize it.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Didn't realize the RFE response was the right venue for that. Makes sense if the original filing raised it and the officer just didn't process it.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
An RFE is essentially an officer saying 'show me' — so if the original filing argued chargeability and they're now asking for proof of a current date, the response is exactly where you present the full chargeability argument with documentation.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Waiting to hear how this resolves. The cross chargeability rules are genuinely confusing and a lot of people in EB-2 with mixed-country couples hit this exact wall at retrogression. The documentation path the people above have laid out is solid — birth certificates, marriage certificate, EB-2 approval, receipt numbers for both cases, clear cover letter.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorGoing to put the full package together this week. The deadline on her RFE notice gives us a few more weeks and I'd rather not use all of it.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Filing well before the deadline is wise. Submitting near the deadline is fine procedurally but leaves no room to fix anything if something bounces back.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Preparing the package early and having someone who knows immigration review it before submission is worth the time on a cross chargeability case — the argument is specific and the documentation has to match the argument exactly.
0 coins
Payton Black
Has anyone had success getting the two I-485 files linked in the USCIS online account so that updates on one show up in context with the other? Or are spousal derivative cases always listed as completely separate cases?
0 coins
Harold Oh
Each I-485 has its own receipt number and its own case entry in the account. They show separately. There's no linked view that shows both together — you have to check each one by its own receipt number.
0 coins
Payton Black
That explains why her account shows the RFE status and mine shows something different — they're genuinely separate entries even though we filed together.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Separate receipt numbers, separate entries, separate status updates. Filing together doesn't merge the cases in the account. You have to track them individually.
0 coins
Harold Oh
Have you talked to an immigration attorney about this yet? The cross chargeability argument in an RFE response is specific enough that having someone who does this regularly review the response before you send it is worth it. The rules here are real and your outline of the situation sounds correct, but the way it's argued in the written response matters a lot.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorWe have an attorney we used at the I-140 stage. Going to loop them back in specifically for the RFE response. I wanted to understand the landscape before that call so we're not just sitting there confused.
0 coins
Harold Oh
That's exactly the right call. Coming into that conversation knowing what cross chargeability requires and what the RFE is specifically asking for means you can focus the attorney's time on the response rather than the background.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Every I-485 response to an RFE needs to reach USCIS by the date on the notice, in one complete submission. The partial submission rule is real — if you send the birth certificates now and the marriage certificate later, USCIS treats the second packet as not part of the response. Everything in one envelope or one upload.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorBoth cases are filed online in the USCIS account, so the response will go through the account's upload function, not mail. Does the one-submission rule work the same way in the online system?
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Yes — same rule. Upload everything together in one go before the deadline date on the notice. The online account upload and a paper response both have to be complete the first time.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
If the online account upload fails partway through for a technical reason, that's worth documenting. But under normal circumstances plan to upload the full package in one session, not in stages.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
The person asking about whether cross chargeability can be raised post-filing had me second-guessing myself for a second, but the correction above is right. What you're doing by responding to the RFE isn't adding a new claim — you're substantiating a claim that was already in your cover letter when you filed. That's different from trying to introduce something new.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorThat framing helps. We did put it in the cover letter at filing so we're not pulling this out of thin air in the response.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Lead the response letter with that — 'as noted in the cover letter submitted with the original filing dated [date]' — and then build the documentation from there. It makes the continuity of the claim clear.
0 coins
Summer Green
My spouse and I are in a situation that's the mirror image of yours — she's the principal on an EB-2 and I'm the derivative, with my country hit by retrogression. We were told the same thing about cross chargeability and we included it at filing. No RFE yet but I've been watching the account nervously ever since retrogression hit. Reading through your situation is the most useful thing I've found on how to handle it if one comes.
0 coins
Christian Burns
AuthorIf you get an RFE, the approach people laid out here seems like the right path. Birth certificates for both, marriage certificate, the underlying EB-2 approval naming both of you, and a cover letter that makes the chargeability argument explicit. Keep copies of everything you filed originally too so you can reference your own cover letter in the response.
0 coins
Summer Green
Pulling all those documents now so they're ready if one comes. The part about the EB-2 approval naming both of us as the key linking document is something I hadn't thought about before.
0 coins
Payton Black
The month-by-month Visa Bulletin watch is real. If your country's cutoff date shifts before the RFE deadline, you might have more options — or fewer. Worth checking each month during this window.
0 coins