Back to New York Unemployment

Miguel Alvarez

Why don t employers want to pay unemployment - what I learned filing my NYSDOL claim

So I got laid off from my warehouse job about six weeks ago and started digging into how the whole unemployment system actually works. Filed my claim with NYSDOL right away, reported everything correctly, thought I was good. Then I get this notice that my former employer is contesting the claim and I'm going into adjudication. That's when I started actually researching why employers fight these things so hard. Turns out the whole system is set up so employers have a real financial reason to push back. Their unemployment insurance tax rate goes up every time a former employee successfully collects benefits. It's tied to something called an experience rating - basically the more claims that get paid out against an employer's account, the more they pay into the state fund going forward. So from their perspective, contesting your claim isn't personal, it's just them trying to protect their tax rate. What gets me is that my employer listed the reason for separation as 'voluntary quit' when I absolutely did not quit. I was told my position was eliminated. Now I'm stuck in adjudication waiting for NYSDOL to sort it out and I have no idea how long this takes or what I should be doing in the meantime. Anyone else dealt with a contested claim where the employer lied about the separation reason? How did adjudication go for you?

Week three of adjudication here when I hit my wall with this same thing. My employer checked 'resigned voluntarily' on their paperwork even though my whole department got restructured and my role disappeared. The phone situation with NYSDOL almost broke me - I'd dial in first thing in the morning and still sit on hold for two hours before the line dropped. Someone in a Facebook group I'm in mentioned Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up on the phone with a live agent without having to burn your whole morning. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see before trying it. I finally got an actual NYSDOL rep on the line and she told me my adjudication was pending because the employer's stated reason conflicted with what I'd written. She flagged it for a determination specialist. Approved two weeks later.

0 coins

My employer did the exact same thing - 'voluntary resignation' when I have texts showing my manager said the contract wasn't being renewed. I've been trying to get through to NYSDOL for days. Does the adjudication interviewer actually look at evidence you submit or does it just sit in a pile somewhere?

0 coins

I'm not sure the timeline works quite the way you described it - two weeks after the agent flagged it feels fast to me. My adjudication ran six weeks even after I spoke to someone. Did they give you any sense of why yours moved quicker?

0 coins

My fourth week into the same limbo right now. I keep filing my weekly claims and doing my three job searches like I'm supposed to but every time I check my Unemployment Services account it still just says 'pending adjudication.' The uncertainty is genuinely affecting my sleep.

0 coins

Sixth week of fighting my own contested claim and I can walk you through what's actually happening on the employer side because I researched this obsessively. The experience rating system is the core of it. NYSDOL assigns each employer a tax rate based on how many former employees have drawn benefits against their account over the past few years. A smaller company especially feels this sharply - one or two successful unemployment claims can bump their rate noticeably. So contesting claims, even ones they know they'll probably lose, can be worth it to them financially because some claimants give up and stop pursuing it. The key thing to know is that NYSDOL's adjudication process is specifically designed to cut through the conflicting statements. They'll look at your separation paperwork, your statement, the employer's statement, and any documentation either side provides. If your employer says you quit and you say you were laid off, the burden actually shifts to the employer to prove you quit voluntarily. That's the part a lot of people don't realize.

0 coins

That last part is what I needed to hear - that the employer has to actually prove I quit rather than me having to prove I didn't. I submitted a written statement through my Unemployment Services portal explaining the whole situation. Is there anything else I should be sending in?

0 coins

I'd push back gently on one piece of this - my adjudication coordinator told me the burden language is a bit more nuanced than a clean flip. Both sides submit evidence and NYSDOL weighs it. It's not quite like a court where burden of proof sits squarely on one party. Still, employers who falsely claim voluntary quit without documentation tend to lose.

0 coins

My HR department tried the same tactic on me and I had an email chain proving they eliminated my position. I sent that in through the portal and my adjudication was resolved in my favor within about three weeks. Document everything you have.

