< Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

Luca Ricci

PA UC eligibility with current Workers' Comp claim? Quit 2nd job due to lack of work

I'm in a complicated situation and really confused about my UC eligibility in PA. I've been working 2 jobs as a home health aide - my main job since January 2023 (still employed there) and a second job from March 2023 until October 2023. For my second job, I ended up quitting after they had no clients for me for almost 6 weeks straight. Even after giving my two weeks notice, they still said they had no clients available for me. Now here's where it gets tricky - I'm currently collecting Workers' Comp from my first job because I got injured on the job. Can I also apply for partial unemployment from the second job I quit? Does being on Workers' Comp disqualify me? I feel like I had good cause to quit the second job since they basically had no work for me for over a month.

You might qualify for PA benefits since u quit cuz they didn't have work for u - that's usually considered employer's fault not yours. But the workers comp thing complicates everything. Not sure if u can collect both???

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

Yeah I'm so confused about the Workers Comp part! I'm not even sure if I should mention it when applying or just apply based on the job I left?

0 coins

This is a unique situation that requires careful handling. In Pennsylvania, you can potentially qualify for UC benefits if you quit due to lack of work - this is considered a necessitous and compelling reason to leave employment. The employer essentially constructively discharged you by not providing work for 6 weeks. However, the Workers' Compensation complication is significant. You must report all income when filing for UC, including Workers' Comp benefits. This may reduce your UC benefit amount or potentially make you ineligible depending on how much you receive from Workers' Comp. PA UC requires you to be able and available for suitable work, which might be questioned if you're receiving Workers' Comp. I recommend applying anyway and being completely truthful about both situations. Let UC make the determination rather than assuming you won't qualify.

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

Thank you so much for the detailed explanation! So if I understand correctly, I should file for UC and make sure to include both that I'm receiving Workers' Comp AND that I quit my second job due to them not providing work? I'm worried about accidentally committing fraud or something.

0 coins

Yuki Watanabe

•

When I was on workers comp last year I tried to get UC too and they DENIED me because I wasn't "able and available" for work according to them!!! The system is rigged man, they'll find any excuse not to pay you. Good luck getting through to anyone on the phone too - I spent WEEKS trying!!!

0 coins

Your situation might have been different. If your Workers' Comp claim indicated you couldn't work at all, then yes, you wouldn't qualify for UC. But if the original poster is on partial disability and could potentially work some hours or in a different capacity than their injured position, they might still qualify for partial benefits. Each case is evaluated individually.

0 coins

Hey there, I went through something kinda similar last year. Honestly, the only way I finally got through to someone at PA UC was using Claimyr (claimyr.com). I was stuck in limbo with a complicated claim too and couldn't get anyone on the phone for weeks. They got me connected to an actual UC rep in about 20 minutes! They have a video that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2 The rep I talked to explained exactly how Workers' Comp affects UC eligibility in my case. Your situation sounds even more complicated than mine was, so talking to someone directly is probably your best bet rather than guessing.

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

Thanks for this! I've been trying to call for days and just get the busy signal every time. I'll check out that service - at this point I'm desperate to just talk to someone who can give me a clear answer.

0 coins

Yuki Watanabe

•

Be careful with those services! They just call for u and charge $$$ for something you can do yourself if ur patient enough! But whatever, do what u need to do I guess...

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

To clarify some confusion in this thread: Pennsylvania UC law does consider leaving employment due to lack of work as a qualifying separation. However, Workers' Compensation creates specific eligibility issues: 1) You must report all income including Workers' Comp when filing weekly claims 2) Your UC weekly benefit amount may be reduced based on your Workers' Comp payments 3) Most importantly, you need to be medically released to work in some capacity The key question is whether your Workers' Comp claim indicates total disability (which would make you ineligible for UC) or partial disability (which might allow partial UC benefits). Ask your Workers' Comp doctor for a clear statement about your work capabilities. This documentation will be crucial for your UC claim. The UC office will likely send you a form to have completed regarding your ability to work.

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

This is incredibly helpful! I'm on partial disability and technically could work some jobs with restrictions. I'll definitely get documentation from my doctor about my work capabilities before I apply. Do you know if there's a specific form I should have them fill out or just a doctor's note?

0 coins

Zoe Papadakis

•

I'm a home health aide too!!!! I got hurt last year lifting a patient and was on workers comp for 3 months. My doctor cleared me for light duty but my agency had nothing available so I applied for unemployment and got it!!! But I had to send in the doctors note saying I could work with restrictions. Every week when I filed I had to report my workers comp payment and they reduced my UC payment. It was still something though!

0 coins

Luca Ricci

•

OMG this sounds exactly like my situation! Did they give you a hard time about quitting your job or was it pretty straightforward since you had documentation? And how long did the whole process take?

0 coins

Zoe Papadakis

•

My situation was a little different because they didn't have light duty work for me (I didn't quit). But the whole process took about 3 weeks from application to first payment. Make sure you upload all your documentation right away through the portal! That speeds things up a lot.

0 coins

ThunderBolt7

•

I had a somewhat similar situation where I was receiving WC benefits and tried to claim UC from a previous employer. Be extremely careful here - there are specific rules about what you need to report. If your WC is for total disability, then PA UC will likely deny benefits because you're not able to work. You mentioned you got hurt at your first job - are you still technically employed there but just collecting WC? If so, you'll need to explain that you're collecting WC from an employer you still work for (but are on leave from), while claiming UC from a different employer you no longer work for. I strongly recommend getting a formal determination from UC rather than guessing. Be 100% honest about your WC status when you apply. In my case, I was initially denied but was able to appeal and eventually received benefits.

0 coins

Jamal Edwards

•

Quick question - when u appealed, did u have to attend a hearing? I'm going thru something similar and just got a hearing notice in the mail and im freaking out about it.

0 coins

Didnt u have to be lookin for work to get UC? How does that work with workers comp?

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

Good question. If you're on partial disability through Workers' Comp and are medically cleared for specific types of work, you can limit your work search to jobs within your medical restrictions. You'd still need to complete and document your work search activities each week (applying to jobs, attending interviews, etc.) but only for positions you're physically capable of performing. The PA UC system allows for this type of limitation as long as it's medically documented.

0 coins

Pennsylvania Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,080 users helped today