< Back to Social Security Administration

Social Security benefit estimate shows $1986 at 62 - will amount decrease if I stop working at 57?

I'm getting ready to leave my job next year (March 2025) when I turn 57. According to my Social Security statement, I'm projected to receive $1,986/month if I start claiming at 62. My question is: Does this projected amount assume I'll keep working until 62? If I stop working at 57 and have zero income for those 5 years before claiming, will my benefit amount go down? I'm trying to budget accurately for retirement and need to know if that $1,986 figure is still valid if I stop working early. If the amount does decrease, does anyone know roughly how much less I might receive? I've worked consistently for 35+ years if that matters for the calculation.

Amina Toure

•

Yes, that estimate on your statement assumes you'll continue to earn approximately what you're earning now until you reach 62. If you stop working at 57, your benefit will likely be lower than the projected $1,986. SSA calculates your benefit based on your highest 35 years of earnings (indexed for inflation). Since you've worked for 35+ years already, you have a full earnings record, which helps. However, those 5 years of zero income could affect your average. You can get a more accurate estimate by creating a my Social Security account online and using the retirement calculator where you can input future earnings (including zeros for those 5 years). That will give you a better projection.

0 coins

Paolo Esposito

•

Thanks for explaining! I do have a mySocialSecurity account (that's where I got the estimate), but I didn't realize you could input future earnings as zero. I'll go back and try that calculator option. If those 5 years of zero earnings will significantly impact my benefit, I might need to rethink my retirement timeline.

0 coins

Oliver Weber

•

I ran into this EXACT problem when i retired at 58 and then checked my benefits at 61. My estimate went down by about 13% from what it originally showed. If you worked 35 years already your not gonna see as big a drop as someone with less years worked.

0 coins

Paolo Esposito

•

That's really helpful to hear a real example! A 13% drop would put me around $1,728 instead of $1,986 - definitely something I need to factor into my budget plans. Did your benefit amount change at all between 61 and when you actually claimed?

0 coins

FireflyDreams

•

The estimate on your SS statement is WRONG!!! It assumes you keep making the SAME income until you claim. I stopped working at 59 and when I finally claimed at 62 it was almost $300 less than what my statement had been showing for years! The SSA doesn't explain this clearly enough and thousands of people plan their retirements based on incorrect numbers. You should definitely call and get a real calculation done with your actual stopping date.

0 coins

I tried calling SSA multiple times about this same issue and kept getting disconnected after waiting on hold for over an hour each time. Finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an agent in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU. The agent was able to run my numbers with my actual planned work history and it really helped with my retirement planning.

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

Your Social Security benefit is calculated using your highest 35 years of earnings, adjusted for inflation. If you've worked 35+ years already, stopping work at 57 will have less impact than if you had fewer years. However, the estimate does assume continued earnings. The impact varies based on your specific earnings history, but here's a simplified explanation: 1. If your recent years are among your highest-earning years (which is common), replacing them with zeros will lower your average. 2. If you have 35+ years of strong earnings already, and your recent years aren't significantly higher than earlier years, the impact will be smaller. 3. The exact calculation involves indexing your earnings to account for wage growth over time. You can get a precise estimate by using the detailed calculator at ssa.gov/myaccount that allows you to input future earnings as zero.

0 coins

Paolo Esposito

•

This makes perfect sense - thank you for the detailed explanation! My highest earning years have definitely been the last 10 years, so I imagine replacing 5 of those with zeros would make a difference. I'll check out the detailed calculator to see exactly how much.

0 coins

Emma Anderson

•

dont worry to much about it. social security pays basically the same to everyone anyway lol. my buddy worked way less than me and gets almost the same.

0 coins

Malik Thompson

•

That's not accurate. Social Security benefits are directly tied to your earnings history. The reason your buddy might get almost the same could be due to the progressive nature of the benefit formula (it replaces a higher percentage of income for lower earners) or because the maximum benefit is capped. But two people with significantly different earnings histories will definitely receive different benefit amounts.

0 coins

Malik Thompson

•

Your benefit estimate will change if you stop working before 62. The statement projection assumes you'll continue earning at roughly your current level until the age shown in the estimate. Since you mentioned 35+ years of work, you already have a complete earnings record (SS uses your highest 35 years). The impact of stopping at 57 depends on: 1. Whether your recent earnings are higher than earlier years in your record 2. How many of those 35+ years were at lower earnings levels that might still be in your top 35 Based on typical career progression, stopping 5 years early might reduce your benefit by approximately 5-15%. You can get an exact calculation using the detailed calculator in your mySocialSecurity account or by scheduling an appointment with SSA.

0 coins

FireflyDreams

•

The 5-15% reduction estimate is WAY too optimistic in many cases! I've seen people with reductions of 20-25% when they stopped working many years before claiming. It REALLY depends on your specific earnings history and whether those last 5 years would have replaced lower-earning years from early in your career.

0 coins

Paolo Esposito

•

Thanks everyone for the helpful responses! I'm going to log into mySocialSecurity and use the detailed calculator to get a more accurate estimate based on stopping work at 57. Sounds like I should expect somewhat of a reduction from the $1,986 figure, but hopefully not too dramatic since I have a full 35-year work history already. I might also try calling SSA directly to get their calculation. That Claimyr service someone mentioned sounds worth trying if I can't get through on my own. This has been really eye-opening - I had no idea the estimates assumed continued earnings! Makes me wonder what other retirement planning assumptions I might be missing...

0 coins

Oliver Weber

•

smart move! i wish id checked all this BEFORE i retired early. would have changed some of my decisions. good luck!

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
7,105 users helped today