0 coins

My layoff paperwork actually said 'position eliminated due to restructuring' in writing, which I would have thought made my claim bulletproof, but my employer STILL contested it. I think some companies just contest every single claim automatically as standard practice regardless of the facts, because even a small percentage of people who abandon their claims saves them money on their tax rate over time. The experience rating system basically creates an incentive for employers to be adversarial toward former workers even when those workers clearly qualify. It's a structural problem baked into how UI is funded in New York.

0 coins

My former company had a third-party unemployment management firm handling all their claim contests - there are actual businesses whose whole model is contesting UI claims on behalf of employers. That's how routine it is for bigger companies.

0 coins

Having it in writing that my position was eliminated should help my case I'd think. I've been holding onto every piece of paper from my separation. Did you end up getting your benefits eventually?

0 coins

My manager at a previous job straight up told me after I left that the company contracted with one of those services. They contest everything and let the third party sort out what sticks. It's genuinely a whole industry.

0 coins

I had no idea this was such a systematic thing. I always assumed employer contests were specific to situations where there was actually a dispute about what happened.

0 coins

My situation involved a 'performance improvement plan' that I genuinely believe was designed to push me out rather than actually improve anything - I resigned after they made the conditions unbearable. That put me in a gray area because technically I did resign. What I learned is there's a specific NYSDOL rule that covers this: if an employer made your working conditions so unreasonable that a reasonable person in the same situation would also have quit, it can still qualify as effectively being forced out rather than a true voluntary quit. It's called constructive discharge and it's worth knowing about if anyone's in a similar boat. I had to document everything - the PIP terms, emails from my supervisor, the whole paper trail. My claim went to adjudication and I did eventually get approved but it took about ten weeks total.

0 coins

I'm not sure your situation and mine are quite the same since I actually never resigned at all, but the constructive discharge thing is something I'd never heard of. Good to know it exists as a category.

0 coins

My sister went through that exact scenario - PIP that felt designed to fail followed by a resignation. She didn't know about constructive discharge and just assumed she didn't qualify. Wish she'd known this earlier.

0 coins

Ten weeks is a long time. Were you filing your weekly claims the whole time during adjudication? I've been keeping up with mine but I wasn't sure if I was supposed to keep doing that while the dispute is pending.

0 coins

You should absolutely keep filing weekly claims during adjudication - this is really important. If your claim is approved, NYSDOL goes back and pays the weeks you certified for. If you stop filing, you lose those weeks permanently even if you win the adjudication.

0 coins

My whole experience with NYSDOL during my contested claim was maddening until I tried Claimyr. I'd been attempting to reach someone for three weeks - early mornings, lunch hour, tried different days - and kept either hitting the automated system or getting dropped after long waits. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an actual agent who pulled up my file while I was on the phone with her. She confirmed my employer had submitted a contest form and told me exactly what documentation would strengthen my adjudication case. That one conversation was worth more than three weeks of failed attempts to reach anyone.

0 coins

My call attempts have been going the same way - I've tried every time window people suggest online and nothing works. How long did it take before you were talking to the agent?

0 coins

I'm a little skeptical about whether the agent you reached would actually be able to tell you what documentation helps - in my experience NYSDOL staff vary a lot in how much detail they'll share about pending adjudications.

0 coins

My agent was genuinely helpful but I'll say you're right that it probably varies. The bigger win for me was just confirming my claim was actually in the system correctly and understanding where it sat in the process. That alone was worth it after weeks of not knowing anything.

0 coins

My employer contested my claim and listed 'misconduct' as the reason, which is even worse than voluntary quit because misconduct is a disqualifying offense under NYSDOL rules. I had to file a detailed rebuttal through my Unemployment Services portal and wait through adjudication. What the NYSDOL adjudication process actually does in these cases is look at whether the employer can back up the misconduct claim with specifics - documented warnings, HR records, that kind of thing. If they're just throwing the word 'misconduct' out there without documentation, it usually doesn't hold up. My case took about eight weeks and was resolved in my favor. The key was writing a thorough, factual statement and not getting emotional about it even though I was furious.

