Can I repay 6 months of Social Security benefits to restart at higher rate later?

Thank you so much! Do you know if I'd need to include interest when I repay? And would this affect my Medicare enrollment at all? I'm trying to figure out if this makes financial sense given the higher benefit amount I could get by waiting until my FRA.

That's really helpful to know! Did you have any issues with the process? How long did it take from submitting the form until they processed everything?

I had the same problem trying to reach SSA about my disability review. Kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. Finally used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a real person in under 10 minutes. They have a demo video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU - saved me so much frustration when dealing with the withdrawal paperwork.

This is excellent advice. When you withdraw your application using Form SSA-521, you're essentially erasing the fact that you ever received those benefits. This means you may need to file amended tax returns for any year in which you reported Social Security benefits as income. The tax implications can be complex depending on your other income and whether you paid taxes on 50% or 85% of your benefits.

You're thinking of two different things. Yes, there is an earnings limit ($22,320 in 2025) if you're working while collecting benefits before your Full Retirement Age. If you exceed that, SSA withholds $1 in benefits for every $2 earned above the limit. What the original poster is asking about is completely different - it's a one-time option to fully withdraw your application within 12 months of first receiving benefits, pay everything back, and start fresh later. This isn't related to working - it's basically a complete do-over.

This is an excellent point about voluntary suspension! If you're approaching your Full Retirement Age, you might want to consider this alternative strategy. After reaching FRA, you can ask SSA to suspend your retirement benefits, which allows you to earn delayed retirement credits of 8% per year until age 70. The advantage of this approach is that you don't have to repay any benefits already received. However, since you started benefits at 64 and are working now, the withdrawal option might be more advantageous if you can afford to repay the benefits, especially if you're planning to work for several more years.

That's definitely not correct. When you submit Form SSA-521, the SSA will send you a letter telling you exactly how much you need to repay and providing payment instructions. You typically have multiple payment options, including check or money order by mail, or possibly electronic payment. You absolutely do not need to bring cash to an SSA office. Your cousin may have misunderstood or unfortunately encountered a misinformed SSA representative.

That sounds like a nightmare. Did she eventually get everything sorted out? Was it worth it in the end for the higher benefit amount?

She says it was totally worth it! Her monthly benefit will be like $600 more per month when she claims again at 70. But she was super organized with all her paperwork which helped a lot.

Thank you for this practical advice! Doing the math, I think my break-even would be around 30 months since I'd get about $450 more per month by waiting until my FRA. Given my family history of longevity (parents both lived into their 90s), this seems like a good financial move. I'm going to download Form SSA-521 today and start this process. Really appreciate everyone's help!