Can I suspend and repay SS retirement benefits taken early to get higher FRA amount?
I started receiving my Social Security retirement benefits last month at 62 years and 7 months. Now I'm having second thoughts because the monthly amount seems pretty low compared to what I'd get at my full retirement age (66 and 10 months). If I suspend my benefits now and pay back what I've already received, will my future monthly amount be higher when I restart at my FRA? I've only received one payment so far of about $1,875. Is there a time limit for doing this? And would I have to pay back the Medicare premium they already deducted? I'm so confused about how this all works.
19 comments
Evelyn Kim
Yes, you can absolutely do this! It's called a withdrawal of application (Form SSA-521). Since you're within 12 months of first receiving benefits, you can withdraw your application, repay all benefits received, and it'll be like you never filed early. When you reapply at your FRA, you'll get your full, unreduced benefit amount. You'll need to repay everything you've received, including any Medicare premiums deducted. The good news is you've only received one payment, so the amount to repay is relatively small compared to someone who's been collecting for months.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•Thank you so much! Do I need to go to the local office to submit the form or can I do this online? Also, after I withdraw, would I need to reapply when I reach my FRA or will they automatically start my benefits?
0 coins
Diego Fisher
I did this exact thing last year! Started at 62, regretted it after 2 months, paid it back, and now waiting till my FRA. Best decision ever. The form was easy but make sure u do it BEFORE 12 months pass!
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•That's great to hear it worked out for you! Did your Medicare coverage continue after you withdrew your application? I'm not sure if I'll have to re-enroll in that separately.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
Just want to add that what you're describing is different from "suspending" benefits. Suspending benefits is what you can do AFTER you reach Full Retirement Age if you want to earn delayed retirement credits until age 70. What you need is a withdrawal of application since you're within 12 months of filing. Also, important to know you can only do this withdrawal ONE TIME in your life, so be sure this is what you want.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•Oh that's important to know! I didn't realize there was a difference between withdrawal and suspension. And I definitely didn't know about the one-time limit. Thank you for clarifying!
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Wait but what about taxes??? I thought you had to pay back the GROSS amount before any taxes were taken out? Then you get the taxes back when you file next year?? That's what happened to my brother-in-law.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
•That's correct. You need to repay the gross benefit amount before any deductions like taxes. When you file your taxes for this year, you'll get credit for any Social Security benefits that were taxed since you've paid them back. The SSA will give you a letter confirming the repayment that you can use for your tax filing.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
I tried calling SSA three times this week to ask about withdrawing my application and got disconnected every time after waiting over an hour. Finally, I used Claimyr.com to get through to a representative in under 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU The SSA rep confirmed I needed form SSA-521 and that I had to include a check for the full amount I'd received. They also explained I'd need to reapply when I reach FRA - it's not automatic.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•That sounds really helpful! I've been trying to get through on the phone too with no luck. I'll check out that service. Did they charge a lot for it?
0 coins
Faith Kingston
•It was worth every penny given the hours I wasted on hold before. The representative I spoke with was really knowledgeable and helped me understand exactly what I needed to do. Much better than trying to figure it out from the website alone.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
my cousin tried to do this but got denied!!! said he missed the 12 month deadline by 3 days so be careful!!!
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
•Yes, the SSA is extremely strict about that 12-month deadline. There are no exceptions to this rule. Once you're past 12 months, your only option is to suspend benefits after reaching FRA, but you can't withdraw the application and erase the early filing reduction.
0 coins
Liam Brown
Just a heads up - your benefit at FRA will be significantly higher than what you're getting now. Taking benefits at 62 and 7 months means you're getting about 27% less than your FRA amount. So if you're currently getting $1,875, your FRA benefit would be around $2,570 per month. That's nearly $700 more per month or $8,400 more per year! And that difference continues for the rest of your life. If your health is good and you can afford to wait, paying back now and reapplying at FRA makes a lot of financial sense, especially if you have a family history of longevity.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•Wow, seeing those numbers really puts it in perspective! I think I'm definitely going to withdraw and wait until FRA. I'm still working part-time and have some savings, so I should be able to manage. My parents both lived into their 90s, so the higher amount will be better long-term.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Make sure u fill out the form PERFECTLY!!!! My friend had hers rejected cuz she didn't include her phone # and had to start over!!!
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•Thanks for the warning! I'll double-check everything before I submit it. Maybe I should take it to the local office in person to make sure everything is correct.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
One last thing to consider - if you withdraw now, you'll need to reapply for Medicare separately when you turn 65 if you're not already on it. The automatic enrollment only happens when you're receiving Social Security benefits. Also, once you withdraw, you should wait until your FRA to reapply unless your financial situation changes. If you reapply before FRA, you'll still get a reduced benefit (though not as reduced as starting at 62).
0 coins
Margot Quinn
•Thank you for all this information! I just turned 63 so Medicare is still a couple years away for me. I'm going to fill out the SSA-521 form tomorrow and get a cashier's check for the repayment amount. This has been incredibly helpful!
0 coins