0 coins

Misconduct must be so stressful because it sounds so serious. I'm glad yours got resolved - did they ever give you a reason why the employer's claim didn't hold up or just notify you of the outcome?

0 coins

My notification just said the employer failed to establish misconduct within the meaning of the Labor Law. No real detail beyond that but honestly I didn't need more than the word 'approved' at that point.

0 coins

My HR actually used the word 'misconduct' in an exit interview when what they really meant was a performance issue. Those are legally different things in New York - performance problems alone don't meet the threshold for misconduct disqualification.

0 coins

My patience finally gave out after four weeks of adjudication with no updates and I managed to get through to NYSDOL on a Thursday afternoon after literally sitting on hold for about 95 minutes. The rep told me my employer had submitted documentation but that it had been assigned to a determination specialist and I should hear something within two weeks. What I found out from that call that nobody tells you upfront: during adjudication you might also get a call from an NYSDOL interviewer who wants to ask you questions about your separation. If you miss that call and don't respond, it can actually delay or hurt your determination. So if you're in adjudication, keep your phone accessible and make sure your contact info in your Unemployment Services account is current.

0 coins

My phone number in my account might actually be an old number. Going to update that right now - I hadn't thought about that at all. Thank you for mentioning it.

0 coins

Four weeks of calling before getting through - I'm on week two of trying and already losing my mind. Did you try different times of day or just keep hitting the same window?

0 coins

Thursdays and Fridays in the early afternoon have worked better for me than Monday mornings which seem to be the absolute worst time to try. Still not guaranteed but anecdotally the lines seem slightly less jammed mid-week.

0 coins

My layoff came with a severance package and I initially wasn't sure if that affected my NYSDOL eligibility at all. For anyone in the same boat - severance typically doesn't disqualify you from unemployment in New York, but how it's structured can affect your benefit start date in some cases. The employer contesting my claim tried to argue the severance meant I wasn't unemployed yet, which is not really how NYSDOL treats it. The adjudication came back in my favor but it took about seven weeks. I'd say the most useful thing I did was write a very clear, chronological account of my separation - date I was notified, what I was told, by whom, severance terms, final day of work. Put it all in the portal and kept it factual.

0 coins

The chronological account idea is good - I've been trying to write mine out and I keep getting tangled up in trying to explain context. Keeping it to dates and facts is probably smarter.

0 coins

I'd just double-check whether your severance was paid as a lump sum or as continued salary payments, because those can be treated differently in terms of when your benefit year effectively starts. Worth clarifying with NYSDOL if you're not sure.

0 coins

My severance dragged on for a confusing few weeks because my former company paid it out slowly and I wasn't sure when to file. Filed as soon as my employment actually ended and it worked out fine.

0 coins

My whole view on this changed when I actually read through some of the NYSDOL employer handbook stuff online. The experience rating can swing an employer's tax rate quite a bit depending on their size and industry. For a company with thin margins and a lot of hourly turnover, unemployment insurance costs are a real budget line they actively manage. That's why a lot of HR departments have standing instructions to contest any claim that isn't cut and dried. It's not cruelty, it's accounting. That doesn't make it less frustrating when you're on the wrong end of it, but understanding the logic helps you approach the adjudication process more strategically - document your side thoroughly, stay factual, and let the process work. I used Claimyr when I was trying to understand where my adjudication stood and it was genuinely the first time I spoke to an actual NYSDOL agent after weeks of trying on my own. The agent walked me through what was in my file and what the next steps were.

0 coins

Your point about HR having standing contest instructions rings true based on what my former coworkers told me. Apparently they contest everything under a certain threshold automatically.

0 coins

My former employer was a mid-size company and I later heard from a colleague still there that they have a policy of contesting any claim where there's any ambiguity in the separation. They basically outsource the judgment call to the appeals process.

0 coins

Understanding it as a financial calculation rather than personal animosity actually does help me feel less targeted by the whole thing. Still stressful but different kind of stress.

