Will NY unemployment take my new benefits to cover an old overpayment from when I started a job?

Yeah, they will most likely take a percentage from each weekly payment until the overpayment is paid off. Your claim will stay active. When I had an overpayment they took 50% of each payment until it was paid back. Dont worry too much, they wont cancel your current benefits completely.

After dealing with the same nightmare of trying to reach ny unemployment for weeks, I finally found a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an actual human at unemployment. Talking to a real person got my overpayment situation sorted in one call - they explained exactly how much would be taken and gave me options. Best thing I've done to get my benefits flowing properly again. Check out their process here: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE

When this happened to me they took 25% of each weekly payment until I paid back what I owed. They sent me a notice first explaining everything. Your claim stays active but your payments are just reduced. You can also call and try to negotiate a payment plan if the reduction is too much for your budget.

THIIIIIIS SYSTEM IS A JOKE. they make simple mistakes and then we gotta suffer. they probably messed up the dates and now ur on the hook. fight it if u can prove u reported correctly. dont just accept it!!1!

If they determine there was an overpayment, they typically recoup it by withholding a percentage (usually between 25-50%) of your current weekly benefits until the overpayment is satisfied. Your claim will remain active during this process. Here's what you need to know: • They should send you a formal Notice of Determination explaining the overpayment amount and how they'll collect it • You have the right to appeal the determination if you disagree • In some cases, you can request a waiver if repayment would cause financial hardship • Your weekly certification process remains the same • The recoupment amount is typically withheld automatically I recommend calling them directly to discuss your specific situation. The automated phone system can be frustrating, but I had success using claimyr.com to get through to a representative quickly. Having a direct conversation about your case will give you the clearest answers about your particular situation. Keep all documentation showing when you reported starting your job last year, as this could be crucial if you need to appeal their determination.

Had this exact situation last month. They took 30% of my weekly payment until the balance was paid off. Your claim stays active - they just reduce the payment amount you receive each week. The annoying part was they didn't tell me ahead of time - my payment just showed up smaller one week.

Im on my 3rd claim with ny unemployment (construction worker, layoffs are normal for us). They ALWAYS find something wrong with previous claims lol. Don't stress. They'll take a percentage of your weekly benefits until it's paid. Your claim stays active. Just annoying to deal with smaller payments for a while.

Omg I'm dealing with the EXACT same thing right now. They said I had a 3 week overlap from 2022 and now they're taking 50% of my current benefits to pay it back. But my claim is still active, don't worry about that part at least.

Everyone here is correct that they'll take a percentage of your benefits, BUT what nobody mentioned is that you can request a payment plan or even appeal the overpayment determination entirely if you have proof you reported correctly. Don't just accept their determination without questioning it!

They'll deduct from ur current benefits but ur claim stays active. BUT! check if the overpayment was due to fraud or non-fraud! if it's non-fraud (honest mistake) they take less percentage. If they say it's fraud they can take up to 100% until paid off. Make sure to clarify that when u talk to them!!!

I swear the NY unemployment system is DESIGNED to be confusing so they can claim overpayments later. But to answer your question: yes they'll keep your claim active and just reduce your weekly payment amount until the overpayment is satisfied.

After 30+ failed attempts to get through to unemployment on my own, I broke down and tried that Claimyr service (claimyr.com). They actually connected me to an agent when I had an overpayment issue like yours. The agent reduced my repayment percentage from 50% to 20% when I explained my financial situation. Worth every penny to get that resolved quickly instead of stressing for weeks.

The amount they reclaim depends on the type of overpayment. If it's non-fraud (honest mistake), they take 25-50%. If they determine it was fraudulent (deliberately misreported), they can take up to 100% of your benefits until it's repaid. Either way, your claim remains active.

In my experience with ny unemployment, they'll keep your claim active but reduce your weekly payment. The bigger issue is that they don't always tell you BEFORE they start taking the money. My payment suddenly dropped by 35% one week with no warning. Had to call multiple times to figure out why.

Hi, I work as a benefits counselor. Yes, your claim will remain active while they recoup the overpayment. They typically withhold a percentage (25-50%) of your weekly benefit until the overpayment is recovered. You have the right to appeal the determination or request a waiver if repayment would cause financial hardship.