Will my WEP reduction decrease after reaching 20 substantial years at age 73 while still working under Social Security?
I'm coming up on a big decision about when to file for Social Security. I'm currently 68.5 years old and originally retired from the public school system in Florida at 55 with a pension. I've been working a second career in the private sector since then, which means I'll be affected by the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP). My current plan is to wait until 70 to file for Social Security benefits, at which point I'll have accumulated 17 years of substantial earnings under SS. If I continue working, by age 73 I'll reach the 20-year substantial earnings mark. Here's what confuses me: I've received conflicting information about how the WEP reduction changes once I hit 20 substantial years. Some people tell me I'll get back 5% of my full benefit for each year over 20, while others say it's a flat 10% reduction in the WEP penalty once I hit 20 years regardless of how many more years I work. I'm trying to figure out if continuing to work until 73 and beyond makes a meaningful difference in reducing the WEP impact. Anyone with experience with this specific WEP scenario who can clarify?
19 comments


NebulaNova
The WEP reduction decreases by 5% for EACH year of substantial earnings over 20 years. So once you hit 20 years at age 73, your WEP reduction drops by 5%, then another 5% for year 21, and so on. If you work until you have 30 years of substantial earnings, the WEP won't affect you at all. I was in a similar position with a California state pension. I confirmed this directly with SSA after struggling for weeks trying to get accurate information. Make sure your earnings each year meet the substantial earnings threshold - it changes yearly ($31,275 for 2025).
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
•My husband went through this exact situation. OP, the 5% per year is correct. Each year over 20 reduces the WEP penalty by 5%.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
its actually BOTH in a way lol. when u hit exactly 20 yrs, your WEP reduction drops by 10% right away (its like a bonus for hitting 20). then after that its 5% less reduction for each additional yr. so yr 21 = 15% less reduction, yr 22 = 20% less, etc. at least thats what happened with my dads benefits when he was dealing with WEP stuff a few yrs ago
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
•No, this is incorrect. There is no special "bonus" at exactly 20 years. The WEP reduction formula simply changes from a maximum of 50% reduction with 20 or fewer years to a gradually decreasing percentage. At 20 years of substantial earnings, the reduction is 45% (not 40%). Each additional year reduces it by 5 percentage points. To be completely clear: 21 years = 40% reduction 22 years = 35% reduction ... 29 years = 5% reduction 30+ years = no WEP reduction You can verify this on the SSA website. The confusion likely comes from people misunderstanding how the reduction calculation works.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
Thank you both! This clarifies a lot. So it sounds like it's definitely worth it for me to continue working at least to 73 to hit the 20-year mark, and possibly beyond if I'm able to. Each additional year would increase my benefit by reducing the WEP penalty by another 5%. What about my benefit recalculation? Will SSA automatically recalculate my benefit once I hit 20 years, or do I need to contact them and request it? I've heard their systems don't always catch these WEP changes automatically.
0 coins
NebulaNova
•Unfortunately, the SSA systems often DON'T automatically recalculate for WEP changes. You should definitely contact them once you hit the 20-year mark. Keep detailed records of your substantial earnings years as well - sometimes their records can be incomplete, especially for recent work years that might not be fully processed in their system yet.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
My wife and I spent WEEKS trying to get through to someone at Social Security who actually understood WEP when she was dealing with her teacher's pension from Arizona! The regular reps gave us completely wrong information TWICE!! We finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got us through to an agent in about 10 minutes instead of waiting on hold for hours. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU Worth every penny to finally talk to someone who knew what they were talking about!
0 coins
Nia Jackson
•That sounds really helpful. I've been dreading making that call because I know how complicated WEP issues can be. I'll check out that service when I'm ready to file. Thanks!
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
I HATE THE WEP SO MUCH!!!!! I worked for 26 years as a teacher in Texas, then 18 years in private industry. STILL got hit with this penalty even though I paid into BOTH systems fully!!! It's ROBBERY and DOUBLE TAXATION!!!! Congress needs to repeal this UNFAIR provision NOW!!!!! I lost almost $450/month because of this stupid rule!!
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
•While the WEP feels unfair, it's actually designed to prevent "double dipping" since pension-covered employment didn't contribute to Social Security. The formula is meant to maintain proportionality between what you paid in and what you receive. That said, there are legitimate concerns about how it's implemented, and there have been several congressional attempts to reform it. The Public Servants Protection and Fairness Act has been introduced multiple times to modify how WEP works.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
To directly answer your original question - it's 5% per year over 20 years of substantial earnings. Here's the exact reduction percentages based on years of substantial earnings: • 20 years: 45% reduction of the first tier of benefits • 21 years: 40% reduction • 22 years: 35% reduction • 23 years: 30% reduction • 24 years: 25% reduction • 25 years: 20% reduction • 26 years: 15% reduction • 27 years: 10% reduction • 28 years: 5% reduction • 29 years: 5% reduction • 30+ years: No reduction (WEP doesn't apply) Also important: The WEP reduction can never be more than 50% of your non-covered pension amount. And if your AIME (Average Indexed Monthly Earnings) is low, you might qualify for the WEP guarantee provision that could further limit the reduction.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
•This is incredibly helpful - thank you for providing the exact percentage reductions. I didn't know about the WEP guarantee provision. I'll need to look into that as well. Do you know if my Florida teacher's pension counts as a "non-covered pension" even though I paid into it for many years?
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
Yes, your Florida teacher's pension is almost certainly a non-covered pension if you didn't pay Social Security taxes on those earnings. Florida is one of the states where many public employees are covered by a separate retirement system instead of Social Security. One more thing to consider: if you continue working past your FRA (which you've already reached), you can actually improve your Social Security benefit in two ways simultaneously. First, by reducing the WEP penalty as others have mentioned, and second, by potentially increasing your overall benefit if your recent earnings are higher than some of the earlier years used in your 35-year calculation. Many people in your situation find it beneficial to work at least until they reach 20 substantial years, as that's when you start seeing the WEP reduction decrease.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
•That's a great point about improving my benefit in two ways! I hadn't thought about the fact that my recent earnings might replace lower earning years in my history. My current salary is definitely higher than what I made earlier in my career, even adjusted for inflation. Sounds like continuing to work until at least 73 makes a lot of financial sense.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
i retired from teaching in NY after 30 years but i never paid into social security during that time so i don't get any SS benefits at all even though my husband worked under SS his whole life. the GPO took away all my spousal benefits. at least with WEP you still get something!!!
0 coins
NebulaNova
•You're describing the Government Pension Offset (GPO), which is different from the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) that the OP is asking about. The GPO affects spousal and survivor benefits, while WEP affects your own retirement benefits. They're easy to confuse because they both impact people with non-covered pensions, but they work differently.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Just want to agree with the comments above saying each year over 20 reduces the WEP penalty by 5%. My husband's situation was almost identical to yours - teacher pension then work under Social Security. Make SURE you keep proof of your earnings each year, especially for years you're right around the substantial earnings threshold. The SSA made a mistake on one of my husband's years and it took months to fix.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
has anyone here had luck getting wep completely eliminated? my neighbor said after 30 yrs of work under SS they removed his wep completely?
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
•Yes, that's correct. If you have 30 or more years of substantial earnings under Social Security, the WEP doesn't apply at all. This is built into the WEP formula by design - at 30+ years of substantial earnings, you're treated just like someone who worked exclusively under Social Security their entire career.
0 coins