0 coins

My determination letter finally came yesterday after nine weeks - approved. I want to give people a sense of what the whole adjudication arc looked like from my end. Weeks one and two: filed claim, employer contested almost immediately, claim went to adjudication. Weeks three through five: filed weekly claims, did job searches, heard nothing. Week six: got an NYSDOL interviewer's voicemail asking me to phone the office, I returned it the same day and spoke with her for about twenty minutes. She asked me to walk through the separation in my own words. Weeks seven and eight: more silence, kept filing weekly claims. Week nine: determination letter arrived saying employer failed to establish voluntary separation. All the weekly claims I'd been filing paid out within a few days of the determination. So keep filing even when you hear nothing.

0 coins

This timeline is exactly what I needed to see - I was imagining it going on indefinitely. Nine weeks is hard but at least there's an end point and the back pay came through. Really glad to hear it worked out.

0 coins

I'm not sure everyone's timeline is this predictable - mine stretched to nearly fourteen weeks because the employer submitted additional documentation late in the process. But the structure you described is basically right.

0 coins

My determination also came as a letter and not through the online portal, which surprised me. I'd been checking my Unemployment Services account constantly and the letter showed up in my mailbox before anything changed online.

0 coins

My situation has a wrinkle I haven't seen discussed here: I was technically laid off but I'd also had a performance review two months before that was mixed. I'm worried my employer is going to try to fold that into a misconduct argument even though the stated reason for my layoff was budget cuts. Is there any way to preemptively address that in my adjudication statement or should I just stick to the facts about my separation and not mention the performance review at all?

0 coins

My instinct and what worked for me: stick to the separation facts unless the employer brings up the performance review in their contest. If you volunteer it, you give them an angle they might not have been planning to use. Let them lead and respond to what they actually claim.

0 coins

I'd lean the same way - in my own adjudication the determination specialist specifically said she was focused on the reason for separation, not my overall performance history. The question is why you stopped working there, not whether you were a perfect employee.

0 coins

Your determination specialist is going to be looking at what actually caused the separation. Budget cuts resulting in a layoff and 'misconduct' are very different legal categories and an employer can't just switch the stated reason after the fact without it raising flags.

0 coins

My former coworker is in the middle of her own NYSDOL adjudication right now and she's been trying to reach someone at NYSDOL for two weeks with no luck. I told her about this thread and she asked me to ask on her behalf: if the employer submitted documentation to NYSDOL during the contest, is there any way the claimant can see what the employer actually said? She's worried they may have included things that are factually wrong and she wants to respond to them directly.

0 coins

My understanding is that during adjudication you typically don't have full access to the employer's submitted documentation the way you would in a formal appeal hearing. The interviewer may share what the employer's stated reason is but not necessarily the full file.

0 coins

If the adjudication doesn't go her way, the appeal hearing is where she'd have full rights to see and respond to the employer's evidence. At the appeal level it's much more like an actual proceeding with both sides presenting.

0 coins

My adjudication interviewer actually read me a summary of what the employer had submitted when I spoke with her by phone. Not the full document but enough to understand their position and address it. Worth asking about when she reaches someone.

0 coins

My background is in HR so I want to give a clearer picture of how employers actually approach unemployment costs, since I've seen it from the inside. Every New York employer pays into the state unemployment insurance fund, but the rate they pay varies based on their claim history. NYSDOL tracks what's called a 'benefit charge' every time a former employee collects - that charge factors into the employer's experience rating, which in turn determines their tax rate. For companies with high turnover, those charges add up fast. What I saw in practice is that companies with dedicated HR teams often do a quick cost-benefit calculation: how likely are we to win this contest versus how much will we spend on the third-party service to fight it versus the potential rate impact if we don't. Smaller companies often just contest everything because they haven't thought it through. Either way, your best defense in adjudication is clean documentation of the actual separation.

0 coins

This is the most useful framing I've seen. So from the employer's side it really is just math. That's clarifying even if it's also kind of depressing.

0 coins

My former company was definitely the 'contest everything' type - probably twenty employees or fewer and no dedicated HR. I don't think anyone there was doing sophisticated calculations, they just reflexively pushed back.

0 coins

My HR at a larger company had a whole flowchart for which claim types to contest and which to let go. It was completely systematized. 'Position elimination with documentation' was actually in the 'don't contest' category, which makes the OP's situation extra frustrating.

0 coins

My own adjudication wrapped up about a month ago and I want to add something to the phone access conversation since it came up earlier. I was in the same boat trying to reach NYSDOL - multiple attempts over two weeks with no luck getting through to a human. Tried Claimyr and ended up talking to an agent the same day. I'd already submitted my documentation through the portal but there's genuinely no substitute for talking to someone who can actually open your file and tell you what they see. The thing nobody explains clearly is that NYSDOL's adjudication and appeals are handled by different units and knowing which one has your case matters a lot when you're trying to get information.

0 coins

My case is still in adjudication so at least I know I'm in the right unit. But I didn't realize adjudication and appeals were completely separate departments. That's useful to know if mine doesn't go well.

0 coins

I've been frustrated because every time I call the main NYSDOL line, I feel like I'm reaching whoever picks up randomly rather than anyone with actual knowledge of my claim. Getting routed to someone in the right unit sounds like the real goal.

0 coins

What you said about knowing which unit has your case makes sense to me now. I think I've been asking general questions when I should be asking specifically about adjudication status.

0 coins

My claim was actually resolved in the employer's favor the first time through - NYSDOL initially sided with their 'voluntary quit' claim because I hadn't submitted enough documentation. I want to be really clear to anyone reading this: if your adjudication goes against you, you have the right to appeal within 30 days of the determination date. The appeal hearing is a completely different process from adjudication. You appear before an Administrative Law Judge, both sides present evidence, and you can ask questions of the employer's representative. I appealed, presented my separation email and texts from my manager, and won on appeal. The whole journey took about five months but I eventually got all my back pay.

0 coins

Five months is a long haul but the fact that you won on appeal after losing adjudication is really important for people to know. A bad adjudication outcome isn't the end of the road.

0 coins

This is both alarming and reassuring at the same time - alarming that you can lose adjudication even with a valid claim, reassuring that there's still a path after that. Thank you for sharing the full arc.

0 coins

My appeal hearing was actually less intimidating than I expected. The ALJ was pretty good at keeping things focused and the employer's rep mostly just submitted paperwork rather than aggressively cross-examining me. It felt more like a formal conversation than a courtroom.

0 coins

My claim went through without being contested, so I don't have personal experience with adjudication, but reading this thread I'm struck by how the whole system seems designed with employers as the primary customer even though employees are the ones paying into it through their labor. The experience rating system makes sense from a pure insurance design standpoint - you want to give employers an incentive not to have massive turnover. But it also creates exactly the perverse dynamic everyone here is describing where it's always worth at least trying to block a valid claim.

0 coins

My read on it is similar. The original design intent was to encourage stable employment. The unintended effect is an adversarial relationship between employers and former employees at exactly the moment when that former employee most needs things to work smoothly.

0 coins

I'd go further and say it's not really unintended - the lobbying around unemployment insurance design has historically been very employer-sided. But that's a bigger political conversation than this thread is probably for.

0 coins

Final update from me: my adjudication was resolved this morning. NYSDOL determined that my employer did not establish that I voluntarily left employment and my claim was approved. My back pay for the weeks I'd been filing is processing now. For anyone finding this thread later going through the same thing - keep filing your weekly claims no matter what, submit a thorough written statement through your Unemployment Services portal, document everything about your separation, and do not give up if the employer contests. The process is slow and stressful but it does eventually work if your situation is legitimate. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences here, it genuinely helped me stay sane through this.

0 coins

Your persistence through this is what made the difference. Glad it worked out - the back pay coming through makes all those weeks of uncertainty worth it.

0 coins

My claim is still pending but this is exactly what I needed to read today. Gives me actual hope that the system can work when you document things properly.

0 coins

Approved outcomes posted on this thread now: mine, yours, and several others. The pattern is pretty clear - thorough documentation, keep filing weekly claims, and don't panic if it takes longer than you expected.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure